7 ms·
Maker of Airport Body Scanners Suspected of Falsifying Software Tests
- redspark 14y agoDoesn't surprise me. Yesterday I set off the alarm because my sock was bunched up, but it didn't pick up my belt-buckle (I forgot to take off my belt). Have also gone through them with a phone in my back pocket on accident, with no alarms.
- smoyer 14y agoHmmm ... anyone for some passive resistence? I think we need to start a public education campaign that encourages everyone to bunch up their socks before entering the machine. That's a pretty powerful statement about the quality of the scanner's results ... something everyone should be able to understand.
- micampe 14y agothat's useless. all you are proving is that it can have false positives, which everyone already knows and rightly doesn't care about. you would need to prove that it has numerous false negatives, without being arrested.
- jlgreco 14y agoIf you want to change policy, there are two routes you can go I think. Proving false negatives is one way, since it proves them worthless, but making false positives skyrocket could be another method. If they simply become an unworkable solution people will call for change just as well.
- ck2 14y agoI wonder how many more times the TSA will be proven worthless and pointless before something changes. But in reality they will just get more tax money thrown at them. 2015? 2020? 2025? By 2030 they will be their entire own industrial complex bigger than McDonalds. The annual incidents should be hitting the opening minutes of TV news in just a few days with the man-on-the-street responses "Oh well, groping our genitals, what can you do - we need to feel safe!"
- jamesmcn 14y agoThe TSA does two things successfully: * It is a large-scale jobs program * The more intrusive security theater is, the better a CYA effect it provides. Up until the next terrorist attack is conducted by some sufficiently determined group. Nothing will change.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoAt one point I was wondering it the TSA might be a sort of 'sand bag' for the administration, if they felt they needed more altitude in their approval ratings they could cut the thing free, which would lower the deficit and make people's lives better. Voila, instant boost in the polls. Ok, so that is pretty cynical. But I've had my run-ins with them and frankly they add no value at all. I made the mistake of pointing out that they spent all this time and energy looking for concealed explosives, but if they found one they had no plan whatsoever except "clear the terminal." WTF couldn't they just put a re-inforced concrete drop well with a vent to the roof next to the check point? It would be cheaper than one of those Xray scanners and if they actually did find something they could just chuck it into the well and continue on as usual. Needless to say they didn't appreciate any practical advice.
- ck2 14y agoYou realize you are having the discussion with people who didn't even go to college? TSA only requires high school diploma or GED, there is no education or critical thinking requirement.
- smsm42 14y agoWhat degree that might that be anyway? Master of Arts of Genital Touching? Bachelor of Beeping Stick Sciences? I don't think there's any degree that adds anything to what TSA is doing.
- 67726e 14y agoMaybe some form of degree involving psychology? If your job is to find certain types of people, understanding how and why we do what we do might be of some help.
- aresant 14y agoLet's break down the absurdity of this situation. There is a likelihood of falsified tests despite the fact that the machines were "tested by a third party". Why? Because “before [a test] gets underway, we might believe the system is on one configuration when it’s not in that configuration.” So the "third-party" that's responsible for testing this isn't actually auditing that the revised software is running, they're relying on the vendor's configuration and asking them to show them the output. What could possibly go wrong? Especially with a deal where the first order was for $90,000,000 worth of these machines? And, the former Homeland Security secretary Michael Chertoff's firm is doing "consulting work" that is vehemently written off by the vendor as "unrelated". Give me a !@%$!@ break, as long as our government is run by fellow humans we can't expect them not to be as self-interested, greedy, and tribally protective as the rest of us.
- rhizome 14y agoIt's pretty much a standardization of the worst testing/QA techniques ever. I have to imagine that RFP's have to meet this standard (if in fact this wasn't a no-bid contract, which I think it might have been).
- Cieplak 14y agoI'm sure they could have thought of a better name than Rapiscan. I don't think many people want to get rapi scanned.
- mattdeboard 14y agoThe name of the company that makes these is "Rapiscan"? I'm assuming that first "a" isn't a long vowel.
- jrockway 14y agoYou can make anything sound bad if you really try hard. It's rapi as in rapid, not rapi as in rapist. Let's debate the technical merits of this device rather than devolve to the level of one of Reddit's make-fun-of-something threads.
- mattdeboard 14y agoYou're not going to have much free time trying to fight this fire.
- jivatmanx 14y agoIf security was the real objective, there would be expansion of bomb-sniffing dogs, who are extremely effective at smelling any chemical they have been trained to. But the dog trainers aren't politically connected.