9 ms·
Why Coke Cost A Nickel For 70 Years
- bhanks 14y agoPrice change is not fundamental to economics. It is fundamental to a post-Fed inflationary policy that seeks for a low (or at least a consistent) unemployment rate. That being said I think this is a great case study of "menu costs" on steriods.
- Symmetry 14y agoKudos for pointing out that this is a classic example of menu costs, but price changes occur for many reasons besides the Fed. Even if you had a fixed supply of gold coins and nobody could ever mine new coins, the value of those coins would change in proportion to the value of the overall economy, and that will tend to change for all sorts of reasons such as population growth.
- mindslight 14y agoBut there isn't a fixed amount of gold. More gold gets mined when the demand for currency rises relative to the price of energy. The price of oil roughly tracks the price of gold not because gold is a magical denominator, but because an ounce of gold represents a certain amount of sunk energy that mined it.
- mindslight 14y agoAu contraire - price change is a fundamental aspect of economics. Why would a new competitor selling the same commodity ever expect to be successful? Because they've figured out how to provide the same product for less expense. So even ignoring expected price decreases due to technological progress, we'd still expect to see prices occasionally decreasing due to organizational progress.
- eru 14y agoAnd a decrease in the cost of one good can lead to an increase in the price of complementary goods.
- sageikosa 14y agoNot to contradict, but to add detail: land, labor, capital, material resources and market seldom exist in the same location for any specific good/service, and the cost of distance (and the cost to overcome those distances) affects market bearable prices. It need not be technological progress that makes one competitive, it may just simply be favorable proximity to resources and markets that gives you an edge. Coca-Cola (the syrup) is produced IIRC in only one place, and bottled/canned with local waters in regional centers because the cost of shipping a product that is mostly water around the country/world will drive costs up. Many auto-makers in the US became "competitive" by closing factories where labor costs were high and opening them where they were lower. Many foreign producers of cars opened factories in the US to offset the increases of labor costs in their own countries while also decreasing shipping costs (especially for Asian car makers who cannot as easily ship to the Eastern US) and nullifying punitive tariffs.
- zissou 14y agoThe way/speed/reason/etc for a change in a price is certainly one of the most fundamental topics to economics. For one, it's a topic that grabs the mind share of both macroeconomists and microeconomists, and there aren't many of those!
- travisp 14y ago>In 1886, a bottle of Coke cost a nickel. It was also a nickel in 1900, 1915, and 1930. In fact, 70 years after the first Coke was sold, you could still buy a bottle for a nickel. Without getting into a huge argument about the causes of inflation, it's really weird that they didn't even mention the word inflation until almost the very end. In 1886, an ounce of gold cost $20.65 and in 1930 an ounce of gold cost $20.65. 70 years after 1886 (1956) it had increased to $34.99 (a 70% increase). But surely a large part of the reason that a Coke cost a nickel for 70 years was that there was no real inflation for a large part of that time, during which time Coca-Cola also had the opportunity to significantly increase production and cost efficiency.
- tptacek 14y agoThat doesn't explain why Coke continued to cost a nickel after WWII, when we started having significant inflation. According to the economists interviewed on Planet Money, Coke has the longest known stuck price of a consumer good in modern history. They attribute it to the original mistaken fixed-price bottling contract, Coke's response of pushing the price down with "predatory" marketing of a 5c price point, and the rise of vending machines and their inability to make change until the late 40's. The best part of this story, and I'll just go ahead and spoil it for you: late in this drama, Coke decided they wanted to raise prices, but since vending machines couldn't reliably make change they were stuck with a nickel-denominated price and couldn't double it. So instead, they stocked vending machines with "official blanks"; one in every 8 times you went to a Coke machine for a drink, you got an empty bottle, and had to pay again, which raised the effective price of Coke across all consumers by less than a cent.
- travisp 14y agoI agree that some inflation occurred (my original comment noted the inflation that was ultimately experienced near the end of the 70 year period), and I agree that the article contains some interesting information about contracts and vending machines (I did read the article). I just think it's disingenuous to say basically "the price was the same in 1886, 1915 and 1930!" and that they don't remind the reader that the price of many things was essentially the same over that same time period. A less informed reader may be unaware of this and be reading the article from the context of modern inflation, for which a 70 year history of no price change would be much more remarkable.
