7 ms·
Apple script resizes iPad banner and pushes Samsung verdict out of view
- w1ntermute 14y agoI really hope they get reamed by the judge again for this. It would be great to see them forced to place the verdict at the top of the page. Unfortunately, the judge probably has no idea what JS is.
- joering2 14y agothis is not 2001. Plenty of judges know this stuff (heck, some been favorized Facebook by slightly skewing their decisionsm, because FB helped them connect with further family) and I am sure well presented and explained case will make it through. I hope they get punished hard.
- meaty 14y agoJudge will work it out. You do not fuck with a legal judgement in the UK - they will start pulling the big guns next. Place your bets: frozen assets or criminal charge?
- Osmium 14y agoWhere in the legal judgement did it say it had to be "above the fold"? They could have specified this if they'd wanted it.
- lutze 14y agoIt's a spirit of the law issue, again. Judges aren't friggin robots. You don't get to fuck around and have them go "BEEP BOOP WELL TECHNICALLY NOT A VIOLATION BEEP BOOP". The whole point of a judge is to, well, use his/her judgement. If this judge thinks Apple is fucking with him AGAIN, I can't imagine he'll be at all lenient. Apple is holding his authority in contempt.
- anonymouz 14y agoI believe the GPs point is that judges do not take kindly to cat-and-mouse games, where you technically follow the court order by the letter but twist and turn it in such a way that it's spirit is violated. The order is not intended as a challenge on how to best wriggle out of it, and just because the court did not explicitly specify every last detail of how the message must be displayed does not mean that it will tolerate any tricks.
- Osmium 14y agoBy that token, though, the court did specify what they wanted: a link, 11pt text. So they'd not afraid of specificity. If they're wanted something more attention-grabbing, they could've said it must include, e.g. "a graphic at least x pixels by y pixels." I think another way of looking at it is this: if they don't request a particular location for the link, do they think Apple's going to put it anywhere other than the bottom of the page? And if so, the consequence (where this javascript exists or not) is that on a great number of devices you won't see it unless you scroll down.
- PeterisP 14y agoThey don't have to also specify that the text should be in a color different than the background and is not covered by a black rectangle. There are rules for contempt of court. They include jail time. They should be applied for such repeat contempt.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jrockway 14y agoWhat would that achieve? The people making the decisions are in the US, outside of the UK's jurisdiction. So the court would have to go after some minion in the UK office, punishing someone for the sake of punishing someone rather than for the sake of justice.
- 14y ago
- colmvp 14y agoIndeed. Do we need studies that show people do scroll below the fold? I noticed that on the Apple homepage the modules cut off at the bottom (on my resolution) it's clear there is more to the page. Seriously, it's 2012. Do we still have to fight about 'the fold?'
- DannyBee 14y agoThis is a very slippery slope to go down. It's arguments like these that cause you to end up with laws that have lists of thousands of things in them. Would you rather have fair use be a list of 10 things, and only those 10 things, or something that you should follow the spirit of?
- Zenst 14y agoIn the UK the judges will not be ammused. But this aspect of legal terminology does cover such matters http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Letter_and_spirit_of_the_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Letter_and_spirit_of_the_law
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pasbesoin 14y agoI don't know how things work in the UK, but I wonder whether the equivalent of contempt charges will be forthcoming. Toss a few of them in prison for a bit, and see whether that improves cooperation.
- pasbesoin 14y agoWhile I was being ascerbic, I was not being facetious. We have a similar problem in the U.S.; in corporations, effectively no one ends up being personally responsible. However, if an individual personally fails to implement a judicial ruling, that anonymization and "monefication" of penalty may dissolve. I'm of very mixed opinion and feeling about several laws that may be involved -- both aspects of IP law and aspects of UK libel law. But I also rather dislike unbridled corporate arrogance.
- theboywho 14y agoI think you too have no idea what JS is. The script basically resizes the window based on weather you're on a touch device or not. It has nothing to do with the Samsung apology.
- chacha102 14y agoI'm using a fairly long screen and I can see the verdict fine. I don't think this was specifically put to get rid of the apology. More likely, the top image is always suppose to be fairly large and fit the screen well. I wouldn't put it past Apple to make things look nice.
- rhizome 14y agoExcept when it comes to the text of the message, for some reason.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- w1ntermute 14y ago> I think you too have no idea what JS is. The script basically resizes the window based on weather you're on a touch device or not. Actually, you're the one who has no idea what JS is. I just resized a Chrome window with http://www.apple.co.uk/ http://www.apple.co.uk/ loaded in it on my Windows desktop PC. As I changed the height of the window, the content above the Samsung apology was resized so that the apology would be hidden unless I scrolled down. It is most definitely not restricted to touch devices.
