7 ms·
Comma openpilot – Open source driver-assistance
- sebmellen 10mo agoComma is my favorite “AI” company. Really incredible piece of tech in a tiny package, and it truly improves your life to have it. I wish it worked with my Mitsubishi Outlander, but just having it on my Corolla is enough. Their supported brand list will definitely factor into my next car buying decision.
- hahahahhaah 10mo agoI like Comma. I like geohot (I wouldn't want to work for him I imagine it is intense) but I like the contrary attitude and also the product as seen as demoed on youtube.
- smallerize 10mo agoHe hasn't been running comma.ai since '22, and even left the board just in November.
- hahahahhaah 10mo agosorry not been keeping up. thanks for the info
- rvz 10mo agoHe (geohot) is still the President of Comma.ai and still owns the majority of the company.
- smallerize 10mo agoHis LinkedIn says he stopped being president in November. https://www.linkedin.com/in/george-hotz-b3866476 https://www.linkedin.com/in/george-hotz-b3866476 I haven't seen any other news about it.
- csto12 10mo agoIm shocked Hotz has a LinkedIn. That seems antithetical to his entire existence.
- dante_dev 10mo agoYou're not wrong. Read his profile. I used to joke about how I used LinkedIn as a dating site, but in the current year this just isn't that funny anymore. The professional managerial class I was mocking is quickly losing its grasp on power, so it's unclear if I'm still punching up. How many of the messages here even come from real people anymore? How many of those people have pronouns in their bio? Are they GPT/GPT? We have a big task ahead of us to define what the "new business" looks like. Comparatively, the revolution is the easy part.
- SirMaster 10mo agoHe's not the type to run a company. He likes to work on code and he works on tinygrad a lot which comma.ai uses.
- torginus 10mo agoHow did his efforts to make the modern AI stack work on top of AMD work out?
- georgehotz 10mo agoTry tinygrad on your AMD machine
- ActorNightly 10mo agoThe problem with geohot is that if there was Musk anounced a medical procedure where men could pay to get pregnant by him, geohot would empty his life savings and be first line line. Seriously, read his blog, and ctrl-f Elon on any post. https://geohot.github.io/blog/ https://geohot.github.io/blog/
- ab_testing 10mo agoHow is the experience on the Corolla. How much can it do by itself?
- mbirth 10mo agoWhat a coincidence, LTT tested it a few months ago in a Corolla. Here’s the video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xdmxM-v4KQg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xdmxM-v4KQg
- lifeisgood99 10mo ago15 mins in. It's terrible. How is this allowed on the roads?
- LorenDB 10mo agoFWIW my experience has been very good, and LTT said recently that they are working on a long term review, so I expect that to be a more accurate review than first impressions when you aren't familiar with how it works.
- sebmellen 10mo agoExtremely good. You can go hands off for long periods.
- StevenNunez 10mo agoRan into this a few days ago while looking for a way out of the subscription hell of self driving offerings. Very excited to watch this space!
- Der_Einzige 10mo agoThe CEO of comma.ai is an absolute class act and is basically the anti-elon musk. Comma is awesome, and more companies should be like them.
- androiddrew 10mo agoI know george hotz was the CEO. Who is it now?
- smallerize 10mo agoThey don't have a single person listed as CEO. It was Ricardo Biasini for a while. https://techcrunch.com/2022/11/02/george-hotz-aka-geohot-is-leaving-comma-ai-for-a-lofty-ai-project/ https://techcrunch.com/2022/11/02/george-hotz-aka-geohot-is-... More recently he was part of DOGE. https://therevolvingdoorproject.org/riccardo-biasini-doge-agent/ https://therevolvingdoorproject.org/riccardo-biasini-doge-ag... Maybe they meant Harald Schäfer (CTO), Alex Matzner (COO), or Adeeb Shihadeh (CPO).
- CamperBob2 10mo agoMore recently he was part of DOGE Maximum ooofage
- nullfish 10mo agogeohotz, the infamous person who cracked the PS3 at the time. Been following him since that time and this project since he started it. His blogs have always teetered on the edge of unprofessional while remaining incredibly knowledgeable and insightful. Truly enjoy all his work.
