5 ms·
There is nothing to save as long as it relies on game studios using Windows workstations, coding in Visual Studio and targeting DirectX. The goal has to be to
by pjmlp 10mo ago
There is nothing to save as long as it relies on game studios using Windows workstations, coding in Visual Studio and targeting DirectX.
The goal has to be to make native Linux attractive, so that they actually bother to create native executables, using Vulkan and co.
Until then it is no different from playing arcade games with MAME on Linux.
- nialv7 10mo agonothing stopping them from developing on Linux workstations, cross-compiling to Windows, and testing with Wine/Proton. saves them Windows license fees too.
- pjmlp 10mo agoThe incentives are not there, as it is, they work as usual, and Valve is the one that has to make it work.
- nialv7 10mo agothere will be incentives once windows becomes shit enough.
- pjmlp 10mo agoNah, regular people buy what is on shopping mall computer stores, they don't go online ordering from Tuxedo. They are more likely to move to PlayStation and Switch than SteamDeck, the amount of sales already show that.
- ecshafer 10mo agoTargeting DirectX and Win32 has become targeting Linux with how good Wine/Proton have gotten. I am able to play brand new games with no Linux support absolutely perfectly through proton. These games run better than games that had linux support actually ran on linux.
- pjmlp 10mo agoThus making Linux irrelevant as target to game studios. For them DirectX and Win32 is what matters, if folks go out of their way to run on Proton, that is Valve's problem.
- seabrookmx 10mo agoYou're assuming no game studio would test their windows executable on proton, just because they develop on Windows. If there's non-trivial market share to capture by being "Deck verified" I don't see why that would be the case. Game devs develop on Windows for PlayStation, Switch, mobile etc. At least with proton they don't even need to cross compile.
- pjmlp 10mo agoI am willing to bet that most don't give a damm about Proton.
- scheeseman486 10mo agoMicrosoft test on and make considerations for Proton for a bunch of their releases. Sony do too. Cyberpunk has specific graphics presets, Baldurs Gate 3 has a native executable, indie games often do too. There's outliers, it'd be fair to say EA don't give a damn. But a lot do and you can't handwave away Microsoft and Sony as small fish either.
- aleph_minus_one 10mo ago> Thus making Linux irrelevant as target to game studios. For them DirectX and Win32 is what matters I don't think so. I rather do believe that many game developers would actually love to give a more native approach for writing GNU/Linux games a try (to make this point more plausible: game developers are very used to game-console-native SDKs). But what these game developers really demand is a very stable user-space API for everything that is necessary for writing games, which will work reliably on basically every GNU/Linux distribution, and will be supported for at least 20 years.
- Shorel 10mo agoThe most stable Linux API is Wine/Win32. There are many older games I can't install on Linux anymore, because they used an older SDL1 or some particular X11 version or some GPU driver that's no longer available for the current kernel. The exact same game, Windows version, can be installed and runs flawlessly on both Linux and Windows. So, native Vulkan executables? Sure, if they can continue to run in 20 years.
- pjmlp 10mo agoJust like for OS/2, what a great success it was.
- aleph_minus_one 10mo agoThe development tools for OS/2 were worse and far more expensive.
- groundzeros2015 10mo agoIt’s working right now, what are you arguing against.
- pjmlp 10mo agoIt seems to be working, that is the thing building castles in foreign kingdoms.
- groundzeros2015 10mo agoWhat do you mean? There is a whole library of thousands of win32 games spanning more than 2 decades and the community is tracking and reporting bugs in each and classifying their level of performance. That’s one of the most successful computer projects I’ve heard of.
- pjmlp 10mo agoSure, if one ignores all the existing emulators for previous computer generations, and game consoles.
- the8472 10mo agoUE can be crosscompiled on a windows host to linux and then it's a few checkboxes to enable the vulkan RHI.
- pjmlp 10mo agoAndroid NDK shares many APIs with regular GNU/Linux, in many cases it could be a simple recompile, yet no studio bothers to do so, because the incentives aren't there.
- jayd16 10mo agoThe only thing that will make native executables attractive is users. A lot of users. Much more than Macos, seeings as few bother with Mac clients either and there's not even a Wine equivalent.
- groundzeros2015 10mo agoThe top played games are not the ones made this year
- hedora 10mo agoI don't see what the problem is with game studios buying Windows licenses. Sure, the platform is enshittified spyware, but that only impacts the game devs on their work machines (which are probably locked down to protect secret IP anyway). Microsoft has basically lost control over their own platform at this point. The game studios have been refusing to migrate to new APIs until after they're working well in Wine. If the rest of us can run something decent at home, that's a > 99% solution to the problem. Put another way, for a long time, you needed to buy an SGI workstation or whatever to make assets for PC games. That didn't hold the DOS ecosystem back. As for the ABI: The Linux kernel has started adding syscalls to enable native-like execution of Windows binaries, and game devs are testing with Linux at launch. In the worst case, these are only used by Wine. In the best case, some good ideas from the Windows kernel will be exposed to regular Linux user-land. I don't see how it really matters if the binaries are targeting libc, musl, or an opensource win32 / win64 layer. It's free software regardless. End-users are getting better backward compatibility under Linux than Microsoft is supporting under Windows. That one victory goes a long way towards winning the entire war. On top of that, Linux is starting to show better framerates than Windows in the same hardware. It's not 100% of the time, but it's enough that you should run the game in both places if you really care to get that extra few percent out of the hardware.
- pjmlp 10mo agoIt is a phyrric victory, because in the end it is no different than using MAME and claiming victory. They still aren't Linux games.
- tracker1 10mo agoFrankly, WINE/Proton are likely more consistent targets for game dev/testing... I wish they'd at least do that much more often than not. At least smooth out any rough edges. I would say it's a lot different, since it's an API implementation, not hardware emulation.
- nickitolas 10mo agoClang can target windows just fine afaik, although I'm sure the whole process could be improved. That said, as long as windows is the bigger more profitable market I wouldnt expect a switch, unless the dev tooling situation becomes dramatically better on linux