2 ms·
Yes, Twenty years after they appeared with the Macintosh, it's becoming clearer they icons are not a particularly useful UI device. I would assert that icons,
by joe_the_user 14y ago
Yes,
Twenty years after they appeared with the Macintosh, it's becoming clearer they icons are not a particularly useful UI device.
I would assert that icons, like skeuomorphs, remain in the graph vocabulary not because of their utility or because they create beautiful designs but because the user a feeling of comfort and familiarity (which is sort-of a design concern but not always a necessary design concern). Further, I don't think this consideration is going to go away once enough electronic "things" replace their physical equivalents - a typewriter is still strong as a symbol even in a world where no one uses a typewriter. Because an electronic "thing" is never going to be "ready-at-hand", it will forever need a ready-at-hand physical object to give a comforting sense of realness.