10 ms·
Poll: Do you select text while reading?
I am surprised at how many people, like me, who select text to highlight what they are reading. Some reasons include tracking your reading position, increasing text contrast, or as an "intra-page" bookmark. If these are common actions, perhaps browsers (or add-ons) can provide purpose-built features for these functions.
- piyush_soni 14y agoMy God. I always thought I'm just one of those few who do it, be for a reason or without a reason - I just keep on selecting text while reading. And that's why - I ABSOLUTELY HATE those overly smart websites which on any random selection show a 'search/definition/wikipedia' buttons just below my mouse, and on the next select I accidentally press that stupid button!
- antijingoist 14y agoboth to increase contrast and figure out where the heck I am. But I also have a safari extension that shades alternate paragraphs as I read them , so I do it much less often now.
- mkhalil 14y agoAm I the only one who read this as: "Poll: Do you text while driving?"
- msrpotus 14y agoTo be honest, never really thought about why I select the text before.
- aaronpk 14y agoSometimes I select text for my own internal emphasis. If I see something important I select it as a way to reinforce its importance to myself.
- xyzzyb 14y agoInteresting! I've never heard of this or even seen anyone do it.
- kzahel 14y agoI've watched people who do this (highlighting text and moving the cursor around while reading) and it bugs the heck out of me. I wonder if there's some kind of app to be made for these people, so that text moves around or changes color when their eyes track toward the text. (This would be horrible, to my taste, but you never know)
- commandar 14y ago>I wonder if there's some kind of app to be made for these people, so that text moves around or changes color when their eyes track toward the text. I really don't think that would help. For me the highlighting is a lot like tracing along text with your finger as you read on a printed page; it gives my eye a visual cue where I'm trying to track. The issue is that I can read text faster than my eyes can track without wandering slightly and losing my position in the text, so simply tracking where my eyes are looking wouldn't do anything to mitigate that. It'd just end up highlighting where my tracking gets off anyway.
- Kluny 14y agoWell, it's a nervous habit, so we'd just have to replace it with a different habit. I would probably bite my nails or scratch at invisible zits, or something equally horrible. So it's nice to have the trackpad to contain your nervous twitching.
- davidw 14y agoI worked for a guy who would sit there selecting bits of text on and off while showing me some web page. I wanted to grab the mouse, wrench it from his computer and stomp on it. If it's the kind of thing that floats your boat, fine, to each his own, but don't make other people watch.
- afaqurk 14y agoI've always considered myself a slow reader. I feel that highlighting words/sentences on a web page helps me read quicker (for whatever reason).
- eric-hu 14y agoDidn't answer, I'd like to choose "Yes, all of the above"
- fendrak 14y agoI select text compulsively while reading. I just double-click whatever paragraph I'm on to make it stand out from the rest of the text, and then just kind of keep clicking. Why? I have no idea, really. Just an odd habit!
- patmcguire 14y agoFor a long time the New York Times had a javascript thing that would pop up a dictionary reference for anything you double clicked on. As someone who compulsively doubleclicks to highlight and unhighlight, it bugged the hell out of me.
- TheCapn 14y agoAn IDE that I use at my job does this trying to pull up variable declarations for whatever you've selected (even if its giant blocks of data). I know that feeling.
- jfb 14y agoI used Glimmerblocker to nuke all Javascript from the Times because of this. What is it about newspaper websites that encourages what I can only assume are normally rational developers to misbehave so unbelievably badly?
- sk5t 14y agoThese terrible, tacky tack-ons have little to no relationship to what the developers would do... unless those same developers are also in charge of partner programs.
- OriginalSyn 14y agoExactly, I can't count the times I've butted heads with our marketing, design and business development teams over silly, annoying and outright ridiculous features they had charged us with implementing... before we became a more agile shop these confrontations usually resulted in me having to back down and implement the features because they were pretty much set in stone by the time they got into our queue but now we can often compromise since we're involved earlier in the planning stages.
- davimack 14y agoI wouldn't attribute the change to "agile" ... but would attribute the problem to poor design. Subtle difference, but you get the same garbage in agile stuff - just depends on the PM, really.
- mason55 14y agoI just spastically double-click words all over the page while I'm reading. No real rhyme or reason to it, it doesn't help me read or anything. It's mostly just an unconscious tick.
- cstrat 14y agoI do this too sometimes. Sometimes I accidentally click a link and that is when I notice... otherwise it is mostly unconscious.
- Scorponok 14y agoThis gets annoying with sites that have actions defined when you click on words, or bring up a popup window when you click, etc. :(
- iNate2000 14y agoI also hate when clicking in "empty" space takes me to an advertiser's site.
- bjhoops1 14y agoOh my god, yes! I am a compulsive margin-clicker. I ostensibly do this to make sure that the browser page has focus, but really it's really just a tick. I love TheOnion.com, but they kill me with their ads-in-the-margins. What I typically do is fire up Chrome developer tools, and DESTROY the offending node. I find this therapeutic. :)
- dbaupp 14y agoThere was a blow-up-the-page book market posted to HNa while back... you might find some pleasure in tthat if someone can dig it up.
- bjhoops1 14y agoYou mean this? http://www.webmonkey.com/2012/07/blow-up-the-web-with-font-bomb/ http://www.webmonkey.com/2012/07/blow-up-the-web-with-font-b... Yeah, I played with that for hours.
- endlessvoid94 14y agoI don't do it when I'm using a trackpad, but I do when I'm using a mouse. Interesting.
- nhebb 14y agoI don't, but I've always wished there were a way to bookmark position within a page.
- millerm 14y agoYes I do, and I really notice it when using O'Reilly's Safari bookshelf. Whenever you select text it pops up a window asking if you want to highlight or make a note, so irritating! If that mouse is in my hand I always select text that I am reading. I am not sure why. Perhaps it's just a reflex so I can keep track of where I am in the text. With so much noise on web pages, it must help. I'll have to test if I do this as often on other things. I know I have accidentally cut and pasted previous commands in a terminal and have been very upset with the consequences. I'm just sloppy with that mouse and middle button I guess. But those darn new line characters on a paste can be catastrophic.
- me2i81 14y agoI do it as a nervous habit.
- fusiongyro 14y agoI usually don't need to unless the design makes it hard for me to keep my place.
- mitchi 14y agoNo
- unit0x03 14y agoSelect to copy, of course.
- fwr 14y agoOnly if the text is multiple paragraphs, otherwise it's too much of a hassle.
