8 ms·
Amazon founder Jeff Bezos calls for governments to end patent wars
- DannyBee 14y agoThey should just retitle this article "Jeff Bezos finally realizes he's next"
- suresk 14y agoThis rings about as hollow as if it were Tim Cook complaining about closed ecosystems. Bezos likely realizes that as Amazon moves into making and selling mobile devices and tablets, they too will be targets for patent litigation.
- mtgx 14y agoDoes it matter who's the messenger if the message rings true? I think it makes sense for victims or potential victims of the broken patent system to complain about it and fight to change or eliminate it. Who else is going to do it otherwise? The patent aggressors like Apple and Microsoft? I just don't see that happening.
- evgen 14y agoWhat matters is that when the messenger is so obviously self-serving and hypocritical it dilutes the message and leads a casual observer to look for the hidden agenda for others who carry the same message. Now that Amazon has used the patent system as a cudgel to achieve a stable position in the market it fears having other companies do to it what it once did to them, Now that Google has used its patents to achieve a solid lock on the search and search advertising market the benefits of strong patents seem less compelling to the founders & board members of that company. If you want credibility then talk about patent reform on the way up, not once you have reached the top and no longer need them to maintain your dominance.
- smokeyj 14y agoWhich patent did amazon need to "maintain their dominance"? Did they patent customer service?
- GFischer 14y agoThey used the One-Click patent against their then biggest rival Barnes & Noble http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1-Click http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1-Click Several organizations have boycotted Amazon for that: http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/amazon.html http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/amazon.html
- smokeyj 14y agoThats pretty low, but only reinforces the notions that IP is bad for consumers.
- Shamanmuni 14y ago1-Click purchases, which is close in ridiculousness. Buying stuff online clicking once was such an outstanding innovation that it surely deserved protection from all those thieves who never could have figured that out by themselves...
- drucken 14y agoSo, if Apple, Google, Microsoft, IBM and all of the other or some subset of the large software companies came out today to say the same thing or completely endorse Amazon CEO's point of view, you would dismiss their message just as equally for who they are and their history?...
- masklinn 14y agolikely not, because they are already in "the battle" and have been on both ends of the barrel, they're not on the outside looking in and considering that they'd prefer not eating a broadside.
- majorlazer 14y ago
- troels 14y agoExactly. Of course Amazon have software patents currently - if they didn't, they'd be easy targets for those who did. I applaud that someone like him stands up to point out the absurdity of the situation.
- suresk 14y agoYes, it does. The message from Bezos, who has a history of abusing the patent system to harm competition, comes off as self-serving and hypocritical, which makes it easier for opponents of patent reform to write it off.
- smokeyj 14y agoSure he's a hypocrite. What does that mean, we should keep patents around? So that.. everybody can abuse patents?
- bediger4000 14y agoOpponents of patent reform will write off Bezos' message no matter what. That's the nature of "intellectual property" maximalism at the moment. The oppoents of patent reform have some "common sense" style platitudes in favor of patents as they stand, and for stricter enforcement. But no facts - the arguments always boil down to "but Private Property!" or something similar.
- rayiner 14y agoThere will be no patent reform as long as the tiny niche of web software people claim that everyone who doesn't oppose the existing system is in favor of "IP maximalism." Patent reform is going to require web software people convincing the electrical engineers why software patents have a very different effect in their space than say the patents on OFDM, and they're not going to do it by being arrogant and dismissive. The rest of the engineering community by and large doesn't understand what software folks are ranting about. People don't accidentally infringe on the OFDM patent, people don't accidentally come up with the same chemical formula for a drug. To them, people who oppose patents are in the same bucket as Chinese companies who rip off American technology--they want to copy other peoples' work for profit. This is not to say that patent reform in the area of software isn't beneficial or desirable. But the attitude that anybody who opposes it won't listen to reason dramatically overstates the universality of the arguments and the consensus around the position.
- rayiner 14y agoThere is no consensus that the patent system is broken. Amazon's self serving position doesn't help build that consensus.
- zmmmmm 14y ago> Does it matter who's the messenger if the message rings true? But the message doesn't ring true if the messenger's actions contradict the message. If I come to you and yell "the building is burning down!!!" and then sit quietly at my desk to continue coding, do you seriously tell me that my actions do not affect how you interpret my message? Bezos could announce he is relinquishing and freely licensing the one-click patent today if he really believes patents hinder innovation and that is bad for society. Then his message would be consistent with his actions. If you don't like this as logic, consider it as an unavoidable fact of human psychology.
