3 ms·

Why should it be? All he is saying: We currently have products in a similar product category (arm based desktop computers) that are widely used and have known

Why should it be? All he is saying: We currently have products in a similar product category (arm based desktop computers) that are widely used and have known benchmark scores (and general reviews) and it would make sense if I publish a new cpu for the same product category ("Reaching Desktop Performance" implies that) that I'd compare it to the known alternatives. In the end you can just run Asahi on your macbook, the OS is not that relevant here. A comparison to macbooks running Asahi Linux would be fine.

amelius 7mo ago
But why would an article address _their_ specific usecase?
- buran77 7mo ago
  > But why would an article address _their_ specific usecase? amelius, if anyone had specific requirements, it was you with your "systems for in-flight entertainment". OP asked a very reasonable question for a very generic comparison to the 800-pound gorilla in the consumer CPU world in general, and ARM CPU world in particular. If the article can reference AMD's Zen 5 cores and Intel's Lion/Sunny Cove, they could have made at least a brief reference to M-series CPUs. As a reader and potential buyer of any of them, I find it would have been a very useful comparison.
  - amelius 7mo ago
    In industry, people want to take computing parts and build products with them. This is not possible with Apple parts. That's what my example was about. It was only specific because I wanted to have a concrete example.
    - buran77 7mo ago
      > In industry Talk about specifics, eh? Didn't you just argue against an article addressing "_their_" specific usecase? In a store people will ask "is this better than an Apple?". And I'll tell you one more thing, when I was in the industry and taking computing parts to build products with them I did not form an opinion by reading internet reviews. I haven't met anyone who did.
GoblinSlayer 7mo ago
Does Apple allow benchmarks on Asahi Linux?
- vlovich123 7mo ago
  Believe it or not Apple has no say about this

amelius 7mo ago

But why would an article address _their_ specific usecase?

buran77 7mo ago
> But why would an article address _their_ specific usecase? amelius, if anyone had specific requirements, it was you with your "systems for in-flight entertainment". OP asked a very reasonable question for a very generic comparison to the 800-pound gorilla in the consumer CPU world in general, and ARM CPU world in particular. If the article can reference AMD's Zen 5 cores and Intel's Lion/Sunny Cove, they could have made at least a brief reference to M-series CPUs. As a reader and potential buyer of any of them, I find it would have been a very useful comparison.
- amelius 7mo ago
  In industry, people want to take computing parts and build products with them. This is not possible with Apple parts. That's what my example was about. It was only specific because I wanted to have a concrete example.
  - buran77 7mo ago
    > In industry Talk about specifics, eh? Didn't you just argue against an article addressing "_their_" specific usecase? In a store people will ask "is this better than an Apple?". And I'll tell you one more thing, when I was in the industry and taking computing parts to build products with them I did not form an opinion by reading internet reviews. I haven't met anyone who did.

GoblinSlayer 7mo ago

Does Apple allow benchmarks on Asahi Linux?

vlovich123 7mo ago
Believe it or not Apple has no say about this