- jandy 14y agoI don't, and it bugs the hell out of me when I'm sat reading with someone else who does. Nothing more distracting than them going nuts with the mouse while I'm trying to read. I get why people do it, but sheesh, take your hands off the mouse for a minute, it won't kill you!
- sareon 14y agoI have on occasion, just when the text is one giant wall, I start having a hard time finding the next line without re-reading the line I just read. If I highlight the previous line I know not to read it.
- woj 14y agoNo, but I do scroll the page up, so that the line I'm reading aligns with the top of the browser viewing area. Some sites nowadays add a floating header to the top of the page that changes size as you scroll down which is super distracting when reading the way I do.
- sebtoast 14y agoYes.
- stephengillie 14y agoWhen using a Chrome browser with adblock and flashblock and HTTPS, and JS disabled, sometimes text isn't where it was designed to be. Sometimes text covers images or runs into other text, and selecting is necessary to be able to read it.
- hnriot 14y agoif you cripple the browser, what do you expect? If you disable JS you might as well just not bother with the web.
- stephengillie 14y agoI understand the way in which I'm hindering the tool I use. I am doing so intentionally. And I understand that having text cover images in this situation can be described as "by design". But it's still a case in which I select text.
- graue 14y agoI do it sometimes compulsively, but I think it started for a legitimate reason: clicking to make sure the text has focus. That way when I use up/down/PageUp/PageDown to scroll, the text actually scrolls. If there is a textbox that has focus, up or down jumps to that textbox instead which drives me bonkers. Also, recent versions of Firefox have a bug where after you bookmark a page, if you've added a tag, the page loses focus and has to be clicked to re-focus (otherwise keyboard scrolling is broken). So far this has never bothered me quite enough to check if the bug was reported. Edit: Since I cared enough to write about it here, I filed a bug report: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=815812 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=815812
- blktiger 14y agoIf you were on a MAC you would only have to make sure the mouse cursor is over the area you wanted to scroll. :P
- graue 14y agoI am actually using a MacBook Air, but I prefer keyboard to two-finger scrolling most of the time.
- z92 14y agoAir arrow keys are half the size of regular keys, which makes scrolling through keyboard even more painful for me. The button is like a single button, and you have to hit its top half or bottom half to scroll. I had been using two finger scrolling since Lion. But most PC user that tries to scroll a page on my laptop, finds it very difficult.
- gideon_b 14y agoWhen I read the title of this post I thought "WHOA, other people do that too?!" and clicked through to take the poll. Your poll is going to have a heavy selection bias towards people who select text while reading. People who don't select text while reading will probably ignore this poll and go read an article on erlang best practices or Paul Graham's favorite color.
- cpeterso 14y agoI had originally posted a poll with Often/Sometimes/Never answers, but I realized, like you point out, that this poll would have heavy selection bias. So I changed the poll to gather reasons why people select. That's probably more interesting data than Yes/No anyways. :)
- sltkr 14y agoThe ratio of people that does this is something that you could accurately measure if you have a somewhat popular website. (The reason why not so much, of course. I doubt many people have a conscious reason for this behaviour anyway. I don't.)
- chollida1 14y agoI do this. I just attributed this to ADD. But I do like the contrast.
- darrenkopp 14y agoI attribute it to my ADD as well, and I have no real reason why I do it. I'm never actually selecting much either, and just random select things around the page as I'm reading, not even what I'm reading.
- chucknibbleston 14y agothis is why I love the 3 finger drag in osx.
- kibwen 14y agoRestless fingers. The other people in my office must think that I'm playing games all day, considering that the uninterrupted rapid-fire stream of clicks I produce when my hand is on the mouse is indistinguishable from playing an FPS.
- hanleybrand 14y agoPeople make fun of me for doing it, but I can't stop. It's the one thing that makes google reader hard to use, because I forget and clicking on a news story makes it jump to the top of the page (note to google reader devs - your thing is awesome, probably needs an update, but GOD DAMN I HATE THE CLICK JUMP FUNCTION)
- aferrari_ 14y agoYes, many times i seek more about a word or expression. Or to translate.
- wh-uws 14y agoNice to know im not alone in the world about this
- pippy 14y agoIt's one of the reasons I hate surfing snoops. I'd spend a lot more time there if I could highlight when I'm reading.
- thechut 14y agoI don't do this. I feel left out now
- okor 14y agoYes, to track my reading position.
- graeme 14y agoNo idea why I do it. I think I just like to do something with my hands.
- xissy 14y agoYes, but sometimes like difficult papers and articles.
- robertmarkbram 14y agoSometimes as a bookmark. Mostly however, because lines are too long (I will sometimes resize the browser to fix this).
- aero142 14y agoWhen people see that I highlight text while I'm reading, they always want to know what practical reason it serves. The simplest answer is that it kind of helps me track the text, but it's less than that. It also isn't quite just a nervous habit. The only description that makes sense to me is that it feels like a physical connection to the page. More like spinning a pen, or rolling an object in your hand while you think about it. Like the mouse is my fingers and I'm just sort of fiddling with the page, like flicking through page edges of a book just for the feel of it.
- experiment0 14y agoYes this is definitely what I do too. I also tend to repeatedly tap the paragraph on the trackpad, so that fits well with your nervous habit analogy.
- sneilan 14y agoYes, it is a motor tic & possibly a bad habit.
- ColinDabritz 14y agoI am a selector, partly by habit/something to do, and partly to track position, especially in wider formats. Newspapers are in columns for a reason! On one site I frequent, it took me a minute to figure out why I kept going to random other websites. I was keeping the mouse out of the way on the (rather large) margins, and apparently the full screen border ad was clickable anywhere that wasn't the center content column or navigation. Just blank space down the page, but I'd click it to select rows of text, and get carted off to the ad website. I suppose that's one way to monetize a strange habit...
- eps 14y agoI "select all" on pages that use bright on dark text, e.g. yegg's and jwz's blogs. Otherwise they are virtually impossible to read for longer than a minute.
- bradly 14y agoThe only time I do it is when the the columns are very wide in paragraph text and flowing from one line to the next is difficult. Sometimes increasing font size so less words fit in a column accomplish the same thing, though.
- namank 14y agoExcellent question! I've been wondering this for the past two years...made an annotator based off of this idea. I found that most people select because they are holding the mouse - they have to use it if they are holding it. Then sometimes you select to preserve your position while scrolling. This also led me to believe that people digest information in chunks. Highlighted text serves as a "todo" - must finish reading the highlighted block of text before diverting focus to something else.
