8 ms·
First Teleportation From One Macroscopic Object to Another
- tokenizer 14y agoI've been hearing about qubits for awhile now and don't really understand the significance of having quantum entanglement in a network. Can you entangle multiple clients in a mesh, and add or remove entanglements? Is that even possible in the future with this? Or can you manufacture entanglement with each connection, where you initiate the entanglement with a client, and maintain that connection during transport? I'm really just curious if you can use this technology, and literally replace the methods of connections and transport as we use them now, or if this is simply a single function method.
- Xcelerate 14y agoTwo cool things: 1) You can have perfectly encrypted communication that no one can eavesdrop on (not even theoretically). 2) You can transmit twice as much classical information using superdense coding: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superdense_coding http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superdense_coding
- EthanHeilman 14y ago>1). You can have perfectly encrypted communication [..] I thought we already had this with quantum encryption (although there a few attacks against it) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_cryptographyhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_cryptography http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_cryptographyhttp://en.w... You can buy real off the shelf devices that will give you quantum encryption. >[..] that no one can eavesdrop on (not even theoretically). Why does this follow? How do we know that there are no measurables that could be used to eavesdrop? >2) You can transmit twice as much classical information using superdense coding: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superdense_coding http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superdense_coding I think you are right that this is probably the primary advantage, but this article keeps talking about "quantum information" and not entanglement. Can this actually send quBits or just bits?
- droithomme 14y ago> You can have perfectly encrypted communication that no one can eavesdrop on (not even theoretically). That is an interesting observation because there is a flip side to it. I can sell you some ordinary looking gear that contains a quantum entanglement based eavesdropper. You can have your device in a cave 20 miles below the earth's surface in a bunker running off diesel generators, with no connections outside the bunker, and here I am, watching everything you do.
- ZoFreX 14y agoCan someone with a greater understanding of quantum physics chime in here - is this correct?
- btilly 14y agoIt is not correct. Quantum entanglement is easy to break, and once broken will not re-establish on its own.
- tgb 14y agoHow would you do that? Quantum teleportation requires the transmission of 2 classical bits for every qubit, by the only method I know about.
- Daniel_Newby 14y ago> You can have perfectly encrypted communication that no one can eavesdrop on (not even theoretically). Not exactly. Quantum "cryptography" assures you that only one party received the data, but not who that other party is. There is no authentication. To prevent a man in the middle attack, you have to use a conventional message authentication code, and the system as a whole is no stronger than the MAC algorithm.
- Xcelerate 14y agoWell, I was implying a few things such as a secure channel already being set up and running.
- sp332 14y agoYou can transport quantum states with quantum networks. So you can do a quantum computation in one place, transmit the quantum data somewhere else, do more processing, etc. and then only measure & collapse the waveform when you're done.
- monochromatic 14y ago> a demonstration that paves the way towards quantum routers and a quantum internet I can already tell that this article is going to be ridiculous fluff without even reading past the headline.
- stcredzero 14y agoIt's pop science press. So most of the time you're right. There are a few decent journalists in this sub genre, though.
- jimbokun 14y agoThat's why we have Hacker News, to get the real story. :)
- mikegirouard 14y agoThe last line is right on par too… > None of those challenges seem like showstoppers. Which means that practical quantum routers and the quantum internet that relies on them are just around the corner. Seems like quite a statement to make.
- binarymax 14y agoAt least they provide a link to the paper. I don't mind distilled optimistic fluff as long as I can see the source.
- javert 14y agoPage doesn't seem to be loading right for me. There is no content, just surrounding boilerplate (like links to other articles).
- 46Bit 14y agoIt's a webfont not loading for you I suspect.
- blahpro 14y agoThat closing line is a bit optimistic: “Which means that practical quantum routers and the quantum internet that relies on them are just around the corner.”
- petercooper 14y agoI'd always wondered what it must feel like to be faced with a radical new set of ideas, for example, people 80-120 years ago with the "atomic" age. I feel that total confusion with this. Many of the ideas around atoms have been simplified enough for schoolchildren to understand now. I wonder if schoolchildren in 100 years from now will find quantum mechanics and instantaneous transportation similarly rudimentary and easy to understand.
- Florin_Andrei 14y ago> I wonder if schoolchildren in 100 years from now will find quantum mechanics and instantaneous transportation similarly rudimentary and easy to understand. They will. And, to some extent, they will be wrong. There's nothing rudimentary about a nuclear reactor, yet indeed the basic concepts are now available for a bright primary school student to grasp. I think we just got better at creating a more accessible mythology that stands in place of rigorous math for the laypeople.
- IanDrake 14y agoGuilty as charged.