- spazmaster 14y agoSame here, 1440x900px screen. You have to make the content tiny before you see the statement above the fold.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- javert 14y agoI really disagree. Forcing someone to say something they don't agree with is a violation of free speech.
- felipeko 14y agoFirst, a corporation is not someone. Second, forcing a corporation to repair the damage they done is the right thing to do.
- javert 14y agoRegardless of "corporate personhood," this still amounts to forcing individual people to say something they disagree with. They should still be forced to pay damages. In this case, sufficient damages for Samsung to publicize the ruling. Forcing people to say something they disagree with is very dangerous. Reminds me of the ancient Catholic Church and their struggles with scientists.
- hahainternet 14y agoPlease name an individual person who has been forced.
- javert 14y agoIn this case, literally everyone who works for Apple or holds Apple stock. Would it help to imagine a company in Apple's position that was a sole proprietorship with no employees? So the company was just one guy? What about a company with 5 shareholders who work on the business, and no employees?
- CamperBob2 14y agoForcing people to say something they disagree with is very dangerous. Reminds me of the ancient Catholic Church and their struggles with scientists. What legal remedy do you feel should be available to Samsung in this case? Apple made a claim in its advertising that was found to be untruthful under the law. Why isn't it fair that they be required to publish a retraction? Bear in mind that the UK does not have anything resembling the First Amendment in the US Constitution, and even in the US, libel in particular and false advertising in general are not considered eligible for "free speech" defenses.
- Shivetya 14y agoHow about reamed by geeks? I for one decided my recent seven inch tablet purchase and now my upcoming ten inch tablet purchase based on Apple's bad behavior. This just reinforces the idea in my head that I made the right choice. The Nexus tablets offer an incredible amount of features at a price point Apple doesn't even try to compete at and all without the Assholiness of Apple
- shinratdr 14y ago> The Nexus tablets offer an incredible amount of features at a price point Apple doesn't even try to compete at and all without the Assholiness of Apple I like how you posted you BS reason and then followed it up with the real reason, pricing is more of a concern to you and you hate Apple. Yeah, something tells me even if this whole incident had never happened, you would end up with a Nexus tablet and not an iPad. Call it a hunch.
- tisme 14y ago>> http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4737400 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4737400 That's the second time you post an almost identical comment in a thread about people not buying apple products due to their behaviour and you're telling them they are not truthful. What reason would someone have to say anything whatsoever about a decision they've made? It's not as if they have Samsung stock or are shorting Apple. They are simple statements of fact. If someone states something about themselves then your best bet is to believe they know better than you what made them decide.
- shinratdr 14y ago> That's the second time you post an almost identical comment in a thread about people not buying apple products due to their behaviour and you're telling them they are not truthful. Actually I was arguing that they aren't buying Apple products because of this particular incident, not their overall behaviour. That I buy, it's a small segment of the population but it does exist. However I'm seriously skeptical that anyone would actually choose an Android tablet instead of an iPad because of this particular incident. It's a ridiculous prospect, and indicative of a consumer that has no real preferences about the device they buy, they're just running purely on spite. GP basically just came right out and said that. > If someone states something about themselves then your best bet is to believe they know better than you what made them decide. I'm not allowed to apply critical thinking skills to statements others make about themselves? That's pretty ridiculous. And since when did I argue against that? I'm sure he does know his motivations better than I. That doesn't mean for a second that he's being honest with us or himself about those motivations.
- jakejake 14y agoI don't really care one way or the other, but I'm curious why Apple is being "shamed" in a sense. There are copyright rulings all the time but I haven't noticed or read about too many websites with notices posted on them. Was this a condition of the plea bargain, or is this just something that is common in the UK?
- Niten 14y agoFirst this is patent, not copyright law. And the issue is that Apple has effectively committed libel against Samsung in the UK with its repeated claims that the Samsung tablet is a copy of the iPad. This claim has turned out to be legally false, and now Apple is obliged to correct any turn of public opinion against Samsung that it instigated by making this false claim in the first place.
- ionwake 14y agoplus apple were DICKS about it
- shinratdr 14y agoOh my god, companies being petty in the legal department!? Say it ain't so!
- jagira 14y agoTotally worth a billion dollars. :-)
- Camillo 14y agoSo it's the same libel laws that we were regarding as batshit insane just a few months ago, when they were being used to silence scientists and journalists. But since they're now being used against a company some people don't like, the tune has changed to "you don't mess with the UK courts", "they had it coming", "my judge can beat up your judge", and similar outbursts of vicarious machismo. I find the tribalism in the tech community reprehensible.
