7 ms·
My son's flashcard routine
- Sukotto 14y agoI use Anki[1] with my kids (grades 1 and 3) for spelling, reading, and math. It works really well, was relatively easy to set up (import csv files), and keeps track of the spacing for me so I never have to worry about unconsciously filtering the hardest cards to the bottom. Even better, Anki v2.0 just came out with the ability to have multiple profiles. (No more including the child's name in the deck's name... yay) The downsides are: The documentation is lacking in all but the most basic uses; The help forums are difficult to find [2]; You are tied to your computer (or smartphone). [1] http://ankisrs.net/ http://ankisrs.net/ [2] https://groups.google.com/forum/?fromgroups#!forum/ankisrs https://groups.google.com/forum/?fromgroups#!forum/ankisrs
- peteretep 14y agoI was unsure why the original poster had developer his own system instead of just using Anki...
- btilly 14y agoThat is addressed in paragraph 2. At the start I needed to address problems with handwriting, which meant that the evaluation of whether he has done the flashcard correctly has to be done by me. Having flashcards on a computer, and then a manual evaluation, seemed like counterproductive complexity. I did not want a computer between me and my son for this activity. But it turns out to be a good thing. Because the fact that I have been involved has let me track down issues, such as the need for a reward activity. Anki currently does not offer that as a feature. However in a year or so I do want to move my son to something like Anki.
- peteretep 14y agoFWIW: I used Anki for learning a foreign language, with the help of a human, who would ask one side, and then rate my answer. This worked pretty well, in fact, and allowed the devolvement to Anki of spacing and scheduling, with the benefits you've mentioned.
- verisimilitude 14y agoI used Anki _extensively_ when I was in dental school--I think I had something like 10000 cards at the end of school. You can seriously pack knowledge into your head with spaced repetition. Anyhow, Anki is AMAZING. The best thing it does is eliminate your downtime when you're studying. If you critically look at your periods where you sit down and do work, there's a fair amount of "staring out the window" time when you are not in [flow][0]. However, because of the timer system, I felt compelled to continue through flashcards throughout my 15 or 20 minute study periods. It feels great not to waste time. I should go donate to that project. [0]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_(psychology) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flow_(psychology)
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Scaevolus 14y agoStoring Anki decks in Dropbox helps make it more portable. There's also an online sync service you can use.
- kellishaver 14y agoFlashcards didn't work for my daughter at all. She just can't learn that way. What we did for spelling and math facts was just to have her write each word/fact in the list X number of times (usually 5) and then we would quiz her on them. If she got them right, she was done. If she missed any, she would do them another X times. The rest of the week, we would quiz her each day before she started and she would only have to write the ones she got wrong. Usually she had everything down by Tuesday or Wednesday and her motivation was the progressively smaller amount of time she had to spend studying instead of playing.
- jerf 14y agoDid you something like what is described in the post, or did you just do "the usual" with flashcards? (I have to admit I'm not confident you read the linked post before commenting based on the word "flashcard".)
- kellishaver 14y agoWhat we tried was a system very similar to what was described in the post that yes, I did in fact read.
- jerf 14y agoIt seems to me that at grade two, by the time you had as much experience as you describe in this post you ought to be blowing the doors off what is actually expected for a grade 2 student in school already, so I was surprised when the teacher suggested other things to be doing. Is he getting ahead now, or just catching up?
- btilly 14y agoOn the material that I've been covering, he is blowing the doors off of what is expected. But that only applies to what I've been covering. For instance the word "because" has not appeared on his spelling tests since I began, so is not in the flashcard set. It turns out that he consistently misspells it and so there is some unlearning to do there. That is issue #2 in the list at the bottom.
- jerf 14y agoYes, it wasn't entirely clear to me what the ratio was, but I think I get it now.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Evbn 14y agoWith no disrespect to the great man, just think "Em, jeff Barr is an Ass." when you want to get embarrassed. Have you tried breaking down words logically by linguistic origin to supplement rote memorization drills?