- 0wza 14y agoWell, it's better than Google. Google just jumped right into the game, though they claimed to disagree with it. Bezos has the cash to play the game. And he had acces to it early enough (remember the one-click patent) to gain a monumental advantage. Relative to the other big players, Amazon has stayed on the sidelines. Not to say Amazon is an angel that sets the standard for fairplay, but they definitely (? prove me wrong!) do not pursue patents to the extent of Microsoft, Apple, Google and others. You can either call them naive for not playing, or you can accept that they may have set a better example.
- suresk 14y agoPursuing patents is one thing, utilizing them offensively against a competitor is another. Amazon used their one-click patent to harm competitors, but I've seen no evidence of Google utilizing patents against companies who haven't first filed patent litigation against them. I don't think Amazon has set the better example.
- jivatmanx 14y agoExactly, patents are like nukes. I can understand why few countries choose not to unilaterally disarm. But to use a nuke offensively is unthinkable. Yet that's exactly what apple has done, and now patent litigation is consuming the entire tech industry.
- hef19898 14y agoInteresting to see how long a bad reputation can stick to someone. So Amazon used some ridiculous patent in the late ninties against the small start-up Barnes&Noble. It made Amazon big and maybe it wasn't right to use it against other ecommerce sites. But that was in the ninties, back than Amazon was far from being as big as they are now. They used what they had to great effect, the only effect patent battles since 201 have are huge law fees and huge costs for companies. So was Amazon right to use one-click back than? I don't know, but it served them in the long run. Does it serve Applesung if they prevent the sell of Applesung products in certain markets? I don't think so. Based on this, yes Bezos is right that the system is broken, as broken as it was back in the ninties but today the associated risks grew higher from my point of view. Why? Because patents are strategic weapon which is now used tacticly, and that is always bad.
- nostromo 14y agoAll major companies must play the patent game today. They would be insane not to. I think it's completely valid to play the game while working to change the rules for the better.
- suresk 14y agoIf Amazon were merely collecting large quantities of patents and using them against companies who instigated patent litigation against them, I wouldn't be calling Bezos a hypocrite. I understand that - not acquiring patents is almost suicidal right now. However, nobody forced him to patent something trivial (One-Click) and abuse it to gain a competitive advantage.
- Dove 14y agoAnd at the end of the battle, Slattery shook Ender’s hand and said, “I’m glad you won. If I ever beat you, Ender, I want to do it fair.” “Use what they give you,” Ender said. “If you’ve ever got an advantage over the enemy, use it.” “Oh, I did,” said Slattery. He grinned. “I’m only fair-minded before and after battles.”
- galactus 14y agoI guess Amazon is forced to do that to the extent that someone else would do it first if they don't.
- rayiner 14y agoYou're really grasping at straws here to make Amazon look good.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoNo, it's better this way. Because Amazon has plenty to lose from letting go of patents, so the message is that much stronger. Amazon is in the game, and if anything on the whole they're winning the game, and they are still saying that the game is messed up and needs to be changed. If Richard Stallman yells that the patent system is broken and needs to be changed nobody is going to listen, of course he's going to say that, he's a zealot with no skin in the game, it costs him nothing to say that.
- Klinky 14y agoI completely agree with Bezos as it's absurd that companies can patent things like rounded corners or 1-Click shopping, oh, oh wait...
- krrrh 14y agoWhat a weak article. The interviewer had Jeff Bezos complaining about patents, and never brought up one-click? He never asked about consistency of position, or if it the uncertainty of being a new entrant into an established market had given him a new perspective on the factors that encourage innovation. The paucity of actual quotes or dialogue in the piece make it seem like the full interview (linked to from the OA) was conducted by sitting behind Bezos in business class and scribbling down what was overheard.
- jrabone 14y agoIt's the Metro - it is given away free on UK public transport (at least here). Not quite a tabloid, but it's not exactly the Financial Times either.
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoHow ironic given the first ridiculous software patent I remember was Amazon's one-click purchase patent that it use as a cudgel against many e-tailers in the late nineties (and may still, for all I know). EDIT: Not saying there weren't other ridiculous software patents; just that this one got a lot of press at the time and brought software patents to developers attention in a way that hadn't happened before.
