10 ms·
How A $19 Million Movie Makes $150 Million - And Still Isn't Profitable
- jivatmanx 14y agoNothing special here, tax shelters work by generating artificial tax losses that are written off, or by using indefinite deferments. In this artificial losses are generated by the movie theater piling each shell company up with faux "service charges".
- azylman 14y agoThe difference is that tax shelters usually aren't used to deprive your staff of salary, they're used to deprive the government of tax revenue. This is both.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoExcept that it doesn't work for avoiding taxes. If you charge ten million in internal advertising to an account, you're advertising division is still making a profit. There are lots of other tricks for avoiding taxes, but what is described is purely for screwing the artists.
- kristofferR 14y agoBut you don't charge your own company, you buy services from a seemingly external company (that is actually operated by you). That's one way to generate a loss while actually just moving money around.
- sokoloff 14y agoYou generate a loss for one company, but income for another company. I don't see how this avoids taxes, just moves them from one entity to another. (so if the second entity is in a tax-friendly jurisdiction, it's obvious how that helps, but it doesn't simply generate a loss and that's the end of the story.)
- chii 14y agoBut then the shell company could just be collapsed, and all its debt obligations (which is really to yourself) could be all moot. Thus, you avoid paying tax like that as well?
- beagle3 14y agoSuch tax loopholes might exist (I am not a tax person), but generally the answer is no: If you take a loan, and don't return it for whatever reason (e.g. because the person to whom you owe it has died and has no heirs; or the bank that gave you the loan decides not to collect), the loan you previously received is instantly converted for tax purposes into your income, and you have to pay income tax on that.
- w1ntermute 14y agoWhen you've got thousands of people willing to take your staff's place, there's no reason to pay them well.
- tomrod 14y agoI don't know many talented directors. I know a few bumblers, but perhaps that's because I don't live in CA?
- w1ntermute 14y agoDon't know if you're joking, but I don't think the directors are getting shafted by this creative bookkeeping.
- tomrod 14y agoI thought the article was clear on this point. The director was paid 5% of net. Net was negative -- the director got shafted. The directors I know are unlikely getting shafted by this method, as their portfolios consist of mainly live births, cattle auctions, and high school sports. Still Art Institute graduates though.
- w1ntermute 14y agoNo, the article wasn't clear on the point. It gave an example of one specific director, Scott Derrickson, getting shafted. No offense to Scott, but as a casual movie watcher, I haven't heard of him. And if casual movie watchers haven't heard of him, he can be easily replaced, and therefore easily shafted.
- antr 14y agoNo that different from Google's, Facebook's, Apple's, et al. methods employed in Europe to avoid paying taxes.
- lquist 14y agoFor those that are unaware, parent is referring to the "Double Irish" strategy (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement).
- antr 14y agoNot really. I'm referring to the operating companies acting as cost centres, rather than profit centres. Avoiding taxes at the HoldCo is another ball game i.e. double Irish.
- beagle3 14y agoVery different, actually: Supposedly, if you look at the big picture, then the amount of taxes actually paid matches the amount that would have been paid had the structure been simple. The IRS is supposedly not that foolish. However, this structure can let the studios (and similarly, record companies) keep a larger share of the real profit, rather then actually do "profit sharing". Supposedly.
- rmc 14y agoAlthough Google Ireland pays feck all taxes and has a tiny 'profit', they do employ thousands of highly paid (& highly taxed) employees localy.
- antr 14y agoI don't think you understood my comment/article. I'm not referring to tax loopholes/advantages, but running operating companies at a country level as cost centres.
- cdk 14y agoIt seems like the people with real leverage (i.e. movie stars) demand a cut of the gross (pre-expenses) instead of the net.
- fatbird 14y agoI was going to say: He should have fired his agent for agreeing to any cut of the net. I thought everyone at this point knew that you always demand points on the gross just because no one every makes net points.
- lquist 14y agoIncidentally, even outside of the movie business, never take net points on anything, for exactly this reason.
- Rev55 14y agoAgreed, it's so easy to get screwed over.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoHe just wouldn't have had the job if he'd insisted on gross at that point in his career. He lacked the clout.