- dustmop 14y agoI used to years ago, but eventually wrote a browser extension Paragrasp to do it: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/paragrasp/lhhabjbhhgemkclgbcejppncnlglefbd https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/paragrasp/lhhabjbh... for Chrome and https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/paragrasp/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/paragrasp/ for Firefox.
- cpeterso 14y agoThanks! Paragrasp is just what I was looking for (but didn't know it). :)
- godDLL 14y agoI only scroll to read very dense text, like technical docs - and those tend to have the kind of paragraphs that take pages to scroll past. On the other hand I most often select text at the bottom of the page before hitting Space to advance the page. If you could place a line of highlight across the page before it starts spinning (or jumps) and fade it out gently after - that would definitely be of use. Or you could think about splitting chubby paragraphs into predictably behaving chunks. Very nice plugin, thank you.
- emeraldd 14y agoI find myself semi randomly selecting things on pages when I'm reading through something quickly or skimming through a page. If something catches my eye, I'll select it as or before I read it.
- MarlonPro 14y agoI do that every time. And I don't need any app/add-on for that. Please, no.
- mhitza 14y agoUsed to. Since using a touchpad I am no longer doing it.
- rocky1138 14y agoIt's funny because I thought I'd do it less with the trackpad, but I've done it twice while reading the comments of this post on my laptop.
- incision 14y agoNo. In terms of add-ons, I'd really like something that combines the function of a speed reader like spreeder [1] with the "articlization" of Pocket [2]. 1: http://www.spreeder.com/app.php?intro=1 http://www.spreeder.com/app.php?intro=1 2: http://getpocket.com http://getpocket.com
- mtinkerhess 14y agoI never thought about highlighting text to increase contrast. Is there some way to change the default selection text color and background color? I would love to make the selection background color black to really max out the contrast.
- radagaisus 14y agohttp://css-tricks.com/overriding-the-default-text-selection-color-with-css/ http://css-tricks.com/overriding-the-default-text-selection-...
- ColinDabritz 14y agoAs a note, this appears to be in response to the top comment on the story "The greatest google mail feature you may not be using" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4838810 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4838810 The comment complains about the behavior interacting poorly with text highlight reading: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4838940 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4838940 I love reading (and highlighting to read) these sorts of discussions.
- utunga 14y agoYes absolutely. I was already familiar with that google mail 'feature' because I/it had unconsciously 'messed up' a couple of my replies before I realised what it was doing (and why).
- calleskonto 14y agoNo, i follow with the mouse but don't select.
- AaronBBrown 14y agoI thought I was the only one who did this. Interestingly, I do it much less when using the Clearly Chrome plugin from Evernote. https://evernote.com/clearly/ https://evernote.com/clearly/
- vostrocity 14y agoGood observation. Same, though I've always used Readability instead of Clearly.
- albertzeyer 14y agoI sometimes do it when fast-reading through something and click on some sections (single or multiple words) which got my attention. And then I read on. It helps me to keep things in my short-term memory or to actually extend my short-term memory.
- jakub_g 14y agoI select all the time, using either mouse or a keyboard. In addition to the mentioned problems with JS popups on click on NYTimes et al, there is another set of annoyances due to invasive keyboard shortcuts. I select text from kbd with SHIFT+arrows (up, down, left, right) or CTRL+SHIFT+arrows (left, right) and scroll the page with arrows. I want to do something nasty to the webdev each time I'm on the page which overrides those shortcuts. Especially when it's sth like redirect to other article on ARROW_RIGHT (sigh). Fortunately I have "Disable JS" button right in the status bar... TL;DR: do not mess with my keyboard or I will find you!
- CKKim 14y agoHaving recorded myself using a computer and watched it back to analyse my habits, I've noticed that I don't begin highlighting when reading an article but if I consciously highlight part to reread for comprehension (or to look up a word) then this triggers twitchy highlighting for the rest of the piece. The twitchy highlighting seems to follow three patterns: bored methodical clicking to help get through big dry paragraphs, fast erratic clicking when something is exciting, and sporadic clicking when I've stopped reading to think about something in the article. When I worked in a high school I noticed almost the exact same behaviours as described, exhibited by students and younger staff. Pretty much all the computery kids were hyperactive click-highlighters and it was only the students who seemed positively uncomfortable around computers who didn't do it at all.
- richforrester 14y agoGood response. That's pretty much my behavior too.
- Randgalt 14y agoAlso to copy the text to look it up in a dictionary
- s00pcan 14y agoNo, because I'm using vimium most of the time I am reading in my browser.
- LiquidEyes 14y ago"I like to move it, move it."
- petercooper 14y agoNot only that but I also click randomly as well. This can get me into trouble, particularly on sites which have giant "background ads". Notably, I don't do this at all with trackpads, only when using a mouse at the desktop.
- KirinDave 14y agoCompulsively. It bothers other people.
- darkstalker 14y agoI don't do it. I've always seen people doing that.
- evancharles 14y agoI do it to reduce contrast, not increase it. White on black is awfully harsh. Never use black: http://ianstormtaylor.com/design-tip-never-use-black/ http://ianstormtaylor.com/design-tip-never-use-black/
- MechaJDI 14y agoI typically don't UNLESS I'm on wikipedia...It's way too common for me to look up one article and end up with 10 or so tabs of different topics/words from the first article...
- joaomoreno 14y agoI do it as a nervous tick. It consumes me as OCD usually does.
- gavanwoolery 14y agoYes, because I am neurotic. (No, really.)
- ajuc 14y agoYeah, but only if the text is unreadable(there's too much text in one paragraph).
- walid 14y agoYes, I search for stuff to know more about the subject.
- pnathan 14y agoNo. I avoid using the mouse if possible.
- jmtame 14y agoThis is how I can tell my roommate is reading: he constantly double clicks, probably once every other second.
- tagada 14y agoYes, sometimes, for both increasing contrast and track reading position.
- w1ntermute 14y agoI think this might go back to our reading habits on paper. I've noticed that many of my friends who use their fingers to guide their reading on paper like to highlight text or move their cursor to mark their position when web browsing. I've never done that though, so I never felt the need to do so on a computer either.
- manicdee 14y agoI'm a heavy trackpad user, I'll scroll the window to the text I'm reading. Even if I'm half way through the page, I'll scroll the next paragraph to the top of the window. That's how I "record" my reading position.
