6 ms·
Don't Blame Your Community: Ad Blocking Is Not Killing Any Sites (2010)
- graeme 14y agoThere is a good article, linked within, about how as an entrepreneur, of things go wrong, it's your fault. I'd say that's valuable advice for humans, not just entrepreneurs. This belief is useful not because it true, but because acting as of it's true offers you the best chance of changing what you can change. http://www.marksonland.com/2010/03/note_to_entrpreneurs_its_your_1.html http://www.marksonland.com/2010/03/note_to_entrpreneurs_its_...
- stephengillie 14y agoOne of my friends uses this philosophy in competitive gaming -- each point lost, each teammate death, each tower destroyed is his fault -- to inspire him to become better. It's too easy to find scapegoats for our blame. I try to remember this when I find myself sliding back into mediocrity.
- debacle 14y agoI think it's likely that this is untrue. Slashdot and reddit are the two examples that come to mind of a userbase who are likely to be filtering ads and thus greatly reducing the revenue of their hosts.
- gilrain 14y ago...you think it's untrue that ad-blocking does not kill sites, because two sites likely to be ad-blocked more than the average are very, very successful?
- mylittlepony 14y agoIn this context successful should be synonym of profitable. Which, last time I checked, reddit is not.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mylittlepony 14y ago"If you run a company, it's your responsibility to put together a business model that works" He's not saying it's not happening, he's saying it's not the users' fault.
- debacle 14y agoWhile I agree with you, the logical next step should be to prevent users who are abusing your business model from using your services.
- graue 14y agoYes and no. I block ads, but when I find a good article I reshare the link to friends/followers who do not block ads. If only two of them view the content and ads, it's a net positive for the publisher to let me view the article. As a side note, I disagree with your choice of word “abusing”. How about “disrupting”? No one has an inherent right to make money.
- mhurron 14y agoSlashdot allows you to turn off ads if your karma is high enough. They have other forms of revenue.
- commentzorro 14y agoThis article is years old and no longer reflects current information.
- mylittlepony 14y agoWhat do you mean?
- citricsquid 14y ago> If you're reading Techdirt, and the ads we serve are not good, you have every right to use an ad blocker. It's your browser, do whatever you want with it. I, personally, do not use an ad blocker because I don't find most ads annoying -- but if you do, more power to you. You're absolutely welcome here on Techdirt. I know I'm in a minority so even posting this is absolutely pointless, but... if I don't like the adverts that a website runs I do one of the following: pay them to not have to view them (if they have a subscription option), don't visit the website again or begrudgingly view them. Yes it's "my browser" but it's also the websites content. If they didn't want me to view adverts they wouldn't have adverts, so the assumption is the adverts are there for me to view them. Either I view the adverts or I don't visit the website. If techdirt doesn't mine me blocking adverts, great, but why not make it a profile option? Sign up and get the option to disable adverts! Maybe I'm crazy, but I view access to websites, media and items (eg: biscuits) the same. If I want access / ownership / consumption of something and the owner wants me to pay $10, view an advert or give them my email address then I do that or I don't get the content. Just like I would hope everyone thinks the same of the content I'm involved in the production of (although I don't run adverts on the websites that I own...) As an aside I know of a website that has been around for a long time now that is suffering because of sticking to their guns regarding advertising. They don't want to sacrifice the "spirit" of the website so they're losing advertising options fast (some of the content is not advertiser friendly...) and this is going to lead to them shutting down soon, which is a shame because it's a website that matters a lot to me and has a significant userbase and is a part of the internet history. Sometimes sticking to your guns to the death isn't the best thing for your users...
- Nursie 14y agoIt's not pointless to post, it's interesting to get a range of views. I do use an adblocker, because I think like the techdirt guy - it's up to me to decide what my browser displays, and I don't like noisy, colourful, moving distracting ads. It's not just the net though, I generally dislike ads everywhere and resent the way we let our world be taken over by them. That said, it's the site owner's right not to give me any service. To that end I fully support people that want to block the blockers like me. I don't have to load ads, you don't have to supply the content I ask for.
- pretoriusB 14y ago>"Ad Blocking Is Not Killing Any Sites" That's only because it's not really prevalent to the general masses. If it was, e.g if browsers came with Ad Blocking pre-installed and enabled as a default, thousands of news sites and blogs would suffer and crash.