- fatbird 14y agoI can understand lacking clout to ask for gross, but I have trouble believing that he thought he'd actually get net. When someone like him gets offered net, doesn't he say "look, we both know that 'net' means 'zero', so don't blow smoke up my ass." ETA: Also, one wonders if relative clout just means asking for a much smaller fraction of gross. Better a tenth of a percent of gross than 10 percent of net.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoI've heard people who are signing deals call net points "monkey points". Everybody knows they're worthless, but you take what there is. Having said that, even experienced people might believe that net points would be worth something if a $19 million budget grosses $150 million. Especially on a project with no gross participants. He might have been able to negotiate performance bonuses, extra money when gross milestones were hit. I've heard of those being a bit more common than gross points. The bigger the budget, though, the more clout you need to get anything at all. I know of deals where gross points were offered to first timers on sub-million dollar budgets, but when you get up in the 10s of millions, it's a different game.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jakejake 14y agoThis is exactly how record deals work as well, I can tell you first hand. The added kick in the nuts which isn't even mentioned is that if the project starts to come close to the level of profit where the artists would get payment - all the studio/label has to do is spend more money on additional, marked-up promotion and the project goes deeper into "debt." Why would they bother paying the artists, when instead they can invest that same money on a 2nd round of advertising? From their perspective it doesn't make sense to ever pay the artist. The only time they do is if the artist gets really pissed off, has some clout and the studio/label wants to keep them happy. If all three of those things happen then maybe they'll get some crumbs. The moral of the story is, unless you have the kind of clout to make your own deal, make sure you get a satisfactory amount of money from your advance (up-front payment).
- theevocater 14y agoHonestly the modern moral of the story is bandcamp or indiegogo or kickstarter or some other service. I'll be the first to say it is going to be much MUCH harder than taking a record deal but we do live in a time where its possible to stay away from the big industry folks and strike gold (or out) on your own.
- hkmurakami 14y agoI truly look forward to the day when supporting (by paying real money) individual creators and independent teams for music, movies, animation, games, and books will be commonplace in the general public. In tandem, I hope that this will spur great creations to come forth that are not bound by the traditional red tape and truly messed up business models of today's media businesses. Such a world will require a lot more independence and proactivity from us the consumers (which we are frankly not accustomed to at all right now), from the extra effort needed to engage in "discovery" and in realizing how much of an impact each consumption & purchasing decision can have on the lives of each creative person we choose to support; but such a world will have far more diversity and niche options than we currently see today, which would be a truly amazing future.
- chii 14y ago
- ta12121 14y agoSigh. Yes, we know. Hollywood Accounting.
- MartinCron 14y agoThis is as good a time as any to suggest Kevin Smith's "Smoviemakers" podcast for anyone who is interested in the art and business of movie production. It's really a great listen, even when he's talking to people I'm not a huge fan of (such as Scott Derrickson --nothing against him, but I just haven't seen any of his movies) http://smodcast.com/channels/smoviemakers/ http://smodcast.com/channels/smoviemakers/
- knowaveragejoe 14y agoMeanwhile this industry is complaining it's being strangled by piracy?
- fpp 14y agoIt's called "Hollywood accounting": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting
- witoldc 14y agoIs there any effect on taxes? Yes, the shell company makes $0 thanks to phantom expenses, but the main company gets all that money and that is profit. So the shell has 0 tax liability and the main company faces all the tax liability. It may screw the crew, but it doesn't matter for tax reasons. Correct?
- djloche 14y agoThe larger company will have losses from unsuccessful ventures, which will offset the profits.
- beagle3 14y agoBut that's not a tax cheat - that's how the tax system is supposed to work. If the total sum of losses is greater or equal to the sum of profits, they haven't actually made any money, and shouldn't be taxed. It's just people who are promised "net points" that get screwed, not the tax man.
- OldSchool 14y agoI cringe every time a movie or event is reported as having "made" its gross ticket sales number. Typically 1/2 off the top goes to theaters themselves, and then all these accounting games begin. Maybe the top line is the only relatively non-fictional number but they could at least report it for what it is: ticket sales.
- Evbn 14y agoWhy? The gross sales are all consumer spending going toward people in involved in getting eyeballs on content. What number is any more honest?
- OldSchool 14y agoI see your logic in that the number is divvied up amongst everyone along the way including the theater, so you could say "The Movie" made that amount. I doubt Hollywood is going that abstract route though. I more get an impression like those articles that call an entrepreneur who reached $1M in sales a millionaire, as though he/she had no costs and no taxes and gets to pocket all the gross. Nothing's more important in Hollywood than money and image so I just assume their intent is more along those lines. I'd be happy to "make" $9M for anyone who first gives me $10M then.