- blktiger 14y agoI sometimes select text while reading to track my reading position. Sometimes as a nervous tic/add.
- guptaneil 14y agoIt's such a relieving feeling when you realize that you are not alone.
- vostrocity 14y agoBack when I used a mouse, I always worried that my compulsive selecting drained my mouse battery faster than it needed to. It probably added a lot to my WhatPulse stats as well.
- fragsworth 14y agoOn a related note, at least in Windows, when triple-clicking to select a paragraph, immediate subsequent clicks (any number) do absolutely nothing. This really bothers me when selecting words because sometimes I triple-click instead of double-click by accident, and I want to undo this but it requires waiting.
- snogglethorpe 14y agoYeah, windows multi-click text selection seems completely weird to me, and very frustrating when coming from other platforms... [Besides the simple "not what I'm used to" factor, any UI behavior that requires waiting seems pretty dubious to me...]
- beemoe 14y ago"any UI behavior that requires waiting seems pretty dubious to me..." Deep down I really agree with that, but I become conflicted when I consider settings with severe limitations that have little else to turn to. For example: the timed hover to select on some Kinect games: touch screens that use longpress as a substitute for right-click; touchscreen keyboards with longpress as a shift-like behavior. It somehow seems regretfully acceptable when dealing with the limitations of a touch screen, single button, or no button environment. One case where I think it is ok to require waiting are "Ejector seat button next to the radio" type situations where user action could have potentially disastrous consequences: I am glad I have to hold down my power button for some time to force a hardware restart.
- mikeleeorg 14y agoNo, but I tend to scroll, so the top of the browser window marks where I should read next.
- beemoe 14y agoAh, I have been looking for this comment. Finally someone else who does this! It doesn't just show me where my current spot to start from is; it prevents me from wasting time re-reading any text that I have already read. Even though this is my most common method, I occasionally use the mouse cursor (without selecting) to keep my place instead, particularly at the bottom of a page where I can no longer scroll down.
- Flenser 14y agoThis is my method too. It also means that if I am interrupted I don't have to do anything to keep my place, although I still sometimes select text if I want to keep something above it on screen for context.
- pud 14y agoAnyone else play with the highlighting on their iPhone constantly? I can't read anything on my iPhone without constantly messing with the highlight UI. It's so fun.
- JacobIrwin 14y agocheckout Hakim's fokus.js if you like to highlight while reading, I run the script in console when I am note-taking (hand writing notes, based on browser text) - very convenient!
- Shahor 14y agoYes, for contrast and reading position
- danabramov 14y agoI do it all the time. Also, when using Safari, I often pinch in and out while reading. The rendering gets blurry until I lift the fingers, and the moment the text is crisp again, I feel certain satisfaction.
- Tycho 14y agoI do this cause I just like to interact with the graphics. Especially if it's a Mac and you have all those nice quartz effects like when you highlight, then click and drag so that the text is floating above some other part of the screen, disembodied from the article. I pause to think a lot when I read, so this is just sort of fidgeting while my mind thinks about something, I suppose.
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y agoI just do it as habit. It's hard to pick the category from those above. It's probably a combination of "to track my reading position" and "to increase text contrast" but I don't consciously set out to do either of those. It's really just a harmless habit.
- WareSarah 14y agoOver 30% of people select text while reading. Markerly.com gives publishers a dashboard of text selection and copy and paste trends. We are about to roll out heat maps that show text selection - it definitely tells a story and differs article to article. Source: I'm CEO of Markerly and I look at this data everyday.
- cpeterso 14y agoThat is a very interesting concept! Can you share how publishers use the text selection feedback to optimize their websites or editorial content? Does Markerly gather all text selection or just text "shared" through Markerly's social tooltip? The former could have privacy or security implications.
- WareSarah 14y agoMarkerly's javascript allows us to collect all text selection as well as text selected and shared. It's all aggregate data, not personally identifiable. You can read about how publishers are able to optimize their content using the copy and paste analytics on this post http://blog.markerly.com/ http://blog.markerly.com/
- eaton 14y agoYes, but I'm ashamed to admit it to my friends.
- shanehudson 14y agoYes, completely. Usually to track what I am reading or to change the colour, but sometimes for the same reason I draw random boxes with the selection tool on my desktop.. because I fidget.
- stadeschuldt 14y agoWhat also makes reading a lot more comfortable is the clipr bookmarklet: http://code.google.com/p/clipr/ http://code.google.com/p/clipr/
- kemmer 14y agoYes: OCD.
- protomyth 14y agoIf I could flip to a reading mode where the center line is the point of scrolling[1] and puts a little extra separation between the center line and lines above and below, I would not highlight. Maybe a subtle greying of the lines above and below. [1] instead of stopping the scrolling when the first line is on the top or the last line is on the bottom, it scrolls to the middle before stopping.
- zerostar07 14y agoI believe it should be a standard feature on browsers to have some identifier or horizontal line so that when scrolling or page-down, you know where to pick up. I use highlight to mark the current position that i 'm reading, then mouse-scroll up/down to read some text i missed. Ideally, i would like to keep the last 2-3 text selections that I made highlighted. I also hate Nytimes and PLoS for hijacking my selections
- jeffchuber 14y agoYes I do it as a tick. In fact I realized I was doing it while reading these comments.
- Peteris 14y agoI just randomly select text as I'm reading. In fact I find it annoying when I cannot do so.
- kevinSuttle 14y agoNo, but I can understand why, based on the responses so far. Makes sense. I'd think they'd be more useful if they were saved somewhere.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoI don't understand how people do this unless they just read really slowly. It's maddening to try to do and have it actually be where you're reading. It also kills me that HN seems to embrace this practice, yet is also so incredibly skeptical of SSS and dyslexia.
- mturmon 14y agoIf you have a trackpad, a triple tap can select a whole paragraph. Unless you write one-sentence paragraphs, this turns out not to slow things down at all. (I read at a "normal" pace and sometimes do this.)
- hhjj 14y agoYes i use text selection to scroll especially on trackpads : begin selection of text near window edge then scroll while selecting further.
- tambourine_man 14y agoYes, to track my reading position, but only when I'm exhausted. I doubt I'd have enough brain juice left at this stage to remember to use an add-on. But it would be nice for very large texts, sparsely read and on normal attention conditions.
- alphang 14y agoYep, it's one of the things I miss when I'm reading on a multi-touch screen - that extra tool of interaction with the page.
- edzme 14y agoYou all are nuts.
- BjoernKW 14y agoI used to do this for scrolling. Weird habit, actually.
