4 ms·

The irony of somebody dumping pages of Claude output into this particular GitHub issue

by kibibu 4mo ago

darkwater 4mo ago
It's really ironic how the maintainer didn't catch that and actually trusted the user that reported the issue (and clearly used a verbose agent to write all the comments)
- torben-friis 4mo ago
  I'd say sad more than ironic. It's a person accepting to engage in discussion about a technical matter and unknowingly speaking with the machine, literally.
- csmantle 4mo ago
  > the maintainer didn't catch that They actually did notice something in <https://github.com/jqwik-team/jqwik/issues/708#issuecomment-4553162327 https://github.com/jqwik-team/jqwik/issues/708#issuecomment-...>: > One short request before I go into details. Could you disclose on whose behalf you're discussing this? Just personal interest is fine, I just want to make sure that I'm not spending my time with some AI-driven company, let alone an LLM-controlled agent.
  - darkwater 4mo ago
    Yeah I read it. To which the other side moved from "we" to first person and said they are a solo developer, in a very long reply.
yubblegum 4mo ago
I thought about this. This isn't irony. The dynamic is the entire underlying professional/industry issue, imho. With advance apologies to 'rbatllet', reading the entire matter and then taking a glance at the repos of public contributions of these two developers -- and I could be wrong -- but the social/professional friction point here is someone like jlink (who clearly can code his heart out without an LLM) is getting LLM lectured by someone who gives impression of being a (relatively) junior s/w developer. I am certain this thought is at some subconscious level affecting many high performing developers.
sph 4mo ago
I'd have felt a little bad if the person complaining was a human. Hard to feel sorry for a machine, or a person that has delegated thinking to one.
vips7L 4mo ago
Personally I would have immediately closed it. If you can’t write it, I can’t read it.

The irony of somebody dumping pages of Claude output into this particular GitHub issue

by kibibu 4mo ago

The irony of somebody dumping pages of Claude output into this particular GitHub issue

It's really ironic how the maintainer didn't catch that and actually trusted the user that reported the issue (and clearly used a verbose agent to write all the comments)

torben-friis 4mo ago
I'd say sad more than ironic. It's a person accepting to engage in discussion about a technical matter and unknowingly speaking with the machine, literally.
csmantle 4mo ago
> the maintainer didn't catch that They actually did notice something in <https://github.com/jqwik-team/jqwik/issues/708#issuecomment-4553162327 https://github.com/jqwik-team/jqwik/issues/708#issuecomment-...>: > One short request before I go into details. Could you disclose on whose behalf you're discussing this? Just personal interest is fine, I just want to make sure that I'm not spending my time with some AI-driven company, let alone an LLM-controlled agent.
- darkwater 4mo ago
  Yeah I read it. To which the other side moved from "we" to first person and said they are a solo developer, in a very long reply.

yubblegum 4mo ago

I thought about this. This isn't irony. The dynamic is the entire underlying professional/industry issue, imho. With advance apologies to 'rbatllet', reading the entire matter and then taking a glance at the repos of public contributions of these two developers -- and I could be wrong -- but the social/professional friction point here is someone like jlink (who clearly can code his heart out without an LLM) is getting LLM lectured by someone who gives impression of being a (relatively) junior s/w developer. I am certain this thought is at some subconscious level affecting many high performing developers.

sph 4mo ago

I'd have felt a little bad if the person complaining was a human. Hard to feel sorry for a machine, or a person that has delegated thinking to one.

vips7L 4mo ago

Personally I would have immediately closed it. If you can’t write it, I can’t read it.