4 ms·
> that everyone else is missing? To be fair, sometimes they do. Musk saw genuine bloat at Twitter. I’m doubtful one can optimize that much out of WarnerBrother
by JumpCrisscross 9mo ago
> that everyone else is missing?
To be fair, sometimes they do. Musk saw genuine bloat at Twitter. I’m doubtful one can optimize that much out of WarnerBrothers. But Hollywood isn’t exactly known for being efficient.
- pinkmuffinere 9mo agoYa, I totally agree, given that both CEOs see some significant value here, and I trust one to be fairly calculated, I assume they’re at least partially correct. But I sincerely don’t know _what_ they think they see. If it’s just layoffs, then why doesn’t WBD see the same thing and do the layoffs themselves? If it’s IP, then why do shareholders disagree? Wtf is it, lol
- rayiner 9mo agoCan’t you replace a lot of Hollywood with AI now? What am I missing?
- onetokeoverthe 9mo ago[dead]
- CyberDildonics 9mo agoProve it
- bandrami 9mo agoNot if you want to copyright the output
- dctoedt 8mo ago> Not if you want to copyright the output That gets tricky: To the extent that an AI is just a tool — along the lines of a trained pair of hands executing a human prompter's specific, detailed instructions — the human prompter might qualify as an "author." From the U.S. Copyright Office in January 2025: "The Office affirms that existing principles of copyright law are flexible enough to apply to this new technology, as they have applied to technological innovations in the past. It concludes that the outputs of generative AI can be protected by copyright only where a human author has determined sufficient expressive elements. "This can include situations where a human-authored work is perceptible in an AI output, or a human makes creative arrangements or modifications of the output, but not the mere provision of prompts. "The Office confirms that the use of AI to assist in the process of creation or the inclusion of AI-generated material in a larger human-generated work does not bar copyrightability. "It also finds that the case has not been made for changes to existing law to provide additional protection for AI-generated outputs." https://www.copyright.gov/newsnet/2025/1060.html https://www.copyright.gov/newsnet/2025/1060.html (emphasis and extra paragraphing added).
- rayiner 8mo agoInteresting, thank you for sharing. That’s surprising to me though when you see the reasoning it makes sense.
- bandrami 8mo agoThe closest analogy is to a music producer sampling public domain audio. The composition will be protected by copyright but each individual sample will not. Every single CGI rendered frame of Shrek is protected by copyright because it was human authored. It they used a diffuser to make Shrek 7, the individual frames would not be protected by copyright but their arrangement into a movie could be. That's a hugely different legal situation (for instance, if I chopped it up and made my own remix of it that would be protected).
- bandrami 8mo agoThough this is complicated by the fact that the LLM initial training may have been massively illegal (or at least massively tortious). There's still a bunch of legal shoes to drop, one way or the other
- ben_w 8mo agoNot "a lot" of Hollywood, not yet. Short clips are doable, but the coherency duration before it goes weird just isn't there yet, unless you're OK with very short segments (like, single-digit seconds) between each AI-equivalent of a cut. That will probably improve, but the tech isn't there yet for "a lot", it's like CGI in the 90s rather than CGI as it is today. That's aside from how AI output isn't copyrightable, which may or may not matter depending on if your goal is money or propaganda.
- fragmede 8mo agoYou haven't been seeing what's been coming out of models from China. Hollywood is the Wiley coyote that hasn't looked down yet. They're turbo fucked.
- happymellon 8mo ago> You haven't been seeing what's been coming out of models from China. Citations? I haven't, and would be genuinely curious if it is better than the AI short clip slop that appears on YouTube and really just needs to be taken out back and shot. I have no doubt that its coming, I just haven't seen it yet.
- ben_w 8mo agoI think there's two things contributing to YouTube slop, the earlier generations of free model being one, the other is more fundamental: most people using these tools for slop only care about advertising money, they neither know nor care about how much of a difference artistic taste makes (hence also why there's so many YouTube shorts which are just a clip from a random TV show with inappropriate music added, sometimes as a mic-drop, sometimes just obscuring the dialogue, but how even are YT shorts monetised?) FWIW, there are models which are better than the majority of the YouTube slop I've seen*; but even then, when I show short clips from e.g. Google's "Flow" generator to others, those others find the results unimpressive. Also, the voice range is weird, my experience playing with them it had a much harder time of creating a decent working-class British accent than Dick Van Dyke. However, amongst the various issues Flow has, the most obvious is length, because even though Flow lets me "extend" a clip, it's not got enough coherency between each (8 second?) segment when I do. The second biggest issue is that, as with Stable Diffusion before it, it quite often produces stuff you just don't want. Junk dealers don't care about that and use the first result, an artist can afford to do 10 attempts and pick the right one, and will care to, too. That's something I can at least expect will be solved, or has been on non-free tools (control nets etc.) even though I don't expect slop dealers to ever bother with them. If each 8 seconds of video was actually Hollywood quality (they're not, in any sense including resolution) and they were coherent when extended (likewise, they're not), as there's 750 times 8 seconds in a 100 minute film, it would still be an existential threat to Hollywood if those segments cost $1333, because that's a million dollars and in the cost range of "micro-budget indie", rather than the tens of millions that even normal-indie films cost (before marketing etc.) or hundreds of millions that blockbusters cost. I have no idea how video generators scale up in cost with time or resolution, let alone quality, so I don't want to make guesses on how much extra compute (or indeed training data) would be needed for a coherent 2 minute cut-equivalent at 4k. As I don't like the epistemic collapse we're already witnessing with clips from video games being passed off as coverage of warfare, I very much hope this is one of those things which fails to scale up. * although even with early models, if you wield them as an artist rather than as a slop merchant you get interesting output; you may remember the Harry Potter Balenciaga videos from a few years back, same channel and you can see how things have changed: https://www.youtube.com/@demonflyingfox/videos https://www.youtube.com/@demonflyingfox/videos
- JeremyNT 8mo agoI mean he bought Twitter for clout / soft power, the business is mostly irrelevant. He arguably single handedly shifted the entire Overton window in the US to the right, and got his preferred candidate elected. It's reasonable to assume that Ellison is interested in the exact same kind of power, but over the broader culture.
- jaredklewis 8mo agoVery hard for me to believe Musk didn’t overpay for Twitter. So whatever he saw, I don’t think was there. Hard to know completely for sure given it is private. But I strongly suspect that money definitely would be making him more in passive investments. If the argument is that it was a stupid business decision, but he had other motives (clout, etc…), sure whatever.
- JumpCrisscross 8mo ago> hard for me to believe Musk didn’t overpay for Twitter At the time? Probably. With the benefit of hindsight? Probably not. Twitter would have made a killing on its own licensing its data to AI companies.
- bluegatty 8mo agoMusk saw bloat at Twitter but made it instantly unprofitable? I see the logic, but not sure about it.
- ben_w 8mo ago> Musk saw genuine bloat at Twitter. I'm reminded of a saying: "Just because they are out to get you, doesn't mean you're not paranoid." That he was able to cut a lot from Twitter, doesn't mean he cut wisely, for reasons connected with reality. It survived the loss of teams dedicated to ongoing feature development, but the loss of teams dedicated to community management appears (from the outside) to have been the proximal cause of the loss of trust that many advertisers, users, and governments have had with the company. Cutting both at the same time suggests the action was not done from a place of wisdom, but rather that it was luck one of the cuts wasn't critical. (This is what I expect given a Muntzing strategy: discover which components are load-baring by seeing what happens when they are removed. But when did I learn about Muntzing, and was it after Musk did his thing with Twitter?)