- CursedSilicon 10mo agoMinor correction. Geohot never cracked the PS3. Fail0verflow did. Geohot watched their talk. Rushed out a "hello world!" jailbroken firmware based on their talk and got the team in massive legal trouble for doing so
- coolgoose 10mo agoStill hoping Opel will be covered
- julianeon 10mo agoThis is awesome. I hope this technology continues to advance and decrease in price - but it's already a great value at this one.
- ActorNightly 10mo agoThe thing is, none of this is really better than any of the simpler systems in terms of use. If you are required to pay attention most of the time, it defeats the purpose of self driving. Most humans can perform very complex tasks while keeping a car in lane, and adaptive cruise control is nothing new. Also, being in my coworkers/friends Teslas that are using Autopilot, it almost seems like there is more cognitive load in using it in crowded areas, because you have to be very attentive to catch a disengagement.
- sergiotapia 10mo agoI was in the market for this for my Pacifica but I couldn't figure out what this does exactly. Is it FSD basically? Is it just lane assist? Can I put an address in a map and it takes me there? Very hard to just get these concrete answers, maybe they just take the newbie experience for granted and assume people know these answers. Anyone who owns one of these can answer? Thank you!
- jackmhny 10mo agoFAQs including - What is openpilot? - How does openpilot work? at https://comma.ai/support#what-is-openpilot https://comma.ai/support#what-is-openpilot
- zie 10mo agoGeneric Openpilot out of the box is just super nice cruise control right now. So it can do longitudinal and latitudinal control. So it lane keeps, stays behind the car in front of you, etc. If you use Sunnypilot or one of the other friendly forks, you can do more, but it's not (currently) to the state of Tesla's FSD. Personally, I recommend buying it if you do a lot of road trips. It's amazing for that. In/around town it's only useful if you have a lot of stop and go traffic, like if you live in LA or other large car-centric city with a big commute.
- guyfromfargo 10mo agoI have one of these and I really enjoy it. No it’s not FSD. There is no navigation at all, you’re correct that it’s “just lane assist”. But the lane assist is next level. I take a few 1,000 mile plus road trips every year and the comma pays for itself every time. Using the stock lane assist, I’m constantly correcting it. The stock assist tries to take an exit, doesn’t handle curves well at all, and any construction or unusual road conditions it won’t work at all. With the Comma, on the highway it’s basically FSD. On my last 1000 mile trip I never had to disengage, only to pass and make turns. The biggest advantage is Comma allows you to be completely hands off the wheel. Where lane assist forces you to hold the wheel at all times.
- geaibleu 10mo ago
- Mountain_Skies 10mo agoWonder if it will be able to work with the Slate pickup when that comes out. Seems like it would be a perfect pairing if the Slate has enough control exposed to it.
- testfoobar 10mo agoReally impressive tech. I don't understand the insurance ramifications of installing and using this system. Comma's website links to a 7 year old reddit thread: https://comma.ai/support#will-my-insurance-cover-my-car-with-a-comma-device-installed https://comma.ai/support#will-my-insurance-cover-my-car-with... As a driver, if in an accident, could someone reasonably assert that you were not paying attention?
- hahahahhaah 10mo agoI guess it would be like open source cruise control. In that they could assert some probability of incorrect installation that caused the accident.
- wing-_-nuts 10mo agoI mean, just like with a Tesla, the driver is responsible for the actions taken by the car, which means you do need to be paying attention, hands on the wheel, ready to take over at all times. We don't yet have the legal framework to say 'Sue company x, it wasn't my fault!' You get sued, then you have a very uphill battle to turn around and try to sue the company that provided the 'self driving' functionality because companies put all sorts of 'I totally accept liability for using this' in the T&C of their products.
- sitharus 10mo agoAt the moment in every jurisdiction I’m aware of the driver is always considered as “in charge” of the vehicle no matter what assistance functions are being used. It’s the driver’s responsibility to avoid collisions in all cases. If you have a collision and your vehicle is judged at fault by whatever authority does it in your area the you are liable.