- theevocater 14y agoPeople have already been making this mistake: calling out Jeff Bezos over Amazon's one-click patent is a strawman by the name of tu quoque (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tu_quoque). This is a non-argument. Being a hypocrite doesn't make you less correct. Regardless of past transgressions, Jeff Bezos is right. Governments and their people need to examine their patent laws (I would argue all IP laws) and figure out what the right amount of protection is necessary given our modern world.
- rayiner 14y agoI hate it when people bring up the logical fallacies in incorrect contexts. The fallacies apply to purely logical arguments. They do not apply to arguments, like Bezos's, that are based on a mix of logic and credibility. The argument against software patents does not go "if A then B, if B then C, therefore if A then C." In this context, labeling someone a hypocrite is indeed not logically relevant. Instead, the argument against software patents is couched at least in part on empirical evidence: we need to reform the system because it holds back innovation, as can be seen from X, Y, and Z observations. In that context, credibility is relevant. Why should we believe you that you're accurately representing X, Y, and Z? Does self-interest color how you're characterizing the patent reform argument? All of these are relevant because it's not a purely logical argument that can be evaluated purely on its own merits.
- aristidb 14y agoYet the idea that hypocrisy is a good reason to ignore a man's arguments wholesale is broken either way. But yes, Bezos cannot be assumed to be without self-interests. Nor can the (former) patent lawyers sitting on patent courts.
- rayiner 14y agoI'm just pointing out the difference between arguments in the Platonic sense and real world arguments. Credibility is never an issue in a logical argument, but there are very few real world arguments in which credibility isn't an issue. A number of the logical fallacies, like ad hominem and tu coque go straight to credibility. That's not a reason to ignore the argument of a hypocrite. It is a reason not to ignore credibility as an important factor because of a misguided application of fallacies.
- TeMPOraL 14y agoYes, maybe Bezos is a hypocrite. His company has a history of abusing the patent system and he's now realizing that software patents are a Bad Thing because he's just about to get on the receiving side of them [0]. So what? Even if he doesn't have the moral high ground, it doesn't change that he's right. And that's a good thing; it's better to have one hypocrite in power with ability to change things for good, even if he does it for selfish reasons, than to have one hundred morally pure [1] people who don't have the power or means to do anything else than whine. Google, Amazon, and others may not be white like snow, but they would serve good as temporary allies in fixing things for everyone. </rant> (In general, I hate when people throw around the label of 'hypocrite'; quite often it's just an distracting ad hominem.) [0] - but hey, "it is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it." (Upton Sinclair) [1] - then again, how many of us are really so innocent? How many would stand to principle if offered a chance to patent some silly software "invention" and thus speed up career development?
- VMG 14y agoTo anyone curious about the actual transgression, here is the WP article: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1-Click#cite_note-16 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1-Click#cite_note-16 The FSF called for a boycott of Amazon once but then reverted its decision: http://web.archive.org/web/20081121093238/http://www.gnu.org./philosophy/amazon.html http://web.archive.org/web/20081121093238/http://www.gnu.org...
- antidoh 14y agoIf anyone has credibility here, it's Bezos (for reasons listed in other posts). Not sarcasm.
- milesli 14y agoThe government has been pretty busy with the debates, I don't think they have attention to patent wars.
- sehugg 14y agoBezos's 2000 open letter on patents: http://oreilly.com/news/amazon_patents.html http://oreilly.com/news/amazon_patents.html Good sentiment, but it's twelve years later and the only positive action we've seen from Amazon concerning patent reform is an offhand comment to a reporter. How's that prior art database coming along, for example? Forgive me for not getting too excited.
- IheartApplesDix 14y agoI wonder why he doesn't pave a way for the rest of the tech industry giants to start innovating?
- waterlesscloud 14y agoGeez guys, when someone hands you a victory, take it.
- cloverich 14y agoWhy is he a hypocrite? To exist as a tech company today, you'd be insane to NOT patent as much as possible. Seriously, if you're developing tech to compete with Apple (or any large tech co), but have no IP of your own, you're defenseless. Thats the impression I get, anyways - that you're best bet is to patent as much as possible. The more vague, the more absurd, the better. It offers more bargaining chips. Because lets face it - can a non multi-million dollar company survive a couple of lawsuits by one of the tech giants? I doubt it. Patent warfare is a systematic issue; its not unreasonable to attack the system (Gov't sponsored patents). That's what I take from this message. I'm sure there's a Game Theory term for this, but its clearly not something that can be resolved outside of the system. Anyone who stops the lawsuits (or threat of) quickly disappears.