- propercoil 14y agoBecause the federal reserve wasn't printing money like crazy and devaluing the currency. When comparing the price of a Coke with real money - gold or silver the price hasn't changed
- icebraining 14y agoActually, it did. Coke remained fixed in USD, so it had to change relatively to "real money". EDIT: I was wrong, sorry. I got the wrong impression from the podcast.
- throwit1979 14y agoNope. Throughout the relevant 70 year timespan, Coke was priced in an environment of first, the gold standard, and second, Bretton Woods. The USD was not fully disconnected from gold until 1971, which is after the timespan the article talks about.
- propercoil 14y agobeat me to comment the same thing - the gold standard. I don't understand why he question marked "real money", i think he thinks the paper money he holds is money and not gold. Let's wait a couple of years
- icebraining 14y agoYou're right, I got the wrong impression from the podcast, which is stupid since I knew about the gold standard and price stability of the time. As for the "scare quotes", I'm aware of the drawbacks of fiat money, but it's still money. Gold is just non-fiat money.
- darkarmani 14y agoSomeone posted that an ounce of gold was $20.65. If we say a bottle of coke is $1.00 today, then gold must be hanging around $412.00 an ounce?
- asdfprou 14y agoI'm surprised the bottlers didn't try to bottle different sizes and charge pricing differences on the larger bottles that Coke wasn't advertising for. Maybe this would have cut into their distribution/packaging costs though since the bottlers would be typically making a smaller margin on the larger bottles?
- eru 14y agoIt would also decrease their benefit from the free advertising.
- redwood 14y agoIt certainly is interesting to think about how, when you're dealing with nickels, the concept of 2.77% inflation has no real meaning for price for a good 7 or so years!
- rb2k_ 14y agoThe original source is Planet Money on NPR: http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2012/11/15/165143816/why-coke-cost-a-nickel-for-70-years http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2012/11/15/165143816/why-coke... I have no idea what "weku.fm" adds to the mix
- eco 14y agoThere is a version that is 5 times longer Planet Money did for their regular (excellent) podcast. http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2012/11/13/165046113/episode-416-why-the-price-of-coke-didnt-change-for-70-years http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2012/11/13/165046113/episode-...
- jivatmanx 14y ago>So they asked the U.S. Treasury to issue a 7.5-cent coin. At one point, the head of Coca-Cola asked President Eisenhower for help. (They were hunting buddies.) No luck. I don't get it. Wouldn't a .5 cent coin make more sense?
- coin 14y agoThe vending machine could only accept one coin.
- kbutler 14y agoI'm going to go out on a limb here and assume that the primary materials cost for Coke over this time period is sugar. There are other costs (production, distribution) but over that time period, those were benefiting from decreased cost through industrialization, etc. This link gives a history of the sugar price (only back until 1912): http://www.tradingeconomics.com/commodity/sugar http://www.tradingeconomics.com/commodity/sugar Basically, sugar did not increase in price over that time span - except for a dramatic spike around world war I and relatively minor fluctuations. That spike put Pepsi into bankruptcy, the company was sold at auction, reorganized, and after the great depression started selling a DOUBLE-SIZE (12oz) bottle for ... wait for it... $0.05). http://suite101.com/article/soda-pops-of-the-1800s-1900s-20s-30s-40s-50s-and-60s-a363069 http://suite101.com/article/soda-pops-of-the-1800s-1900s-20s...
- eru 14y agoI wonder how much of the cost of Coke was materials cost, and how much logistics and mark up for the retailer.
- gadders 14y agoI always assumed that the syrup being sold to bottling plants was done for Tax Avoidance purposes, like Starbucks does now. (i.e. bottling plants make a loss because of high cost of the syrup, so no taxes to pay).
- ajays 14y agoWho writes these things? " In 1886, a bottle of Coke cost a nickel. . . . . In 1899, . . . Coke was sold at soda fountains. But the lawyers were interested in this new idea: selling drinks in bottles." So was Coke sold in bottles in 1886 or not?
- tptacek 14y agoNo; according to Coke's historians, the first bottle of coke was sold in 1894. The author of this Planet Money summary probably just misspoke, or meant "the price of a bottle's worth of Coke".
- Pwnguinz 14y agoThat had me scratching my head as well... Ugh. Can anyone actually shed some light on this conundrum?
