5 ms·
The Problem with the Ferrari Luce EV Offers a Lesson for Every Leader
- jeffrallen 6mo agoIt should not be a surprise that if you hire Ive to design something, it's gonna look like an iPad. It should not be a surprise that Ferrari stakeholders don't want an iPad car. This is just gross incompetence all around. Above all, Ive had an ethical responsibility to protect his clients from harming themselves by refusing the commission.
- raverbashing 6mo agoGiven it's Ive I'm surprised he didn't try to make the car as thin as possible
- Mashimo 6mo agoAnd you have to flip it over and charge it from the underside.
- imp0cat 6mo agoThe jokes practically write themselves, right? :)
- amelius 6mo agoOr make it look round: https://www.apple.com/shop/buy-airpods/airpods-max-2/starlight https://www.apple.com/shop/buy-airpods/airpods-max-2/starlig... => https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiat_Multipla https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiat_Multipla
- neogodless 6mo agoThe squircles and rounded triangles kill the interior for me.
- binarymax 6mo agoOr arbitrarily remove something that everyone takes for granted. Like the glove box or the door handles.
- shmeeed 6mo agoLet' just hope it doesn't bend.
- amelius 6mo agoI mean, if Rolex hired Apple and gotten the Apple Watch then nobody except Jony Ive would have been happy either.
- deleted 6mo ago[deleted]
- gbil 6mo agoI hope that at least they keep the one great thing from this exercise, the controls-UI bundle. Looks really great, intuitive and unique enough for the brand
- michaelteter 6mo agoI don’t possess the design vocabulary to properly roast the design, but it looks like an amateur’s first sketch at a “car of the future”. Or it look like a modern successor to the Pontiac Aztek. I can only imagine what the Italian designers have to say about it…
- madduci 6mo agoDon't worry, they are all pissed off
- Lucas12546 6mo agoWhen I first saw this car, I thought it was ugly and expensice. Look at Chinese cars, they're cheap, stylish, and comfortable. I really envy Chinese people who can buy those cars.
- Mashimo 6mo agoThe inside looks so freaking cool: https://www.ferrari.com/en-EN/auto/ferrari-luce-design https://www.ferrari.com/en-EN/auto/ferrari-luce-design Look at those tactile buttons and knobs. For cruise control and wipers. And the flip switches for Infotainment / climate. The "LUNCH" mode button that you have to pull and then shows a glowing ring. Feels 90s science fiction. I wonder if I can 3D print a replica, not sure for what yet, but I want it. It's literally inspiring for me. The outside though :(
- jonplackett 6mo agoI think all cars should have a ‘LUNCH’ button. It can be sponsored by Uber Eats and whenever you press it, it automatically orders a burger to your current GPS co-ordinates.
- shalmanese 6mo agoAmericans when describing their ideal car interior: "Imagine a burger ordering button".
- jonplackett 6mo agoIt sounds like it should be in that car Homer Simpson designed, although I guess it would order doughnuts in this case
- embedding-shape 6mo ago> Look at those tactile buttons and knobs. For cruise control and wipers. And the flip switches for Infotainment / climate. Are we looking at the same images? The steering wheel (https://ferrari-cdn.thron.com/delivery/public/image/ferrari/bc62ad44-f5e1-4f22-b3ca-b3cd56ebe557/bocxuw/std/0x0/bc62ad44-f5e1-4f22-b3ca-b3cd56ebe557?breakpoint=961&type=original https://ferrari-cdn.thron.com/delivery/public/image/ferrari/...) has a bunch of switches, yeah, but the Infotainment/climate (https://ferrari-cdn.thron.com/delivery/public/image/ferrari/b39f75f6-6829-48d6-a259-a31695d9af39/bocxuw/std/0x0/b39f75f6-6829-48d6-a259-a31695d9af39?breakpoint=961&type=original https://ferrari-cdn.thron.com/delivery/public/image/ferrari/...) seems to be all touchscreen buttons on the huge iPad-like device in the middle? Like most modern cars, it looks incredibly difficult to use and outright dangerous.
- vmsp 6mo agoWith the kind of press it’s getting, I bet this model will outsell all others made in the last 10y. I don’t remember the last time a Ferrari was on the news.
