4 ms·
> quite skeptical of Tesla's reliability claims I'm sceptical of Robotaxi/Cybercab. I'm less sceptical that FSD, supervised, is safer than fully-manual control
by JumpCrisscross 10mo ago
> quite skeptical of Tesla's reliability claims
I'm sceptical of Robotaxi/Cybercab. I'm less sceptical that FSD, supervised, is safer than fully-manual control.
- misiti3780 10mo agothis ^^
- madsmith 10mo agoHaving handed over control of my vehicles to FSD many times, I’ve yet to come away from the experience feeling that my vehicle was operating in a safer regime for the general public than within my own control.
- Rover222 10mo agoI think you greatly overestimate humans
- ihaveajob 10mo agoThe problem IMO is the transition period. A mostly safe system will make the driver feel at ease, but when an emergency occurs and the driver must take over, it's likely that they won't be paying full attention.
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- Retric 10mo agoWe aren’t talking about the average human here. On average you include sleep deprived people, driving way over the speed limit, at night, in bad weather, while drunk, and talking to someone. FSD is very likely situationally useful. But you can know most of those adverse conditions don’t apply when you engage FSD on a given trip. As such the standard needs to be extremely high to avoid increased risks when you’re sober, wide awake, the conditions are good, and you have no need to speed.
- izacus 10mo ago> On average you include sleep deprived people, driving way over the speed limit, at night, in bad weather, while drunk, and talking to someone. FSD is very likely situationally useful. Are those people also able to suprevise FSD like the law and Tesla expects them to? That's also a question.
- fragmede 10mo agoFSD will pull over and stop if it detects the driver has passed out. Can the law do that automatically?
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 10mo ago> you greatly overestimate humans Tesla's FSD still goes full-throttle dumbfuck from time to time. Like, randomly deciding it wants to speed into an intersection despite the red light having done absolutely nothing. Or swerving because of glare that you can't see, and a Toyota Corolla could discern with its radars, but which hits the cameras and so fires up the orange cat it's simulating on its CPU.
- fragmede 10mo agoYeah even corollas have better sensors than a Tesla for driving in fog. It's embarrassing.
- smileysteve 10mo agoKeeping a 1-2 car's length stopping distance is likely over a 50% reduction in at fault damages.
- protimewaster 10mo agoYou can get this with just a fairly dumb radar cruise control system, though.
- panopticon 10mo agoWhere I live isn't particularly challenging to drive (rural Washington), but I'm constantly disengaging FSD for doing silly and dangerous things. Most notably my driveway meets the road at a blind y intersection, and my Model 3 just blasts out into the road even though you cannot see cross traffic. FSD stresses me out. It's like I'm monitoring a teenager with their learners permit. I can probably count the number trips where I haven't had to take over on one hand.
- apearson 10mo agoDo you have HW3 or HW4?
- lotsofpulp 10mo agoThe newest FSD on HW4 was very good in my opinion. Multiple 45min+ drives where I don’t need to touch the controls. Still not paying $8k for it. Or $100 per month. Maybe $50 per month.
- fragmede 10mo agoIt's your sanity (and money) ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- panopticon 10mo agoHW3, unfortunately. Missed the HW4 refresh by a couple of months.
- elif 10mo agoit's edging into the intersection to get a better view on the camera. it's further than you would normally pull out, but it will NOT pull into traffic.
- seanmcdirmid 10mo agoThe software probably has a better idea of their car’s dimensions than a human driver, so will be able to get a better view of traffic by pulling out at just the right distance.
- bayarearefugee 10mo ago> I'm less sceptical that FSD, supervised, is safer than fully-manual control. I'm very skeptical that the average human driver properly supervises FSD or any other "full" self driving system.
- microtherion 10mo agoSupervised FSD — automating 99.9% of driving and expecting drivers to be fully alert for the other .1% — appears to go against everything we know about human attention.