- Zenst 14y agoTHe judges a couple of days ago already lambasted Apple for the wording, details such as JS will not phase judges. It is the output and end result and if somebody smells something a miss then the judges will be told. They may not be the fastest or most aware, but they do look at the end result and if they see shinangigans or even a hint of it then they will ask what is going on. If they are not happy with the answear then they bite and they can bite. Generaly there pretty firm but fair so apple needs to play ball and stop trying to be clever as it will only work against them.
- jsnk 14y agoJust for the record. var HeroResize=AC.Class({initialize:function(b){this._height=null;this._hero=$(b); AC.Object.synthesize(this);this.__boundResizeHero=this.resizeHero.bindAsEventListener(this); if(typeof window.ontouchstart==="undefined"){this.resizeHero();Event.observe(window,"resize",this.__boundResizeHero) }},setHeight:function(b){this._height=(b<0)?0:b;return this._height},resizeHero:function(){this.setHeight(parseInt(window.innerHeight||(window.document.documentElement.clientHeight||window.document.body.clientHeight),10)-310); this.hero().style.height=this.height()+"px"}});Event.onDOMReady(function(){var b=new HeroResize("billboard") });
- jrajav 14y agovar HeroResize = AC.Class({ initialize: function (b) { this._height = null; this._hero = $(b); AC.Object.synthesize(this); this.__boundResizeHero = this.resizeHero.bindAsEventListener(this); if (typeof window.ontouchstart === "undefined") { this.resizeHero(); Event.observe(window, "resize", this.__boundResizeHero) } }, setHeight: function (b) { this._height = (b < 0) ? 0 : b; return this._height }, resizeHero: function () { this.setHeight(parseInt(window.innerHeight || (window.document.documentElement.clientHeight || window.document.body.clientHeight), 10) - 310); this.hero().style.height = this.height() + "px" } }); Event.onDOMReady(function () { var b = new HeroResize("billboard") });
- Tyr42 14y agoI don't see the Samsung verdict anywhere on the page or in the source.
- Breakthrough 14y agoIt only shows up on http://www.apple.co.uk http://www.apple.co.uk, since the ruling was made in the UK.
- kordless 14y agoI wonder if I go to http://www.apple.com/ http://www.apple.com/ if it redirects to the UK site if I'm in the UK?
- Osmium 14y agoIt doesn't, but this has always been the case. Apple didn't even own apple.co.uk until recently; the official site was apple.com/uk
- chris24 14y agoMost likely not. Apple generally does not redirect people to their locale-specific version of their site. I'm in Canada, and I can visit apple.com without being redirected to apple.ca, for instance.
- Breakthrough 14y agoMan, this just keeps getting better... You think after the first time they would just have accepted the loss, put up the message, and gone on with things. It's amazing the extent they are willing to go to subvert the verdict. Of course, this is only if the script is indeed meant to push the ruling out of view...
- joering2 14y agoreally? Don't you think that trillion dollar valuation gave every exec @ Apple some steel balls? Apple products are so loved by masses that I bet ya if, for example, a judge would ban sell of Apple products in the city like New York, you would find some idiot on a manslaughter mission.
- rhizome 14y agoI think even without the script story it's plain that Apple is acting like a child here.
- tnuc 14y agoWhat page of the apple site should I be looking at to see this script in action?
- jimrandomh 14y agoAdditionally, there is a script to measure what fraction of people scroll down. That script is not new; Apple knows exactly how many people this will prevent from seeing the notice.
- rogerb 14y agoDo we know whether or not this was the behavior on the site prior to them having to post this ?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ______ 14y agoJudging from the fact that this same behavior does _not_ occur on the apple.com site, which is running the same exact promo of the iPad mini, my guess is that this is something new and not the existing behavior.
- jason_slack 14y agoCan someone explain though, non-code, under what conditions is the resizing taking place?
- NoahSussman 14y agoThe onresize event fires whenever you change the sized of your browser window. Eg it occurs when you maximize the window or when you click-and-drag on the corner of the window in order to make it smaller or larger. See also https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/DOM/window.onresize https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/DOM/window.onresize
- Heliosmaster 14y agoand when you zoom out.
- dmbass 14y agoIt resizes the height of the "hero" element (the iPad mini promo at this time) so that it takes up the whole height of the browser window, pushing the footer below the fold.
- jason_slack 14y agoso thus pushing the verdict out of view without scrolling down....which if they make it take up the whole space, most people dont bother scrolling down...