- btilly 14y agoThe only two mnemonics that I've taught him are, There are two too many ways to spell 'tu' and I before e except after c, or when says "a" as in neighbor and weigh. I know that lots of people use mnemonics, but I've personally tended to find them more trouble than they are worth. Until this week we hadn't encountered any facts that were sufficiently hard that he had to break them down to successfully master them. It is clear that he uses tricks acquired from one card to do another card. But I've not had to tell him how to do that. I should note that drills usually involve under 10 cards. We're not talking about endless work. (In fact most of the work is reading to him. Which stretches his vocabulary, and is also a learning exercise, but I won't tell him that if you don't tell him that.)
- DanBC 14y agoThe i before e rule isn't much use. There are so many words that don't fit, and so the rule gets expanded. I before E. I before E, except after C. I before E, except after C or when the sound is "a" as in neighbor and weigh. It's a weird rule. Off the top of my head: seize, eider, science, frequencies, vacancies, fallacies, either, feisty, society. Etc etc.
- gjm11 14y agoThe form of the rule that I was told in school is: I before E, except after C, when the sound is "ee". This (1) is pretty simple, (2) has rather few exceptions, and (3) does correctly give the spelling of lots of words that some people would otherwise find tricky. Note that "except after C" means "ignore the rule in this case" rather than "reverse the rule in this case". That is, it doesn't mean "E before I, after C". Of the 9 words on your list: 5 (science, frequencies, vacancies, fallacies, society) are "after C" and therefore not covered by the rule; 2 (eider, feisty) are never pronounced with an "ee" sound and therefore not covered by the rule; 1 (either) is sometimes pronounced that way and sometimes not and therefore a kinda-half-exception; 1 (seize) is a definite genuine exception. There are a few other exceptions, but the rule in this form correctly fixes the spelling of a whole lot of common words (a few examples: piece, frieze, grief, believe, retrieve) that would be easy to get wrong without it.
- LinaLauneBaer 14y agoI have developed a flashcards app for both iOS ( http://christian-kienle.de/Flashcards-Pro/ http://christian-kienle.de/Flashcards-Pro/ ) and OS X ( http://christian-kienle.de/Flashcards http://christian-kienle.de/Flashcards ). For the development of these apps I tried several different learning systems and interviewed friends who are learning with flashcards how they do it. I found out that everyone learns a little bit differently so it was hard to find one system that everyone could work with. So I decided to make the system pretty flexible by introducing smart decks - something like smart playlists but for decks of cards. The drill mode described in the blog post cannot be emulated in a nice way by my apps. I may adopt it because it seems really good to get the information in your short term memory which is the first step. Thanks for sharing your experience.
- joezydeco 14y agoThe Pimsleur language instruction CDs use a similar method of spaced repetition. At least for me, it was incredibly effective.
- rweba 14y agoWhat language(s) did you learn, how long have you been learning (them) and what level of fluency have you reached? I have been using the Pimsleur Spanish CDs for almost 6 months. I have made a lot of progress (especially with vocabulary) but am still at a beginner level (high beginner though, almost low intermediate).
- joezydeco 14y agoI finished German 1 a few years ago. I have 2/3 but haven't had time to work on them. #1 taught me so much so quickly that it was enough to get me through a couple of trips.
- clueless123 14y agoI learned basic Mandarin Chinese by using those CD's (Pimsleur) on the way to work and back for a whole year. I am still amazed of how "organic" was the learning.. I mean, after some time I just started "understanding" more advanced conversations to the point that even my chinese friends got startled. Also, I have not used the CD's for over 3 years (or spend time in china) and I still recall most of what I learned.
- joezydeco 14y agoI think that's what stunned me the most about this type of learning is how deep the knowledge gets burned into your brain. It's not like cramming for an exam or reading the language dictionary on the flight over.
- clueless123 14y agoThe basic idea is to keep the knowledge "in" the different memory spaces (short,medium,permanent) for it to get moved up to the next memory space, until it becomes "permanent".
- jedberg 14y agoWhen I was kid, my flashcard routine was this: Show the card. If it is right it goes to the done pile, if it is wrong, it goes to the back of the current pile. Repeat until there is nothing left in the current pile. Then do the same thing the next day. We did this until I could get through the entire pile in one try. This method seems overly complicated for both child and parent.
- verisimilitude 14y agoIt's just more efficient & really shines for long term retention + large datasets (i.e. learning nouns in languages).
