4 ms·
This kinda stuff makes me really cross/sick; as someone majorly opposed to cencorship.... It's a fairly pathetic episode and a sad description on modern religi
by ErrantX 18y ago
This kinda stuff makes me really cross/sick; as someone majorly opposed to cencorship....
It's a fairly pathetic episode and a sad description on modern religion.
(as an addendum when I asked the Church at the end of the road to stop handing leaflets/preaching to my young cousin as she walked passed I got into all sorts of trouble for religious descrimination.... double standards!).
/rant over (sorry)
- wheels 18y agoThis isn't censorship, it's a boycott, and it's a perfectly valid way to express your dislike for a company's PR decisions. I don't care about the ads, but I wish more consumers would put their money where their mouth is in dealing with company practices they find inappropriate. Censorship would be these groups lobbying the FCC to ban the commercials.
- ErrantX 18y agoIt's boycott to a point yes. But spamming media outlets with it is an attempt at censorship. It's a fine line but if the aim is to make GoDaddy tone down the Ad's to "religion approved" [sic] versions (as it seems it is) then it is an attempt at censorhip surely ;D
- wheels 18y agoNo, really, it's not. A boycott wouldn't do much good if you didn't tell people about it.
- ErrantX 18y agoNo really it is ;) As I said it is a fine line: but read into it and their main aim is to stop them using the ads. That's an attempt at censorship (I'm not disagreeing that it is a boycott too).
- wheels 18y agoCensorship requires a censor with the ability to remove information. They don't have that and at least as far as is reported in this article, they're not pushing the people with the power to censure the media to do so. Trying to get a company to stop doing something that a consumer considers offensive isn't censorship. This is just like the anti-sweatshop boycotts that are common on the left end of the political spectrum.
- ErrantX 18y agofair enough :)
- _phred 18y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship "Censorship is the suppression of speech or deletion of communicative material which may be considered objectionable, harmful or sensitive, as determined by a censor." vs. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boycott http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boycott "A boycott is a form of consumer activism involving the act of voluntarily abstaining from using, buying, or dealing with someone or some other organization as an expression of protest, usually of political reasons." Clearly, the Christian businessman in the article would like GoDaddy to "clean up" their act, but I didn't find any request by him for government intervention, nor any government action at play with regard to GoDaddy. Plain and simply, he has a moral objection to pornographic advertising, and has chosen to take his business elsewhere. As a Christian myself, I've held the same stance towards GoDaddy for a long time, because I personally don't like being sold domain names with sex. They can continue to do business as they choose, and I can continue to state my opinion about their practices and take my business elsewhere.
- robotron 18y agoCensorship 2.0, then. Easier to create an uproar on the internet than bend the FCC to your will. Personally, I found the commercials stupid and I dislike GoDaddy for reasons beyond their advertisements.
- nonrecursive 18y agoSince you consider it censorship, would you prefer that these people continue giving their money to a company they find morally objectionable?
- robotron 18y agoThey can take their money wherever they want. That's not what they are doing, though. Rather, they would have GoDaddy adhere to their moral standards.
- jimbokun 18y ago"That's not what they are doing, though." Yes, that is precisely what they are doing.
- nonrecursive 18y agoWhat's wrong with that?
- nonrecursive 18y agoWhy am I being downmodded for asking someone to clarify his position?
- wheels 18y agoSee, I'm really anti-censorship, and pro-consumer activism, which is why I keep coming back to this thread. Usually I don't care about terms being wrong, but censorship's an important topic, so it's worth being pedantic about the semantics. Let's pretend this isn't about commercials and boobies, but about companies employing sweat shop workers, companies serving meat from animals that were fed growth hormones, a company treating its employees poorly, etc. If I'm morally opposed to cows being fed growth hormones and tell some friends and write in my blog that I'm not going to buy hamburgers from McWendy's or whatever, is that censorship in your book? Is me holding the companies I patronize to some set of moral standards wrong? Now, if this were a controversial news story, and back-room pressure from an influential advertiser, I might be more opposed to the exertion of economic pressure. But it's not. It's a commercial trying to get you to buy domains with low-brow boobie jokes. And for some customers, rather than making them want to purchase the product, it made them want to avoid the product, and they're now voicing that. There's nothing scandalous going down here.
- drewcrawford 18y agoParent is trolling, but there is an interesting slippery slope here that should be explored. If a government shuts down GoDaddy's web ads, that's censorship. Writing a law as a member of the Senate to shut down Godaddy's web ads is probably censorship. Is organizing a lobby to campaign to shut down their web ads censorship? Is writing a blog post asking people to vote for a law in which Godaddy's web ads are shut down censorship? Is voting for such a law censorship? Is saying "we should have such a law" censorship? In a democracy, at what point do we go from saying "Godaddy should shut up", which is a first amendment right, to full-on censorship? A government is full of people; there's nothing fundamentally different about a group of people executing their rights in a boycott and a group of people exercising their voting rights to accomplish some goal.
- yters 18y agoWell, the main difference in my mind is that the government can legally apply force to make someone stop doing something.
- ErrantX 18y agoHey! I'd dispute it was trolling. That's extremely offensive, I'd ask you to retract the comment. It was rash and strongly (and probably badly) worded. > Is organizing a lobby to campaign to shut down their web ads censorship? Yes: if the aim is to get someone to shut them down then it is an attempt at censorship (and if they succeed it is). That is not, and I believe wheel would agree here, simply a boycott anymore. > Is voting for such a law censorship? That's a difficult question. I'd probably say yes.. but I'd want it to actually happen before acusing everyone (so you could check motives etc.) I've admitted I was wrong to call it censorship - but I do still think it's getting a lot more press than it deserves. Lots of people "boycott" GoDaddy for non-religious reasons (some in protest at the adverts - comments here are testament to that) and have been doing so for a long while. Why is it such a big deal now? Because this guy "represents" religion.. which is media friendly. Indeed these ads have been around for a while: why is it such a big problem now? It's certainly the perfect basis for the lobby group (and I am sure the Christian lobby groups will sieze on it at some point :)). I think in a democracy that people forget it is "majority rule". You are, of course, entitled to your own opinions and ideas of what is right (that, though, is probably not part of the democracy per se). But you view does not represent everyones unless a majority of people agree with it. Therefore IMO it is wrong to try and turn a legitimate boycott on personal grounds into an attempt to impose your morals onto the majority. I would say that most people either do not care or enjoy the ads (probably mostly in the former category). The person in question did not write the letter in a way to say "I am not using your service any more, this is why" he wrote from the perspective of "your offending out sensibilities so please change or we'll stop using you". Which is a threat in my eyes :D