10 ms·
Richard stallman has always been eccentric and unwavering in his stand on politics around software. Somehow, people find this odd, wrong, and or bad, and I don
by belorn 14y ago
Richard stallman has always been eccentric and unwavering in his stand on politics around software.
Somehow, people find this odd, wrong, and or bad, and I dont understand it. On basically all political issues, unwavering is a good attribute. Even being an eccentric is better than not caring for the issue. eccentricness is often a key aspect before a change reach a critical mass.
Take a random politician opinion about abortion or nuclear power or any other common political subject. Say his/her opinion is "well, some should be able to do it, but then again there are problems so maybe not, and the issue is not one that need to be address today, and the system today do continue to work, and well, legal greyness is not that big of an issue, only for those in the courts...".
Clear, direct, and consistent opinion is a good thing. Diplomacy and "meeting half-way" has it places, but in politics, there is also times when it should be clearly avoided. In software politics, there are plenty of people working the diplomatic route. There is no shortage of diplomats, and a few eccentric and unwavering voices is then much more useful to maintain the goals of where we want to actually go without moving the goal in favor of diplomacy.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Nursie 14y agoI weirdly agree and disagree with you :) Stallman's ethical and philosophical approach is awesome, and his unwavering stand behind those things is also. I don't agree with everything the man says, but I agree with a lot of it and it's clear he's thought it all through. I really, really, really hate this when applied to politicians though, because they ought to change their positions based on evidence. When they're crowing about how unwavering they are it's usually because they're flying in the face of common sense and raw, obvious fact.
- Tyrannosaurs 14y agoThis comes down to what the basis for beliefs are - as the quote goes you're entitled to your own opinion, you're not entitled to your own facts. Politicians are an odd breed though. By the time you've made it to elected office you've almost certainly had your beliefs and how (or even whether) you can express them so warped that I almost think it's unfair to hold what they say against them. They're the product of a screwed up system - most of them are (or were) smart principled individuals until they got too close to government.
- danso 14y ago> On basically all political issues, unwavering is a good attribute. Only in the movies. In real life, this trait can be disastrous towards making any progress for the betterment of society.
- tankbot 14y ago> Only in the movies. You mean the movies made about people who were unwavering in real life? Gandhi, MLK, Lincoln are a few high-profile figures that spring to mind, but there are countless throughout history who have made a difference by standing up for what they believe in. I understand your point, that romanticized notions rarely have a place in reality. But I think Stallman, even with all of his eccentricities, is the perfect figurehead for these ideologies. He is a believer, and that gives others permission to believe themselves. It's a very powerful thing.
- jfb 14y agoThe idea that Lincoln was some kind of ideological purist is utter nonsense.
- tankbot 14y agoTrue. I almost didn't include Lincoln because of this. But even if Lincoln hated black people outright (highly unlikely), history remembers him (somewhat incorrectly) as a believer in human rights. In reality he was probably just trying to hold the U.S. together and prevent the South's succession. But if this is the case, then it was his belief in his country that motivated him and that qualifies Lincoln as a believer. In my mind that was enough to not delete his name after typing it. :)
- luser001 14y agoI used to think this until I read book The Long Pursuit. It's highly likely that Lincoln thought slavery was intrinsically bad. It's a thin-ish book and I highly recommend it. http://www.amazon.com/The-Long-Pursuit-Lincolns-Thirty-Year/dp/B001PO6AZY http://www.amazon.com/The-Long-Pursuit-Lincolns-Thirty-Year/...
- rimantas 14y ago> On basically all political issues, unwavering is a good > attribute If nothing changes, then yes. If situation changes and your stance does not, it may indicate less desirable things. I'd understand Stallman's position in the world few decades ago, when almost all software was by developers for developers. In todays world it is bordering on absurd (imho).
- coldpie 14y agoWhy, exactly? If you buy a piece of software and uncover a bug, why shouldn't you be able to pay someone to fix it? As a consumer, why wouldn't you demand this?
- astrodust 14y agoI, for one, still oppose putting these "horseless carriages" on our roadways! The dangers of these contraptions are far from understood!
