4 ms·
Any distribution system where human examiner is involved is prone to corruption. Doubt it worked that smooth back then either.
by varjag 14y ago
Any distribution system where human examiner is involved is prone to corruption. Doubt it worked that smooth back then either.
- kinghajj 14y agoIt's worse than that, the exams were pointless because they only tested knowledge of Confucianism.
- seanmcdirmid 14y agoThey were useful as filters, if somewhat crude. The tests were partly responsible for advancements in Chinese civilization.
- continuations 14y agoThat's not any different from today's liberal arts degrees, which have nothing to do with the careers most people end up going into.
- wisty 14y agoThe difference being the Confucianists got jobs which they didn't deserve.
- dietrichepp 14y agoI know you're trying to say that testing for Confucianism is not the same as testing for how well you can do a government post, but these weren't worthless tests. 1) Passing old Chinese tests required literacy, something we want bureaucrats to have. This is a big chunk of what liberal arts degrees are about. (Calligraphy, too, was included in the test.) 2) Studying Confucianism meant that you at least had to think and respond about moral and ethical matters. Again, I'd rather have a bureaucrat who has thought about morality and ethics than one who hasn't. And according to Wikipedia, > The core of Confucianism is humanism, the belief that human beings are teachable, improvable and perfectible through personal and communal endeavour especially including self-cultivation and self-creation. 3) People with liberal arts degrees quite often take posts that are entirely unrelated to their field of study. Saying that "Confucianists got jobs which they didn't deserve" is just a pathetic jab at Chinese culture.
- continuations 14y agoAs opposed to liberal arts majors becoming government bureaucrats?
- jimworm 14y agoVery true. My partner is currently a schoolteacher in China, and has to go through regular examinations. However if a teacher does not have a politically powerful background, or fails to bribe the appropriate contacts, the result is guaranteed failure and missed promotion opportunities.