- btilly 14y agoI did something similar to that as a kid. I hated it. It worked, but much less efficiently. The strategy that you describe causes you to spend most of your time looking at cards that you've already mastered. You don't have the ability to slowly add to the list. You don't have the ability to have as many flashcards. And, according to the research, long-term retention is worse. He currently has 465 cards that he's shown some retention on. Of those, tonight he will do 14. Your system would have him spending 33x as much effort maintaining that knowledge as what we're currently doing. A factor of 33 is worth some bookkeeping on my part.
- jedberg 14y ago> Your system would have him spending 33x as much effort maintaining that knowledge as what we're currently doing. A factor of 33 is worth some bookkeeping on my part. I will grant you that. We only used this strategy for the times tables up to 12x12, which has a finite set of cards (144 if I remember my facts correctly :) ). If I wanted to do an ever growing set, I might consider this method. > And, according to the research, long-term retention is worse. Can you point me at some good research on this area? I believe you, I'd just like to read more, as someone who is interested in this sort of thing.
- btilly 14y ago
- revelation 14y agoWhen I was a kid.. I was outside playing. Seriously. And then when I got older and could read, I was often reading books. And I think the knowledge and information you can glean from just reading books is enormous. Language isn't about spelling stuff right [1]. It's about having a comfortably large set of words at your disposal and knowing what words can go together to express feelings, atmosphere or intent. [1]: the fascination with spelling seems to know no end in the USA. Spelling competitions?!
- frossie 14y agothe fascination with spelling seems to know no end in the USA It's not unique to the USA - the French could tell you a thing or two about the Championnats d'Orthographe.... I agree with your point though. There is a telling moment in the OP, where it says that the son's reward for working the flashcards is the parent reading him books beyond his reading level. What is the point of spelling words ahead of your reading level? Spelling prowess comes from repeated exposure to written words[1]. It's called "reading" and I can't see any reason (aside from stupid standardised testing) that a kid's spelling ability needs to be ahead of their reading level. [1] This is if why you are a perl programmer the word "pearl" starts looking wrong. Edit, due to comments below: The question is why are teachers asking for words to be spelled essentially out of context. I just can't think of a good reason because the only way you can learn them is by flashcard games, and like the comment above, I just can't see how it is a good use of a kid's time. I certainly do not blame the parent for making sure their kid does well at school, I just don't see the sense of school being this way. Take the word, oh I don't know. Serialization. Or hypervisor. Or encryption. Most people here can spell them (I assume!) even though you were never required to learn to do so at school - you have learned by sheer exposure. You also know that the opposite of encryption is not unencryption, but decryption, and a decrypted message is not the same as an unencrypted message. Now of course there are linguistic reasons for all this, but the point is that you know these things because you encountered these words in context. A kid that reads a Star-Trek tie-in is sure to be able to spell "teleportation". Yes, you can also teach a kid to spell that out of context with a flash card. But why? I just don't get it. [Disclosure: frustrated non-native English speaker who had to teach a first grader to spell "reduce, reuse, recycle" this week, gaaaaah].
- yakiv 14y agoWould it make more sense to say that his son is ahead in letter reversals?
- druiid 14y agoThis made me think back to Wordsmith (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wordsmith_%28TV_series%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wordsmith_%28TV_series%29). It was the show that got me from a young age thinking about how you break up and form words, etc. To this day in my head from time to time I'll often play over words, breaking them up and similar (as though getting a 'taste' for the word). I wonder if perhaps this show might be of benefit as well to the son of the submitter.
