5 ms·
It must be tough being a search engine these days. On one hand, you've got people like this complaining that your software is working exactly as intended and ju
by freehunter 14y ago
It must be tough being a search engine these days. On one hand, you've got people like this complaining that your software is working exactly as intended and just linking to a website that is publishing reports that, at first glance, link the person to a crime (which he is technically "linked" with the crime, being a victim). On the other hand, once you start filtering results to avoid these types of complaints, people start complaining that you are no longer an impartial aggregator, and accusing you of potential bias.
I'm not saying the man was wrong for demanding Google take down the results. I'm also not saying he is right. Google was working as intended. The site they had crawled made an unfortunate implication. This isn't Google's fault, this is the downside to being involved in a crime. You have limited control over what others say about you or how they use your information. Google is in the sticky situation of legally needing not to offend, but also legally needing to be as impartial as possible. The courts are making this extremely difficult for them. If anything is directly to blame, it's a lack of understanding the nature of search engines.
This further goes to show startup founders the troubling legal situation that exists in the world. Bring a lawyer onboard, but even then you have to recognize that you will likely find yourself in a sticky situation at some point.
- nodrama 14y agoit didn't work exactly as intended: "As a result of the attack Mr Trkulja said that entering his name into Google Images brought up images of other people beneath which his name appeared. He said some of these figures were allegedly murderers and one a drug trafficker."
- Dylan16807 14y agoHey nodrama, you seem to have gotten hellbanned for insulting QR codes, despite usually making good posts. In reply to your comment of: it didn't work exactly as intended: "As a result of the attack Mr Trkulja said that entering his name into Google Images brought up images of other people beneath which his name appeared. He said some of these figures were allegedly murderers and one a drug trafficker." If the internet thinks that his name is associated with murderers and drug traffickers, then I think it's part of the job of a search engine to reflect that. Search engines don't just help you find information, they also help you find conversation.
- colkassad 14y agoRegarding hellbanning, I just checked nodrama's history as well and there are a lot of posts by nodrama since he/she was hellbanned. I tend to think before I post so even a small reply by me may have taken me five or more minutes to think about before composing. It's sad to think of all the wasted time this person is spending posting here, all because he/she called someone's post "stupid". Hellbanning should be reserved for true trolls.
- lclarkmichalek 14y agoModeration around here is hardly transparent, I doubt we'll see anything change any time soon.
- andybak 14y agoThis seems like an especially egregious case. Where does one complain/appeal round here?
- DanBC 14y agoYou send a very short email to pg with links to your user name and comments, and asking for an unban. Or you just create a new username.
- andybak 14y agoExcept the point of hellbanning is that the accused never knows they've been banned. Which is why it seems particular unjust in borderline cases. It should be reserved for intentional trolls and spammer only.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoIt was a comment worth downvoting, but every other commenter on the post agreed with him, and the post itself was flagged into oblivion. Hellbanning is a pretty harsh sentence for something that probably only deserved negative karma. Even worse, qrafti.com is a joke/troll site. It's not particular surprising that nodrama fell for it. The joke is not revealed until you try and use the site. nodrama cannot be faulted for only reading the cover copy. If you have showdead on, you can check it out at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4217358 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4217358 Moderators, please correct this injustice. Thanks.
- magicalist 14y agoI'll go ahead and say that I feel bad for him, but he's still wrong. He shouldn't have the right to have it taken down, but it does get into the interesting area of how "free speech" is defined around the world. In theory, Google (web search) just helps you find what other people are talking about. "What are the sites that mention 'Milorad Trkulja'?" "well, one of the sites is this melbourne crime site..." It's kind of interesting to consider that Google -- by finding that result and giving it to you (especially with a snippet) -- is in fact repeating the statements contained in the result. However, it seems like they should be able to argue that it's not libel, because it is a fact that some site wrote that content. If that's not upheld, search engines become useless or sued out of existence (as does, say, the news). This is the dangerous water we're wading into with any "right to forget" focusing on search engines (because they're the big fish and can bear it financially, essentially) instead of the actual source of whatever a person wants forgotten. You can pretty easily imagine large sections of the internet that aren't allowed to be indexed based on arbitrary submissions by people, presumably unevenly applied if there's not a central clearinghouse of "statements of which we shall not speak", but instead, notices are sent to whatever search engines/major sites that the person happens to notice (DMCA takedown notices fit that bill too well already, but this would be even worse, as it's not specific links, but "don't associate my (somehow disambiguated) name with this subject"). It's hard to know exactly what to do in this case, though, because the original offending site really does appear to be "defunct" and the only links I can find to it lead to a domain registration page. The search results are also now flooded with this story, of course, so, is he only winning on past defamation? The procedure should be to get the offending site to take down the content and then have Google remove it from its cache, but that appears to be already done.
- DanBC 14y ago> The procedure should be to get the offending site to take down the content and then have Google remove it from its cache I agree. What happens when the original site takes down the content, but it stays in Google's cache even after they've been contacted? What if the content was very much worse? (eg, 'NAME is a convicted pedophile', with images of the person's face; where that allegation is totally false and malicious.) EDIT: Looks like I'm mostly wrong about this particular case. (http://ozsoapbox.com/melbourne/yahoo-held-liable-for-search-results-in-defamation-case/ http://ozsoapbox.com/melbourne/yahoo-held-liable-for-search-...)