3 ms·
> The immigrant will either spend or invest his pay. This is flawed logic for two reasons: 1. As I'm an immigrant here myself, I have a lot of friends that ar
by grecy 14y ago
> The immigrant will either spend or invest his pay.
This is flawed logic for two reasons:
1. As I'm an immigrant here myself, I have a lot of friends that are also immigrants, although most are of the kind I discussed, working minimum wage for the Wal-Marts of the world. I can guarantee you, they send every penny they can spare to their family in their home country, and themselves live in second world conditions (10 to a house, eating rice for every meal, hand washing clothes, absolute minimum heat in the winter etc. etc.) so they are spending extremely little. A local person earning that same money would be spending/investing more.
2. These immigrants are earning $x, likely minimum wage. So they only at most $x to spend or invest. The employer would have had to increase wages to $x+y to attract a local, so that local would be spending or investing $x+y, which would be better for the economy.
Bringing in people to work for less money than a local person would do it only helps the company increase profit.
- eru 14y agoAbout 1: Either the money comes back to the US eventually, or if it doesn't, the Fed can just run slightly looser monetary policy. About 2: The solution is of course, to set up a second firm to compete with the first one. The wages saved should thus eventually go away from being excess profit to making prices cheaper for the consumer.
- grecy 14y agoI can't tell if you're trolling or not.... > Either the money comes back to the US eventually, or if it doesn't That may be the most superfluous statement I've ever read. > The solution is of course, to set up a second firm to compete with the first one. The wages saved should thus eventually go away from being excess profit to making prices cheaper for the consumer. And it will put every local person out of a job, or force them to work for a wage lower than they were willing to accept in the first place, thus driving down minimum wage. That's a great way to turn your country into a developing one.
- eru 14y ago> And it will put every local person out of a job, or force them to work for a wage lower than they were willing to accept in the first place, thus driving down minimum wage. That's a great way to turn your country into a developing one. I can't tell if you're trolling or not, either. I hope, you know, wages are high in the rich world because of high productivity (in sectors that produce tradeable goods)? Not because we have _not_ allowed foreigners to come in. (And if I lived in a country where that was the case, I'd be off for a less fragile economy within days.) Immigration used to be much easier in Europe and the USA in the 19th century. When those countries first became great. Full disclosure: I am leaving Europe for Singapore. A country with a very business-friendly immigration policy. > That's a great way to turn your country into a developing one. Poland and a few other countries to the east of Germany joined the EU. Their inhabitants now have the right to work everywhere in the EU. Did wages in the rest of the rich parts of the EU fall down to Polish levels? No.
- jimbokun 14y ago"I hope, you know, wages are high in the rich world because of high productivity" I'm pretty sure productivity has been rising rapidly over the last decade in the U.S., with no increase in wages. "Their inhabitants now have the right to work everywhere in the EU. Did wages in the rest of the rich parts of the EU fall down to Polish levels? No." What levels did they fall to (I honestly don't know)?
- justincormack 14y agoThey did not fall significantly at all (although in some countries wages stagnated much like in the US). Self-employed wages (plumbers being a common example) may have fallen, but salaried rates did not seem to in aggregate. I hired many people from Poland, as they were very good and well qualified, but did not pay them less. Offshoring still pays less, so that is common too, but then the cost of living is still less in those countries.
- eru 14y ago