3 ms·
Does anyone have a link to a good political model for Iran? This looks maximally stupid given the American hardware in the region. But there may be internecine
by JumpCrisscross 10mo ago
Does anyone have a link to a good political model for Iran?
This looks maximally stupid given the American hardware in the region. But there may be internecine angles I’m missing. (Which factions benefit from American air strikes?)
- abtinf 10mo agoNo one is afraid of the US. Iran has continuously waged war on America since the revolution, killing countless soldiers, as well as murdering civilians on western soil. America’s response has been essentially non-existent. Short of an unignorable mass attack on the homeland, America has a proven track record of turning the other cheek.
- JumpCrisscross 10mo ago> No one is afraid of the US No one should be. But only idiots, today, are not fearful of the largest and most-comprehensive war machine in human history. > America’s response has been essentially non-existent Are we starting the clock after the Israeli campaigns that established air superiority over all of Iran?
- abtinf 10mo agoAfter waging war on America continuously for 46 years, the response was to take out a handful of targets, leaving the entire theocratic regime and nearly all of its regional military capabilities intact. Yep, that’ll show them.
- engineer_22 10mo agohttps://tatsuikeda.substack.com/p/iran-strike-probability-just-dropped https://tatsuikeda.substack.com/p/iran-strike-probability-ju... This writer has developed a model of the situation
- idolofdust 10mo agoClicked on the podcast portion and its Google Notebook LM AI Slop
- engineer_22 10mo agoI hadn't noticed that, thanks. Check out the guy's LinkedIn! https://www.linkedin.com/in/tatsu https://www.linkedin.com/in/tatsu
- DoctorOetker 10mo agosure this writer has developed a model, but I disagree with his assessment: when they open a "diplomatic channel" just to say "our existential weapons programs are nobody else's business", it just creates the appearance of diplomatic cooperation in global media without actually having sincere diplomatic conversation.
- alephnerd 10mo agoI'd recommend Vali Nasr and Payam Mohseni's works. But frankly, Iran as it stands today is structurally similar to pre-1976 PRC, and requires an Iranian "Deng Xiaoping", but the only reason Deng even got as far as he did was because the Sino-Soviet Split made the PRC an attractive partner against the USSR and because it took someone with the stature of Mao to host a "Nixon in China" moment, which made partnering with America politically palatable. The key economic and political institutions in Iran (Army, IRGC, Bonyads) would need to be incentivized to flip to being pro-EU and pro-America in order to sustain the semblance of democracy and secularism because frankly, Russia, China, India, portions of the Gulf, and much of ASEAN is fine working with Iran as it stands today because it is a critical regional power. Turkiye, the UAE, Qatar, KSA, and Pakistan are probably the best regional players to push a gradual re-opening of Iran.
- breppp 10mo agoSome discussion: https://x.com/RZimmt/status/2017587629424849161 https://x.com/RZimmt/status/2017587629424849161 https://x.com/Omid_M/status/2017365676634075527 https://x.com/Omid_M/status/2017365676634075527
- awesome_dude 10mo agoUnfortunately (perhaps) Iran isn't as "weak" as we in the west are led to believe - the drone strike on the USA base in Qatar, for example, we were told that there was no damage done to the base, and the POTUS laughed at how "weak" Iran's attacks were. Then it turned out to be bluster, there /was/ damage.[0] It's /really/ hard to get good independent coverage of most politically charged events (The fog of war, etc) [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iranian_strikes_on_Al_Udeid_Air_Base#Damage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iranian_strikes_on_Al_Udeid_Ai...