- tedivm 14y ago>On basically all political issues, unwavering is a good attribute. The complete inability to compromise is the defining point of the republican party. I don't consider this to be a good attribute at all.
- ajross 14y agoRMS is an activist, not a party. If you were to hand him control of the house of representatives, indeed, he's be pretty damaging. That doesn't mean his ideas are wrong. I spent years in the "the FSF are unrealistic nuts standing in the way of open source" camp too. The problem, looking back on those years, is that RMS was right about pretty much everything that mattered. I give him a lot of slack these days in my personal judgements, and the occasional shouting match with a law professor seems like a small price to pay.
- pnathan 14y agoI have had a similar journey. Over the last decade, I've moved from a "MIT License" stance to a "AGPL3 License" stance. Stallman has been too right about too much for me not to change.
- jeremyjh 14y agoI want to hear more about that. I think the Apache license has been incredibly successful. Sure certain companies have taken httpd or other products and rebranded and tried to sell them but they never approach the popularity of the community supported branch - at least not for any product I can think of. I also agree the GPL has been very successful and neither provide a counter-example that disproves the benefits offered by both models.
- pnathan 14y agoThe simple answer is that software has social value, and that it ethically ought be modifiable by its users. Two key things have driven my desires for a GPL world. (1) Reading about historical software now unavailable and (2) working in the corporate world as a tools developer. The question is pretty much, are you weighing the distributor's freedom more than the user's freedom? When you want someone to be able to use your program and not publish their fixes, MIT-style licenses become more your style. This is preferred by corporations, AFAICT. However, when you want the end user to be able to modify software and to be able to trust the software, you start wanting the GPL world. Of course, the idea of a typical non-technical user doing technical work is illogical. But with the GPL, they have the freedom to hire people to do technical work. That can be really important for things like crypto! Another way to consider the situation is that the GPL enables viral transmission, and more broadly, forcibly enables a survival of the fittest. If software is really good and GPL, it'll get used, and the users must publish to their users, and so forth. So good software can now survive longer, perhaps after its starting point's death. This in particular struck home with me when I was reading of the software systems from the '50s and '60s. They were doing things then that were not to be done for decades. As a social value, some of those old software systems would have been tremendous. I'd like to build on old & reliable stuff, not reinvent the wheel! A concrete way to approach this idea is to consider infrastructure tooling. I write that, every day. It's my job. Sometimes I ask myself: Don't a hundred other companies already do this? What if software licenses were so written as to require these tools to also be published? We've been able to publish one Mercurial extension, and it has been a great experience. But what if we did that with everything? I wish all the companies that developed infrastructure opened their source and worked with each other to build a common world of amazing. The GPL style license is key, because it requires this republishing thing. Under the GPL, sharing becomes required. And then someone else can build on that, and they must also share their additions. That's the kind of world I want to live in. Not a world where we guard our little towers replicating each other's work time after time. We can go do different things, safe in the knowledge that in the common areas, improvements will be published and worked on by all. edit: With respect to RMS- In particular, his short story Right to Read really hit home with me when I read it in 2008 or so. I have read one or two other things by him from the... 90s I think... that really indicated he understands the logical outworkings of certain processes, as his predictions came to pass in the late '00s. I figure if you're going to agree with someone, you had best agree with someone who seems to be proven right. :-)
- mkr-hn 14y ago"Unwavering" is a good prefix for a lot of things. "Unwavering advocate for software freedom" is good. "Unwavering support for free software projects" is another. "Unwavering asshole" is the part that causes problems.
- rogerbinns 14y agoQuite frankly that is the worst possible thing. For some bizarre reason we expect politicians to have an opinion, never change it and be right. I'd much rather a politician update their opinions based on new information, evidence and research that comes in. Slavishly sticking to something despite changes in information, evidence and research is really stupid.
- eggnet 14y agoUnwavering means not constantly changing the weight you give to specific pros and cons which ultimately results in changing your mind about the main issue in question. It is the opposite of indecisive. You are confusing unwavering with stubborn. A stubborn person would not react to new evidence that invalidates their beliefs. An unwavering person would.