- mirkules 14y agoIt's interesting that without javascript the menu is less spaced-apart, and the iPad Mini image is smaller. You can see the elements shift up and down the page as you turn on/off javascript. I do suspect that this is nefarious because the US version of the front page does not exhibit the same behavior -- i.e. disabling javascript does not move elements (and thus, the judgement) up and down the screen at all, nor does it resize the iPad mini image.
- 14y ago
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- kami8845 14y agoThe statement can be found on http://www.apple.co.uk http://www.apple.co.uk for anyone wondering.
- archgrove 14y agoThis behaviour is the same on apple.de or apple.jp, so it's not just the UK site. Moreover, it was added only 2 days after the judgement was upheld: HEAD /v/home/n/scripts/hero_resize.js HTTP/1.1 Host: www.apple.com HTTP/1.1 200 OK Server: Apache **Last-Modified: Sun, 21 Oct 2012 19:31:51 GMT** Accept-Ranges: bytes Content-Length: 632 Content-Type: application/x-javascript Cache-Control: max-age=600 Expires: Sat, 03 Nov 2012 17:04:23 GMT Date: Sat, 03 Nov 2012 16:54:23 GMT Connection: keep-alive I believe this was before the homepage was altered to display the ruling. Moreover, this was also just 2 days before the iPad mini was announced. Far more likely this is just related to new product announcements than any nefarious scheme.
- jrajav 14y agoI don't see how it matters that the behavior was added before the text itself. It's more relevant that it was added after the judgement.
- archgrove 14y agoSo anything, any time, that alters the vertical spacing of the Apple homepage around the world, even if it's only 2 days before a major product roll-out is related to an 15pt font paragraph at the bottom of their UK homepage that no-one except the lawyers will even click on? Moreover, given that they've pissed off the judge once, their own lawyers won't have signed off on 5 times over? I find that rather implausible, though I guess it's not impossible.
- uvTwitch 14y agoConsidering the original snarky wording of their non-apology, I find it highly implausible that it's related to anything but.
- tankenmate 14y agoIn other words, plausible deniability in action.
- deleted 14y ago
- fludlight 14y agoI don't see what the big deal is. When I go to http://apple.co.uk http://apple.co.uk I see a statement about Samsung in reasonably sized, clear print: "On 25 October 2012, Apple Inc. published a statement on its UK website in relation to Samsung's Galaxy tablet computers. That statement was inaccurate and did not comply with the order of the Court of Appeal of England and Wales. The correct statement is at Samsung/Apple UK judgement." Screenshot, in case you see something else: http://imgur.com/79bBm http://imgur.com/79bBm Edit: Oh, I see...the statement gets pushed below the first visible page so you have to scroll to see it, which most people don't. Still, so what? Where did you guys expect them to put it? Tattooed on Tim Cook's forehead? Joe the plumber doesn't care about intellectual property disputes between electronics companies.
- tankenmate 14y agoJoe the plumber may not care, but then Joe can't hold Apple in contempt.
- sigzero 14y agoNeither can the Judge. The exact wording is right there. So what if you have to scroll to see it. That isn't contempt.
- tankenmate 14y agoIf the intent is for it to be readily visible, then it may be contempt; they could have set the text colour to be #FFFFFF and it would still be the right words on the front page....
- pfortuny 14y agoThey are really playing with fire...
- MattDL 14y agoI could have seen this being unrelated and just a UX polishing touch, but then they didn't think to put it on the other versions of the site to at least try and make it less suspicious. Pushing past the limits of acceptability now, they should face some fairly serious punishment for this.
- frugalmail 14y agoThe sleezy-ness of Apple is completely unacceptable as of late
- sek 14y agoThis stuff makes this company so incredibly unlikable. Maybe some uninformed consumers don't see it, but for informed people Apple loses sympathy every day with this behavior.
- TillE 14y agoAs someone who wants to like Apple (and owns a bunch of iOS gear), I agree. But the fanboys are loving it. I'll never understand that kind of corporate partisanship. Realistically, 99% of potential customers won't even know about this sort of thing. But sometimes I do wish Apple would just make the tiny bit of effort to step on to the moral high ground.
- Osmium 14y ago>I'll never understand that kind of corporate partisanship. It's no different from sport and patriotism. It's exactly the same mentality. Everyone* has their team.
- TillE 14y agoBut with sports, at least there's a purpose. It's not very interesting if you don't care about the outcome, so you pick teams to support. Preferably local ones so you can go to games. And it's fun. With companies, you gain absolutely nothing by "supporting" them in the same way. You're just ceding objectivity that's useful when making purchasing decisions.
