3 ms·

Exactly

rvz 5mo ago
This is exactly how Anthropic will market this rewrite towards companies thinking about doing more layoffs. 1 person did a rust rewrite that took 6 days that would have taken hundreds of engineers more than a year to do.
- baq 5mo ago
  The saving grace here is a rewrite of a project with a good test suite is the sweet spot: LLMs are great at translation and do great with verifiable goals. I agree it’s still mind blowing compared to before times, though.
- xienze 5mo ago
  > 1 person did a rust rewrite that took 6 days that would have taken hundreds of engineers more than a year to do. Even cheaper would just be to not do it in the first place. Was there a pressing need to rewrite it?
- Dylan16807 5mo ago
  > would have taken hundreds of engineers more than a year This is estimating what, 10 lines per day each? No way translating code is anywhere near that slow.
- Aurornis 5mo ago
  > 1 person did a rust rewrite that took 6 days that would have taken hundreds of engineers more than a year to do. The entire bun team was only about a dozen people and they wrote it from scratch. It would not take hundreds of engineers to port the existing codebase to another language. I think this is a cool experiment, but some of these claims are getting absurd.
- 59nadir 5mo ago
  It probably wouldn't take a single person who knew what they were doing more than a year to re-implement Bun in basically anything, by hand and from scratch, i.e. not even looking at source. Writing the code for something you already understand and have built before is incredibly fast. I'm sure they'll market what you said, but it's so ridiculous that I would hope people would see through this stuff.
- slopinthebag 5mo ago
  The majority of Bun was written by one guy in less than a year. In what world would a rewrite take hundreds of engineers more than a year to do? The hyperbole is getting ridiculous.
- seanclayton 5mo ago
  And he has zero idea how it works. His capacity for understanding it is tied to his wallet now.
  - Kwpolska 5mo ago
    It's actually tied to his employment at Anthropic.

Exactly

rvz 5mo ago

This is exactly how Anthropic will market this rewrite towards companies thinking about doing more layoffs. 1 person did a rust rewrite that took 6 days that would have taken hundreds of engineers more than a year to do.

baq 5mo ago
The saving grace here is a rewrite of a project with a good test suite is the sweet spot: LLMs are great at translation and do great with verifiable goals. I agree it’s still mind blowing compared to before times, though.
xienze 5mo ago
> 1 person did a rust rewrite that took 6 days that would have taken hundreds of engineers more than a year to do. Even cheaper would just be to not do it in the first place. Was there a pressing need to rewrite it?
Dylan16807 5mo ago
> would have taken hundreds of engineers more than a year This is estimating what, 10 lines per day each? No way translating code is anywhere near that slow.
Aurornis 5mo ago
> 1 person did a rust rewrite that took 6 days that would have taken hundreds of engineers more than a year to do. The entire bun team was only about a dozen people and they wrote it from scratch. It would not take hundreds of engineers to port the existing codebase to another language. I think this is a cool experiment, but some of these claims are getting absurd.
59nadir 5mo ago
It probably wouldn't take a single person who knew what they were doing more than a year to re-implement Bun in basically anything, by hand and from scratch, i.e. not even looking at source. Writing the code for something you already understand and have built before is incredibly fast. I'm sure they'll market what you said, but it's so ridiculous that I would hope people would see through this stuff.
slopinthebag 5mo ago
The majority of Bun was written by one guy in less than a year. In what world would a rewrite take hundreds of engineers more than a year to do? The hyperbole is getting ridiculous.
seanclayton 5mo ago
And he has zero idea how it works. His capacity for understanding it is tied to his wallet now.
- Kwpolska 5mo ago
  It's actually tied to his employment at Anthropic.