- adrianscott 14y agoI've read that these days many theaters only get 10% of the ticket sales for the first week or so at least on major films, (before dropping substantially, combined with much shorter runs. So the theaters get less than they used to as far as i know, especially that first week or so.
- OldSchool 14y agoInteresting, that's a pretty harsh deal considering how extravagant movie theaters are expected to be these days. Considering whom they're buying from, I guess I'm not surprised.
- andreasvc 14y agoWhy isn't this stuff outlawed? To me it doesn't sound like accounting tricks at all, it sounds like outright fraud.
- noonespecial 14y ago"Outlawed" is a difficult concept at this level. All justice above "street level" is simply politics. The executive summary is that if you did it, it would be fraud because you haven't made enough campaign contributions.
- EricDeb 14y agohttp://ycombinator.com/rfs9.html http://ycombinator.com/rfs9.html
- ktizo 14y agoOne of the most egregious examples of this is David Prowse not getting any residuals for Return of The Jedi, as it also apparently hasn't made any profits yet. - http://www.slashfilm.com/lucasfilm-tells-darth-vader-that-return-of-the-jedi-hasnt-made-a-profit/ http://www.slashfilm.com/lucasfilm-tells-darth-vader-that-re...
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoI just want to know what part of "Everybody knows" does everybody not actually know. The director of a film I have actually heard of, took 5% of net. But everyone knows you want a percentage of gross. When was this not known to people working in the industry? This also adds to my totally unsubstantiated belief that a large portion of fortune 500 would be unprofitable without tax dodges
- vacri 14y ago"Give me 5% of gross" "No. We'll look for another director, there are thousands" "Okay, I'll take 5% of net"
- dennisgorelik 14y ago"Okay, I'll take 2% of gross". "Net" should never be a part of such negotiations.
- tsotha 14y agoOnly a handful of people have that kind of clout. Everyone else is getting part of the net, realizing they're getting screwed, and hoping the current project will be so successful they join the powerful handful.
- dennisgorelik 14y agoIf all non-important participants are getting part of the net, that guarantees that net would be negative. Why even bother asking for it and putting it on a contract? Ask for tiny gross part or for small hourly raise, but treat net share exactly as zero.
- tsotha 14y agoMost of the "talent" gets a fixed amount. The net percentage is like getting stock options as a programmer - if the stars align just right you might get something. Maybe.
- mistercow 14y agoWhile the general idea of this is obviously gross and greedy, this part makes perfect sense: >with some of the big studios, some of this money involves paying itself for advertising on its own properties. The idea of opportunity cost applies to advertising; any advertising they do on their own properties is advertising they could have sold to somebody else. So it's clearly legitimate to count that as a cost.
- randomfool 14y agoThis seems like the opposite of performance-based compensation. No wonder Hollywood sucks- no one cares how much their movie makes!
- Evbn 14y agoWait I thought the profit motive driving studios to produce safe sequels the mass market say they want is why movies were are so bad. Which is it?
- majormajor 14y agoSo, as someone who's never been involved or close to the sale of a heavily funded startup, this sounds on the face of it similar to taking equity in a startup that then raised more money and diluted that equity and then was sold in a deal where that equity ended up turning into nothing—I've read a fair number of stories on here that toss around terms like "preferred stock" or whatnot, but still don't really know how the sausage is made. It sounds an awful lot like this, though: the people who put in the most money also have tricks of making sure they get paid, while most of the people doing the work don't have the clout to get in on it.
- aptwebapps 14y agoWhat I don't understand is, why would anyone accept terms that had any relation to profits at this point? Surely this is well-known by now? I can understand this working for a while, but it's amazing how long it's been going on.
