3 ms·
...all consumer electronics can now defined as "pre-Apple" or "post-Apple" just by looking at them. So the Braun T3 radio[0] and LE1 speaker[1] are definitely
by nitrogen 14y ago
...all consumer electronics can now defined as "pre-Apple" or "post-Apple" just by looking at them.
So the Braun T3 radio[0] and LE1 speaker[1] are definitely post Apple, right?
[0] https://barryborsboom.files.wordpress.com/2008/10/172_721-rams-ipods-1.jpg https://barryborsboom.files.wordpress.com/2008/10/172_721-ra...
[1] https://barryborsboom.files.wordpress.com/2008/10/mac-speaker.jpg https://barryborsboom.files.wordpress.com/2008/10/mac-speake...
- fwr 14y agoYou are comparing a radio and a speaker with an mp3 player and a computer. Not everything is design.
- pbhjpbhj 14y agoThis whole deal is about design patents (or registered designs, depending on jurisdiction), basically the look of the box that the electronics are housed in; the content ot the box is immaterial in this respect.
- nitrogen 14y agoOsmium made the claim (which I quoted) that Apple's rise to power marks a dividing line in history, with consumer electronics from before and after that line recognizably different. My reference to two decades-old products that look far more similar to Apple hardware than a Samsung phone does to an iPhone is meant to address that specific claim. Also, seconding what pbhjpbhj said, design is all that matters in the context of a design patent/registered design.
- aes256 14y agoApple products are not designed in a vacuum. Their designers take inspiration from many sources, and Braun is one of them. There is a big difference between being inspired by a design, and blatantly ripping it off.
- nitrogen 14y agoThere is a big difference between being inspired by a design, and blatantly ripping it off. Indeed. Apple is now famous for both (Inspiration: LE1 speaker->iMac; Ripoff: Swiss Railway clock->iPhone clock). If the iPod design is "inspired by" the T3 radio design, and not a blatant ripoff, then current Samsung phones are definitely not ripoffs of the iPhone design.