3 ms·
> The actual ingredients are literally on the safety data sheet This is an oversimplification, in a way that is likely not obvious to a lot of people on this (
by 7bees 10mo ago
> The actual ingredients are literally on the safety data sheet
This is an oversimplification, in a way that is likely not obvious to a lot of people on this (software-focused) forum. An SDS does not have to list exact amounts, does not have to disclose some details of how an ingredient or mix of ingredients was processed, and (depending on jurisdiction) may not have to identify some "safe" ingredients at all. Some ingredients may be identified in relatively vague ways, that are sufficient for safety purposes but do not reveal the exact product. As the SDS you linked to says "The specific chemical identity and exact percentages are a trade secret". An SDS is certainly very helpful to reverse-engineering a product, but it doesn't tell you everything.
All that said, yes, the main strength of WD-40 is its marketing and ubiquity, and claims about its secrecy have more to do with marketing than anything practical.
- Scoundreller 10mo ago> Some ingredients may be identified in relatively vague ways, that are sufficient for safety purposes but do not reveal the exact product Where I find this can be fun is that different countries seem to have different requirements for precision. Or just straight up different formulations for the same thing. German wd40 says it’s all c9-c11 carbon chains: https://smarthost.maedler.de/datenblaetter/EG_SIDA_WD40_EN.pdf https://smarthost.maedler.de/datenblaetter/EG_SIDA_WD40_EN.p... US has a CARB and non-CARB formulation which are also different: https://files.wd40.com/pdf/sds/mup/wd-40-multi-use-product-aerosol-low-voc-sds-us-ghs.pdf https://files.wd40.com/pdf/sds/mup/wd-40-multi-use-product-a... https://files.wd40.com/msds/latam/GHS-SDS-WD-40-Multi-Use-Product-Aerosol-English-LATAM.pdf https://files.wd40.com/msds/latam/GHS-SDS-WD-40-Multi-Use-Pr...
- OhNoNotAgain_99 10mo ago[dead]
- lazide 10mo agoI wonder how many different chemicals can be described as ‘c9-c11’ chains. Thousands?
- Scoundreller 10mo agoYes but I doubt the manufacturer is consistent with how much of each is in there either
- NedF 10mo ago[dead]
- Incipient 10mo agoThe SDS should include all SAFETY relevant information/ingredients for whatever jurisdiction. If the local area doesn't really care if it's hexane or pentane from a safety perspective, they'll likely just be lumped together behind a generic name/cas number. It's absolutely not a BOM to reproduce a product.
- logifail 10mo agoI'd say a BOM is more like the list of ingredients (or inventory) of what's in a product. Depending on what the product is, this may still be a long way from the full "recipe" (or method) to recreate the product.
- TeMPOraL 10mo agoHopefully if you sum enough of those SDS across different jurisdictions, the actual list of ingredients will come out. Though I guess it isn't that simple.
- wolfi1 10mo agoI once had a problem with the ignition lock I couldn't turn the key, my mechanic told me that that could happen on a very hot day with that model. "use a lubricant or wait till it's colder" - "Would WD-40 do?" -"Guess so" made it worse. with the help of the AAA (well, the equivalent in my country) and an oil spray I could turn the key, since then I've always an oil spray with me
- anticodon 10mo agoHad the same problem with my moto (key not turning the lock). Fortunately, there was a car nearby and owner had a spare jug of oil. I put some oil on the key, put it in the ignition lock, waited for 5 minutes, and it started to turn again. Although I must admin WD-40 helped me in the past opening an old door lock.
- regularfry 10mo agoI suspect the difference is whether (as with the old door lock) there is no lubricant at all and anything is better than nothing, or whether (as with the ignition key) there is a lubricant there which was designed for the purpose but for some other reason isn't working as intended, and which the WD-40 will displace and replace with something worse. "Fails in hot weather" sounds either like some sort of thermal expansion problem or the intended grease gets too thin to properly lubricate a high-pressure contact area. Or there just isn't enough of it.
- cucumber3732842 10mo agoYou're not supposed to use lube on locks because the film strength of the oil will be enough to make tight pins that have tiny clearances not move. Not really applicable in an automotive lock which start out as hotdog down hallway when new and only expand from there.
- lazide 10mo agoIn both cases, the real issue is when the oil (eventually all do) oxidizes and ‘gums’. Tight tolerances make it cause worse problems sooner of course, but it’s the same problem eventually. Putting new fresh oil in it often temporarily fixes it because it dissolves some (or a lot) of the old varnish. Acetone can often do the same thing too, but can also wash the varnish deeper into the mechanism where it turns into really solid ‘plastic’ when the acetone dissolves.
- echelon 10mo ago> An SDS is certainly very helpful to reverse-engineering a product, but it doesn't tell you everything. NMR and gas chromatography to the rescue!