2 ms·

"Amaze, amaze, amaze!" I wonder if there would be interest in an Asahi Remix spin focused on a more Mac-like out-of-the-box experience: cmd as the main modifie

"Amaze, amaze, amaze!" I wonder if there would be interest in an Asahi Remix spin focused on a more Mac-like out-of-the-box experience: cmd as the main modifier key, Mac-like keyboard shortcuts, theming, gestures, etc. Of course, you can tweak any distro however you want, but I think a curated default experience is a different thing.

omnimus 5mo ago
Cmd as main modifier is lost battle. I've tried it multiple times. In the end just accepted ctrl life and sold my last macbook.
WhyNotHugo 5mo ago
Cmd as a “main” modifier? Ok typical X/Wayland setups, Cmd is already the main modifier for DE features, while Ctrl is the modifier used at an application level. There would be a lot of weird overlap with changing that.
- throwaway27448 5mo ago
  > while Ctrl is the modifier used at an application level. DE features don't matter at all outside of cmd-tab and whatever the equivalent of spotlight is. The application level is the main modifier, and changing them all to cmd is essentially impossible at this point. A detail Haiku got just about perfect, I think. Either way, ctrl as a gui modifier is a dealbreaker for me. It also breaks the use of readline keybindings for text entry.
- deleted 5mo ago
  [deleted]
Nevin1901 5mo ago
I've managed to get close enough w/ kde. I just asked claude code to implement it for me, and it web searched and built config files.
jkl5xx 5mo ago
I’ve had the same thought and would love this. MacOS shortcuts are too deeply ingrained in my fingers. But every attempt of mine to make Linux shortcuts Mac-like has had too many sharp edges to be useable. Toshy didn’t seem to work well with Wayland and felt heavy. Probably the best so far I’ve found has been keyd and custom configs for your most used apps. A community effort might get us there. Distribute the hours of tinkering across many passionate users instead of everyone doing it in a vacuum.

omnimus 5mo ago

Cmd as main modifier is lost battle. I've tried it multiple times. In the end just accepted ctrl life and sold my last macbook.

WhyNotHugo 5mo ago

Cmd as a “main” modifier? Ok typical X/Wayland setups, Cmd is already the main modifier for DE features, while Ctrl is the modifier used at an application level. There would be a lot of weird overlap with changing that.

throwaway27448 5mo ago
> while Ctrl is the modifier used at an application level. DE features don't matter at all outside of cmd-tab and whatever the equivalent of spotlight is. The application level is the main modifier, and changing them all to cmd is essentially impossible at this point. A detail Haiku got just about perfect, I think. Either way, ctrl as a gui modifier is a dealbreaker for me. It also breaks the use of readline keybindings for text entry.
deleted 5mo ago
[deleted]

Nevin1901 5mo ago

I've managed to get close enough w/ kde. I just asked claude code to implement it for me, and it web searched and built config files.

jkl5xx 5mo ago

I’ve had the same thought and would love this. MacOS shortcuts are too deeply ingrained in my fingers. But every attempt of mine to make Linux shortcuts Mac-like has had too many sharp edges to be useable. Toshy didn’t seem to work well with Wayland and felt heavy. Probably the best so far I’ve found has been keyd and custom configs for your most used apps. A community effort might get us there. Distribute the hours of tinkering across many passionate users instead of everyone doing it in a vacuum.