4 ms·
Few seem to want to hear it, but the housing 'recovery' is based strictly on a Fed that provides perpetual QE to hold down interest rates forever. Not to mentio
by adventured 14y ago
Few seem to want to hear it, but the housing 'recovery' is based strictly on a Fed that provides perpetual QE to hold down interest rates forever. Not to mention they've removed trillions in junk mortgages from the market, leaving them one of the world's largest land owners. That has also made it easier for the banks to go back to bad real estate policies, since those toxic mortgages have been effectively bailed off their balance sheets. It is currently the Fed's stated intention to create another housing bubble (in their terms they want to inflate asset values, har har), and they're working very hard at it. A large portion of California's supposed improvement is based on rising property values, making home owners feel better off again.
It's all fantasy land economically. Mortgage rates at 3.4% is obscene based on any historical norm. When those rates revert to an average (or worse) as they must, the housing market will tank. The opposite reaction that the Fed's extreme intervention will invite, is going to cause massive destruction just like the last housing bubble they brewed. They learned nothing from their past mistakes.
- aptwebapps 14y ago"perpetual QE" It's hard to cast 2007 to date as perpetual and the end goal is not to keep interest rates down, but inflation.
- 001sky 14y agofed has said this will policy position will go forward for the 'forseable future' or some-such In particular, the Committee also decided today to keep the target range for the federal funds rate at 0 to 1/4 percent and currently anticipates that exceptionally low levels for the federal funds rate are likely to be warranted at least through mid-2015. http://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/press/monetary/20120913a.htm http://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/press/monetary/2012...
- aptwebapps 14y agoYes, by which point they hope that they won't need to keep interest rates down. In fact, this statement and others made at the time are an attempt to get additional traction with expectations about future interest rates.
- 001sky 14y agothey hope... -- nuff said.
- aptwebapps 14y agoSorry, that just seems like a throwaway comment. They have to get traction somehow. Because of the inability to lower short terms rates any further, QE was introduced. As that failed to have enough of an affect they decided to assure the market that that they won't revert to business as usual at the first sign that things are springing back. Setting this expectation is necessary for them to get any traction with the market. Of course, if you think the slow recovery we're experiencing is going to falter or halt, then they might well be pursuing such policies for a long time. If it comes to that politics is likely to intervene in a large way.
- 001sky 14y agoIts not a throwaway comment because you're confusing analysis with non analysis. 2007-2012 = 5 years 2007-2015 = 8 years It goes without saying that these are not equal. or equivalent. etc. If you google "fed" and "forseable future" you will get a variety of reports discussing the recent movements and QE decisions from 9/12 (at various levels of sohistication). So to sum, the notion of "perpetual" (or: open-ended) QE is closer to realtity than what you suggest (the finite 5 years of QE, etc). [1] TLDR: we are in a period of "open-ended" QE edits: clarity __________ [1] The fed hasn't gone further explicitly because "further" is not "foreseeable" with any credibility. Policy parameters = f('hope') is not what they get paid for, or why they are entrusted with power. etc.
- aptwebapps 14y agoI still want to nitpick on 'perpetual'. Not in any conceivable usage, but in the context of that post. "Few seem to want to hear it, but the housing 'recovery' is based strictly on a Fed that provides perpetual QE to hold down interest rates forever. ..." That's a much stronger statement than saying it's open-ended. Maybe I should have let it slide as a little hyperbole, however I disagree with overall thrust of the comment. Plus, the Fed's current policy is only open-ended in the sense that the recovery is not guaranteed because nothing is guaranteed. On our current trajectory it's not looking too bad. A lot slower than we'd like, but there is progress. I do not think it is unreasonable to expect the recovery to be complete to the Fed's satisfaction (with respect to their QE promise) in three or four years. (I'm not saying we'll have unemployment, for example, where it was in 2007 anytime that soon). If you add on a further period of QE to let them meet the commitment they have made, then I grant that is a long time but it is not forever. "Policy parameters = f('hope') is not what they get paid for, or why they are entrusted with power. " I was being a little flowery with 'hope', is all. They do have to act on what they believe are the facts and what they believe will happen, whether or not I call it 'hope'. However, what the Fed is supposed to do is look after inflation and unemployment. They've been very assiduous about the former while neglecting the latter for some time now and are finally allowing the idea that inflation could go a little higher than 2%.