- charcircuit 10mo agoWhat if there is no driver because the car is self driving?
- gegtik 10mo ago
- frakkingcylons 10mo agoWhen one of my coworkers bought a used car, he went out of his way to buy a model year that was compatible with Comma. He has lots of praise for it.
- alephnerd 10mo agoAre they still being extra and only asking about Putnam scores during interviews?
- defrost 10mo agoDamn, well, that's me and Terence Tao out of luck.
- literalAardvark 10mo agoI hear he's beside himself
- defrost 10mo agoThe first Banach–Tarski-Tao Cut is the deepest.
- adeebshihadeh 10mo agowe hire through https://comma.ai/leaderboard https://comma.ai/leaderboard and i think our interviews are relatively chill never heard of anyone asking for anything like that
- alephnerd 10mo agoThis was back around 2017-19 (can't remember the exact year), but it was definetly pre-Covid and left a bad taste in my mouth, just like Jane Street and FTX at the time - especially given that your then competitor Deepscale didn't have that style of interview.
- georgehotz 10mo agolol I think I actually responded to you once before, you have the wrong company. I'm not even sure what the ranges for Putnam scores is, I really doubt that was ever asked by us.
- letmeinhere 10mo agoI'm supposed to entrust my life and others' to this and they're bragging on their home page about GitHub stars?
- grepfru_it 10mo agoIt’s open source bro, just read the code if you don’t trust it. /s That said I am intimately familiar with the code and it’s pretty well designed with safety in mind. Plus your vehicle has safety parameters that limits the ability for the software to do something insane. That said there are a few stories of open pilot running into a curb, hitting a car in the neighboring lane, etc
- geaibleu 10mo agoComma is anal about safety. Few years ago they went as far as to ban anyone tinkering with Ford trucks/vans via park assist commands since those had unlimited steeeing torque/angle (and speed spoofing).
- georgehotz 10mo agoHere's some context for why those park assist commands are so dangerous. https://blog.comma.ai/safer-control-of-steering/ https://blog.comma.ai/safer-control-of-steering/
- geaibleu 10mo agoHoly fuck, didn't expect reply from the man himself. First thank you for Open pilot, it's truly an amazing project, I've been user since 2019. Second, comment re Ford was not to criticise you but to underscore that Comma and you personally take safety very seriously.
- jimmar 10mo agoSeeing things like, "<h2 id="new-driving-model">New driving model</h2>" on their list of latest releases does not inspire a lot of confidence. Yes, the HTML tags are displayed on the page. Some basic quality assurance on the website would help me trust the quality assurance applied to their product offering. https://comma.ai/openpilot https://comma.ai/openpilot
- nomel 10mo agoThere's a few Lex Fridman podcasts with George Hotz, the founder. Highly recommend them: #31 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iwcYp-XT7UI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iwcYp-XT7UI #132 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_L3gNaAVjQ4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_L3gNaAVjQ4 #387 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dNrTrx42DGQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dNrTrx42DGQ
- jyscao 10mo agoNo idea how Fridman manages to bring on the type of high profile guests that he does. Guy does not ask good questions and has the charisma of a wet rag,
- Powdering7082 10mo agoYeah I loved the guests he had, but eventually had to stop listening to him
- dandersch 10mo agoGuests don't care about charisma, they care who your previous guests were. He early on got Elon Musk as a guest (AFAIK by writing a paper that was overly favorable to Tesla) and managed to snowball that into a big podcast. Also guests agreeing to go on your show means they already want to talk about something, so in a way it's more important to shut up than ask good questions.
- lern_too_spel 10mo agoBut then he gets guests spewing utter nonsense and just agrees with them instead of following up. It's unlistenable.
- NitpickLawyer 10mo agoHuh, I'm the exact opposite. With the exception of Hannah Fry's work at deepmind (where she acts as a charismatic proxy for the more nerdy guests), he is by far the best interviewer on technical stuff (AI stuff mostly, but some early robotics stuff as well). He knows the field, he asks pertinent questions and more importantly he knows when to just let the speaker speak. Compared to someone like Dwarkesh, it's night and day. There's a fine line between pushing the guest and just interrupting them every 2nd thought to inject your own "takes".