- doctoboggan 14y agoI would not call it mythology, instead I would use the term analogy.
- Florin_Andrei 14y agoRight. Well, what I had in mind was the huge pile of sterile discussions on topics such as black holes, speed of light, quantum mechanics, etc, that one could see all the time on... well... just about any forum online. And most of the comments during such a discussion are... I would not even call them "wrong", you'd need at least some relation to reality to earn this badge. They're more like pure fantasy, unhinged. For those people, modern science has replaced mythology. But I agree with you. Pop science, correctly done, is heavily indebted to analogy.
- 14y ago
- sravfeyn 14y agoMany of the ground-breaking research and the research papers I study for my Physics term papers originate from Chinese Scientists. I just mean Chinese Scientists appear more frequently and this is a perfect example.
- freehunter 14y agoChina isn't the only one conducting this kind of ground breaking research, but they do put a lot of money into it. I don't have any numbers, but I wouldn't be surprised if China's investment in research was higher than most other research countries.
- leeoniya 14y agoI wonder if in 50 years only quantum physicists will truly understand how technology works. Perhaps the days of cheap tinkering with electronics are numbered, in the future requiring multi-million dollar quantum labs.
- possibilistic 14y agoThis is how things have been in the physical science fields. Chemistry, biology, you name it--capital intensive. The computing and theoretical fields (so long as they're non-experimental and require no more than simple simulations) are the exception to the rule rather than the rule itself. Also, until a space is commoditized, working in it is expensive and time-comsuming.
- ZoFreX 14y agoThirty years ago, the most advanced multi-million dollar laboratory in the world would not have been able to understand or tinker with the computer you're sat at currently.
- jakeonthemove 14y agoI think it'll be more akin to the situation with through hole and SMD components. The former allowed one to tinker with PCBs with a simple soldering iron, while the latter require a reworking station no matter what you want to do. Thankfully, these stations have dropped in price a lot - you can easily buy a good one for ~$200-300, which would allow you to repair your phone, modify your motherboard, resolder memory chips and whatnot...
- steve_b 14y agoI have a rework station but almost never use it for SMT. I find a good pair of tweezers and chip quik makes working SMT easy and fast. http://www.digikey.ca/product-detail/en/EROPAASA/EROPAASA-ND/114196 http://www.digikey.ca/product-detail/en/EROPAASA/EROPAASA-ND... http://www.digikey.ca/product-detail/en/SMD4.5NL/SMD4.5NL-ND/1164267 http://www.digikey.ca/product-detail/en/SMD4.5NL/SMD4.5NL-ND...
- jeremyarussell 14y agoI need to catch up on my quantum physics, every time I read that someone pulled off quantum teleportation I'm disappointed when I read the line "here we realize quantum teleportation between two remote atomic-ensemble quantum memory nodes, each composed of 100 million rubidium atoms and connected by a 150-meter optical fiber" taken from the source article. http://arxiv.org/abs/1211.2892 http://arxiv.org/abs/1211.2892 I know there's a difference between what they did and regular fiber optics. It just doesn't seem to be quite the same. Can it be done without the interconnecting material? If not it's really useless. When I picture practical uses of quantum teleportation I picture things like rovers instantly sending data and receiving instructions.
- mistercow 14y ago>When I picture practical uses of quantum teleportation I picture things like rovers instantly sending data and receiving instructions. That won't happen. It's impossible to transmit classical information faster than light via quantum teleportation. You don't necessarily have to have "interconnecting material", but there will always have to be a classical information channel, and that will always be light-speed bound.
- jakeonthemove 14y agoI don't think it's useless. As I understand, quantum teleportation would allow for a massive increase in bandwidth. That's a pretty good result, and who knows, maybe they'll get rid of the interconnecting cables in the future, as well.
- Osmium 14y agoNote that this is "teleportation" of quantum information and not teleportation of matter. To the layman, referring to this sort of thing as teleportation seems a bit misleading to me.
- maushu 14y agoI concur, but still, instant teleportation of information? Awesome. No more lag because of distance, no wires, no radiation... the future is going to be awesome. I wonder, since this experimented worked on macroscopic scale, it will possible to transmit "energy"?
- derekdahmer 14y agoQuantum teleportation does not allow for faster-than-light information transition. While changing particle A makes particle B change, the second's information can't be understood without transmitting a third piece of information from A to B. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_teleportation#A_summary http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_teleportation#A_summary
- bones6 14y agoEven if it's not faster than light I'm hoping for teleportation that means no line of sight required and distance boundless wireless transmission. I could totally settle for that.
- olalonde 14y agoDoes that mean that Quantum teleportation will never have practical applications? If you need to send a third piece of information at the speed of light or slower, why not send all your information through that channel?