- Osiris 14y agoI have a co-worker that constantly selects and re-selects text in everything from web pages to Sublime Text. I think he's developed some weird form of subconscious text-selection syndrome. He literally cannot stop doing it even when we bring it up to him. It's really bad doing remote screensharing because the screen has to constantly redraw. I've never seen the behavior before. It's quite odd. I never select text except for copy/cut operations.
- knave 14y agoTo be totally honest, it's part tracking my reading position and part to settle my idle hands & pacify my ocd tendencies
- andyfleming 14y agoFor me, it helps me pick up where I left off reading when scrolling down the page.
- erickhill 14y agoI never consciously asked myself why I select text, until now. As a result, it wasn't something I did. Fascinating question. It is purely a mouse-driven habit, too, by the way. I now wonder if all my years selecting text in old versions of Internet Explorer (to see how pages were built in HTML) was partly to blame? This technique was useful to see where clear gifs and other artifacts were often hiding.
- xcirrian 14y agoyes
- nsoldiac 14y agoI've gone through different phases of this as a tool to fight my ADD impulses. My main reason was to avoid that scenario where I would find myself reading and then snap and ask myself "where the hell am I in this paragraph/page/article?" I highlighted sentence by sentence as I read through, but it results in too many iterations. Then I highlighted whole paragraphs, worked better but reading through blue colored background when there's white background all around it made my eyes drift away to the lighter areas. Now I'm highlighting the paragraph prior to the one I'm in, it serves as a bookmark of sorts. It's still a work in progress but its damn better than not doing it!
- danabramov 14y agoI didn't when I used default selection color. I remember starting doing it because I really enjoyed OS X yellow selection option.
- djbender 14y agoWhen the lines are ridiculously long and/or there isn't enough line spacing. Like on Hacker News.
- CmdrKrool 14y agoSometimes I highlight from the middle of one line of text to the middle of the next line of text, trying to get the start and end of the highlight to line up exactly.
- Zaheer 14y agoA lot of times I'll select some text on a page right before I scroll to help my eye focus and track where I am on large text pages.
- snogglethorpe 14y agoI don't do it habitually, but it's invaluable for all those web pages where the author thought blinking yellow text on a magenta background was neat... [Not just myspace and old geocities sites...I run into this sort of thing all too often, even on "real" (modern, corporate, well-funded, etc) websites. Sometimes it's just that the site designer seemed to be going for some sort of artistic/funky look, but in other cases the site looks fine in ie6 but becomes unreadable in FF or chrome... >< ]
- Buzaga 14y agoYes, and I thought about posting about this a here lot of times to know if people also do this because of how much I hate websites that remap the arrows to "next/previous article", it must stop!
- stouset 14y agoDoes anyone else want to answer "Yes" for all of those reasons?
- yeonhoyoon 14y agoTracking the reading position with a visual guide is one of the fundamental techniques in many speed reading methods. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_reading http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_reading
- hayksaakian 14y agoInteresting, I would have thought that spending time to constantly mark your position would be detrimental to speed reading.
- eekfuh 14y agoI tend to use it for sites that have low line-heights. Like this site. The wide page and low line-height make it really hard for me to read. For reading content I'd say a min of 160% line-height.
- swah 14y agoI like to read longer articles with the diigo highlighter.
- spideyunlimited 14y agoWhen I'm reading something really intense, it helps me focus -both visually and mentally, on say two or three paragraphs at a time, before moving on.
- harel 14y agoI do it. It does not help me in any way. It annoys people reading with me or sharing my screen. It baffles even myself. But by god, I cannot help it. Have you tried selecting text and doing circles or rectangles? Amazing satisfaction!
- mogop 14y agoYes, to track my reading position Yes, to increase text contrast
- chadgeidel 14y agoI've seen people do this and I've wondered why they do. Thanks for answering this intriguing question!
- bradleyland 14y agoI answered yes to the first three, because I find myself doing it for a variety of reasons at different times. The most common reason is to keep track of my place when someone calls me or walks in to my office. The next most common reason is related to the first reason, and it's a shame that I have to do so. When you use text highlighting to track your reading (line by line), it's a sign that the site you're reading has poor typography. Usually: Measure is too long - when lines of text are long, our eyes have a difficult time "tracking" back to the next line. Leading is too small - Leading is the space between lines. The space between lines creates a negative void that our eyes follow back to the beginning of the next line. Not enough leading and the line is thin and hard to follow. Too much leading and your eyes get lost in a sea of space.
- Flenser 14y agoWhen the typography is really bad I use readability, although I'm sure I select text on readability too.
- peterwhitesell 14y agoAfter a few days of use, I customized my readability (actually I use clearly now. http://evernote.com/clearly/ http://evernote.com/clearly/) style to make highlighted text easier to read. After I moved to a theme with dark background and light text, the contrast between selection text and selection background was annoyingly low.
- peterwhitesell 14y agoEven when typography isn't bad I've always had a hard time tracking back to the next line both with text on paper and on screens. My most common use is to highlight one line at a time, although I sometimes highlight to save my place (arbitrary length selection) and sometimes to emphasize a concept out of a larger mess of text (context based selection length). Usually I highlight from near the middle of one line to near the middle of the next line. If near the end of reading line N I highlight from the middle of line N+1 to the middle of line N+2, I can use the one highlight three times to help me track back: first I track back to the first line above the highlight (N+1), second I track back to the highlighted line (N+2), third I track back to the first line under the highlight (N+3). Similarly highlighting multiple lines at a time it's easy to subconsciously remember which line of the selection to read next (first, second, third, ...) without having to visually track back, as long as the selection isn't very long (much like how it's harder to keep track of where you are in a longer paragraph).
- digitalWestie 14y agoI'd say a combination of the top two.
- bpatrianakos 14y agoI picked placeholder but I also just randomly select as I go along sometimes with no reason at all. So I kind of track my position but not really because I can track it fine without it but do it sometimes randomly anyway.
- slake 14y agoYes. All the time!
- pixelden 14y agoCompulsively. I hate it when my magic mouse sometimes registers it as a right click.
- lobster_johnson 14y agoI used to scroll. Then I started scrolling so that the line I am reading is always the first line in the window (thus obscuring everything above), which means I can read about tracking downwards, and I don't have muck about with text selection.
- lobster_johnson 14y agoUsed to select, sorry.
- TomGullen 14y agoYes, just by habit!