- nashashmi 10mo ago> Currently, openpilot performs the functions of Adaptive Cruise Control (ACC) and Automated Lane Centering (ALC). openpilot can accelerate, brake automatically for other vehicles, and steer to follow the road/lane. [1] [Some of the] Cars that are currently supported already have "smart cruise" and "lane follow". Why then use a third-party self-driving system? [1] https://comma.ai/openpilot#:~:text=Currently%2C%20openpilot%20performs%20the%20functions%20of%20Adaptive%20Cruise%20Control%20(ACC)%20and%20Automated%20Lane%20Centering%20(ALC).%20openpilot%20can%20accelerate%2C%20brake%20automatically%20for%20other%20vehicles%2C%20and%20steer%20to%20follow%20the%20road/lane. https://comma.ai/openpilot#:~:text=Currently%2C%20openpilot%...
- CamperBob2 10mo agoI have a car with smart cruise, but there's plenty of room for improvement. It isn't very smart at determining when it can avoid braking, such as when a car well ahead has slowed for a right turn. It also brakes too aggressively when someone cuts in front of me on the highway, in situations where just lifting off the gas would be better. It also times out very quickly when traffic comes to a complete standstill, requiring manual intervention to get going again, and it doesn't give any indication to the driver when that occurs. If these things bothered me much more than they do, I'd be interested in comma.ai as a possible solution. As it stands, the OEM radar cruise control is "Eh, good enough, I guess."
- mitchell209 10mo agoI’m fine with BlueCruise but my free sub is up next year and that’s when I’ll look into comma hardware.
- pkaeding 10mo agoMaybe this doesn't beep at you if you take your hands off the wheel? And people think that is a good thing?
- sieabahlpark 10mo ago[dead]
- Spikeysash 10mo agoI've been using comma 2 and now 3, for over 5 years and its my most favorite thing that I own. I would never buy an incompatible car going forward and got my tucson 2024 specifically for use with comma. I did once think I really wanted a tesla but I realized I just wanted self driving. I routinely tell everyone about comma + openpilot and am surprised I've never seen another driver on the road with one. People are still mostly in the stone age with respect to driving. Granted I think you are always solely responsible for your car when behind the wheel and should only treat it as an assistant but it sure does make driving chill.
- rvz 10mo ago8 years later, comma.ai is still standing and operational despite several VC backed competitors raising significantly more than Comma and those competitors (except for Tesla) are now no longer in business. People here have no idea they are looking at a robotics and AI company which that is Comma.ai
- tootie 10mo agoThis runs with just a single front-facing camera?
- SirMaster 10mo ago3 cameras. Front facing 180 degree, and front facing telephoto. Rear facing 180 for driver attention monitoring.
- plun9 10mo agoLooks like there are 3 cameras on the Comma 4. There's a narrow FoV camera facing forward for distant objects.
- rootusrootus 10mo agoDepends on the car what it has access to. It may leverage radar data, for example. Some cars (Ford Lightning for example) it only does lateral (steering) control, longitudinal control is still under the control of the OEM adaptive cruise.
- tokyobreakfast 10mo agoI read at least one thread per day criticizing Tesla self-driving (which has hundreds of highly-paid engineers working on it) as unreliable vaporware, meanwhile I'm supposed to hack my car with some code off a GitHub repo? I'll be adding this to my list of 101 creative ways to die, behind basement apartment in Venice, Italy.
- bad_haircut72 10mo agoNobody is making you do this, they're not even charging you for it. Comparing to a company worth billions is disingenious.
- tokyobreakfast 10mo agoThose companies worth billions like GM and Tesla perform extensive testing to prove to regulators their software isn't going to kill people and does not pose an unacceptable risk to other drivers on the road. Do you get to sidestep all that if you post your code to GitHub?
- october8140 10mo agoImagine if they all worked together on an open source project together.
- rogerrogerr 10mo agoI’m imagining it… marathon meetings, everyone worried about code standards, someone made Claude rewrite the whole thing in Prologue and is zealously arguing for it in a 900-comment PR. And somehow half the time invested in the project is arguing about a code of conduct.
