7 ms·
American aviation is near collapse?
- verstandhandel 8mo agono paywall: https://archive.ph/20260323153943/https://www.theatlantic.com/newsletters/2026/03/aviation-failures-tsa-dhs-shutdown/686505/ https://archive.ph/20260323153943/https://www.theatlantic.co...
- aa_is_op 8mo ago[flagged]
- SecretDreams 8mo agoThe final paragraph is maybe the most relevant. It goes well beyond just aviation. I'm sure we've all felt this. > The ICE deployment is a particularly extreme example of what the political scientist Steven M. Teles has dubbed “kludgeocracy,” in which the government reaches for short-term, improvised solutions while resisting real reform. “‘Clumsy but temporarily effective,’” Teles has written, “also describes much of American public policy. For any particular problem we have arrived at the most gerry-rigged, opaque and complicated response.” The U.S. aviation system has been held together by such patches for years, but the kludges may finally be failing.
- wagwang 8mo agoYes, that's how I would describe using immigration to address labor shortages
- convolvatron 8mo agoI don't think there is anything inherently wrong in using immigration to address labor shortages. however, not having an official policy, such a labor visa with clearly defined rules, combined with a stable population of 'illegals' that don't have the same labor protections, is and was not really a fair or sustainable situation.
- SecretDreams 8mo agoAgreed. Immigration for a labour shortage is a tale as old as time. Mass migration was very common post WW1/2 Europe. People went where there were jobs and labour shortages. Policy around this type of thing is important. My post is more about the general dysfunction and solution schemes we see in some governments. I think having the ICE example might bring about some bots and trolls, though. I don't care for the ICE example, it's just a part of the quote.
- ryandrake 8mo agoThe US policy seems pretty clear: Allow companies who employ undocumented workers to benefit and profit from it, while making sure only the individual workers shoulder the criminal and livelihood risks.
- trimethylpurine 8mo agoI thought the policy is that you can't hire without documentation. Do you mean that there is a scheme in place, outside of the legal framework?
- ryandrake 8mo agoThere's written policy and then there's policy as-enforced.
- array_key_first 8mo agoYes, there is a legal scheme in place: you're not allowed to validate the authenticity of provided documentation as a company. If someone is undocumented, they can forge documents and that's completely allowed. The reason we have this loophole is because many industries, particularly in the South, rely directly on immigrant labor. The republicans cannot risk alienating their consistency or further hurting the already brittle economy of Red states. That's why we get a constant flow of completely ineffective and performative solutions, like ICE. Just start locking up executives who have employees that are undocumented, and the problem would disappear before your very eyes. But, building a wall is easier, and you can see a wall.
- ambicapter 8mo agoDescribes problem-solving in every company I've worked at as well.
- woodpanel 8mo agoClumsy solutions for short term political wins, you say? So like instead of hiring by merit doing it via DEI?
- mikkupikku 8mo agoI'm not saying the article's thesis is wrong, much of it rings true to me, but we have very comprehensive data and statistics concerning air travel so I'm deeply unimpressed by this article instead hanging its argument on a hodgepodge list of incidents instead of digging into the data to get some proper numbers.
- postflopclarity 8mo ago> but we have very comprehensive data and statistics concerning air travel somehow I feel like conditions may have changed since that data was collected. just a hunch.
- mikkupikku 8mo agoSafety / incident data collection and publishing from the FAA and NTSB are basically live, you'll get incidents logged within days at most and preliminary reports usually within a few weeks. What lags the most are data analysis and interpretations, but major newspapers should probably be prepared to do their own data analysis if they're making grand proclaiments like the collapse of an industry...
- happytoexplain 8mo agoWe have "very comprehensive data and statistics" indicating that US aviation is not nearing collapse? I don't understand what you mean.
- n_u 8mo agoI think they mean they would prefer more rigorous statistical analysis. "Rigor cleans the window through which intuition shines" - Ellis Cooper
- HPsquared 8mo ago"Collapse" isn't within the statistical distribution though, so you'd still to apply judgement in any case. I suppose it's a word with many definitions.
- exe34 8mo ago[flagged]
- billfor 8mo agoIt’s a good thing new hires don’t have to wait or be rejected because the FAA needed to hire a different race or sex for the position.
- nathan_compton 8mo agoThe FAA never had any such policies as far as I can tell.