- tokenadult 14y agoBen, I didn't realize you had a child of just that age. Please allow me to recommend to you and to other HN participants who surf by who are parents of children learning to read the best--bar none--approach to initial reading instruction in English for native speakers of English. It has worked for all four of my children, including the three who spent significant parts of their childhood in a mostly Chinese-speaking environment (reducing their exposure to English speech and English printed materials). The book Let's Read, a Linguistic Approach http://wsupress.wayne.edu/slp/bloomfieldlr.htm http://wsupress.wayne.edu/slp/bloomfieldlr.htm http://www.amazon.com/Lets-Read-A-Linguistic-Approach/dp/0814334555 http://www.amazon.com/Lets-Read-A-Linguistic-Approach/dp/081... by Leonard Bloomfield (an eminent linguist and pioneer of new methods of teaching hard-to-learn languages) and Clarence L. Barnhart (a lexicographer) has now been revised by Cynthia A. Barnhart and Robert K. Barnhart (I presume they are the original co-author's children). I used the first edition, and can recommend it UNRESERVEDLY. The first edition appears to no longer be in print, and some Amazon reviewers say they prefer the first edition, but the second edition, currently available, surely is better than the great mass of school materials used for English reading instruction. How I used the book is to set a goal of somewhere between one lesson a day and six or seven pages a day, and then read each lesson out loud to my child, with my child then reading the lesson back to me, with adaptation earlier in the book to do the reading and reading back a sentence at a time, and near the end of the book for the child to read by himself or herself without me reading first. All my children are strong readers who love to read. You'll find that this book, under Bloomfield's pedagogical influence, makes good use of spaced repetition of the key sound-symbol correspondences in Engish. But this is reading connected text, rather than just looking at flash cards, and the stories are remarkably interesting for their carefully graded vocabulary. More details if you like. My main online involvement in the early 1990s was discussion of optimal reading instruction approaches for United States schools, but now I've discovered that mathematics education needs at least as much help, and have shifted focus to that. But I could provide (old) links to rationale for this approach if you like, and anyway an ounce of inexpensive prevention is worth a pound of expensive cure when helping a child's initial reading instruction prevents future reading and spelling difficulties. And kudos to you for continuing to read aloud to your child as he learns to read. Not reading to children beyond school age is one of the big missed opportunities in many middle-class families. Aside to other participants: I'm wondering how many people who have used flash cards for foreign language learning have put their languages to the test in a country where those languages are spoken. I have studied many languages (I think there is a partial list in my user profile), and what I have observed over and over is how each language maps reality in a different way, so that ones rarely correspond one-to-one in the manner expected by flashcards. I much preferred learning to read Chinese, for example, by using the excellent Chinese Reader series by John DeFrancis http://www.amazon.com/Beginning-Chinese-Reader-Part/dp/0300020600/ http://www.amazon.com/Beginning-Chinese-Reader-Part/dp/03000... through which I first learned about Bloomfield's approach to foreign language teaching. (DeFrancis was a student of Bloomfield's.)
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pixelcort 14y agoThe startup I'm working on is a flashcard mobile webapp that uses spaced repetition, but also uses multiple choice quizzes for new cards that get harder each time a card is shown again. This lets students transition from answer recognition to answer recollection without that anxious feeling that comes from trying to recall recently learned cards. It was designed for adults learning vocabulary for second languages or professional certifications, but lately we've been trying to see what kinds of features we could add to make it more useful for kids as well. The recognize-to-recall transition could really be useful for students who otherwise would be overwhelmed from the anxious feelings of recalling recently new cards. One feature we're looking at is the use of mini games and tiny (10-15 second) video clips to make the app more fun and help space out new cards a bit more. If anyone has a child who could benefit from reduced-anxiety learning, I'd love to chat with you and get your thoughts. Check out my HN profile for my contact info and more about the webapp.
- rubberbandage 14y agoEnglish word construction seems like anarchy, but there really are rules—they’re just rules for all the different languages that english draws from, respective to each word. I learned to recognize the origin of words (from Greek, Latin, German, French, etc.) pretty early on, and it drastically cleared up the seeming chaos of how a word was spelled. Is your son getting any context behind the words? Otherwise I could see these exercises being as frustrating as trying to learn a modern symphony by ear with no knowledge of music.