- tomrod 14y agoI'm not sure about this specific example, but I could see a couple of reasons: * One really wants the movie to be made, like a Clint Eastwood figure director who likes the script, regardless of the cost to self * Director is new and potentially naive; agent is no good * Director is new, not naive, and wants to make a brand for him- or herself in the movie world (and knows the movie isn't bound for a Saturday Syfy special... /snark)
- aptwebapps 14y agoThe thing is, people who are that new and naive can't demand much in the first place. People who are in a position to take a slice worth worrying about would presumably know better. I guess that's not completely true, going by the Scott Derrickson example, but it still seems strange to me.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoHe had done a direct to video movie before Emily Rose, a Hellraiser thing with a budget of about $2 million. For that he likely made around $100k salary and if he had any net, it was worth nothing. But that project proved he could direct an acceptable film, which isn't as common a skill as you might imagine. So once he'd done that, he had the chance to move up to the next budget range, $20ish million, plus or minus. For that, as I mentioned above, he probably got in the neighborhood of $500k. Maybe a little more, but certainly less than $1 million. Then when that movie did extremely well, he went on to do The Day The Earth Stood Still, an $80 million dollar project. Whatever he got paid for that is highly variable, but it was likely a million or two. As he mentions in the podcast, TDTESS did 80 million domestic, total of 240 global. Which made it a success in terms of money, but since the domestic was so low it wasn't perceived as such in the industry. So he didn't move to the A list after that. He said he got offers for things like big franchise sequels, but his own dream projects weren't able to get the greenlight. If he'd taken the hired gun route on studio sequels, he said he'd probably make a couple million per. So what he did instead was go and make his own film, cheap. He made the current movie Sinister for $3 million. Again he's back in the few hundred thousand range at most for salary. But this time, since it was his movie and he made it cheap, he's got real gross participation. As he says in the podcast, after the movie hits a certain breakeven point (which it likely is very close to doing if it hasn't already), the money starts rolling in for him and he'll be "rich". From the podcast, it seems likely his deal on this project will let him get what would be called FU Money here. It's not a terrible system, really. Directors aren't completely screwed, they do ok for themselves. The real secret is to own the property yourself.
- ErrantX 14y agoOn a related note; if you've not seen "Monsters" then you should track it down, a great film! (it should have had a BAFTA but had the misfortune to be released the same year as the even better "Four Lions").
- rickyconnolly 14y agoThis reminds me of the method used by Starbucks to avoid paying tax in the UK [1]. They set up their UK operations as a separate legal entity, and then charge it considerable licensing fees for the use of the Starbucks brand. This way, the UK branch appears to be making a loss on paper, when it is actually generating considerable revenue. [1]. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-19967397 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-19967397
- hermannj314 14y agoShouldn't this say, how a $19 million movie that spends $50 million in advertising and $250 million in distribution can make $150 million and not be profitable? Your marketing and distribution costs are real costs aren't they? I don't get how this is "Hollywood Accounting", it sounds like actual accounting.
- HelloMcFly 14y agoThe point is a lot of those "figures" aren't real or objectively driven, they're just numbers being shuffled around within the company to make the movie seem more expensive. There's a wikipedia article on it that may make the concept more clear.
- hermannj314 14y agoThank you, it did seem a little more clear after reading that. Basically, no one is claiming the movie didn't "spend" $50 million on advertising, the claim is that the studio is inflating the $50 million advertising expense while hardly providing anything close to that value in return. Wouldn't that be caught in an audit? Aren't there (shouldn't there?) be laws prohibiting corporate-to-corporate transfers that are just money dumps not tied to legitimate verifiable expenses? I am ridiculously naive about this topic, but it seems the directors of these movies could sue if the studio were lying and exaggerating expenses?
- shinratdr 14y agoSo you can spend years in court fighting the defacto standard only to win a pittance as well as an informal blacklisting? Most filmmakers would rather just suck it up, move on, and learn from the experience rather than dwell on it and make it worse.
- Nick_C 14y agoThere's no lying or fraud. Company B (the production company) agrees to pay Company A (the studio) $X for services. Done, price agreed. Of course, both companies are owned by the studio, so it is just transfer pricing as far as the studio is concerned. But it is a real cost for the production company so that that there is no profit for residuals. Intentionally.
- joshuaheard 14y agoWhy don't you just take a percentage of the gross revenue instead of the net?
- undantag 14y agoSimilar thing happened to a friend of mine who worked at a game development startup. A company was set up for that game, and the whole crew of developers were hired by it, while the two "founders" held the parent company. Everyone worked for low-to-no wages under the promise that they would see bonuses based on sales. When the game released, all the sales revenue went to the parent company and the only ones receiving bonuses were the two founders.
- Evbn 14y agoWell they certainly got the the expected value of "promises".
- dllthomas 14y agoI think it's amusing that the movie industry complains of piracy hurting the artists, while at the same time charging the artists exorbitantly for things (promotion, distribution) which piracy helps with.
- TwoBit 14y agoHow is it that Hollywood Accounting is legal? The US has its problems, but people's leal rights is one thing the US is usually pretty good about.
- shinratdr 14y agoMy favourite example of this classic accounting practice is MF DOOM simply warning listeners right off the bat to pirate his Venomous Villain album because his contract for it blows: "Dub it off your man/Don't spend that ten bucks/I did it for the advance/The back end sucks."