- joeyespo 14y agoFrom what I've been reading it's mostly for security, not speed. Using Quantum teleportation, nobody can get any useful data from intercepting that third piece of information.
- sravfeyn 14y agoI have question that suits the context. Will Quantum Teleportation, if possible, let us reduce, if not remove, the hardware for communications? As in, there will be no need for giant fiber-optic cables or wireless routers?
- jcfrei 14y agono, there's still a huge confusion out there towards what constitutes quantum teleportation. all I can say as a layman is that this title is very misleading, you still need a standard information channel to transport the information about a single qubit. wikipedia has more: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_teleportation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_teleportation
- ta12121 14y agohttp://xkcd.com/465/ http://xkcd.com/465/
- simpleshadow 14y agoI've written about an alternative "teleportation" method in what I call a Teleroom: http://www.thenureality.com/the-teleroom http://www.thenureality.com/the-teleroom I get excited about the potential of replicating data of physical things. :D
- confluence 14y agoCan someone with physics knowledge tell me the difference between quantum entanglement and the following example: 2 pens spinning in exact opposition, one clockwise the other anticlockwise, are hurled from a space ship in opposite directions. You do not look at them when you are doing this. When a pen is found light years away, that person instantly knows how the pen on the other side of the universe is spinning and in what phase. No teleportation has actually taken place. Information has not been transferred faster than the speed of light. This assumes that pens travel through empty space and do not interact with things that would affect their rotation or movement.
- ccozan 14y agoI'll venture for an answer: none. The moment you decide to check for a pen, you sealed his fate ( ie. which rotation it has ) and also of the other pen. So to say, you collapsed his wave. Kind of a Schroedinger's cat experiment. The reason you know about the both pens in the moment you look at them is, well, because they are "entangled". But no information has been sent. You had this information all along with you, bound by the space-time and it's C speed limit.
- confluence 14y agoSo is it's an ok analogy then (obviously heavily simplified)?
- asayers 14y agoNo, it's actually quite different. The scenario you outlined is quite important and actually has a name: it's the "Bertlmann's Socks" thought experiment, and if you want to read about it I'd seriously recommend the paper by the great J S Bell[1]. To use the language of your example, both pens begin in a superposition of clockwise and anti-clockwise. It's not the case that each pen has a particular spin value, and that we're simply unaware of which has which. The pens really are in a superposition. Until, that is, a measurement is made on one of them. At this point the joint pen-pen system collapses and both pens have determinate spin values. The nature of the entanglement ensures that those spin values are different. The notion that quantum-entangled particles could have well-defined properties that we're just ignorant of was actually pretty popular in the early days of quantum mechanics. In fact, the theory was put forward by Einstein, among others. As it turns out, however, that we can test for this. The tests have been done, and it seems Einstein was wrong on this one. [1]: J. S. Bell (1980), "Bertlmann's Socks and the Nature of Reality"
- hcarvalhoalves 14y agoI have no idea how this whole thing works (quantum mechanics, entanglement, "teleportation"), still there are news all over saying it's the future. I shouldn't need a degree in Physics to understand how it works. Is it really that complicated and magical, or is it still so barely understood that no one can explain in simple terms? Anyone feels the same?
- asayers 14y agoIt depends how deep an understanding you want. You don't need a degree in Physics, but if you want anything more than a superficial idea then you do need degree-level knowledge of the necessary maths and physics.
- hcarvalhoalves 14y agoI don't need a degree in Physics to understand Newton's laws, even though I couldn't derive these laws on my own. Heck, the explanation fits in three lines, and it explains a ton of things. That's the kind of understanding I mean. It seems there isn't one concise, simple explanation for these effects. I wonder if it's because the reasoning behind it is that complex that you need to resort to esoteric math and abstractions (in which case, the current theories might be crude, Occam's razor and all), or if it's because no one truly comprehends it enough to explain concisely. By the way, I picked up Leonard Susskind's lectures to watch. It was all fine up to special relativity - his explanation about frames of reference was so obvious, it just made sense. After that, though, nothing made sense anymore.
- asayers 14y agoNewton's Laws fit into three lines because most of us are already familiar with the integral concepts: force, mass, inertial reference frames, etc. The concepts involved in quantum mechanics are fairly alien to most people, so explaining the theory takes longer. The fundamentals of orthodox QM can be fit into three principles: 1) The Time-Dependent Schrödinger Equation; 2) The Time-Independent Schrödinger Equation; and 3) The Born Rule. Even writing these out in full doesn't take long. Explaining what they mean, however, can take a while. Frames of reference are fairly obvious in SR. In General Relativity they're more non-trivial.