3 ms·
> I also see no mention of why using urine is better/worse than just using regular water. I am guessing because "Putting electricity in water generates hydrogen
by stcredzero 14y ago
> I also see no mention of why using urine is better/worse than just using regular water. I am guessing because "Putting electricity in water generates hydrogen" is a less exciting title.
This is not electrolysis of water. In theory, they are decomposing urea to get their hydrogen, which uses far less energy. This is the same principle that would cause a hydrogen economy to be run off of natural gas. Sometimes a little knowledge is a dangerous thing. Or, in the words from Spinal Tap, there's often a thin line...
- ars 14y agoThere isn't all that much urea in human urine - less than 3%.
- stcredzero 14y agoI point this out in another comment, but that's a good point I hadn't taken into account. Getting hydrogen from urea is better than electrolysis, but there's not that much urea. Still, if the entire village contributed, it might be enough to charge cell phones and run LED reading lights, which would still be a huge boon.
- bradleyland 14y agoYou still have to input energy to get hydrogen from urea, so why not just use that energy directly? The only good reason to extract hydrogen is for storage. For example, solar energy could be used to extract the hydrogen from urea, which could then be burned at night to continue to generate power. On it's own, any technology that requires extraction of hydrogen will result in a net loss. Sometimes a HUGE net loss.
- ars 14y ago> You still have to input energy to get hydrogen from urea, so why not just use that energy directly? If you can do it efficiently enough, in theory electrolyzing urea then burning it to water (and nitrogen) is a net gain in energy.
- davorak 14y agoI believe you are mistaken in this case. The technical paper, linked from the article, will explain better then I can: http://www.suttonfruit.com/pics/urea_electrolysis.pdf http://www.suttonfruit.com/pics/urea_electrolysis.pdf
- grecy 14y ago> Still, if the entire village contributed, it might be enough to charge cell phones and run LED reading lights, which would still be a huge boon. If you think people in undeveloped countries need to generate power from their urine to charge their cell phones, you really need to get out and see the world.
- eblume 14y agoGranted, I really do need to get out and see the world. But I had thought that 'burner' cell phones were quite ubiquitous in the developing world?
- grecy 14y agoSure they are. Anywhere in the developing world that has power to run a cell tower clearly doesn't need to be extracting power from urine.
- joe_the_user 14y agoI would assume running wires to a few cell towers considerably cheaper than running wires to many villages. Indeed, isn't that why cell phones themselves are much more common than landlines in rural Africa?
- grecy 14y agoNo, it's because many developing countries "skipped" a technology. They missed out on land-lines because they were undeveloped, and now they have electricity and infrastructure, they jump straight to cell phones. For this reason, countries like Ecuador, Guatemala, etc. Have cell phone rates higher than developed countries like Australia and the US. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_number_of_mobile_phones_in_use http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_number_of_...
- joe_the_user 14y agoJeesh, it's like you're missing the trees for the forest here. Skipping technologies is the pattern but there's a reason for pattern. Developing countries don't skip technologies out of a desire for hopscotch or something. They skip wired tech because copper wires are expensive, their expense doesn't go down over time in contrast with the increasing sophistication of chips. Conventional phone lines and electrical power are both wired tech. Thus both are harder in third world conditions.
- ars 14y agoThat doesn't help. If you electrolyze water with 3% urea the vast majority of your energy is used to split water, and only a small portion of it will split the urea. But electrolyzing water, and then burning hydrogen is a net loss in energy, and the 3% urea does not give enough advantage to offset this. Maybe if you had some way to preferably electrolyze just the urea and leave the water alone, but then you have to deal with batch process (instead of just continually adding liquid), and the lower voltage makes the reaction too slow.
- davorak 14y agoThe technical paper linked from the article[0] explains how this is done. The electrolysis of urea does compete with the electrolysis of water, but it happens at a lower voltage. [0] http://www.suttonfruit.com/pics/urea_electrolysis.pdf http://www.suttonfruit.com/pics/urea_electrolysis.pdf edit: grammer
- pstuart 14y agoThere's probably more value in the urine as fertilizer.
- stcredzero 14y agoIs this a common practice in Africa? If it's not, then a village already meeting its fertilizer needs can have power after dark in addition.
- bduerst 14y agoDepends on the salt (Na) content.