- billfor 8mo agoThis will get downvoted from the mindless reactionaries here but here’s the link to the practice. https://nypost.com/2025/02/10/us-news/air-traffic-controller-shortage-of-3800-due-to-dei-practices/ https://nypost.com/2025/02/10/us-news/air-traffic-controller...
- nathan_compton 8mo agoThis is just some claim by a person. I appreciate the context but as far as I can tell no such policy was on the books. The person making the claim has a clear motivated reason for claiming such and its all pretty vague.
- exe34 8mo agoIt's okay, one claim is all that's needed for this adminstration and the current overton window in the US. The eternal leader himself changes his tune from sentence to sentence - the US has already won, the US needs help, the US was just testing the US has agreed to a ceasefire after discussions with Iran, even when Iran wasn't actually there. What matters is that the claim was made, and now you have to pretend it is true.
- 8mo ago
- ryandrake 8mo agoJust a standard warning to readers: when you use an archive.ph (or other archive.today) link, you risk your computer's resources being used to participate in a DDOS against another web site, as reported/discussed recently on HN[1]. 1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46624740 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46624740
- davidcollantes 8mo agoGot a link to the entry?
- ryandrake 8mo agoUpdated my reply with the initial story, but there have been followups on HN.
- jasonmp85 8mo ago[dead]
- samschooler 8mo agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Archive.today_guidance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Archive.today_guidan...
- TacticalCoder 8mo ago[flagged]
- bena 8mo agoYou are being disingenuous. The article is about the aviation industry as a whole. The article talks about various accidents that have occured in the past few years. What it means for airports, etc. Then there's a section about the airports and TSA. TSA is currently working without pay due to a shutdown over funding. The issue of contention in this funding bill is ICE. The administration is responding by sending ICE to airports to fulfill TSA functions or not, it's, as always, unclear with this administration. The article has 10 paragraphs. 3 mention ICE.
- mhb 8mo agoUh, they know their audience? I read about the crash on the NY Times. Then I saw that there were comments so I thought to myself what can people have to say about a plane crash where it looks like ATC told the truck to stop? Times readers did not disappoint: Congress and government shutdown, lack of TSA staffing, Trump’s fault, ICE, DOGE…
- poink 8mo agoThe article is clearly not "about" ICE. One paragraph talks about the ICE deployment
- hnburnsy 8mo agoIt is the Atlantic, surprised Elon Musk didn't catch some strays in this piece.
- oblio 8mo agoYour numbers for France don't match anything I can find online. The number of immigrants per year seems to have been max 340k, about 50% have employment quickly, etc. You complain about "leftists" but as someone who definitely doesn't want open borders, the general fear in your comment and the numbers that seem made up make your comment read a lot more like (far-) "rightist" stuff.
- riffraff 8mo ago
- Someone1234 8mo agoA lot of core services in the US are near collapse, because society focuses on short-term value extraction, over long term success. If you look at the US's history, there was a much better balance between the two (with the core being seen as a lever towards future wealth). You see this in education, infrastructure, public health, scientific research, housing, and energy. All foundational systems of a society, which compound the value of everything else, but they aren't immediate profit centers so kick the ball down the road. It is an attitude problem first and foremost; and I'm not sure how you fix that. PS - This also impacts private enterprise, like corporations. Enshittify their current offerings for the next quarter bump but ruin their brand reputation/long-term viability.
- esafak 8mo agoThrough the right incentives, like repealing quarterly reporting requirements. https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/us-sec-preparing-eliminate-quarterly-reporting-requirement-wsj-says-2026-03-16/ https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/us-sec-preparing-el...
- lotsofpulp 8mo agoQuarterly reporting requirements are clearly not the causal factor in short term incentives. All the best performing publicly listed businesses invest on decades long timelines risking billions and tens of billions of dollars. Simultaneously, plenty of non publicly listed businesses make decisions that benefit in the short term at the expense of the long term. Reducing quarterly reporting requirements does reduce transparency, however,
- Ethee 8mo agoI'd argue more that it's an incentive alignment problem. From the 70s on we changed the way a lot of the incentives work so corporations could more freely capture markets and a lot of Americans were convinced that this would help enrich them as well. All it's done is hollow out our social services and further consolidate wealth in this country. Ironically the people most hurt by these policies are the ones who keep voting for them so until we hit some catalyst inflection point where people can map the policies being enacted onto what's happening in their own lives this cycle will continue. Most Americans seem pretty ready to accept whatever bullshit makes them feel good so the beatings will either continue until morale improves or until everyone feels beaten enough to do something. Seems more likely it's the former than the latter.