- geaibleu 10mo agoThere have been dozens of fatalities due to Tesla self driving tech. As far as I know there haven't been any fatalities due to Comma tech.
- bhadass 10mo agothere is also sunnypilot, which is a fork of openpilot, and supports more behaviors and cars: https://github.com/sunnypilot/sunnypilot https://github.com/sunnypilot/sunnypilot
- _blk 10mo agoWhat's different? From the README I only get that it's trying to match comma's safety as closely as possible - whatever that means
- SirMaster 10mo agoAbility to decouple gas/brake control from steering, so you can control gas/brake yourself and let comma steer at all times. With OpenPilot, when you touch the gas/brake, the steering also stops. Ability for the comma to read your car's blind spot monitors and automatically change lanes without you having to nudge the wheel. Ability to use dynamic mode which dynamically switches between chill mode and experimental mode, so you get the best of both worlds. Ability to fine tune many settings related to gas/brake and steering sensitivity and control that you can't play with in OpenPilot. That's the main differences i'm aware of, but there are more.
- srameshc 10mo agoCan someone with technical knowledge explain the key differences between the assisted driving technologies used by Waymo, Tesla, and comma.ai?
- ranon 10mo agoWaymo put a ton of sensors, including lidar and cameras, to create a truly driverless experience. Tesla put a ton of cameras to make a mostly driverless experience (but when you need a driver you NEED a driver). Comma strapped a cellphone cam to the windshield to make a semi driverless experience on straightish roads, and a driver must take over when anything complex happens. Source: very happy comma.ai user for many years now
- ActorNightly 10mo agoWaymo basically prioritizes accuracy of surroundings. This is why they started to operate only in certain areas after mappings have been completed. Then within those surroundings they do a mix of things including ML reinforcement learning for behavior as well as optimizations in terms of route planning. Tesla on the other hand basically went on Musk infinite wisdom and said "humans only need eyes to drive, so we are going to do cameras only". Their methodology is essentially end to end - i.e take a sequence of frames, and train a model to predict where the car is going to go based on human driving data. Comma Ai basically followed Tesla, except they did so with a much more hacked together approach. Their final product is good, but there is a reason Waymo is winning. Geohot, holding the title for being #1 simp for Musk, of course subscribed to that philosophy.
- LoganDark 10mo agoHuh, no love for the Toyota bZ / Subaru Solterra. I wonder if there's a reason or if just nobody's gotten to it yet. (It does have good built-in ACC.)
- rootusrootus 10mo agoSome cars it does not support because nobody has been interested in testing it out. Some cars will never be supported because they are using an encrypted CANBUS. The list of cars on that list goes up every year. Eventually no current models will be supportable.
- dymk 10mo agoThey’re adding new models all the time
- hashmush 10mo agoThat's covered by: > Some cars it does not support because nobody has been interested in testing it out. The issue is that the percentage of new cars that could be supported drops as more and more starts encrypting the CAN bus.
- grepfru_it 10mo agoNew Toyotas are encrypted and will likely not be supported.
- LoganDark 10mo ago2025 bZ4X is just the 2022 with some tweaks. Definitely does not have encrypted CAN bus. Maybe the 2026 bZ has it encrypted.
- rootusrootus 10mo ago2023+ bZ4x has an enhanced version of TSK (security/encryption) and is not supported as a result.
- t1234s 10mo agoOEMs would be smart to donate money to this
- positron26 10mo agoAnyone who hates driving, being stuck in traffic, anyone who benefits when the cost of transportation is cheaper, anyone who hates insurance, all of society benefits. In some parallel universe self driving and fusion are both crash projects receiving well administered social scale funding. Lots of things are. It is somewhat miraculous that we don't all live in this conclusion, realizing these huge value creation opportunities by investing aggressively in the upstream tech. There is a horse I would very much like to drown for only a few million USD.
- zoeysmithe 10mo agoNone of that is solved by automated driving. You want public trains, BRT bus systems, trams, etc. The ideal universe is you stepping on public trans, not piloting various rube goldberg-esque machines that are far more dangerous and will always contribute to traffic and "one more lane" does not work.