- olegious 14y agoI used to select text much more than I do now. When I was taking the Series 7 exam, I was selecting so much text and clicking as I did so, that the exam software froze (I was about 75% done with the test). Luckily the system reboot didn't result in any data loss- I'm not sure who was happier, the test proctor or me ;).
- sharavsambuu 14y agoyes, always :)
- chm 14y agoFor me, it's just been a habit since immemorial times. Growing up in the 90s, I had access to Win95 from the start, and I can't remember not doing this.
- MemorableZebra 14y agoBased on what people are saying here, I think there are a lot of different styles. For instance I have a friend who frantically selects and reselects small portions of the text the whole time. I on the other hand just highlight a line and hold shift then down arrow at the end of each line I know exactly which line is next to be read.
- antoko 14y agoI need to vote 3 times! I'm a yes to position reading, and place holder for sure... contrast issue is dependent on the regular contrast it doesn't happen often but I do use it that way. Now I'm a self-confessed habitual selector I feel compelled to say that in no way, shape or form do I select text like some kind of nervous tic. I rarely select text when reading HN comments for example, they're mostly short enough so I'm not going to have to scroll or have time to get pulled on to something else before finishing. I voted for reading position because that's the one I use it for most.
- sherjilozair 14y agoIt helps me focus.
- geoka9 14y agoI have to, sometimes, when I read a site with a fancy new design (with grey text). Other than that, no.
- shakeel_mohamed 14y agoYes, usually for reading code if the syntax highlighting gets screwed up by one of the Chrome extensions I have installed.
- jasonpbecker 14y agoI'm super surprised people do this. Generational gap? I'm 25 and absolutely never would think to do this.
- jamesmcn 14y agoI occasionally do, but some spam-happy sites will pop up all sorts of crap when you click on their page. So I'm fairly cautious about where I'm willing to click.
- gruuby 14y agoI was shocked to find out after my Google interview that you can see your collaborator selecting text in Google Apps. I was nervously selecting wafts of text constantly throughout the whole thing. I never heard from them afterwards :/
- rdwallis 14y agoFor those using selecting to track reading position, I built a chrome extension that specifically solves this problem. I haven't started promoting it yet because of a bug in incognito mode but it's available at: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/magicscroll-web-reader/ecldhagehndokdmaiaigoaecbmbnmfkc https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/magicscroll-web-re...
- nirmel 14y agoThe top story on HN is about how Gmail only includes the highlighted section of an email in the reply. This is the bane of my life for this reason! Highlight a paragraph to read it, hit reply, and only that paragraph is included in the response. Most unintentionally annoying feature ever.
- nvader 14y agoThe Evelyn Wood speed reading system recommends using your finger on a page to trace lines of text. When reading long passages on the computer, I achieve the same goal by highlighting. I generally only do this when reading longer content: never when reading comments on HN.
- tuananh 14y agoi select text so that when i scroll down, i can quickly see where i was, to continue reading.
- mchavezi 14y agoI do it to make sure I followed what is written.
- vinojeyapalan 14y agoYes sir.
- bajsejohannes 14y ago> Yes, as a placeholder to pick up reading later This is my answer, and it's a habit I picked up while using Skype, since they don't track my position very well when new messages comes in. (OS X)
- bfung 14y agoI only do it when someone else is looking at the same screen as me, and there is a lot of text (not watching video together, but reading article). It's like a highlighter to coordinate reading.
- levelboy 14y agoCool, I thought about asking this :)
- caffeinewriter 14y agoI do this, because it helps me remember important points, cause I tend to read highlighted points twiceover or more.
- ttflee 14y agoI used to. But I stopped selecting text right after... perhaps I began using a WebKit based browser. Sometimes, text selection in WebKit based browsers looks ugly and weird compared with that in Firefox, however, these browsers are just damned fast.
- fudged71 14y agoOnly when I am changing font sizes on the page, to bookmark where I am. Browsers tend to jump around an article when you do this and it's easy to lose your place.
- jacoblyles 14y agoConstantly. Spastically. Unless I'm on the nytimes website.
- rangibaby 14y agoI often double click on a paragraph to highlight all of it, and keep track of where I'm reading.
- macu 14y agoI'm glad to see others do this. I don't think I would use a browser plugin; selecting with the mouse is completely satisfying for whatever reason I do it. I think it's a way for me to feel connected with the text, too. reading a book, I either trace with my finger or a piece of paper I slide down the page (not word-for-word, but by sentences and paragraphs).
- cpher 14y agoI am absolutely amazed at the response this poll is getting. You people are a bunch of freaks! ;) I frequently select text when I need to get up from my desk at home to deal with the kids (and not lose my place), but not to the extent that other here are describing, unless it's the random tick click thing. I'm sure there's a psychologist in our midst that can explain this phenomenon. But, I'm still shocked that this post has generated this much attention.
- lancefisher 14y agoI never even realized I did this until my wife asked me what the heck I was doing one day. I'm still not sure why I'm highlighting all the time, but sometimes it is to keep my place when I scroll the page. Other times it is completely subconscious.
- utunga 14y agoi think i do it to make the text feel 'tactile' and thus more engaging
- georgemcbay 14y agoI highlight text to increase contrast, but only in situations where the "designer" has totally failed and done something terrible like put dark color text on a black background.
- ricardobeat 14y ago> If these are common actions, perhaps browsers (or add-ons) can provide purpose-built features for these functions. Maybe this is one of those cases where nothing actually needs to be done. Highlighting is highlighting, it works great and fulfills different needs. There are lots of add-ons for focus, black-out, markers and other features, but none is widely used. In adittion, we are moving towards touch interfaces. I haven't seen anyone frantically touching the screen to highlight text in those; as some have confessed here, I believe this behavior has a lot to do with the mechanical act of clicking, the sound and feedback that for some reason feels good and ends up becoming a compulsion.
- peterwhitesell 14y ago> I believe this behavior has a lot to do with the mechanical act of clicking, the sound and feedback that for some reason feels good and ends up becoming a compulsion. I'm a compulsive highlighter for most of the reasons people have described. I don't hear any sound when I click though, because I use a touchpad with no mouse buttons or clicking (tap to click, tap-tap-drag to highlight, two finger tap to right click, two finger scrolling). Since I started reading a lot on a touch screen phone I've been frustrated by the lack of easy highlighting, and I compulsively scroll to track my place instead.
