2 ms·

How's this compare with street complete? It seems like the categories are different and maybe wider? just curious how the different tools the community has mad

How's this compare with street complete? It seems like the categories are different and maybe wider? just curious how the different tools the community has made stack up

matkoniecz 5mo ago
For start StreetComplete is an Android app unavailable (for now) elsewhere. MapComplete has multiple in-depth layers, while StreetComplete is more general. StreetComplete puts more focus on being usable out-of the box for newbies, while I would describe MapComplete as having focus on usability but allowing deeper dive in specific topics. (disclaimer: I helped with developing StreetComplete)
PetitPrince 5mo ago
Streetcomplete can filter the map with a variety of filters for features you can edit or complete(Street lighting, Surfaces, Sidewalks, Bike paths, Street parking, Addresses, Places, Things, Buildings). Plus there's some specific "quests" where you can complete information for specific POI ("Does this bench have a backrest? Yes|No", "Where does this fire hydrant lies? On the grass | On the roadway | On a walkway | On a parking). Mapcomplete also offers filling info about existing POI, but you can filter on specific theme (Drinking water, sports) or very specific theme (etymology) or even your own. There's also an UI to add new POIs; I don't think it's possible with StreetComplete. Either way both are great.
- matkoniecz 5mo ago
  > There's also an UI to add new POIs; I don't think it's possible with StreetComplete. You can do it in Things and Places layers (layers can be enabled by tapping circle in top-right)
- schoen 5mo ago
  What does the etymology theme do? Allow you to add the etymologies of place names?
  - pietervdvn 4mo ago
    https://mapcomplete.org/etymology https://mapcomplete.org/etymology links objects (mostly streets, but also parks, schools, ...) to the Wikidata enitity of of what that street was _named_ after. If the link is already there, it shows the relevant Wikipedia page. E.g. the 'Willow Street' would show the Wikipedia page on willows. As a downstream effect: those links are also used in https://equalstreetnames.org/ https://equalstreetnames.org/ to make gendered maps.
pietervdvn 4mo ago
Hi! MapComplete dev here! One of the major differences is that, in StreetComplete, an object is hidden from the view once all quests are done. That makes StreetComplete a 'contribution-only' tool. (This changed in recent years, where Westnordost created 'overlays'). StreetComplete was a major inspiration though. In MapComplete, you will see _all_ objects (known in OSM) for a specific topic, wether or not there are unresolved questions. That makes it a tool for both using the data and contributing. Another difference is that MapComplete started as a webapp (but there is a version packaged as Android app too); whereas StreetComplete is (for now) an Android-only app (iOS is in the works) A more abstract difference is that MapComplete has some highly specialized questions. At last, MapComplete has some integrations with other FLOSS-tools, such as: - Wikidata/Wikipedia for additional pictures and articles - Mangrove.reviews for reviews - Panoramax to add pictures - Mapilarry to link pictures to objects - Plantnet to determine the tree species on https://mapcomplete.org/trees https://mapcomplete.org/trees

How's this compare with street complete? It seems like the categories are different and maybe wider? just curious how the different tools the community has made stack up

matkoniecz 5mo ago

For start StreetComplete is an Android app unavailable (for now) elsewhere. MapComplete has multiple in-depth layers, while StreetComplete is more general. StreetComplete puts more focus on being usable out-of the box for newbies, while I would describe MapComplete as having focus on usability but allowing deeper dive in specific topics. (disclaimer: I helped with developing StreetComplete)

PetitPrince 5mo ago

Streetcomplete can filter the map with a variety of filters for features you can edit or complete(Street lighting, Surfaces, Sidewalks, Bike paths, Street parking, Addresses, Places, Things, Buildings). Plus there's some specific "quests" where you can complete information for specific POI ("Does this bench have a backrest? Yes|No", "Where does this fire hydrant lies? On the grass | On the roadway | On a walkway | On a parking). Mapcomplete also offers filling info about existing POI, but you can filter on specific theme (Drinking water, sports) or very specific theme (etymology) or even your own. There's also an UI to add new POIs; I don't think it's possible with StreetComplete. Either way both are great.

matkoniecz 5mo ago
> There's also an UI to add new POIs; I don't think it's possible with StreetComplete. You can do it in Things and Places layers (layers can be enabled by tapping circle in top-right)
schoen 5mo ago
What does the etymology theme do? Allow you to add the etymologies of place names?
- pietervdvn 4mo ago
  https://mapcomplete.org/etymology https://mapcomplete.org/etymology links objects (mostly streets, but also parks, schools, ...) to the Wikidata enitity of of what that street was _named_ after. If the link is already there, it shows the relevant Wikipedia page. E.g. the 'Willow Street' would show the Wikipedia page on willows. As a downstream effect: those links are also used in https://equalstreetnames.org/ https://equalstreetnames.org/ to make gendered maps.

pietervdvn 4mo ago

Hi! MapComplete dev here! One of the major differences is that, in StreetComplete, an object is hidden from the view once all quests are done. That makes StreetComplete a 'contribution-only' tool. (This changed in recent years, where Westnordost created 'overlays'). StreetComplete was a major inspiration though. In MapComplete, you will see _all_ objects (known in OSM) for a specific topic, wether or not there are unresolved questions. That makes it a tool for both using the data and contributing. Another difference is that MapComplete started as a webapp (but there is a version packaged as Android app too); whereas StreetComplete is (for now) an Android-only app (iOS is in the works) A more abstract difference is that MapComplete has some highly specialized questions. At last, MapComplete has some integrations with other FLOSS-tools, such as: - Wikidata/Wikipedia for additional pictures and articles - Mangrove.reviews for reviews - Panoramax to add pictures - Mapilarry to link pictures to objects - Plantnet to determine the tree species on https://mapcomplete.org/trees https://mapcomplete.org/trees