- fc417fc802 10mo agoSure, public transit can be nice. But so is owning my own vehicle that isn't subject to routes, schedules, and minimal luggage constraints. I'd much rather hang out and read a book or play a video game than babysit a vehicle in stop and go traffic for half an hour. Even if traffic is moving at a decent clip I'd still rather do something else.
- mlrtime 10mo agoCool, in this universe I have a train stop in my front yard?
- fatata123 10mo ago[dead]
- neilv 10mo agoWill this be deployed mostly by those with the worst judgment? For example, that video is implied to be of some open source self-driving project, run on an active public road, at 42mph. A lot of sensible people would say that's irresponsible or unsafe, and not do it. Move-fast-and-break-things bros and narcissists, however, wouldn't see a problem.
- ripped_britches 10mo agoI'm sure the technology is great, but what would be really great for me to use theoretically use it would be for it to be if the company was liable if it caused an at-fault accident. I don't know much about the law around this, but I comfortably get in a Waymo all the time because I have some intuition about it that tells me that their lawyers are scared shitless of killing someone. It's a hard sell for me when it says "self-install at your own risk" but I appreciate the effort.
- knowitnone3 10mo ago[flagged]
- ddalex 10mo ago> anyone stupid enough to install and use this on the road I can't believe that people are willing to put their lives in the hands of a DIY solution with no convincing acceptance tests.
- tomhow 10mo agoPlease don't fulminate on HN. The guidelines make it clear we're trying for something better here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- justapassenger 10mo agoIt’s NOT self driving. It’s level 2 driving assist. Really good one, but that has nothing to do with self driving. You are driving the car all the time, it’s only assist that can (and will) try to kill you (and others) with 0 notice if you don’t pay attention.
- ddalex 10mo ago> Really good one ... that can (and will) try to kill you (and others) ... I'm afraid to ask about the bad ones.
- justapassenger 10mo agoIronically - bad ones will effectively try to kill you less. That’s the thing about any automations that are just aides. Humans are extremely bad at monitoring machines, and if aide system is good enough that trick you into thinking it’s actually stand alone and in control, you get complacent very fast, stop pay attention as you convince yourself that automation got it. So bad level 2 driver assists are so bad, that no one will get complacent, as they give you only very minor help. Really good ones (like comma) can trick you into thinking that they can do much more than they’re designed to do.
- SirMaster 10mo agoEveryone that I have heard from who uses one say that it reduces the monotonous mental load and frees up their brain to focus more on being aware of other drivers and what's happening on the road, rather than worrying about their speed and exact steering. People report being more alert and more aware of things about to go wrong.
- thunfischtoast 10mo agoI've made a similar experience. Not having to focus on my exact speed all the time (using adaptive cruise control) enables me to watch the mirrors more. It also enables me to keep my attention over multiple hours. On a kinda unrelated note: I lately see more and more people watching streams or Tik Tok while driving. If of course you use your newly acquired freedom for that it will lead to more accidents.
- brownpoints 10mo agoThis looks neat, does it require anything specific to work? What if certain sensors are not available in some geographies. Probably a dumb question
- SirMaster 10mo agoNo it doesn't need any sensors. Just needs your car to be on the compatible list. It plugs in-line with the plug behind your rear view mirror and you pick the vehicle model to receive the correct adapter plug with your unit.
- grepfru_it 10mo agoDepends on the car. Some require to intercept at the canbus gateway. I could recommend an installer
- nubg 10mo agoHow does it steer the wheel) Is there like an "API standard" for sending steering direction to cars via some physical port?
- johschmitz 10mo agoThe control messages are transmitted via CAN bus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CAN_bus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CAN_bus The exact message content and protocols are reverse engineered. Some cars use FlexRay instead of CAN bus but that has only experimental support.
- grepfru_it 10mo agoFlexray is supported only on Audi on a specific Flexray-canbus integration board that was just end of lifed and Comma has no desire to support other boards. It was a proof of concept for anyone wishing to implement the same
- ActorNightly 10mo agoIt requires a car with lane centering capabilities -i.e a module that commands the steering angle through canbus. Thats why not all cars are supported.