- bob001 6mo agoYes, people spend $640,000 based on some news...
- jonplackett 6mo agoAs apposed to spending it based on feels? For people who buy a Ferrari the price is not part of the equation at all. Also Ferrari’s whole game is demand and supply manipulation - there are always more people who want a Ferrari than can actually buy one. These will all sell out whatever happens.
- soco 6mo agoThat goes the other way as well: who spends 640k on a car won't care much about the opinion of influencer X on platform Y.
- dist-epoch 6mo agoExactly, everybody will instantly recognize it, like the Cybertruck. While all the other recent Ferrari's are basically a blur, I bet 95% of people could order then roughly by year.
- bob001 6mo ago> will instantly recognize it, It looks like a generic Hyundai. If not for the badge I'd have assumed it was some Chinese mid tier EV.
- m463 6mo agoThe worst thing about those kinds of EVs is the "generic alien orchestra" sounds they make in the parking lot. It is sort of bland-nonoffensive like motel 6 artwork.
- kumarvvr 6mo agoI just want to know what exactly is wrong with it? I get the history with Ferrari cars and their aesthetic and all. But it looks like what one would expect from the man who designed iPhone.
- cpursley 6mo agoIt's an overpriced Hyundai. Just because it has a Ferrari badge does not make it a Ferrari. Here's what an electric EV supercar could look like: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wlRIdLz6Juk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wlRIdLz6Juk
- monooso 6mo agoYou just identified what (some) people dislike about it. It's the disconnect between your final two sentences.
- plun9 6mo agoIt would have worked fine with a much lower price and if it were badged as an Apple car.
- topspin 6mo ago> what exactly is wrong Some chucklehead car review guy on YouTube is going to get their hands on one of these, put a Door Dash car topper on the roof and drive around town to see if anyone notices the $640k delivery vehicle. Few people will, and that's what's wrong: the entire point of Ferrari, for better or worse, going on 85+ years, is to get looks. If all the people that have ever purchased a Ferrari for its interior design vanished today, there are so few it wouldn't make a headline. The Testarossa interior was so tragically bad it probably shouldn't have been permitted by the DOT et al. Yet there it was, plastered on posters and magazine covers; a thing of dreams around the world. So only yet another case of complete disconnect between a brand and its loyalists. Not the first, and given the myopia plaguing such folk today, not the last.
- soco 6mo ago> from the man who designed iPhone How about this: techbros got their hands everywhere nowadays, so even an iconic car brand is forced to use their brainfarts? Forced by market pressure, forced by export conditions, you name it, but I cannot fathom why otherwise getting a tech guy design a car. I actually like the design, but I must agree it doesn't look Ferrari at all. Did they fire Manzoni or what?
- jrmg 6mo agoIsn’t it kinda traditional for people to say new Ferrari models are ‘ugly’ and ‘not a Ferrari’?
- hresvelgr 6mo agoThe new Toyota Prius looks better than this. I know beauty is in the eye of the beholder, but if Ferrari is being outdone on design by a common commuter vehicle it looks terrible.
- cucumber3732842 6mo agoIt's like "that's not a real Jeep real Jeeps have..." but for white collar office people.
- ahmedfromtunis 6mo agoThis is a different kind of ugly. For previous models, it was the excessive "sportiness" that sometimes made them look like a car from a mecha anime. Luce's is more of an underwhelmed look, especially with the outstanding interior design it was privileged to have that was (rightfully) overhype over the last few months. A car with that kind of an interior deserved a much bolder design.
- bob001 6mo agoIt's not ugly. It's generic. That's the problem. Ugly can be eye catching. Generic will never be. Ferrari sells eye catching.
- deleted 6mo ago[deleted]
- mellosouls 6mo agoIts ugly and not fast for its class, even compared to much cheaper cars. That's a paradigm shift for Ferrari which has always been associated with exclusive performance and beauty - and the removal of that USP is why it is seeing such pushback.
- enahs-sf 6mo ago0-60 in 2.5s — faster than a GT3RS, but slower than a 911 turbo S. I guess for north of half a million, you should be able to keep up with the german top dog.
