3 ms·
This is absurd -- "moot" is a common word, not a trademark or copyrightable property. http://fairuse.stanford.edu/commentary_and_analysis/2003_09_stim.html htt
by lutusp 14y ago
This is absurd -- "moot" is a common word, not a trademark or copyrightable property.
http://fairuse.stanford.edu/commentary_and_analysis/2003_09_stim.html http://fairuse.stanford.edu/commentary_and_analysis/2003_09_...
A quote: "Copyright laws disfavor protection for short phrases. Such claims are viewed with suspicion by the Copyright Office, whose circulars state that, '... slogans, and other short phrases or expressions cannot be copyrighted.'"
- courtneycouch0 14y agoSeriously. kind of baffling that he even decided to try this!
- tl2201 14y agoI sent you an email on this matter...please read
- tipiirai 14y agoIndeed. I guess he simply trusted on his big name on this. Tried to scare.
- bobsmith4219 14y agoParis Hilton disagrees http://gawker.com/5648787/paris-hilton-owns-the-phrase-thats-hot-and-other-revelations-that-could-ruin-the-weather-channel http://gawker.com/5648787/paris-hilton-owns-the-phrase-thats... No matter how absurd, anything is possible. Welcome to 2012
- tipiirai 14y agoWow. That's hot! Welcome to USA.
- jannelehtinen 14y agoOr maybe just Paris :P
- lutusp 14y ago> Paris Hilton disagrees That's not a good example. Consider "Sun Microsystems". Can "Sun" be protected? No. Can "Microsystems" be protected? No again. Can both together be protected? Yes, of course.
- dangrossman 14y ago> Can "Sun" be protected? Yes. Why do you think it can't? Recall that Apple has successfully gained and defended its trademark on the word "apple", easily as common a word as "sun", in the relevant industries it operates. "Time" is trademarked by TIME Magazine, and "caterpillar" by Caterpilllar Inc., the construction equipment company. Feel free to check yourself. Federally registered trademarks are publicly searchable on the USPTO website. You'll find not only the registration for the word APPLE, but if you do a design mark search, you'll find quite a few drawings of the sun are registered trademarks as well.
- lutusp 14y ago>> Can "Sun" be protected? > Yes. Why do you think it can't? Because it cannot be protected, not that an agency won't issue a document to that effect. A company that expects to use a common word as a trademark can expect to have a public-relations nightmare on their their hands as they try to keep people from using the "protected" word for any other purpose. Examples abound -- even words that aren't everyday words lose protection over time. How successful has Xerox been in getting people to say "dry electrostatic copy"? How successful has Johnson & Johnson been in getting people to say "adhesive compress" instead of "Band-Aid? This isn't about law, it's about reality. Reality trumps law. The present controversy over software patents shows the degree to which people in the legal profession think they can prevail over reality. They can't -- not for long, anyway.
- dangrossman 14y agoI gave you three examples of single common word marks that are currently protected and have been defended without courts declaring them generic words, which is the danger you're hinting at. How can you seriously write this response while ignoring three counterexamples already given? Do you know of any companies successfully selling their products under the Xerox and Band-Aid brands other than Xerox and J&J? In 'reality', as you put it, both companies have successfully had law enforcement intercept, destroy and file charges against counterfeiters of their products. A mark is effective 'in reality' as long as the courts are willing to defend it, and unlike those few high-profile software patent cases, a totally different area of law, these marks have all been upheld in court. It's really non-constructive to compare trademarks to software patents, too. There are no "trademark trolls", as a mark cannot exist without continual use in commerce. There are no uses of trademarks as proxy wars for attaining licensing agreements without running afoul of antitrust laws as the mobile phone industry is doing with patents right now.
- dangrossman 14y agoTrademark, not copyright, is the applicable law here. Copyright protects creative works like books or paintings or program code. Trademark protects names and marks used to identify the source of things. Brands are commonly one word or even one symbol and have trademark protection. If you can't identify the applicable law for a situation, you're probably not in a position to make any comments about the merits of the claim. Common words can be trademarked. Apple Inc holds the trademark to "apple". Time Magazine holds the trademark to "time". Caterpillar Inc holds the trademark to "caterpillar". They're all common words and they all appear in the federal trademark register, which you can check yourself at USPTO.gov. If someone else uses these common words in commerce in the industries the trademark holders operate in, they will be infringing, they will be taken to court, they will lose their cases, and they will pay damages to the trademark holders. What's absurd is operating in the software industry without even basic knowledge of intellectual property laws.