3 ms·
In the best of all possible worlds, icons don't need labeling. In the real world, a large portion do. Which brings-up the question of "why do we need icons at a
by joe_the_user 14y ago
In the best of all possible worlds, icons don't need labeling. In the real world, a large portion do. Which brings-up the question of "why do we need icons at all?". And one could argue that often we don't.
For all its flaws, Microsoft Metro has the merit of realizing that icons often don't really have the communicativeness that many designers imagine. Sometimes a word is worth a dozen very sketchy pictures too, or at least is more specific than any given picture.
- ebzlo 14y agoOn the contrary, I think icons have become indicative of actionable text or a button. Just today there was an article on HN that criticized Windows 8 of being too minimalistic-- it was hard to understand at first glance what was merely a label versus an actual button. And in the real world, icons, symbols, or colors help users immediately understand how to use something (while driving, I would stop at a red octagon even if it didn't explicitly say STOP).