- siscia 14y agoI used to have the same problem... I was young, about 5th grade and all my essay where horrible full of grammar error and I always got very bad grades on those. Then I move in the Junior High / Middle school and I was still doing very bad error, but the content of my essays was great so I was able to get about 60-70% on my test even if, again, the content was above the average. It was bad especially in Italian (my first language), where how you say a word is exactly the same way in which you spell it, we don't even have idea of what a spelling competition is, it just doesn't make sense. Then I move to high school, in my first essay I didn't do any single grammar error, it was great, no error at all. I probably do have some problem especially with pronunciation, my parents used to bring me to some kind of doctor who I remember I hated, in my mind words were (and are) fine, but they just come out wrong out of my mouth, I ramble a lot. Some people say that my mind just work faster than my mouth so I can't keep up with words and some of them come out wrong, obviously I can simply talk right if I put a little of effort on it, but sometimes especially when I am talking just because and other person are not suppose to care of what I am saying I just ramble (yes, I talk with myself, ok ???) People usually don't define me like a dumb person, and my ramble nowadays is a problem only when I want it to be a problem... I know that it is very hard to say, especially at a father, but kids most of the time just need time, your son is not stupid I won't stress him with those card, if you really want him to make some exercise ask him to keep a diary it helps a LOT, and not only with spelling but also with construction of phrase and syntax that is what really shape the mind of a person. (NB Keep a diary is WAY HARDER than play with some cards, not because the spelling or the syntax, but because is something hard to do, it takes more effort, more time and he must be very determined doing that (I am not able to as instance) but it will lead to better result, it will give your son a wonderful memories especially for when he would be a teen or an adult, and it will teach your son DETERMINATION that is the only thing can be teached in order to make a successful person)
- nemo1618 14y agoNot very relevant, but gee, wouldn't it be nice if spoken and written words were isomorphic? Think of all the frustration we could spare children if every time they heard a word, they could figure out exactly how to spell it. Once they master the individual letters, spelling becomes all but trivial. One can dream... http://www.lojban.org http://www.lojban.org
- btilly 14y agoYou mean like happens in Russian, Hebrew, German, Italian, Spanish...? I would love that. At least until I was faced with the shock of something like http://www.i18nguy.com/twain.html http://www.i18nguy.com/twain.html.
- asimeqi 14y agoAlbanian, my mother tongue, is such a language. In first grade it took me all of 4 months to learn how to read and write everything. But that didn't mean I was reading everything. In fact I read my first book when I was in second grade and was reading independently only in fourth grade. One needs to practice reading to be able to read. Spelling also is not trivial. There is a one to one correspondence between sounds and letters, yes, but before you can write the word you need to figure out all the sounds that make up that word and that is not trivial at all. Again from my experience, we were taking dictations until second year of high schools and we were still making mistakes. I think that grammar actually plays a more important role in writing ability, at least when comparing Albanian and English. A verb in Albanian can appear in more than 70 different forms depending on the tense and other grammatical categories that I can't even translate, while a verb in English can appear in a very limited number of forms. I think it is much easier in English to remember by heart how to write those few forms than in Albanian to figure out how to write each form by sounding it. Of course an Albanian can predict how a verb should be written from the context (there are rules) but that cannot be done before having studied Albanian grammar for a few years.
- donniezazen 14y agoPost has been removed. Privacy?
- btilly 14y agoI misclicked inside of blogger. Fixed. Sorry.
- frannk 14y agoIt seems in english speaking country there is a need for flashcard system too. I want to share my view on "flashcard" app. I am a chinese coder, who love learning and reading english. To help people learn english words in long term(for school Exam,SAT,GRE, or just for work), I have made two web app. 1. jianbing.org (running for 2years, shutting down for bad UX, 20K users) 2. http://rollingword.com http://rollingword.com ( alpha, Launching, without rollingAlgorithm shipped) To make things simple, I have a simple philosophy : Our brain is a distribute network system just like DNS! so our memo brain have two parts 1. Area like Local DNS (8.8.8.8) , which is fast(fast CPU) but memo unit have TTL (time to live). It just a cahce with small latency. 2. Area like Authority DNS( Like Router53) , slow CPU, Big database hard drive.It like computing strategy, coding, Learning. We can not remember a word because it is not in the Local DNS(maybe in the Authority DNS area but it is a so slow CPU), or it is expired. So our algorithm(calling rollingAlgorithm,which make word/cards rolling ) is to copy a Local DNS ttl table by collecting user test feedback; how to test? first user can get a list of cards/words, , by rollingAlgorithm(based on Actuarial Science, which used to calculate people life time). the learning and reviewing is in a row. we show user a "pile" of card ,if user hit his cache , user click "Learn",we say he remember the word , send back a high score to rollingAlgorithm; if cache missed,user click "fail", he will relearn the word and the word is queued in the row and will come up again (if missed again,come up again),send back a low score to rollingAlgorithm; we collect user memo performance while they are learning! we make your memory rolling, at best performance.