4 ms·
It's also important to note that you consent to the search by choosing to travel by air in the United States.
by philwelch 14y ago
It's also important to note that you consent to the search by choosing to travel by air in the United States.
- michaelfeathers 14y agoIf someone feels that they can tell me what I consent to, they do not understand the meaning of the word consent.
- tptacek 14y agoYou can not walk up to the security checkpoint at the airport. To see why this matters, imagine that the TSA could, as soon you bought a ticket, search you in your home. The police can actually do that, if they have a warrant.
- lambda 14y agoThere is a difference between "consent" and "putting up with because you want something else more." I generally have a greater need to fly than to avoid being felt up. This does not mean I consent to being felt up. The fact that the Supreme Court mistakes this for consent bothers me greatly.
- awj 14y agoNot in this case there isn't. You showing up at the airport and going through security is implied consent to the search, just like opening the door to them without explicitly denying consent is enough for police to legally enter your house.
- michaelfeathers 14y agoThat's merely because the concept of consent has become polluted. Anyone who wants to know what I consent to has to ask me.
- flyinRyan 14y ago>just like opening the door to them without explicitly denying consent is enough for police to legally enter your house. That's another example of where the US fails on human rights.
- philwelch 14y agoThat's like saying I consent to have the sandwich you made but I don't consent to give you money for it, therefore you the sandwich shop owner are robbing me. You analyze the cost-benefit and consent to the whole package. You can't pick and choose.
- lambda 14y agoNo, nothing like that. I do not have a constitutionally protected right to eat a sandwich. I do have one to be free from unreasonable search and seizure. Furthermore, with the sandwich, there are alternatives available to me. I can choose to go somewhere else that serves cheaper sandwiches, or make my own. There are some places that I just cannot get to without flying; and some for which getting there would take so long as to be completely impractical, thereby cutting me off from a large swath of possible activity if I do not "consent" to being touched in the nether bits. Their argument is like saying that by walking into a fraternity, a woman consents to being groped. Hey, maybe they even put up a sign saying "we grope women who enter here." That argument does not make it consent. Furthermore, you are not able to remove your consent once you reach the head of the line. At may airports, they subject only some passengers to having nude photos taken of them by x-ray (or groping if you don't consent to the backscatter). But at the point when you get to the head of the line and find out if you're lucky, you are not able to leave in order to avoid the search; they have arrested people for trying to do so. There are certain ways to coerce people to create an illusion of consent; but that shouldn't be confused with actual consent.
- philwelch 14y ago> I do not have a constitutionally protected right to eat a sandwich Nor do you have a constitutionally protected right to air travel.
- coin 14y agoNot a constitutional right, but one granted by public law. http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/49/40103 http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/49/40103 "A citizen of the United States has a public right of transit through the navigable airspace." I choose to exercise that right by paying an airline to transport me by air.
- mikeash 14y agoIf this really were the doctrine under which these searches were instituted, wouldn't there have to be a situation where the search procedures are fixed at the point where you bought your ticket, and they can't spring surprises on you by changing procedures between purchase and travel? Maybe I'm being unreasonable, but if the idea is that you implicitly consent when you sign up, then it seems like they should not then be able to change what you consented to later.
- tptacek 14y agoThat's not the doctrine the searches fall under.
- mikeash 14y agoSo then what does it mean that "you consent to the search by choosing to travel by air in the United States"?
- tptacek 14y agoExactly that? Consent isn't what enables the search, but it's still good that the TSA can't raid your house. What enables the search is (i) no investigative intent and (ii) no discretion on the part of the searchers as to who to search.
- sneak 14y agohttp://articles.latimes.com/2011/dec/20/nation/la-na-terror-checkpoints-20111220 http://articles.latimes.com/2011/dec/20/nation/la-na-terror-...
- tptacek 14y agoI remember that consent/voluntarism being important to the lawfulness of airport searches, but I thought the big two elements of administrative search were (1) searches not being intended to collect evidence for criminal investigations and (2) officers not having discretion as to who to search.
- jpxxx 14y agoNegatory. Consent is not relevant in the case of airports, per the 3rd and 9th circuit courts. http://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-9th-circuit/1265662.html http://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-9th-circuit/1265662.html
- enjo 14y agoThat's such a bad argument. I do no such thing. However, the reality of my profession requires me to fly. So I "consent" only under considerable duress. The choice is literally "put food on the table" or submit to incredibly intrusive security. That's not consent, that's coercion.
- danielweber 14y agoThere are good arguments against "automatic consent" but this isn't one of them. You consent to lots of things by driving on public roads, yet many people's livelihoods depend on driving on public roads. It doesn't mean that the consent for driving wasn't given.
- jackpirate 14y agoThe choice is literally "put food on the table" or submit to incredibly intrusive security. No it's not. You can quit and get a new job. If you can't immediately find a new job, you will be on unemployment and food stamps. You will literally still have food on the table. Edit: by quit I meant don't get on the plane, resulting in being fired
- settrans 14y agoWhere would you be eligible for unemployment after voluntarily quitting?
- r00fus 14y agoAh, the clickwrap and EULA argument. I hated it back in the 90s when it was introduced.
- darkarmani 14y agoThat's like saying you consent by leaving your house. I guess you also think the airlines consent to having the TSA search their customers? I'd love it if airlines could opt-out. Let the market decide who thinks it is a risk. They could charge more money for the privilege of flying unmolested.