- benn_88 14y agoHoly fuck, I thought it was just me. I think I do it more with black on white. I find it difficult to focus reading from a large bright screen. I do find I end up not bothering to read a lot of articles I'd like to online, end up either bookmarking and ignoring, or just skimming over. Think it's because reading long articles in a particular layout is a chore. A layout browser extension might help, I should give it a try.
- DustinCalim 14y agosee my other post
- benn_88 14y agoThanks
- DustinCalim 14y agoAnyone highlighting text for the contrast will love this Chrome extension: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/hacker-vision/fommidcneendjonelhhhkmoekeicedej https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/hacker-vision/fomm...
- wallywax 14y agoI do this, and another "silly" thing I do is when I copy something to the clipboard, I often hit cmd-c three or four times quickly. I don't remember why or when I picked up this habit. I imagine maybe at some point I had a system or program that didn't always register the copy the first time? Or maybe it's just completely random. But I don't even notice I'm doing it until someone points it out and asks me about it.
- imechura 14y agoYes. I do for multiple reasons
- prawn 14y agoI do it primarily as a way to track my place in the text when I scroll down the page. Or because, forever multitasking and getting distracted, I need a way to remember where I was up to.
- phillc 14y agoYep, it focuses my eyes. While pair programming, it tends to drive the other person nuts.
- etsimm 14y agoNo - but I've never used a highlighter in meatspace either.
- lalitm 14y agoYes, most certainly.
- rogerchucker 14y agoNever select text on readonly documents (like reading emails) for purposes other than copying/pasting.
- speednoise 14y agoThis habit is an example of what Chris Noessel calls "One Free Interaction"[1]. Another prominent example is the bounce on iOS scroll views. There seems to be something about being able to fidget with a UI that makes it more comfortable to use. [1] http://www.cooper.com/journal/2009/01/one_free_interaction.html http://www.cooper.com/journal/2009/01/one_free_interaction.h...
- rjzzleep 14y agono, but i'm surprised nobody brought this up yet: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-us/firefox/addon/reasy/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-us/firefox/addon/reasy/ you select text and it turns it into some speed reading format. tiny plugin and plain awesome
- r0s 14y agoInteresting, I've been developing a very similar idea independently.
- ryangallen 14y agoTo mark my place when scrolling.
- gaetan 14y agoNo, I read the whole page top-down and press the "space" key to scroll down to the next page.
- biddyco 14y agowoah, this is fascinating to me. I've never heard of someone highlighting text while reading
- ern 14y agoI used to do this quite often when reading on a laptop with an external mouse, as an alternative to scrolling, so I could see where I was, especially on single page/printer friendly views. Having an iPad and doing a lot of reading on Flipboard has "untrained" me, and I don't think I do it anymore on any platform.
- raintrees 14y agoSome HTML/CSS design decisions leave me selecting to read, if not just copying and pasting into a text editor.
- adnrw 14y ago> Yes, but for some other reason It's a compulsive habit that I can't stop, it serves no practical reason whatsoever. I also bite my nails. Same problem.
- eclipticplane 14y agoFor long articles, or content I really want to digest, I copy the text into a text file in a directory in my home space (with original URL and under git control). When I get to it, I delete the lines I've read, or add notes to follow up with more research or comments. This is all under automated git commits, so I can track my reading backlog at any point in time, and can go back to an article 6 months ago that I may have "deleted" simply by searching my automated commits.
- kellishaver 14y agoI don't do it all the time, but when I do it's usually to increase contrast, or to mark my place in long text that I'll need to come back to. I also do it to find the mouse cursor. The text cursor is thin and not always easy to find amongst a large wall of text, so I'll click and start dragging and look to where the page is highlighted in order to find it.
- kashif_hn 14y agoYes, to track my reading point and sometimes to increase contrast.
- Falling3 14y agoWe've all heard about the multitasking-induced attention problems. I tend to select and deselect text frequently as something to keep the ADD part of my brain busy.
- instakill 14y agoOnly select a sentence or two when I need to scroll back up and long page and get back to where I was reading quickly afterwards.
- Flenser 14y agoI do this too. I also sometimes do it when I scroll down a page to skim the content to see if I want to carry on reading.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- moo 14y agoEasiest way to read my comments on HN. After I've been down-voted.
- Yhippa 14y agoIn an HCI class I took over 10 years ago at university I did an eye gaze study where I was the observee. The professor noticed that I selected text as I went along to help focus on where I was reading. Good to know that there are others like me out there. I wonder if there are any practical implications for this?
- Ygg2 14y agoYeah, it is the same as me. I select paragraph so I can focus on reading it exclusively (among other things).I also didn't thought others did it. Other than allowing people to select text on your webpage, I don't see any immediate HCI implications.
- jacquesm 14y agoI do. But I'm also one of those people that will highlight text in 'real' books using a marker. I read destructively, you really don't want to be the next person in line after I'm 'done' with a textbook. And being able to permanently highlight stuff on the screen so that when I re-visit a page later and it still contains my highlights is something I miss.
- swah 14y agoTry diigo for doing that, works well enough: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/diigo-bookmark-archive-hi/oojbgadfejifecebmdnhhkbhdjaphole https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/diigo-bookmark-arc...
- 6ren 14y agoadblock the js that is triggered by highlighting (e.g. NY Times dictionary lookup).
- freedrull 14y agoI do it all the time without thinking about it. I have no idea why. Please help me. :(
- thiderman 14y agoI was once developing a message board. It had a threaded message model and a high resolution of notifications, so when entering a thread with multiple new messages, the new messages where all highlighted with a different background color. I implemented a JS feature where double click on a message body would send mark-as-read to the server via AJAX and remove the background color. When the feature entered testing, almost all the testers opposed it, as their behaviour with double clicking to select words or paragraphs they were reading was affected. The feature was never deployed.
- shn 14y agoI've been using Readability a lot for the last one year. FYI, using it ever more after I discovered that you can send the article to kindle with the stoke of a few keys (mine is Shift+Control+K)
- cnaut 14y agoI also do this to scroll the page at the same time.
- babebridou 14y agoSometimes I manipulate a touch screen when I read a long and dense text but that's just to prevent the mobile device from sleeping.
- austenallred 14y agoI do sometimes when I'm on a desktop, but other wise it slows me down way too much. And I'm rarely on a desktop.
- bmunro 14y agoI repeatedly click and drag, click and drag. I have no idea why I do it.
- misleading_name 14y agoUsually - when I'm reading - I don't have my hand on the mouse... Just they keyboard, so no... Funny how many people do... It would seem distracting to me.
