7 ms·
I am a statistician and I buy lottery tickets
- hdivider 14y agoNice calculation, but it doesn't contradict the 'rational' argument at all. Slightly disappointing: looking at the title and first paragraph I expected some weird statistical wizardry on why the calculation of expected values is fundamentally flawed somehow. (Which would be surprising, given that it's an important mathematical tool in quantum mechanics (even though the formalism there is different).) Also, why pay for the privilege of imagining a better outcome? Imagination is >free< and virtually unlimited, surely.
- dchest 14y agoExactly. I'm entertaining myself every time I release some software and imagine that I'll sell millions of copies :)
- architgupta 14y agoReminds me of a dilbert comic: http://dilbert.com/strips/comic/2011-02-12/ http://dilbert.com/strips/comic/2011-02-12/
- MichaelApproved 14y agoThat's not >free< You probably spent many hours writing that software.
- dchest 14y agoNo, the dreams are free, as I make software for a living anyway.
- olalonde 14y agoHe does contradict the "rational" argument that you should only factor in money when doing your expected value calculations. > Imagination is >free< and virtually unlimited, surely. I guess he gets more entertainment out of knowing that what he is imagining has a chance of becoming a reality.
- Evbn 14y agoI just imagine that my dreams can come true! Maybe I bought a ticket yesterday and just forgot! Or my mom secretly bought a ticket for me!
- kryptiskt 14y agoThe expected value isn't flawed, but it's often not an useful guide to what action you should take. Imagine a lottery with an accumulated jackpot of $11 million, and there's one million $10 tickets (this isn't all that rare). Should you take all your savings and buy 1000 tickets? You have a positive expectation value, and 99.9% chance of ending up penniless. Is one that buys the tickets really a much more rational person than one who does it when the jackpot is $8 million? One can make just positive expectation bets and be certain to lose it all. The Kelly Criterion is a nice little formula for calculating the optimal bet size from the risk and the expectation.
- hdivider 14y ago"The expected value isn't flawed, but it's often not an useful guide to what action you should take." Yeah, I agree with that - if good decisions could be made that easily we'd all be phenomenally successful. There are mountains of complications (both qualitative and quantitative) that must be heaped on top of expected values if they're going to be any use at all in deciding what action to take. Perhaps this was the author's point, but perhaps that's sort of obvious anyway.
- koningrobot 14y agoThis is because you're not after money but after welfare (whatever that is).
- JonnieCache 14y agoThis is some really sophisticated trolling. Hats off. /me grabs popcorn.
- wilfra 14y agoCliffs: he doesn't mind lighting money on fire because he thinks imagining winning the lottery is fun.
- MichaelApproved 14y agoHe doesn't think imagining winning the lottery is fun, it actually is fun for him. He's actually entertained and is comfortable spending money for a little imaging and escapism. What's wrong with that?
- Jach 14y agoLots of illegal drugs are actually fun, too. While they probably shouldn't be illegal, they can easily (much more easily than other things) lead to self-destructive life styles with the user laughing all the way. That's what's wrong with them. Similarly for becoming addicted to gambling, which at least doesn't create a chemical dependency.
- wilfra 14y agoNothing is wrong with that. When I go to Las Vegas, I play craps for the same reason. But I didn't make a massive blog post that implied I could beat craps, get it on page 1 of HN and after 20,000 words and numerous graphs and tables announce to the World that it's ok that I donate some money to Bellagio once a year because it's my money and the waitresses are hot and it's fun. I wouldn't do that because no amount of eloquent prose and statistical evidence is going to change the fact that I just stated the blatantly obvious. That's why everybody gambles.
- staunch 14y agoThere is that Stanford math PhD that won four lotteries. http://www.forbes.com/sites/kiriblakeley/2011/07/21/meet-the-luckiest-woman-in-the-world/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/kiriblakeley/2011/07/21/meet-the...
- wilfra 14y agoThat's really interesting. Seems pretty obvious she cheated in some way. If something only happens once every 'quadrillion years' that's pretty much evidence right there, but given all of the other suspicious things as well...ya - I think there is basically no chance those were legit wins.
- Evbn 14y agoThere is a similar story of a Canadian or somewhere that cracked a weakness in the mechanics of a scratch off game (Monty Hall paradox exploited in real life!) for consistent average winnings. And of course the famous MIT Blackjack team. Of course, a lottery loves publicity, and they don't care which player wins, so win-win.
- vibrunazo 14y agoI had a statistics professor at college who were addicted to gaming. There were stories about him losing a lot of money, car, job and wife because of his addiction. I thought it were just a joke, you know, statistics professor addicted to lottery? Duh, I wouldn't fall for that. Until one day, to demonstrate that a specific class of combinations were too rare, he challenged a girl in the first row that if she rolled a dice x times she wouldn't get that kind of result. He was so confident that he told us he would pass us all in the test if she did. Well, she did. He did keep his word and passed us. Did I mention he was a phd? That thought me a huge lesson about argument of authority. And about the quality of college graduates in Brazil.