- jeremyjh 14y agoThis sounds good at first, but I don't know how to apply it since I do not have access to information about the "weighting" a political figure assigns to particular values. The only information I have relates to the outcomes of their decision process: speechs they give, statements they make to media (or reported by media), bills they sponsor, their voting record, etc. Because this is all political theater, I don't even really know what they are actually trying to do by making these statements, these votes, etc. So there are at least two layers of obfuscation between the ideas a person holds sacred and my ability to measure those things. The result, is that when we say a political figure is unwavering, we really just mean that these little plays they act out for us always have the same theme. Even if their beliefs change they cannot afford to rewrite their own character in the middle of the scene. That would just be confusing. Better to bring in a new character entirely.
- arrrg 14y agoI think Stallman’s moral worldview is wrong and misguided. That’s why I disagree with him. I also think that unwavering stubbornness is a negative trait, not a positive one, but that is rather secondary.
- specialist 14y agoStallman is an ultimatist. Just like the NRA, ACLU, NARAL, BBV, etc. His role is to yank the Overton Window back towards rationality. Meaning his job is to create the space for a more constructive policy debate. Stallman is not a politician or a diplomat. Nor should he be. Trading horses and compromise is someone else's problem.
- belorn 14y agoAgree. I used politician to mean a person with views and driving force around political issues, and not specifically a career negotiator. Ultimatist is a good technical term for the role he commonly occupies.
- justin66 14y ago> Richard stallman has always been eccentric and unwavering in his stand on politics around software. Somehow, people find this odd, wrong, and or bad, and I dont understand it. "Eccentric" is synonymous with "odd". It would be irrational if people somehow found him eccentric and not odd.
- dllthomas 14y agoUnwavering philosophy, in the face of shifts in opinion: good, provided the philosophy was something we approve of in the first place. Unwavering opinions, in the face of shifts in the situation: bad. Sometimes, it's hard to distinguish the two. There's a separate, important question of how much to prioritize strategy versus tactics. Probably, we need some people to keep an eye on each, but unfortunately infighting can get bitter.
- pessimizer 14y agoThe situation doesn't seem to have changed, other than the SaaS loophole which was accounted for in GPLv3.
- dllthomas 14y agoYour comment doesn't seem grounded in reality. The situation has changed tremendously since rms started the GNU project. I own my own computer, and so does (literally?) every single person I know. The internet makes sharing with these people (and with people they know, and with strangers) trivial. At the outset, rms made money selling copies of GPL software for $150 each! The situation has changed! Now, whether it has changed in a way that makes the positions held by rms less relevant or appropriate is quite another question. It sounds to me like you read my comment as some kind of attack on rms: it was not intended to be anything of the kind; I very much value the man's input to our collective discourse, and tend to agree with him more than not.
- pessimizer 14y ago>whether it has changed in a way that makes the positions held by rms less relevant or appropriate is quite another question It's the only relevant question in this thread. I'm sure that there's been some global temperature change since the GPL was come up with, but I'd like to hear a case about why it matters.
- dllthomas 14y agoSo, let's address it explicitly: predominately, I would say that these changes have made his positions more relevant, but I am not confident that I'm not missing things. A lot has changed in highly pertinent areas.
- demallien 14y agoActually, I don't know about his stance being 'unwavering'. The iconic story of why he got into the whole free software things to start with was because he wanted to modify the source code of a laser printer, which is surely not a general purpose computing device. He appears to have stepped away from arguing that he should have access to firmware... Either that or he thinks that firmware should be patentable, but that you should be allowed to freely modify and distribute it anyway, which kind of defeats the purpose of patenting it.
- Shorel 14y agoWe simply dislike the GPL (for our projects) because we want to use more permissive licenses. He wants everyone to only use the GPL and ignore everything that's not GPL, he even dislikes the term 'Open Source' and the rest of the Libre licenses. That's a clash of interests and the reason for our dislike.