- gurkendoktor 14y ago> But the fanboys are loving it. I see that it's problematic to point at people on the internet - but is there any proof of this? I get the impression that the whole internet knows that "Apple fanboys are like that" when there are only 2.5 people somewhere deep inside MacRumors who actually confirm the stereotype.
- Cbasedlifeform 14y agoThis whole thing is turning into a PR disaster for Apple... Some variation on the Streisand Effect. When Apple first posted the "apology" Gruber et al all whooped up how clever Apple was. A bit of blowback now.
- aes256 14y ago> This whole thing is turning into a PR disaster for Apple... Some variation on the Streisand Effect. Hardly a PR disaster. 99% of Apple customers don't have a clue this is even going on.
- shinratdr 14y ago> Some variation on the Streisand Effect. In this case, the variation is "a bunch of nerds try desperately to make a mountain out of a molehill and nobody cares except themselves". Maybe we should come up with a new name.
- Cbasedlifeform 14y agoThe "Kardashian Effect"? After all, nobody gives a fuck about her :)
- nirvana 14y agoOh, such a disaster. The UK legal system is shown to be the joke it is, sowing contempt among thinking people everywhere. The mindless apple haters whoop and cheer and continue their petulant childishness. Samsung, and android, still fail in the marketplace, which, at least for now, values technical innovation over counterfiet crap.
- mcpoulet 14y agoThis script was already used in september for the iPhone 5 homepage. This is simply called vertical responsive design. See these screenshots for exemple : http://www.flickr.com/photos/shawnblanc/7980347228/in/photostream http://www.flickr.com/photos/shawnblanc/7980347228/in/photos... It has nothing to do with the Samsung trial's verdict.
- leddt 14y agoIt is not used on the US site which does not feature the statement. If it did I might agree with you, but in the current state of affairs it looks really fishy.
- msbarnett 14y ago> It is not used on the US site which does not feature the statement. But the resize is used on apple.de, apple.co.jp, apple.ca, and a lot of othe country-specific sites, none of which display the statement.
- mcpoulet 14y agoThe US site has the iPad 4 featured on the homepage. All the other sites have the iPad mini featured. I'm pretty sure that once the other countries switch to the iPad 4 feature, the script will disappear as well.
- lignuist 14y agoI guess the judge will soon design the Apple frontpage himself with MS Paint, if Apple doesn't stop this behaviour in the next few days.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoWhile a bit deceptive, I think it's rather funny and cute. I almost get the impression that Apple is intentionally mocking the court. I know it doesn't make business sense, but it seems like they had to know they're taking a bit of a risk in not complying in full-faith.
- metatronscube 14y agoI went to the page to see what all the bother was about and ended up buying an iPad mini (to replace nexus 7). Thanks Samsung. You can't pay for this publicity.
- msg 14y agoPlausible deniability or no, Apple was very dumb not to put themselves above reproach here. If a CSS/JS behavior interferes with your ability to comply with a court order, that just means you have two problems. I for one don't believe Apple is being contrite and forthright about the harm they were judged to do to Samsung in the marketplace. These judges will clearly lean on Apple until they get the message.
- radley 14y agoThis post's title is a little off. Apple is using a script to push the verdict "below the fold".
- mamby 14y agounfair!
- kbs 14y agoThey are also using a 'sosumi' comment, guess they still want to tweak someone's nose. $ curl -s www.apple.com/uk/ | grep -A 1 /sosumi </div><!--/sosumi--> <p class="statement">On 25 October 2012, Apple Inc. published a statement on its UK website...
- swang 14y agoThat's actually for the div for Apple's copyright notice, which has a classname of sosumi.
- aggarwalachal 14y agoDid they just update the homepage on apple.com? Shows the iPad 4th gen now.
- whoisstan 14y agoSamsung is a soul less copy cat. Of course I push any word of them below the fold.
- RKearney 14y agoUnfortunately in trying to be clever, they destroyed the page when trying to zoom in and out. http://i.imgur.com/ssKsU.png http://i.imgur.com/ssKsU.png So they sacrificed accessibility for what, trying to be childish and clever in the execution of a court order?
- alextingle 14y agoThey've still got the deliberate line break between "do not" and "infringe". That trick is designed to blunt the impact of the message: do not</span> <span class="nowrap">infringe
- orionblastar 14y agoThis is just a trick by Apple who don't want to admit to doing anything wrong. Expect the judge to notice this and issue another order that the text must be readable and not covered up with Javscript tricks.