- georgehotz 10mo agoYea most modern cars have a Python API. https://github.com/commaai/opendbc https://github.com/commaai/opendbc
- micw 10mo agoCan this be legally used in Europe, especially in Germany (i.e. is is allowed by the German traffic laws "Straßenverkehrsordnung")?
- whazor 10mo agoI think as a company you could do: https://single-market-economy.ec.europa.eu/sectors/automotive-industry/technical-harmonisation/technical-harmonisation-eu_en https://single-market-economy.ec.europa.eu/sectors/automotiv... But you would probably need to sell a car together with Comma integrated. And also test every update as well.
- croisillon 10mo agopretty sure you can buy it, but i hope you can't use it
- rovr138 10mo agoUnless something’s changed. It can’t even be used legally in the US. They sell the device without firmware and you have to acquire and install it yourself to bypass government regulations. Or something like that.
- spacecadet 10mo agoSelf driving cars are for scum.
- LorenDB 10mo agoI got my Comma 4 a week and a half ago and absolutely love the thing. Is it perfect? No. But I can install a fork (Sunnypilot) and tweak the settings and/or code until I get something that I like.
- wffurr 10mo agoWhen Consumer Reports tested ADAS systems in 2020 [1], they gave their highest rating to the Comma Two. I'm sure it's only gotten better since then. I really like my 2017 Chevy Bolt except that it doesn't have ACC. I wish I was comfortable installing a Comma on it, but it requires a gas pedal interceptor [2], and I'm not willing to do that to a car that I transport my family in. [1]: https://data.consumerreports.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/consumer-reports-active-driving-assistance-systems-november-16-2020.pdf https://data.consumerreports.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/... [2]: https://github.com/commaai/openpilot/wiki/comma-pedal https://github.com/commaai/openpilot/wiki/comma-pedal
- buildbot 10mo agoFYI if I get hit by someone and I find out they are using comma, everyone’s is getting a lawsuit. Is there a hard safety check for an insane steering angle? Full brake or throttle? ECC error? What happens!? That’s what a safety standard checks and certifies for. Incredibly dangerous, irresponsible, and illegal to be using this around other people. At least Tesla vaguely pretends to work with regulators. The cute download your own firmware so they aren’t shipping an illegal device? Encouraging hands off, inattentive driving? Let’s see how civil court sees that.
- geaibleu 10mo agoYou aren't going to like answer but yes, there are firmware safety checks + CAN checksums. And driver facing camera tracking your attention so you aren't asleep behind the wheel. Something that your Tesla apparently failed to consider https://driving.ca/auto-news/crashes/sleeping-tesla-driver-reportedly-pulled-over-by-german-police https://driving.ca/auto-news/crashes/sleeping-tesla-driver-r... Your attitude reminds me of how Microsoft fans talked down Linux and GNU; blah blah open source can never be as good/secure/stable as our billion-dollar commercial product because money/certificate
- buildbot 10mo agoOkay, is every change validated by a safety agency? No. I asked a lawyer this question and the answer was “on every level yes you could sue them”. Edit - Further back and forth and depending on the circumstances, comma could be criminally liable. I don’t have a tesla or a car.
- geaibleu 10mo agoYou have an auto industry lawyer on retainer to ask hypotheticals on Sunday evening? First answer your own question (and ask lawyer while you at it), is every changed pushed by Tesla reviewed by EU/CA/US regulators? And then explain to me how your Tesla still allowed driver to fall asleep. FYI that was not a singular accident.
- buildbot 10mo agoAnyone using this in Washington is breaking the law, IMO - https://dol.wa.gov/vehicles-and-boats/vehicles/vehicle-registration/register-other-vehicles-and-other-services/registering-autonomous-vehicles https://dol.wa.gov/vehicles-and-boats/vehicles/vehicle-regis...
- SirMaster 10mo agoI don’t see anything there that would suggest a comma unit breaks the law. First off comma isn’t even autonomous, it’s a L2 driver assistance system.