- commandar 14y ago>To exist as a tech company today, you'd be insane to NOT patent as much as possible. Patent holders are not required to actively defend patents in order to maintain their rights to them. That's only trademarks. Amazon has a history of not just filing patents of questionable validity, they have a history of going after competitors for infringement. The most obvious example would be suing Barnes & Noble over the One-Click patent.
- adastra 14y agoI look forward to Bezos matching his words with actions. It's pretty well known that Amazon's lobbying in DC is entirely focused on preventing Amazon from having to pay state sales taxes. Bezos has never lifted a finger to help any other tech cause -- note that Bezos didn't co-sign the open letter on SOPA from tech CEO's[1], and that Amazon didn't co-sign the company letter[2], for example. If he does become active on this, that's great. But given his history I'd be shocked if he put real resources behind it. And until he does it will just be empty words. [1] http://venturebeat.com/2011/12/14/tech-execs-anti-sopa-letter/ http://venturebeat.com/2011/12/14/tech-execs-anti-sopa-lette... [2] http://www.protectinnovation.com/downloads/letter.pdf http://www.protectinnovation.com/downloads/letter.pdf
- johnrgrace 14y agoActually, I think Amazon has switched gears and now is for Sales tax everywhere because they can deal with it better than most other players.
- conanite 14y agoThe article ends with Mr Bezos would not be drawn on whether Amazon plans to release a smartphone of its own. Amazon's plans in the smartphone market may be influencing Jeff's argument.
- merwill 14y agoI think more important than the level of protection at this point is public knowledge and awareness of just what patents are out there. One project that might galvanize federal action just launched and is seeking crowdfunding to shed light in this arena. Specifically, IP Checkups aims to map out the patents and shell companies of Intellectual Ventures, and potentially other mass aggregators, to foster public knowledge and the original purposes of the patent system. For more information, see: news.cnet.com/8301-13578_3-57532492-38/patent-activists-lets-light-up-intellectual-ventures-ip-portfolio/
- OldSchool 14y agoI think we all would love to see an end to patent threats in software not so much for the sake of the big players but for the sake of small businesses attempting to bring a product to life. If it took Amazon to make it happen then great. Heck, if Steve Ballmer brought an end to software patents I'd be thrilled. Whatever ill will Amazon created amongst the technorati more than a decade ago pales now in comparison to Ballmer's inept continuation of Microsoft and the post-iPhone Apple walled garden and patent actions. Less obvious but significant are the erosions to privacy brought on with the help of Google. I vote Jeff Bezos "least evil" at this moment. Someone I know even said he was a "nice guy." Small sample, yes. I'm not particularly hopeful that we'll see meaningful legal reform in software patents. There is too much money to be made by lawyers in filing and litigation. Their brethren in government making the laws are't going to one day just shut down this little parasitic industry that feeds many of their friends and likely contributors. Until then, where's the most troll-free place from which to conduct a software business? Black and white immunity is not necessary, just a not-worth-the-effort situation for trolls??
- stcredzero 14y agoSort of like 1973, when the largest stockpilers of nuclear weapons started to talk about limiting them. The weapons holder is in a unique position to know how bad the use of weapons can be.
- WalterBright 14y agoRealistically, the only way the patent wars can end is if Amazon, Google, Apple and Microsoft all get behind ending it.
- tsycho 14y agoBut not necessarily in the right way. They can also _agree_ to not sue each other, (or more legally, cross-license each other for free), and the patent wars will end. The small startup will continue to get screwed regardless.
- CrankyBear 14y agoI'd respect this more if he hadn't patented 1-click shopping. Oh yeah, that was innovative. Now that he has "his," he wants to change the rules. Love your company Jeff, hate your IP policy and not impressed by your flip-flopping.
- duxup 14y agoIt doesn't say exactly what change he wants. The devil is in the details.
- lh7777 14y ago"Jeff Bezos calls for governments to end patent wars" seems a bit dramatic when you consider his actual statements. From the article, he actually said (emphasis mine): "...we're _starting_ to be in a world where [patents] might start to stifle innovation...Governments _may_ need to look at the patent system and _see_ if those laws need to be modified..." If he truly believes that the patent system needs to change (and I really think he does), couldn't he have left those qualifiers out? As it is these just seem like timid observations, far from a call for governments to step in and do something.
- chj 14y agoHe had very good reasons, Amazon is going to sell a lot of kindle fire and people are going to come after them.