- tobyhinloopen 6mo agoIt’s 0.4 seconds faster than a 50K Model 3 performance. At that point, does it even matter
- darkwater 6mo agoPure acceleration is not everything, especially on track. But I guess a Model S Plaid (RIP) would beat easily a Luce.
- cucumber3732842 6mo agoIt's acceleration by itself isn't noteworthy for it's class but it's a Ferrari and they don't really half ass these things. I'm sure it handles amazingly. Same reason why people buy Porche SUVs instead of 700hp Grand Cherokees (it's a fucking shame they never tossed that engine in the Journey though) or Corvettes instead of Chargers.
- bdcravens 6mo agoI know there's reasons they don't, but just take a form factor that is already loved, and stick an EV drive train in it. There's nothing about electricity that requires everything to look like something from Star Wars.
- binarymax 6mo agoThey specifically avoided this due to the center of gravity issue, as mentioned in a top gear article several days ago. The design philosophy makes sense to start from scratch - but IMO they hired the wrong designer.
- rozab 6mo agoPorsche do this and have been very successful. Speaking of Porsche, they did once design a Star Wars ship and ended up with something super generic that looked like a free sci-fi model on sketchfab. Same as this car. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wJevc8fQVEg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wJevc8fQVEg
- DeathArrow 6mo agoFerrari devalued their brand. From manufacturing luxury vehicles they are now manufacturing gadgets. If someone is interested in buying a tablet on wheels, he can shop Tesla or Xiaomi, they don't need a Ferrari.
- TheAlchemist 6mo agoHilariously, the quote that comes to my mind when reading about this monstrosity, is one from Steve Jobs "Everything around you that you call life was made up by people that were no smarter than you". Ferrari sells dreams. That's not a car anybody will dream about.
- ReDeiPirati 6mo agoI really like how you put it down! This is how I'd have imaged to be the Apple car, not a Ferrari. The "irony" of people defending this monstrosity are saying thing like "this is the type of comments of someone who cannot afford this", but they are completely missing the point. If it doesn't making people dream about it, then it's not worth of being a real Ferrari product.
- everyone 6mo agoIt's literally retro futuristic. Looks exactly like a concept car from the 80's
- DeathArrow 6mo agoThere's a reason why the top Swiss brands don't manufacture quartz watches. From some point on, people buy stories, experiences, luxury. Gadgets don't provide the same experience.
- ahoka 6mo agoThey do.
- ruicraveiro 6mo agoExcept for Breitling, Omega, Tag Heuer, ...
- DeathArrow 6mo agoTop brands like Patek Philippe, Audemars Piguet, Vacheron Constantin.
- ruicraveiro 6mo agohttps://www.patek.com/collection/movements https://www.patek.com/collection/movements https://www.jaztime.com/audemars-piguet-royal-oak-quartz-33mm-rose-gold-diamond-baguette-bezel-purple-dial-67656or-zz-1261or-01 https://www.jaztime.com/audemars-piguet-royal-oak-quartz-33m... https://www.vacheron-constantin.com/ww/en/collections/overseas/1225v-200r-h031.html https://www.vacheron-constantin.com/ww/en/collections/overse... They all include quartz watches.
- lovlar 6mo agoI had a conversation with my industrial design teacher at university once about how slight ugly and uncommon design might have a positive effect on consumer demand over time. I don’t know if there is a psychological term for that phenomena in design but I think it’s related with mere-exposure effect [1]. A design that stands out and is uncommon, will evolve a deeper relationship over time with the observer than a well-polished predictable design. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mere-exposure_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mere-exposure_effect
- dist-epoch 6mo agoBalenciaga
- servo_sausage 6mo agoThe problem is that the eFerrari looks like a slightly improved bog-standard $40k Chinese EV crossover suppository. It's not all that ugly, it just doesn't really hit any Ferrari design language, or even do something interesting enough to justify the extreme cost.
