5 ms·
Yup. That was the first line that stuck out to me too and prompted me to come over to HN and comment. Innovation is happening at a breakneck pace despite softw
by malandrew 14y ago
Yup. That was the first line that stuck out to me too and prompted me to come over to HN and comment.
Innovation is happening at a breakneck pace despite software patents because everyone is just ignoring them and inventing anyways.
The patents do damage after the fact, killing good tech jobs by diverting money from engineering and R&D to the zero-sum game of patent litigation that just leaves society as a whole poorer.
TBH, I don't know how many entrepreneurs opt out of entrepreneurship due to the risk of being sued down the line, but I doubt that it is very high. Most of the entrepreneurs worried about patent litigation will just start amassing a patent portfolio of their own as a defensive strategy. The end result of that game is less progress since innovation efforts are diverted to patent defense efforts.
I don't know about everyone else here, but I would love a conversation on a national scale to discuss jobs that don't move the country and humanity forward, but just move cash from one pocket to another without benefitting anyone but the people moving the money. Wall street financial innovations, patent litigation and the TSA are just three examples of areas that have experienced job growth in the past 20 years (even with the 2008 meltdown), but that do little to nothing to improve the human condition. For some reason, the more we automate jobs and increase the productivity of the American worker, the more we divert our attention to creating jobs that don't add value.
- dllthomas 14y ago"[T]he zero-sum game [...] leaves society as a whole poorer." That's not zero-sum.
- Avenger42 14y agoThe lawyers are getting richer.
- nealabq 14y agoDavid Kappos was an IP lawyer at IBM before moving to the Patent Office. He's an insider who has benefited from and built a career around IP litigation. I'm sure he sees his profession as worthy and noble. Certainly not parasitic and destructive. A stout defender of the status quo. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Kappos http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Kappos
- chrismcbride 14y agoBetween the firms fighting its zero-sum. Everyone spends a lot of money acquiring a large patent portfolio for defense. No one wins or loses. But overall it is a misallocation of capital. All that money and human resources could be spent on further innovation.
- zanny 14y agoIt is still a loss, because you are spending capital on patents you should be spending on innovation. It is a complete black hole of investment because nothing positive comes out of software patents, in the end they just feed lawyers, who are producing no benefit to society as a result of it. It is the same reasoning why paying people to dig holes and fill them in isn't actually economically stimulating. If the fruits of labors expended serve no practical purpose, they are an effective money sink that slows down the economy.
- dllthomas 14y agoRegarding the first part, that is very much true for money spent litigating patents. It is not necessarily the case for money spent to purchase patents, which in theory is going (directly or indirectly) to people who are innovating (assuming the patents are actually innovative and useful).
- chii 14y ago> money spent to purchase patents, which in theory is going (directly or indirectly) to people who are innovating (assuming the patents are actually innovative and useful). unfortunately, the patents purchased are not likely to be useful (in the sense that the creation of that patent brought value), and i think this is especially true in software patents. I say so because i expect that those patents purchased are already used by various software engineers (probably unknowingly). The creation of those patents did not add value, due to the fact that no creative forces were involved. In a real arms race, the race to produce weapons might induce economic activity because metal needs mining, manufacturing and jobs. This does stimulate the economy, and you can construe that theres some benefit to be had. For software patents, it does not stimulate anything! Perhaps lawyers who gets paid drafting it, but actual creative output isn't there, and so it is a net drain to even create the patent.
- TerraHertz 14y ago"jobs that don't move the country and humanity forward, but just move cash from one pocket to another without benefiting anyone but the people moving the money." The accumulation of such 'societal overheads', as entrenched systems act to grab more resources for themselves at the expense of everyone else, is a common factor in all civilizations. Specifically, it's a common factor in the process that ultimately leads to the collapse of complex societies. Read the book 'Collapse of complex societies' by Tainter. It's a study of failed human societies throughout history, and the common factors in their process of collapse. Yes, it turns out there is a single, driving common factor. Complex societies go into violent, chaotic and permanent collapse, at the point when their available resources (of all kinds, including manpower, energy, knowledge, food, water, etc) become less than the resources required to maintain the social infrastructure. At that point there's a rapid structural implosion, with failing infrastructure leading to inability to allocate resources to maintain the infrastructure - a positive feedback process that bites hard. Usually, almost everyone dies. The snowball can begin when some external challenge requires an extra expenditure of resources - which are not available. Or it can begin simply because the social structure grows too complicated and parasitic, thus exceeding physical limits. Human societies almost never seem to be able to collectively say "hey, we don't need all this useless crap, let's simplify!" The patent system, copyright, and indeed most if not all of the Federal Government and related structures like the Federal Reserve Bank (three things it actually isn't) as they are now,are all examples of wasteful, parasitic overheads with net negative benefit to American society. Which are major factors bringing society closer to systemic collapse. The energy crisis is rapidly lowering the 'available resources' ceiling, while all these parasitic, self-serving layers of social/legal complexity are inexorably raising the required resource expenditure. Maybe these lines on the graph have already crossed - there's some inertia and lag in this process, but it's still a mathematical reality that can't ultimately be avoided. Personally, I consider the entire legal framework of corporate personhood, stock holding and the abstractions of social responsibility, finance and control that creates, to be another massive layer of harmful complexity. Creating 'inhuman' immortal entities which then grow to direct most of society's resources and control most of the media and government structures, seems like a very, very bad mistake. The present insane state of the patent and copyright systems is merely a side effect of that more fundamental error. By now the entire corrupt, self-serving octopus of corporate/government parasitism is probably too entrenched to 'simplify' back to a sensible, workable level via methods available within the existing system. Personally, I'd say the optimal level for such things would be 'gone entirely'. I'm aware most would not agree. I've also long felt that without a second American Revolution, there's no chance of making any progress in cutting back these existence-threatening layers of self-serving complexity. Lately it seems like I'm not so entirely alone in that view.