6 ms·
Are all the network carriers (who arguably profited from carrying the traffic) also charged? I'd very much like to see some protection for carriers, be they ne
by e12e 14y ago
Are all the network carriers (who arguably profited from carrying the traffic) also charged?
I'd very much like to see some protection for carriers, be they network operators, or "softer" Tor etc operators.
Yes the most heinous things on the Internet will crawl through. I'm not a supporter of child pornography -- but shouldn't we focus on finding those making porn, actively abusing kids, rather than those distributing it?
Is there even a real economic incentive to distribute that filth?
- csense 14y ago> Is there even a real economic incentive to distribute that filth? I'm not a predator, and I'm not really trained or experienced in criminal justice or psychology, so everything I say about how they think is pure speculation. But I'd suppose that there is economic incentive: (1) Direct payment. I'm sure some people are probably willing to buy such content. I'm also sure that, if somebody else can figure out how to charge buyers and receive money, without leaving a trail back to themselves, some people are willing to sell such content. (2) Reciprocation/barter. Instead of trading money for content, they could trade content for content between individuals. For people who publish to message boards and the like, I assume they're trying to reciprocate for value they receive from others' posts. Or encourage others to post more, perhaps even saying they'll post an image from their collection for every image posted by someone else. (3) Enjoyment of the act of posting itself. One of the reasons people choose a criminal lifestyle -- or any extreme lifestyle, really -- is the pleasure of taking risks. Distributing illegal content is risky and some people may enjoy it for that reason.
- e12e 14y agoI suppose a more sinister (and perhaps) real profit is that it serves as commercials/advertisement for child sex rings/human trafficers. If by nothing else boosting demand. But then that would have to be conclusively proved (another possibility is that paedophiles are less likely to prey on real children if they have access to child porn. Based on studies of porn in general, I'd doubt that, however).
- VMG 14y ago> shouldn't we focus on finding those making porn, actively abusing kids, rather than those distributing it? False dichotomy. Regardless on how you stand on distributing child pornography, a person actively distributing it from their connection and a person allowing others to route CP via their connection are logically equivalent in my opinion.
- e12e 14y agoI didn't mean to set them up as mutually exclusive -- but surely what we want to stop is the abuse of kids? While I don't have a problem with banning child porn (which would be what? Younger than 21 in the US, younger than 16 in Norway and younger than 12 in the Netherlands? Who would decide? Does it include all pictures of naked kids? Artists renditions ?). The real offence is the making of porn that involves kids. Also; I think it is really weird that possessing (or distributing) any media file can carry a minimum 6 year sentence. That's more than manslaughter. If for no other reason that it pretty much renders everyone vulnerable to blackmail by very easily planting evidence.
- wwwtyro 14y ago> a person actively distributing it from their connection and a person allowing others to route CP via their connection are logically equivalent False equivalence. Someone can simultaneously support anonymous communication without supporting CP (philosophically, if not practically). They're not specifically allowing distribution of CP, they're allowing distribution of all anonymous communication.
- baak 14y agoThat makes it totally okay then. Whew, I was worried they were specifically allowing Child Pornography. Thankfully, the distribution of pictures of naked kids is just a byproduct of their freedom.
- Tipzntrix 14y agoThe distribution of illegal drugs to greater distances is just a byproduct of public transit or automobile sales.