- shrikant 14y agoInteresting you should say that. Richard Feynman on education in Brazil: http://v.cx/2010/04/feynman-brazil-education http://v.cx/2010/04/feynman-brazil-education ..and the associated HN discussion: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2483976 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2483976
- jere 14y agoI loved Surely You're Joking Mr. Feynman! But to be fair, it was written nearly 30 years ago. I would hope things have gotten better since then.
- raverbashing 14y agoNot really, no
- dsego 14y agoWow, I had never read this piece before, but it exactly describes the croatian school system. Kids & students just memorising information. Even the teachers don't explain what something means, because they also went through school memorising stuff.
- outworlder 14y agoNot really, at least, not consistently. "Thus, it must be possible for some people to work their way through the system, bad as it is." It is possible. When my young brother asked me about how electrical generators worked (which is, by itself, an unusual question), I had an idea. I hooked up a DC motor to a LED and started cranking it, and he could see the LED lighting up, however faintly. Only then I tried to explain roughly how it worked - that little demonstration kept him interested. And he could explain it later, on his own words. He didn't grow up to be a scientist, but he thinks like one. I like to think that those little 'scientific' experiments of our youth had something to do with it.
- brianwillis 14y agoLooking back, there seems to be a correlation between the times in my life when I've bought lottery tickets, and the times in my life when I've felt hopeless. If I ever feel trapped by circumstances, depressed, lost, or I don't have optimism for the future, the less logical part of my brain will somehow rationalise the remote chance of winning millions as a perfectly justified excuse for buying a ticket. The author of this piece is right about how lottery tickets buy you a sense of hope, and prompt you to envision your life being better. So these days I see it as a sign that something in my life needs to change when I take an active interest in this week's Powerball prizes. It's become a kind of signalling mechanism for my subconscious.
- muppetman 14y agoThat's a very interesting view point/experience. For me, it's been the opposite. If I'm really happy, feel a bit like I'm on top of my fiances for this fortnight, I'll "splash out" and buy a Powerball ticket. If I'm down, the idea of giving away money on such a silly endeavour seems stupid. Anyway, here's hoping you don't buy too many powerball tickets in the immediate future!
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Evbn 14y agoConspicuous consumption.
- frobozz 14y agoI buy lottery tickets occasionally when I feel a bit down about money - doing so is a win-win. If I win a prize greater than my stake, then that's great. If I don't, then it reminds me that I can still afford to throw away a few pounds every now and then without it being a significant loss.
- lazyjones 14y agoEven though you do actually buy a sense of hope, it makes you worry more about missing an opportunity to win ("if only I had bought a few more tickets"). So it goes both ways and personally I feel happier by ignoring these (statistically - mostly false) hopes. (OTOH I still need to worry about key employees winning the lottery, but that's another sad/cynical story.)
- olalonde 14y agoThis boils down to "expected utility != expected value". His expected utility is positive despite the fact that buying lottery tickets does have a negative financial expected value. So yes, buying lottery tickets is perfectly rational for him.
- aes256 14y agoIndeed, this is Von Neumann–Morgenstern rationality for anyone interested: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Von_Neumann%E2%80%93Morgenstern_utility_theorem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Von_Neumann%E2%80%93Morgenstern...
- olalonde 14y agoThanks for the reference. I didn't know there was a specific term for that.
- paulsutter 14y agoInsurance has an interesting comparison to lottery tickets. In a lottery ticket, the expected return is usually about 50%. Which is exactly the same as insurance (the premium is about double the expected payout). Yet people regard insurance as prudent, and lottery tickets as foolish. Me included (as long as its a risk you cant easily cover). But our explanation, that "Lottery tickets are foolish because they have a negative expected return" isn't exactly credible if we think insurance is a good deal. Any thoughts?
- afhof 14y agoUnless you can sustain a $100,000-$300,000 loss before you have have paid into the insurance pool more than that amount, it makes sense. If you had gobs of money, then it wouldn't make sense for you to have insurance. (preconditioned on insurance being a profitable business, etc.)
- paulsutter 14y agoBy analogy - if a person thinks "spending $5 has no impact on my life, but winning $10M will", is that really any different from our justification of insurance? (I agree with you - thats the same way I view insurance. Yet I view lottery tickets as silly, but I can't clearly articulate why).
