4 ms·
Great Depression is thoroughly unrelated. It was because of excess agricultural production by overleveraged farmers that forced them into further undermining th
by anovikov 9mo ago
Great Depression is thoroughly unrelated. It was because of excess agricultural production by overleveraged farmers that forced them into further undermining themselves by overproduction, and eventual contagion of bad debt of those farmers propagating across the economy - made worse by unhinged, and unregulated, leveraged stock trading.
It did not happen because of sudden productivity increase that put too many people out of work. No economic crises ever happened that way, and there is no reason to believe any will. This is what every economy strives to achieve and it's kinda stupid to be afraid of it. Some people can be hit hard, and it always happens during every technological revolution, but with sufficient investment into predictive policing and law enforcement overall, this is a manageable risk.
Surely, a stock market shock can happen other way around - if AI will turn out to be a flop - but i believe this is not the risk you are talking about.
- verdverm 9mo agoYou're looking at causes, that's the wrong side. Your prior claim was about how you couldn't see the downsides of high unemployment. Look at what happened during the Great Depression, when unemployment was high. It doesn't matter how we get to high unemployment or depression status, but for sure there will be a lot of bad things, many more than you proclaim. Look to the Great Depression to see what the human condition and spirit was like if you are having trouble imagining possibilities
- anovikov 9mo agoDuring the Great Depression there was also an economic collapse with deep decreases in production and consumption of just about everything - except useless production of what was already overproduced anyway. That could naturally make people depressed, strive for radical changes like Communism, etc. But we are speaking simply of mass unemployment. That alone is not enough to cause widespread despair.
- verdverm 9mo agoUnemployment is one of the conditions I think a simple question, where do the unemployed eat and sleep during extended, high-unemployment? Are breadlines in 21st century America not a thing you foresee in a 21st century depression?
- benSaiyen 9mo ago[flagged]
- verdverm 9mo ago[flagged]
- benSaiyen 9mo ago[flagged]
- verdverm 9mo ago[flagged]
- benSaiyen 9mo ago[flagged]
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- dang 9mo agoYou also broke the site guidelines several times in this thread, and it looks like some of your other comments (e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46838413 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46838413) have been doing that as well. We ban accounts that do that repeatedly, and I don't want to ban you because some of your other comments have been substantive and fine. Would you mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and sticking to the rules in the future? We'd appreciate it. p.s. I've added more here than I did in my mod comment to the GP because your account is new and I thought the extra information might be helpful to orient to the kind of site we're trying for.
- benSaiyen 9mo ago[flagged]