- WinstonSmith84 6mo agoThis is an uncommon design for a Ferrari, but this a very common design for commoners. What is more common than a Nissan Leaf? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nissan_Leaf https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nissan_Leaf
- dist-epoch 6mo agoThis is exactly the Innovator Dilemma at work. Ferarri took the bold action to not be tied with it's past. One of their director explicitly said they used an external design company to intentionally to avoid a minor refinement of its ICE cars. They knew how this car will be perceived, if only because surely there must have been fierce internal resistance.
- randomNumber7 6mo ago"Know your place" is what came to my mind when I looked at this. I get that they think about going away from the combustion engine, but as a manufacturer of insanely expensive, loud and overpowerd sports car this doesn't make sense. It's like if I as a software dev would be worried about the future market and suddenly advertise myself as a psychologist in search for clients.
- Sweepi 6mo agoRegarding "The exterior looks like an iPad since Jony Ive designed it": Marc Newson is also on the team, and there striking similarities to (t)his 27 year old concept car[1]: https://marc-newson.com/ford-021c-concept-car/ https://marc-newson.com/ford-021c-concept-car/ Regarding the UI: This is miles ahead of any other digital cockpit made by Ferrari. Also pretty good overall. [1] via https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48271629#48278841 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48271629#48278841
- danbruc 6mo agoIgnore that car, but what is this? This is a brand that permanently banned Paris Hilton for painting her Ferrari pink, Kim Kardashian for modifying her 458, and Justin Bieber for wrapping his in neon blue. Where does that fall on the line between your product, your rules and I bought the thing, I own it, I paint it blue? My gut reaction was that this should totally not be legal, neither telling people how to paint their car, nor telling them what [not] to do with it, or to which places they can take it, seriously? And also banning people from buying one to enforce this.
- xethos 6mo agoFerrari's done this for... I don't know how long. Hilton bought one, she owned it, and she painted it pink. That's all legal. Then Ferrari fired her as a customer - also legal. You missed out on the more egregious (IMO) points about having to buy certain "entry" Ferraris to be allowed to buy the rarer ones too.
- danbruc 6mo agoWhat if they reject a customer not because of their wrong Ferrari color but their wrong skin color? I am not saying that they are the same thing, but there are probably acceptable and unacceptable reasons for rejecting a customer. And to me painting a Ferrari pink seems to be pretty far on the unacceptable side.
- xethos 6mo agoLegally, "Pink Ferrari owners" are not a protected class, and Ferrari's legally in the clear here. Morally... I dunno. Telling a customer they're not worth the headache is something I'm generally on the side of, so long as the goods being sold are entirely optional. Once again, Ferrari's in the clear. A Lamborghini may not be exactly the same, but they're wildly different goods they are not. And as lazy a counter it is: If you disagree, you're more than welcome to start your own luxury car brand. That's even how Lamborghini got their start - to knock Ferrari down a peg
- TheChaplain 6mo ago
- thefz 6mo agoI am Italian. I recognize Ferrari is one of our most iconic and exported brands. Also I could not give any less fucks about the new Ferrari, the fact that it's ugly, the fact that it's probably going to tank or be a hit. They and their products are so detached from the lives of 99.9999999% of the population. Also, what do you expect from a guy that used to design computer mice.
- xtiansimon 6mo agoI don’t see the “face” in the design. Is this a break from that tradition?
