4 ms·
In many countries you are only allowed to call yourself a Software Engineer if you actually have a professional title. It is countries like US where anyone can
by pjmlp 9mo ago
In many countries you are only allowed to call yourself a Software Engineer if you actually have a professional title.
It is countries like US where anyone can call themselves whatever they feel like that have devalued our profession.
I have been on the liability side ever since, people don't keep broken cars unless they cannot afford anything else, software is nothing special, other than lack of accountability.
- joe_mamba 9mo ago>It is countries like US where anyone can call themselves whatever they feel like that have devalued our profession. How have they devalued the profession when the labor of that professions is worth the most in the US?
- pjmlp 9mo agoProfessional labour value isn't synonymous with late stage capitalism without ethics or morals. Now if you mean for own much one is willing to sell themselves to late stage capitalism, producing low quality products and entshtification, maybe that is the bang for buck right there.
- kortilla 9mo agoHow do you explain the low quality of software coming out of all of the other countries you have mentioned with protected titles? The software is happening regardless of title and you haven’t given any examples of the value of where kissing the ring to get the certification has been critical to Canada/Germany/Switzerland producing better software.
- godelski 9mo agoAre all programmers called engineers in these countries? You've made such a wild assumption that I'm convinced you're more interested in fighting then discussing
- kortilla 9mo agoNo, im looking for literally any evidence that the quality of software that comes from areas that require the protected name is better than something like the NASA coding guidelines.
- pjmlp 9mo agoThere are engineers, and there are brick layers. You mean Android's great quality, or Chrome CVEs by the way?
- joe_mamba 9mo agoJust because you have an engineering degree doesn't mean your code is of better quality and security than someone without an engineering degree. Signed, someone with an CS engineering degree.
- pjmlp 9mo agoIt surely means one has the responsibility to be one as such, having had the education that others have not.
- joe_mamba 9mo agoMost web dev, gaming jobs don't care about those things, they care if you can ship fast and cheap. There's embedded and safety related SW that need well thought out safeguards but a lot of that slow moving SW has been farmed out to Asia, EE and India.
- kortilla 9mo agoNo it doesn’t. Getting an engineering degree does not allow you to use the protected title. The protected titles are gate kept by associations and are not tied to knowledge.
- kortilla 9mo agoI mean the quality of people following NASAs C style guidelines. Where is there any evidence that people using the protected title are producing higher quality software than companies in equivalent industries in the US?
- joe_mamba 9mo ago>Now if you mean for own much one is willing to sell themselves to late stage capitalism The government is the one selling you out to late stage capitalism through rampant inflation, business and fiscal regulations and deregulation, offshoring, and various nefarious policies on housing and labor migration. People just adapt to survive by taking the best paying jobs, since voting clearly doesn't help them. Don't tell me you're not developing SW for the highest bidder and would take the salary of a fast food worker out of class empathy just to stick it to the evil capitalist.
- pjmlp 9mo agoThat is the difference between the US mentality of the winner takes it all that has given us late stage capitalism, entshitification and Trump, and most of the world. Quality of life and health matters more than anything else. After a certain point, more money doesn't bring any of that, one is not taking the money into the grave, other than build a mausoleum.
- joe_mamba 9mo agoYou talk around the issue throwing the blame on others, but you intentionally avoided answering my question, as if you're not part of the problem, and are working for peanuts, virtue signal points and "thank-yous". Sorry but my bank and landlord doesn't accept those, only money and the government makes sure those get more and more expensive.
- godelski 9mo agoIf I start calling "bananas" "apples" then I devalue the meaning of the word "apple". You can't differentiate which I'm referring to. If I start calling "bananas" "apples" the price at the store doesn't change. I think you don't understand what the word "value" means. You understand one meaning, but it has more than one.
- drysart 9mo ago> If I start calling "bananas" "apples" then I devalue the meaning of the word "apple". You can't differentiate which I'm referring to. In French, potatoes are called what translates to English as "apple of the earth". Nobody confuses a pomme de terre with an apple, because nobody calls a potato an apple without the adjective attached. That's what the additional adjective as part of the title is for; like how apples and potatoes are vaguely related in that they're both plant-based food but are otherwise entirely different; turning "software engineer" into a compound term that has the extra word is specifically to differentiate it from expectations of it not having the extra word. Software engineering is legitimately engineering going by the etymological meaning of engineering; but it's not really one going by some of the other (mostly orthogonal) things we've layered onto the term in many contexts over the years. It's creation through ingenuity. It has as much claim to the word as part of its title as any other usage of the word does.
- jjkaczor 9mo agoExactly this - I had a role in a multinational, US-founded company, however - I was based in Canada - our title had the name "engineer" contained within it. We were NOT by any means certified professional engineers according to any regulatory body - we were great at our jobs, but that was the reality. We were NOT allowed to refer to our job title when deployed to the province of Quebec, which has strong regulations around the use of the term "engineer". It was fine - we still went, did our jobs, satisfied our customers and fixed their issues.
- kortilla 9mo agoAnd the people of Quebec are much safer for it. /s This divide between Canada and the US has existed since the birth of software engineering as a thing. Where is the evidence the protected name has done anything useful for either Canadian software engineers or its citizens?
- Teever 9mo agoIt's really hard to disentangle the myriad of factors that go into the differences that we see in life expectency and quality of life between Canada and the United States but it wouldn't surprise me that this is one of those ones that accounts for some miniscule amount of the difference.
- Betelbuddy 9mo ago>> In many countries you are only allowed to call yourself a Software Engineer if you actually have a professional title. Which countries are those? Are you also only allowed to call yourself a Musician if you a Conservatory Degree?
- pjmlp 9mo agoPortugal, Germany, Canada, Switzerland are the ones I am aware of. Software Engineering degrees are certified by the Engineering Order, universities cannot call themselves that just because they feel like it, and any kind of legal binding documents when notarised required the professional validity.
- Betelbuddy 9mo agoThey regulate the title not the profession.
- pjmlp 9mo agoI mentioned legal signatures for a reason.
- Betelbuddy 9mo agoNo Software Engineer in title or in real skills will do such a thing.
- pjmlp 9mo agoSign project contracts with Eng. and find out when liability comes into play.
- wink 9mo agoFirst of all, hardly anyone cares (default email signatures etc.pp even if the people don't want that - but you said legally bindign, and I think that just usually never happens.). And second, at least in Germany it's also somewhat of a bullshit situation that 80% of the people who do a "normal" Computer Science degree don't have that (Diplom-Informatiker/M.Sc), but the 20% who happen to study at a certain uni in a certain degree (that is mostly related, but not the default Computer Science/Software Engineering one) are/were getting their "Diplom-Ingenieur".