- graeme 14y agoThe cumulative impact of a lifetime of spending $5 per week is much less than winning a lottery. Most people can sustain a $5 per week hit, especially if they get the mental benefits described by the parent article. There are better things to spend $5 on, but it's not a huge deal either way - as long as you stay out of the addictive/compulsive zone. The losses covered by insurance are very impactful. Most people can't sustain the massive financial hit that comes from, say, their house burning down. It can make sense to lessen their day-to-day quality of life by spending money on insurance, to guard against that massive downside risk.
- 14y ago
- jpdus 14y agoThe real rational reason for buying lottery Tickets is unfortunately not mentioned.. You may not think of expected return but of a Chance to move up a bracket reg "Standard of Life" which would not be possible by other means. You wont move down a bracket by buying lottery Tickets (prob not even on a long term) - which makes it perfectly rational to play the lottery for some Kind of people (in the "poorer bracket") in my opinion.
- mrb 14y agoIt does mention why he buys tickets: not for the expected return, but for the pleasure of entertainment.
- pbhjpbhj 14y agoWell it mentions why he 'says' he buys tickets. >The standard argument of people who think that lotto is for suckers is based on expected return. They are taught at school that a rational investment is one with an expected value greater than the price paid. I have some problems with this argument, but I’ve never really calculated it before, so let us consider the numbers. // This para to me says he's not really looked before at why he buys tickets, he's certainly not calculated his expected returns even though - as he says - he's a statistician. That seems a bit weird to me, like a mechanic that doesn't check his own oil or something. So I think he now has a reason to tell people why he buys tickets but that perhaps before [and maybe still] there was some irrationality (humanity you might call it) in there too. >I’ve also heard the belief that the lottery is a tax on poor people. I have a different view, that buying lottery tickets is perfectly rational for me. // At the start he says this. And then, like others in this thread, says it's about hope and dreams - that seems contradictory in some sense. It's about hope beyond the mathematically expected financial return? The cost of doing the lottery for me exceeds the entertainment value it provides but the draw of the chance to "solve all my problems" is very strong. Perhaps not a tax on the poor but a far less easily avoided irrational expense? Aside: I also like the way he presents his calculation of expected return as if it's going to turn out that the lottery makes an ongoing loss and it's going to show that he was acting rationally all along (although it wouldn't show that of course because you have to have the argument first for the behaviour to be rational, don't you; otherwise it just happens to be coterminous with rational behaviour).
- WA 14y ago"The odds against winning the big prize are 45,379,619:1" I have a hard time imagining how low these odds are but once my math professor gave us an interesting analogy. One person drives from Los Angeles to Las Vegas and throws a quarter out of the window at any point in time. You then follow this person along the same route. You win the grand price if you manage to stop your car such that your front wheel stops at the exact same position as the quarter (10cm tolerance). This image made me never play the lottery.
- gojomo 14y agoThe imagery of this explanation adds to the lottery-aversion on a subconscious level, as well: it reverses how a lottery is usually portrayed. Instead of 'only a dollar' entry cost and 'millions' if you win, this analogy associates entry with a long and costly task (some or most of a cross-country drive) and winning with a single quarter. Clever!
- njharman 14y agoThis analogy reinforces why people should and do (incl author) play the lottery. A nice roadtrip through the country, entertainment. If you happen to stop and find a quarter, bonus!
- danmaz74 14y agoWith cumulative jackpots, it is indeed possible that the expected returns on some plays are a net positive. But if you just consider lotteries for what they are - a form of entertainment - that doesn't make so much difference...
- dhechols 14y ago> So why do I still buy lottery tickets? Definitely not for the expected monetary return on investment. I think of it as a discretionary entertainment spend. I get literally hours of enjoyment from fantasizing what I’d do if I won. Why not spend it on hookers and blow instead? THINK OF ALL THE FUN YOU'LL HAVE. :|
- saraid216 14y ago...because hookers and blow are expensive and have a lower money-to-fun ratio? And, honestly, I wouldn't actually have fun with hookers and blow. But that's just me.
- Ironballs 14y agoKari Enqvist, a professor of cosmology, said something very insightful in an interview about gambling in general: "Insurances yield a peace of mind and lotteries yield dreams, the values of which cannot be measured in mere terms of probabilities or money." In my view, lottery tickets are not meant to be rationally justifiable, nor should they be required to be. Yet, I don't fancy the idea of committing to such vain pursuits comfortable at all, but I can understand people who act upon their dreams, and will not berate those who do.
- fcmk 14y agoAlso, in Finland the state lottery redistributes the profit to good use. By law the arts get 38.5%, sports 25%, science 17.5% and youth work 9%. 10% goes to whatever the Ministry of Education decides that year. Whenever I play lottery I think I'm partly giving money to charity and partly buying a dream.
- Evbn 14y agoI bet you would be more effective donating directly to a worthwhile recipent than running through layers of adminstrative overhead.
