4 ms·
For one, everything its 'intelligence' knows about solving the problem is contained within the finite context window memory buffer size for the particular model
by walrus01 6mo ago
For one, everything its 'intelligence' knows about solving the problem is contained within the finite context window memory buffer size for the particular model and session. Unless the memory contents of the context window are being saved to storage and reloaded later, unlike a human, it won't "remember" that it solved the problem and save its work somewhere to be easily referenced later.
- resident423 6mo agoWhat your describing sounds more like the model is lacking awareness than lacking intelligence? Why does it need to know it solved the problem to be intelligent?
- walrus01 6mo agoWe say African Elephants are intelligent for a number of reasons, one of which is because they remember where sources of water are in very dry conditions, and can successfully navigate back to them across relatively large distances. An intelligent being that can't remember its own past is at a significant disadvantage compared to others that can, which is exactly one of the reasons why alzheimers patients often require full time caregivers.
- peteforde 6mo agoYou are confusing lack of intelligence with the presence of impairment.
- resident423 6mo agoThere's probably a limit to how intelligent something can be with no long term memory, but solving Erdos problems in 80 minutes is clearly not above it, and I think the true limit is probably much higher than that.
- jychang 6mo agoThere's humans that have memory issues, or full blown Anterograde amnesia.
- emp17344 6mo agoThere are humans who can’t read. That doesn’t mean Grammarly is “intelligent”. These things are tools - nothing more, nothing less.
- jychang 6mo agoThere's no structural difference in the brain between those who can read/write vs those who can't. It's not a distinction. Would you consider Socrates not intelligent since he was illiterate and had contempt for the written word? If you want to classify intelligence, you need to define it properly.
- bpodgursky 6mo agoAll modern harnesses write memory files for context later.
- charcircuit 6mo agoAs another commenter pointed out these models are being trained how to save and read context into files so denying them to use such an ability that they have just makes your claim tautological.
- in-silico 6mo agoFor one, everything humans' "intelligence" knows about solving the problem is contained within the finite brain size for the particular person and life. Unless the memory contents of the brain are being saved to storage and reloaded later, it won't "remember" that it solved the problem and save its work somewhere to be easily referenced in a later life.