- mylittlepony 14y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4804474 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4804474
- gurkendoktor 14y agoAs the author states in the last paragraph, this is exactly the same argument as with piracy, but the OP is in a worse position to make it because the author has to pay for traffic - unlike pirated music/ebooks/software, where pirates generously share the bandwidth costs. And the impression I get is the same as with piracy. A few % have no problem because they are huge, have a devoted following, another income stream or because they post link-bait without mercy. It's like the lottery winners calling other people stupid for not winning. (Same reasoning in the software world: Adobe still exists despite lots of people torrenting Photoshop, Apple doesn't even bother to add copy protection to its OS, so then why are all the little crybaby studios whining about piracy?! Similar examples exist for games, music...) The headline, as explained in the article, is also a tautology. Because if a site goes bankrupt due to ad blocking, it is the staff's fault, and therefore the site did not go bankrupt due to ad blocking. Besides, it is conveniently hard to prove for what reason a site went bankrupt - same story as with pirated goods again.
- snowwrestler 14y agoA major failing of this article is that it presupposes that people actually considered the quality of advertising in their decision to run ad blockers. When running an ad blocker, most ads are blocked by default on every site. Therefore the user never even has a chance to see if the ads are "good" or not. The question is, what happens if everyone starts using this software? Granted, it's a very unlikely scenario since it takes effort to install and manage ad blockers. But it's not hard to imagine that a relationship would exist between marginal increases in ad blocker usage, and marginal decreases in ad revenue. Most of the "good" examples in this article are not even ads, they are sponsored content. It's roughly analogous to using product placements in TV shows to replace revenue lost to ad skipping software in DVRs. But not many websites are big enough (like TechDirt is) to command the special attention from advertisers to create these "one off" deals.
- Karunamon 14y agoI use an adblocker because most sites I visit that serve ads do not personally vet the ads that run (with the great exception I can recall being 4chan, of all places!), they use an unfiltered third party network, which generally are great vehicles for malware. The few tenths of a penny my ad impression is worth does not offset the cost, nor the risk, of your site infecting me with the rootkit of the day. Where do I send the bill? The second reason being the ads are generally scammy (One simple rule...), distracting (moving things, sound, etc), irrelvant (I live at home by myself. I am male. Why are you showing me women's fashion magazines and breast enlargement ads?!), etc. I've got no problem with text ads (ala Google) which eliminate most of these concerns - heck, in Google's case, they're even usually relevant!
- Goronmon 14y agoI use an adblocker because most sites I visit that serve ads do not personally vet the ads that run (with the great exception I can recall being 4chan, of all places!), they use an unfiltered third party network, which generally are great vehicles for malware. While sites might not be able to vet individual ads, they do get to choose which advertisers to use and it's glaringly obvious which ones use the ads people hate. Why not just not visit sites that decide to use annoying ads?
- kamjam 14y agoI started using an ad blocker because I got annoyed at all the personalized ads I was seeing. I'd go to a website, view cost of item, every ad I then see related to that store/product. It got to a point where is was a little freaky and stalker-ish. Also, same reasons as you listed in 3rd sentence but also I'm on a limited bandwidth plan now (the joys of internet costs in Canada!) so don't want a load of bandwidth sucked away for nothing. At this point it actually costing me money to watch irrelevant ads. It annoys me more when your site is not optimized for mobile either and I'm forced to loads ads on my data plan, where I don't have ad block installed (my phone is not rooted). I tell you what though, it's amazing how much cleaner and more readable site content is without all those adverts. I find it extremely strange to view some sites on computers without ad block now!
- kushti 14y ago"Ad Blocking Is Not Killing Any Sites" - another false-positive thought of trendy venture-backed hipsters. Ok, speak your post-scarcity bla-bla-bla further.
- hayksaakian 14y agoThe qq around ad blockers is the same as the qq around piracy. Bootleg vhs tapes were available before streaming media, relatively easy to make, and share. However the vast majority of people do not consume them to a damaging extent. The same is true for ad blockers and content distribution now. Ad blockers are a solution to a usability and business model problem. If you as a producer of content find it to be a huge issue, then you have it in your power to change it. Only when its more convenient to do something the 'correct' way will it be guaranteed to be the predominant way.
- TomMasz 14y agoI don't mind ads when I want to buy a product or service and don't know where to look, but otherwise they're just noise that generally slows page loading or makes the readable content scroll up and down (I really hate those ads). I use an ad blocker to make reading web content as easy as reading the newspaper (where I can skip entire pages of ads). If I like a web site, I'll pay for it. But I'm paying because I like the content, not to remove the ads. It's a thank you, not a ransom payment.
- leeoniya 14y agoi use ad blockers primarily so that third parties cannot track me across different domains all over the internet and to increase page load times dramatically.
- DanBC 14y agoI would love for a simple easy way to make micro-payments to the websites I use regularly. It'd be even better if that allowed me to turn off ads. I'm gently concerned that would mean that site owners would allow obnoxious ads in an attempt to drive people to paying, but I guess they realise that people would ad-block or never visit again.
- rprasad 14y agoI use an adblocker at home but not at work. Honestly, for most of the sites I visit, there isn't much of a difference (anymore). Websites have realized that having fewer high-quality ads is better than having a massive number of crap ads.