- dewiz 14y agocorrelations to age and wearing glasses would be interesting
- sgornick 14y agoAnd how many also are OCD?
- okonomiyaki3000 14y agoNo I don't. I also don't move my lips while reading.
- usmanghani 14y agoNo
- sherjilozair 14y agoSo, this poll didn't tell me a simple question: do more people select text while reading or not?
- thomasd 14y agoSometimes, when the paragraph is wide, it's hard to continue reading on the same line and that interrupts and slow my reading down. I do it so that I stay on the same line. Sort of like a ruler
- noelwelsh 14y agoScience says yes: http://jeffhuang.com/Final_CursorBehavior_CHI11.pdf http://jeffhuang.com/Final_CursorBehavior_CHI11.pdf More precisely, the paper above ("No Clicks, No Problem") demonstrates that tracking cursor movements provides useful predictive value of reader interest. Selecting text is a special case of this.
- xentronium 14y ago* Contrast * Search web for highlighted terms * Open new tab with selected link (when no proper anchor provided or when I want to open some part of given link)
- Aissen 14y agoNo. It messes with my clipboard, hard. So I try not to do it, I like to have a clean clipboard history for re-use. BUT: I tend to select-all + copy any text of a form (this comment) before submitting. You never know when browser/back/website/connection is going to abandon you.
- digitalwaveride 14y agoWith reading tools like dotdotdot.me selecting text makes even sense in the longterm. building a kind of memory...
- sayhitofrank 14y agoYes, I was searching for a read it later app that allows me highlighting and saving stuff for years..
- snjha1712 14y agoYes
- markokrajnc 14y agoI used to do this several years ago. Not doing anymore. :-)
- cafard 14y agoBut I do underline, here and there.
- pyroMax 14y agoNo, but I obsessively scroll down so that the paragraph that I'm reading touches the top of the viewport. The last few paragraphs become a pain of course.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- geldedus 14y agoyes, helps me to focus on the paragraph i am reading
- ARRR 14y agoYes, to track my reading position
- axansh 14y agoYes,for intra-page bookmark
- prawks 14y agoI don't at all, but I still think it's a very interesting concept I'd love to see taken further. I almost felt bad hitting "No" because of it. Maybe I'll become a convert.
- eggoa 14y agoPeer pressure in action?
- freeduck 14y agono
- atesti 14y agoIn the days before mouse wheels, I always used selecting to scroll: If you move the mouse downwards while selecting, you'll start to scroll. This was nice until mouse wheels were invented. Nowadays I often still click the middle mouse button to enter a scroll mode where there's a cursor with arrows on the screen. Moving it scrolls. Unfortunately this feature was removed in Visual Studio 2010, but an extension brings it back.
- mcovey 14y agoI generally use the keyboard to do everything it can on the computer, including to navigate long articles. I use the arrow keys to keep whatever I'm reading near the top of the page. In fact, if there were an easy way to keyboard-navigate the entire internet, short of scrolling around with the arrow keys, I'd never touch my mouse.
- jakespencer 14y agoI just randomly select blocks of text on the screen. Usually text that I am not currently reading. I don't scroll, I don't use it to highlight where I'm reading. I just do it for fun.
- TianCaiBenBen 14y agoNo
- desslock 14y agoYep...trackpoint on Thinkpads tends to fix this problem for me.
- duncan 14y agoI select text and have osx's speech to text read it to me while i'm reading. That way I can read way more and way faster.
- demetrius 14y agoI would hate it if browsers started getting in the way with my text selection. The best thing about it is that it works almost everywhere. I don't select text when I read something in the terminal, though, only in GUI applications. I guess I don't like lines being selected completely for some reason.
- minibus 14y agoI select text to copy/paste to Twitter. So frustrating that there's no comparable CTRL/CMD + C, CTRL/CMD + V commands on Android.
- Semyaz 14y agoThe obvious reason that people do this is because of wider and wider screens. Some web pages or applications still show text that fills the width of windows. If you have to turn your head back and forth, then you are much more likely to lose your line on a large block of text. It's much easier to pick out the next line with a line marker.
- e12e 14y agoI'm always surprised people actually use the web browser in full screen. I usually divide my (23" 16:9 2048x1152) screen in at least two, sometimes three "panes". This is a lot easier to do when using a tiling window manager -- but I hardly ever use the entire screen for the browser. Still, even with just half the screen -- the browser pane is roughly equivalent to an A4 page -- way too wide for a single column of text -- so on poorly designed pages I frequently end up resizing the window to get a usable line width.
- e12e 14y agoI should add that due to RSI I use the mouse as little as possible, preferably using a tiling window manager like awsome or xmonad, and vimperator for Firefox.
- timeshifter 14y agoYes, and if you auto-deselect the text I've selected to try to prevent me from copying it, I'll copy it anyway, because screw you for interfering with your user's experience. If you try to disable right-clicking, I will disable JavaScript and right click anyway, because screw you for interfering with your user's experience. If you log what I select via AJAX, go check your logs, because I left you some colorful words, because you're an asshole.
- jankeromnes 14y agoHell no, selection is too distracting, and the margin above / under the selected text is too small to allow comfortable reading.
- dpcan 14y agoHackerNews is the only place I've ever heard of this happening :) In the "wild", I've never witnessed it once, so I'm actually curious what it means. Do you select the entire block of text you are in the process of reading? Do you drag your mouse cursor along as you read? Isn't this horribly frustrating most of the time with all bad style sheets and ad overlays and embedded ads, etc, on most big news sites?
- clueless 14y agoCoincidentally, I know of a new web service (http://amazd.com http://amazd.com) that lets you record your highlights as you're reading an article (in the most natural way I could imagine) so you can save the parts that were insightful. That's the only reason I usually highlight text when reading these days.
- davimack 14y ago1) When scrolling is erratic (due to the mouse, the browser, or what have you) and reading a long article, I highlight a word in the last-read paragraph to allow me to scroll that paragraph up and not lose it. 2) When pages have low contrast, but I don't want to say View / Style / No Style (alt+v, y, n - in firefox), I'll select the whole page. 3) When pages have extra-wide text lines without sufficient spacing between lines (i.e., they do not conform to typographical rules for reading ... for example, Hacker News comments), I'll select individual lines in order to better follow the length of the line. 4) When interrupted in reading a lengthy article, so as not to lose my place, I'll double-click (middle wheel button is keyed to double-click) my reading position to highlight just that word.
- md8 14y agoYes, stimming.