- jopt 14y agoMeanwhile, the people who sell you the lottery ticket act completely rationally. Funny---it's still lottery tickets, but when the odds are in your favour the hope is no longer needed.
- philh 14y ago> the values of which cannot be measured in mere terms of probabilities or money. Sure they can. I'll pay $X for insurance but I won't pay $Y. Peace of mind is worth somewhere between $X and $Y to me. If I offer someone $Z to never play the lottery again, they'll either take it or not. If they take it, they valued those particular dreams less than $Z. (Unless $Z is high enough to fulfill some of those dreams, but I suspect many people would accept a $Z which is not so high.) There's no simple trade-off where I'll always accept some number of units of money for some number of units of peace of mind; but the same is true of cars.
- lotto 14y agoI won the UK National Lottery jackpot as part of a syndicate. Two years later, I won it again on my own. The wins have had two effects on how I evaluate odds: first, so-called 'remote' probabilities I once found reassuring – the odds of being hit by lightning in your lifetime is 1 in 10,000 or the chances of being killed in a train crash are 1 in 500,000 – no longer have a calming effect. This can make me both nervous and acutely risk-aware. Some people call this introverted. Second, the converse has also become true: so-called 'impossible' odds – the chance of winning the National Lottery jackpot three times, for example – no longer deter me from participating. This can make me both irrational and actively risk-seeking. Some people call this extroverted. Regardless of this dichotomy, the OP's point of view rings true for me: the decision to play the lottery lies in entertainment value alone. It is unlikely that I will win again. But it is hard to resist the questions hammered out in lottery marketing campaigns. The ones designed to undermine rational resistance to extraordinary odds: "What would you do if you did win?" or, more bluntly, "How would you spend it?" It is harder still to resist simple cost-benefit analysis, which leaves the same question I've had since the beginning: is dreaming worth the cost of entry? My answer is always the same: You bet it is.
- rvkennedy 14y agoThe main thing to be learned from this post is that the “Super 7’s Oz Lotto” is clearly a badly run lottery. If the expected return for a ticket is greater than the price, this lottery is losing money for the organizers. Perhaps this explains the glum-looking face on their logo: https://media.tatts.com/images/lotto/tattersalls/site-logo-tattersalls.png https://media.tatts.com/images/lotto/tattersalls/site-logo-t...
- megablast 14y agoThe money is so big because it has rolled over, it has not been won for a while.
- dimitar 14y agoAn honest question: Why don't hedge funds buy lottery tickets?
- gvb 14y agoHedge funds are hedging against (sort of) specific bad things happening. To do this, they buy into an investment that (hopefully ;-) has a [edit] positive correlation to the "bad thing" they are hedging against so that, if the bad thing messes up your primary investment, the hedge investment gains compensate (some of) your losses. Example: http://money.stackexchange.com/questions/6473/where-should-i-invest-to-hedge-against-the-stock-market-going-down http://money.stackexchange.com/questions/6473/where-should-i... Since winning the lottery is not correlated at all with something bad happening to an investment firm's investments, it is a very poor hedge against their investments failing to come through.
- andreasvc 14y agoBecause it wouldn't make them money (expected value) and would probably be against the rules anyway.
- barefoot 14y agoI also have a background in statistics (to a degree) and gamble but prefer deep OTM puts to powerball.
- EzGraphs 14y agoA mathematically friend who gambles a bit expressed it this way: "Chances of winning - 1 in <some ridiculously high number> ...I'll play anyway - somebody's got to win."
- andreasvc 14y agoIt's fine to say I play the lottery because I like to be irrational, but in that case it's a complete red herring to play the I-am-a-statistician card.
- WalterBright 14y agoI would think it would be easier to calculate the payout ratio simply by looking at how much the government kept of the lottery revenue, rather than by calculating the odds.
- jimrandomh 14y agoInteresting that he claims this lottery has positive expected value, but I don't think it's true. He forgot about income tax. This is one of the standard tricks for making lotteries look better (or less bad) than they really are. (The other common trick is paying an annuity instead of money, and advertising its nominal value instead of its actual value, which is substantially greater. This one doesn't seem to be doing that, though).
- andrevan 14y agoFunny that he started the article seeming like he was going to show using math that the lottery was a good investment idea, when in fact it isn't according to his own estimation. As to the entertainment value of dreaming that you've won the lottery, obviously nobody should be told they CAN'T enter. But what some call a dream I call self-delusion. We have a pervasive idea in this country that we're all going to become rich eventually and it's simply not true.
- dennisgorelik 14y agoHe forgot that lottery can be rigged. He also forgot about paying taxes in case of winning lottery. Not sure why he cannot dream about getting rich without playing lottery.