- nimbius 8mo agoit is a perfect storm: - deregulation of airlines in the 1980s led to rampant consolidation of routes and SPOF hubs that only work for revenue purposes and offer no real resilience in traffic planning. over-subscription of flights and lack of any real competition compounds this issue. - climate change and global warming increasingly exacerbate severe weather conditions that ground aircraft and incur delays or cancellations in an already fragile system - reagan-era policy hostile toward air traffic control labor unions that once checked the excesses of capital resulted in understaffing issues for more than two decades later. poor regulation of working hours, outmoded systems, and wage stagnation has further stressed the ATC system. - the partial government shutdown has caused massive delays and cancellations of flights as the artifice of security theater begins to break down under its own political morass. the solution is reform and regulation through policy change and investment. this is not possible in late stage capitalism (Streeck, 2016.)
- jjk166 8mo agoCalling it a perfect storm is too generous. This is deliberately tearing down the floodgates that protect you from the extremely normal and predictable storms.
- jeffbee 8mo ago[flagged]
- HarHarVeryFunny 8mo agoProblems related to air traffic controllers and TSA staff aren't a sign of "american aviation" being near collapse - they are a sign of american goverment being near collapse. This is critical national infrastructure - stop playing stupid political games with it.
- jorblumesea 8mo agoThis is largely true for almost all US public services. Decades of focusing on the needs of the 1% is producing a situation where almost everything is under funded or poorly implemented. Critical infrastructure isn't a priority.
- buredoranna 8mo agoPeople who dedicate their lives to studying an industry, can get very good at being able to predict the probability of events in their domain. These same people are commonly off by orders of magnitude when predicting the magnitude of these same events. The author of this article won the "Toner Prize for Excellence in National Political Reporting". I'm going to infer from this, that he's better at political reporting, than he is at predicting the future of an entire industry. And if he is truly convinced of this outcome, he should be shorting the airlines. (I'm gonna guess he hasn't done that). (edit: syntax)
- rsync 8mo agoI am flying from SFO -> DEN in a few days and I see that Denver wait time is 4 minutes and, as is well known, SFO does not use TSA or federal security staff. Denver does, however, so I wonder why there is no wait at DEN and hundreds of minutes at Houston/Atlanta/JFK ?
- oceanplexian 8mo agoI’m a frequent flier and flown into all of the above, the ones with TSA issues have been perpetually mismanaged under the best conditions, it’s not even remotely surprising that they are having issues under pressure.
- znkynz 8mo agoI am amazed every day that people are expected to turn up every day to work while being unpaid. In westminster-style parlimentary systems, if a government can't guarantee supply[1], they are sacked, and a snap election is called. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confidence_and_supply https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confidence_and_supply The paralysis of the political system in the US is either a feature or a bug depending on your point of view i suppose, but no question that it is entirely dysfunctional that a government can continue existing if it can't pass a budget.
- kimos 8mo agoThis is how Canada works (Westminster style). When a govt tables a budget it goes to a vote, and if they can’t get the votes to pass it it triggers a no-confidence vote in the govt and away we go to an election.
- Helloworldboy 8mo ago[dead]
- riffraff 8mo agoThis is not news, there was an episode of Last Week Tonight on the Air Traffic Control crisis last summer[0]. From memory: on the human side airports are understaffed, there are no young controllers in the pipeline, attrition is high, and the less people are available the higher the burnout rate, which creates a vicious cycle. On the technical side, airports are unmaintained, systems are obsolete and crumbling. John Oliver makes the case that most of the issue is that the FAA is financed through discretionary spending so e.g. it's subject to shut downs and can't do long term planning. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YeABJbvcJ_k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YeABJbvcJ_k
- FpUser 8mo ago>" A careful, iterative process of safety regulation culminated in a 16-year period, from 2009 to 2025, when no U.S. airline had a fatal crash." This is quite amazing
- jeremie_strand 8mo ago[flagged]
- jeremie_strand 8mo ago[flagged]
- jeremie_strand 8mo ago[flagged]