4 ms·
Why's this poorly written piece on top of HN?
by ismepornnahi 6mo ago
Why's this poorly written piece on top of HN?
- trollbridge 6mo agoI rather enjoyed it. I also enjoyed reading something that did not give me the immediate impression it was AI generated.
- linkregister 6mo ago"Write a snarky, cynical opinion piece about Google in the style of Lewis Black." The Opus 4.7 output was remarkably similar to the content in this blog.
- alexgieg 6mo agoI noticed it as LLM-written by the middle of the second paragraph. The text is filled with classic rhetorical structures LLMs love making, especially the "it isn't X, it's Y" and "not A, not B, not C, but D" patterns.
- lemontheme 6mo agoIt’s the repetitive paragraph structure that raised my suspicions. Sentence. Short sentence. Noun. Noun. Noun. Sentence to reflect. Wrap it up in a bow. Sequences of short incomplete sentences, particularly in threes is such a tell
- deleted 6mo ago[deleted]
- amazingamazing 6mo agohate pieces tend to rank highly. better if it's hating on big co
- jeffbee 6mo agoWhy is the cat in the catnip again?
- ryanisnan 6mo agoWhat makes you say that it was poorly written? I actually quite enjoyed it. I don't know if that says more about the writing, or me. In english lit as a high-school student, I always thought I did reasonably well on my assignments, but consistently got C's. It was very infuriating.
- deleted 6mo ago[deleted]
- benhurmarcel 6mo agoIt has a good title