- bborud 6mo agoI didn't know Jony Ive was involved. That may explain why it looks so disappointing. Jony Ive is a brilliant example of the role selection plays in evolutionary processes. It is the sorting method that punishes bad ideas with death and allows good ideas to survive. After Jobs passed away the selection mechanism that only let Ive's good ideas pop through disappeared. It is popular to accuse Jobs of credit hoarding, but in that relationship he was the talent. Ive just someone who could generate ideas for him to choose from. More than a mutation agent, less than a good designer. What makes Ive bad for Ferrari is that he operates under the delusion that he is a great designer. This makes him arrogant. Arrogance paired with mediocrity isn't the best of combinations. And Ive sans Jobs is mediocre on a good day. But his myth is persistent. Ferrari has a long history. Ive completely ignored it and designed a mediocre bar of soap. If he did so out of an abundance of arrogance, or simply because he actually doesn't understand Ferrari is unclear. But it is an undeniable fact that the car neither looks like a Ferrari, nor is it a particularly elegant car. If you saw it without knowing what it was you could be forgiven for thinking this was a more modestly priced asian mass market car. For admirers of a brand that aspires to make iconic cars this is, of course, a disappointment. I did like the instrument cluster though. It dials back the somewhat childish and gaudy displays that sports car manufacturers have offered for the past couple of decades and replaces it with something that is more tastefully retro. A lot of older Italian cars had beautiful dashboards that give off strong race car vibes. (for instance the Bertone-designed Alfa Romeo GTV from the late 60s and early 70s - those had gorgeous instrument clusters)
- rumori 6mo agoI think Ive deserves some respect. His portfolio makes it clear what type of car he will design, same with Newson. It’s Ferrari’s leadership that has to be held accountable for the decision, my guess is they wanted to break into a brand new demographic. Many say it should have been a sub-brand, for some reason they didn’t use that option. I don’t lien the car’s look, but also don’t hate it. Let’s see it on the road, get some review on the comfort etc. I honestly think it will be all fine, once the current wave of criticism blows over.
- bborud 6mo ago
- pnexk 6mo agoI wish there was an article on this matter that wasn’t written like a capitalist industrial consumer taste manufacturing piece. Takes longer to get to the point too, but that’s just me.
- 6stringmerc 6mo agoAlso relevant: the “swallow my pride and do this for the clicks” videos in the day of release that YouTubers began posting once the embargo was lifted. It was obvious no matter what they actually thought they were going to toe the line Ferrari wanted. Sad but hey, lie with pigs expect to get dirty…
- gilbetron 6mo agoCharging it is an interesting choice: https://drive.google.com/file/d/13-ZdXDJTIfhe1vkAuzssvRx9bOQ7oreG/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/13-ZdXDJTIfhe1vkAuzssvRx9bOQ...
- juancn 6mo agoThe interior design by Jony Ive is outstanding. The perfect mix of tactile controls and mechanical needles with the screens feels revolutionary. I expect others will follow replicating some of the ideas.
- m463 6mo agothe (moving) turn signal buttons suck. and why paddles? I thought EVs didn't need gears? EDIT: "paddles on the steering wheel control regenerative braking and torque delivery."
- em-bee 6mo agothe gist of the article is that people don't like change. and the lesson is: don't change your style, because your fans will hate you. even star trek felt that lesson. the backslash they are getting in recent years is disturbing. but ferrari is arrogant too: "This is a brand that permanently banned Paris Hilton for painting her Ferrari pink, Kim Kardashian for modifying her 458, and Justin Bieber for wrapping his in neon blue." WAT? how dare someone tell me what i do with my car. but back to the argument: people don't like change. but change is inevitable. sure, some change is objectively bad, but we are talking about style here. get over it. if you don't like it, don't buy it. the article argues that the problem is not the switch to electric, but how the car makes you feel. i'd argue that electric feeling different is unavoidable. the article fails to show an example that does this better. the tesla example is unfair because tesla didn't have an existing brand image to follow. they could start from scratch. if the luce looks like a car designed by apple, that's obviously no surprise. it will certainly appeal to apple fans. so to me the lesson is this: don't change your brand, or it will hurt, if you want to innovate, create a new brand. but the consequence is also that if brands can not change they will eventually have to die and be replaced. that is not new, we have known this for some time now. but i want to ask: is it possible to break out of that cycle? only if we teach people to be more open to change. and if we teach them to stop complaining about things that don't concern them. go complain about the cybertruck, that thing is objectively ugly. or about SUVs, they have no place in the city. but complaining that the luce does not fit the ferrari brand should be left to those that actually buy from ferrari.
- ChrisArchitect 6mo agoRelated: Ferrari shares fall after launch of first EV as Jony Ive design proves divisive https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48282034 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48282034 Ferrari Luce https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48271629 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48271629
- JumpinJack_Cash 6mo ago[flagged]
- JumpinJack_Cash 6mo agoThe tree huggers ruin everything they touch. Bezos is right, things are either contracting or expanding...the saving and conserving energy to extend the runaway will only lead those who do to perverted and depressed outcomes. Such as this monstruosity