- justsayin13 14y agoFake account, but I wanted to say that I think Marijuana has been $10/gram for as long as I can remember. People do alter price based on different parameters, but $10/gram has been a long standing unacknowledged truth.
- eru 14y agoDidn't purity change quite a lot in different places over time?
- cpeterso 14y agoIt even has a name: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/dime_bag https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/dime_bag
- sievert 14y agoI think the weight may vary depending on the cost of production/risk but it gets sold at the same price. The idea of paying $10.50 for something like that due to inflation does seem a bit strange :)
- Spooky23 14y agoI think the answer really is that the steadily increasing cost of raw materials for soda (which remained stable in real terms for most of those 70 years) was countered by other efficiencies. For example, in 1886, 1,000 cases of coke were delivered by a bunch of coachman with a horse-driven wagon serving customers in a limited area. In 1936, 1,000 cases of coke were delivered by a much smaller number of truck drivers serving more customers in a wider area. 8 oz bottles of coke were also re-used. So the machinery used to wash those bottled became more efficient throughout those 70 years. Another key factor is alternate delivery mechanisms. At some point, soda fountains became a common and higher margin channel for selling Coke. The margins on bottles were tighter, but the bottles probably helped drive sales at the fountain. Remember that Coke the trademark owner is distinct from Coke the bottler/distributor. The Coke bottler owned the relationships with stores and restaurants, and probably had the ability to sell complimentary products (pretzels, etc) when they were dropping off the Coke order.
- tron_carter 14y agoWhenever an article with price/inflation implications hits HN, it's like the gold-bug bat signal goes off.
- melvinmt 14y agoI see a great analogy with the whole Nexus strategy. The break-even approach doesn't make economical sense at first sight but Google is selling Android bottles for a nickel until there are no competitors left.
- zissou 14y agoLevy, the main author of the academic article behind this story, is one of my mentors. We taught a class together while I was a PhD student in economics at Emory. I first heard the Coke story during his presentation during a fly-out weekend before starting graduate school, and it is to date still one of the most interesting economic stories I've ever been told. The question is simple, thought provoking and appealing to almost anyone. The poster (Symmetry) that said "the relevant basket of goods is the inputs in materials and labor that go into a bottle of Coke" is absolutely right, and that's exactly what Levy/Young point to in the academic paper. However, the puzzle that remains is that input costs still don't explain the [lack of] variation in the price of coke over the relevant 5 cent years. Although the CPI/inflation answers seem to be the reasonable explanatory variables here, the most explanatory factor is pretty simple: menu costs + marketing contracts/agreements. Menu costs, which are the costs associated with changing your prices, used to be a pretty popular topic in macroeconomics. However, as time has gone on and with the rise of the Internet, menu costs have lost a lot of their explanatory power since they are far less significant in a digital age. But of course, in the early 1900s changing your price, especially for a good which was widely distributed at the time, was a pretty costly matter. Tack that onto that the agreements over price (but not quantity) that were made when the early licensing deals were made and you have a completely reasonable explanation for the sticky price of Coke.
- nhaehnle 14y agoMenu costs and fixed contracts are not necessarily sufficient to explain what happens in such cases - they may be sufficient in the coke bottle example here, but they are insufficient for a similar story here in Germany. Prior to the introduction of the Euro, the price of a standard bar of chocolate has remained constant for around 50 years. The size of those chocolate bars was also fixed, unlike the Hershey's example somebody else mentioned. The single most relevant factor explaining this is psychology: the price of chocolate was very much ingrained in people's minds, and people simply rejected the standard bar of chocolate above a price point of 0.99 DM. Chocolate manufacturers had to squeeze the last bit of efficiency out of their production lines, and turn to larger chocolate bars with special gimmicks or other chocolate-related products for making a decent profit.
- sievert 14y agoWhen trying to make my own version of coke it was interesting to learn that the real secret is the flavorings, which are then mixed with sugar and caffeine etc to form the syrup, which is finally mixed with carbonated water to produce the final product. As the flavorings are such a minor portion of the actual drink (<0.1%) it's really hard to reverse engineer
- dbbolton 14y agoIIRC Hershey kept the price of their flagship chocolate bar constant for a long time by making the size smaller until it was no longer a practical option.
- atakan_gurkan 14y agoThe vending machine part of the story is a bit strange. Why did they not make a machine that would accept a dime and return a couple pennies with the coke?