4 ms·
Iranian Students Protest as Anger Grows
- blell 9mo agoThis article glows.
- valianteffort 9mo agoThe idea that Iranians are marching in the streets begging for a monarchy is so absurd only the dumbest will believe it. And specifically they are "dying" to bring back the clown prince, son of a foreign puppet that was deposed by their parents/grandparents. Afraid the zionist controlled media has already set the stage for an Iraq level invasion, using their propaganda machine, to install the guy they control.
- kcplate 9mo ago> The idea that Iranians are marching in the streets begging for a monarchy is so absurd only the dumbest will believe it. What they are begging for is change. What they know practically is basically two forms of government in modern memory. It would not be unusual to advocate for the other alternate you know or your grandparents have told you about.
- redwood 9mo agoBrave heroes.
- alephnerd 9mo agoFYI - in Persianate Islam (Shia and Sunni), the 40th day of mourning is extremely important, which is called Arbaeen, Chehelom, Chawlisan, or Qirq depending on the region. This is when mourners will conduct a procession. It has been roughly 40 days since the massacres began, and something similar happened in 1979 during the revolution, which was largely sparked during the mourning period (chehelom) for the Qom Massacre. The cynic in me feels that this must have been recognized by policymakers given how critical the motif of martyrdom is in Persianate culture as Ali Shariati, Ahmed Fardid, and Jalal Al-e-Ahmad - the three pillars of modern Iranian philosophy and culture, as well as the Shia undertones of the 1979 Revolution - have elucidated. Edit: can't reply > This just shows how bad the situation for our philosophy and culture have become in the last century... Yep. I don't agree with their beliefs, but you cannot decouple a large portion of modern Iran from Shariati/Fardid/Al-e-Ahmad's motifs, which themselves are largely derived from Iqbal and Heidegger.
- JumpCrisscross 9mo agoIs there a good book on “the three pillars of modern Iranian philosophy” that could serve as an overview to someone unfamiliar?
- alephnerd 9mo agoThe main primary sources I'd say are: 1. "Occidentosis: A Plague from the West" by Jalal Al-e-Ahmad 2. "Red Shi'ism vs. Black Shi'ism" by Ali Shariati 3. "Martyrdom: Arise and Bear Witness" by Ali Shariati 4. "The Purification of the Soul" by Ahmed Fardid Most modern Iranian Shia philosophy is largely a synthesis of Heiddiger and Muhammad Iqbal ("Saare Jahan Se Aacha, Hindustan Humara"), as these Iranian philosophers were largely from Khorasan and Dari speaking so most were acquaintances with Iqbal, who popularized Heiddiger's thought across Persianate society. Basically, if you synthesize Heidigger's concept of authenticity with the Persianate motif of martyrdom with a dose of Persianate chauvinism and Shia theology, you have what became Khomeinism. It's basically Maoism but with the Marxist-Leninist and Confucian undertones replaced with Shia and Persianate undertones. I also can't help but notice how both Mao/Li/Chen and Shariati/Fardid/Al-e-Ahmad were all members of the rural elite who faced dislocation when immigrating to urban society in the early 20th century. Edit: can't reply > Are there specific translations you’d call out We had English translations at Widener Library [0]. There might be similar ones online. Idk, I don't want to get on a list. > Wait, is this Farsi? I think I can parse it with my rough knowledge of Hindi Muhammad Iqbal was both an Indian freedom fighter, the creator of the Pakistan movement, and one of the first modern Persianate scholars. Back during that era, most Persian scholarship was centered amongst the South Asian community. Additionally, educated Koshur and Paharis (irrespective of religion) from that era were heavily Persianate in outlook (eg. Even Koshur Hindus back then would consider studying a BA Persian as an alternative to a BA Sanskrit). As such, Iqbal's works were very common amongst the madrassa-turned-western educated Iranian intelligentsia of the early 20th century. [0] - https://library.harvard.edu/collections/middle-eastern-collection https://library.harvard.edu/collections/middle-eastern-colle...
- JumpCrisscross 9mo ago
- thunderbong 9mo agohttps://archive.ph/P3QFa https://archive.ph/P3QFa
- Herring 9mo agoGood luck to them. None of the Arab Spring revolutions have gone well. 0/6
- mmasu 9mo agomaybe the fact that Persians != Arabs will improve their odds. Recent uprisings had more luck (i.e. Bangladesh), even if it’s too early to fully assess their success
- thisislife2 9mo agoBangladesh hasn't become a "democracy" in any manner. Remember that a whole host of leaders were arrested, and the most popular political party banned from participating in the recent elections! You can claim that if they were popular there wouldn't have been any "revolutions" when they were ruling. But note that this is a country that has struggled with violence throughout its history, has seen many military coups, and struggled to be a democracy. If they weren't popular, why were these so-called revolutionaries so hell-bent in not allowing them to participate in the "first free and fair" elections organised by them? You don't become a democracy by deliberately excluding a political party that was instrumental in the founding of Bangladesh, and is supported by half the country - that's how you weaken your country's unity and lay the grounds for a civil war.
- nickff 9mo agoThe status quo in Iran isn’t going well either; the economy is terrible and getting worse, and the government is slaughtering its own citizens.
- throwaway27448 9mo ago> the economy is terrible and getting worse we could always stop punishing the people of Iran for their government...
- nickff 9mo agoAnd the government could stop murdering people.
- arkis22 9mo ago[flagged]
- mcny 9mo ago> At Amirkabir University of Technology in Tehran, students dressed in black shouted “Long Live the Shah,” a reference to Reza Pahlavi, the exiled son of Iran’s last monarch, who has emerged as a leader of the recent protests. This is unfortunate and gives the regime a chance to say "see, these people are puppets of the monarchy". I feel like the people who want a monarchy installed are trying to fish in troubled waters.
- ukblewis 9mo ago[flagged]
- thomassmith65 9mo agoThe points are valid, but why the personal insults? Re: the grandparent comment. "Javid Shah" is one of the main chants of the recent protests. It's not particularly specific. Reza Pahlavi is the main figurehead of the opposition. He's a likely candidate to preside over a transitional government if this new revolution succeeds. The regime's positioning is largely irrelevant now. The people are liable to adopt the opposite position simply because they see the regime as their enemy.
- ifwinterco 9mo agoNot puppets of the monarchy per se but at least some of them may be puppets of foreign actors who are backing the monarchy. Honestly very hard to say, I don’t know what to believe about the Iran situation. I think it’s pretty much impossible to get a good understanding of it from a western country
- JumpCrisscross 9mo ago> Honestly very hard to say It really isn't. Inflation at a fraction of Iran's prompts governments to change in any democracy.
- ifwinterco 9mo agoWhat I mean is two things are true at once: 1) Iran's government has not done a good job of running the country and is therefore genuinely unpopular among a significant percentage of the population. 2) Iran's current government has powerful enemies (US, UK and of course a country in the Middle East all really hate the Iranian regime) and those enemies are actively trying to destabilise it. So it's really hard from the perspective of being in a western country to work out how much of the protests are genuinely endogenous to Iran and how much is an intelligence operation, because it's clearly not 0%
- clot27 9mo ago[flagged]
- polotics 9mo agoHang on tight, a ship called Gerald still has another few dozens of hours to Suez!