7 ms·
FTFA>Windows 8 ships with its own app store and it is not an open platform anymore. If having an app store is the criterion for not being an open platform, not
by Karunamon 14y ago
FTFA>Windows 8 ships with its own app store and it is not an open platform anymore.
If having an app store is the criterion for not being an open platform, not even Ubuntu qualifies. And last I checked, I can still compile and run whatever I damn well please on Win8.
There wasn't even this level of derp when Apple launched the app store for OS X.
Straight up FUD. Windows will always be the premier gaming platform as long as it has the majority of the desktop base, and by extension the best driver support, and by extension the most games written for it.
Valve is going to kill themselves to attempt to make a point, at this rate.
- h2s 14y agoThis is quite a ropey writeup of the talk by the looks of it. I imagine what was actually said was probably different and might even have made sense.
- gagege 14y agoMy question is, did Valve say that or is that just some really bad editorializing from the person who wrote the article? I bet it's the latter.
- Alterlife 14y agoLarry Ellison said a lot of interesting things about the cloud. Steve Jobs said a few things about the tablet foam factor. Even if the gentleman from Valve did say that, they're not just going to throw away their business. They're probably playing for the 25% or so Linux gaming market that the Humble Bundles have shown exists.
- w1ntermute 14y ago> If having an app store is the criterion for not being an open platform, not even Ubuntu qualifies. It doesn't say "Because Windows 8 ships with its own app store, it is not an open platform anymore," so you misinterpreted that. The difference between the Windows 8 app store and Ubuntu's Software Center is that you can easily add 3rd party repositories to the latter. Also keep in mind that on Windows RT (the ARM version of Windows 8), you can't install any apps from outside the app store, period. > Windows will always be the premier gaming platform as long as it has the majority of the desktop base, and by extension the best driver support, and by extension the most games written for it. Linux doesn't have to have the best driver support to be sufficient as a gaming platform. If it has enough driver support for games to run well, it has a chance. And the proprietary NVIDIA Linux drivers right now work quite well in my experience. There are a few bugs, but nothing that can't be ironed out with a little time. Just because Windows has the "majority of the desktop base" doesn't mean it has to be the premiere gaming platform. Gamers are a very select group of people, and there's no reason Valve couldn't target them. If I were Valve, I would start programs such as "if you spend X hours playing Steam games on Linux, you get a discount on your next game." That would have a huge impact on what gamers are using to play games, and could push other developers to port their games to Linux. As the middleman between millions of gamers and hundreds of game studios, Valve has enormous power here.
- Sumaso 14y agoThe fact of the matter is, of the 250+ games I have in my steam library <50 of them work with mac. This ties me to windows. When I run windows 8, I can run steam and all my games, they dont magically stop working. While windows 8 RT isnt an open platform, the windows i will be running on my laptops and my desktops will be. I'm very disappointed in valves wording, and it shows how poorly their responding to their first real competition.
- w1ntermute 14y ago> The fact of the matter is, of the 250+ games I have in my steam library <50 of them work with mac. This ties me to windows. And what has Valve done to promote gaming on OS X exactly? Sure, they had a short Portal promotion and have added games since, but they haven't exactly pushed the platform. And besides, Macs are not good gaming machines. Desktop Macs (iMacs and Mac Pros) are much more difficult to upgrade than Linux/Windows desktops, and you get less powerful hardware for your money. You can't install OS X on a non-Apple desktop (not without a lot of hassle, anyway), and very few people have done that. OTOH, you can easily install Linux on a Windows desktop, which is what most gamers have at the moment. A lot of the people on HN have spent a lot of time in the Bay Area and have forgotten that 90% of the population doesn't own a Mac, so let me remind you of that fact. Unlike with OS X, gamers can move to Linux without purchasing any new hardware. Therefore, using the lack of success of OS X as a gaming platform since Steam added support for it to say that Linux won't succeed either is faulty logic. > When I run windows 8, I can run steam and all my games, they dont magically stop working. Well, there are many of us who already run Linux and only keep around a Windows install to play games. The vast majority of my time is spent playing Source-based games. If I were given the option of playing Source-based games in Linux, I would spend very little time in Windows. > I'm very disappointed in valves wording, and it shows how poorly their responding to their first real competition. I think they're responding the best they can. They're going up against Microsoft, which is well known for its anticompetitive behavior. The Windows 8 app store will be installed by default and given prime real estate (baked into the UI) in Windows 8. Valve needs to do something quickly before Microsoft starts abusing this power, and the best way to do that is to get gamers onto a platform no one controls - Linux.
- BasDirks 14y agoBig boy betting against Valve in a bout of cheap indignation.
- Dylan16807 14y agoI suppose it doesn't affect you if you compile everything yourself. But you can't run a Metro app that anyone else has compiled. Store or bust. That is a bad path. I certainly wouldn't say windows 8 is 'open'.
- Karunamon 14y ago>But you can't run a Metro app that anyone else has compiled. It's metro - who cares? You get more functionality with the desktop. On a less snarky note, yes you can. All that's necessary is your system has to trust the CA that signed the app - which is itself a few mouse clicks away. http://blogs.msdn.com/b/windowsstore/archive/2012/04/25/deploying-metro-style-apps-to-businesses.aspx http://blogs.msdn.com/b/windowsstore/archive/2012/04/25/depl... I've personally done this to load a leaked Skype beta for Metro. Put the requisite commands in a powershell batch file and it becomes so easy your gran can do it.
- Dylan16807 14y ago1. It matters because metro is a core part of the new OS and what microsoft is focused on. 2. I didn't realize you could set up sideloading on non-enterprise versions. As long as that is intentional and not a side-effect of implementation, I take back my complaints about windows 8.
- Karunamon 14y agoRe: 2, you can't. It's the enterprise editions only, I'm afraid. The preview was the one I did my experiment on. That said, there's nothing saying you can't use the enterprise version at home...