3 ms·
> why do we continue to allow them to operate Healthcare facilities? We don’t want to pay for them. When private equity is forced to sell, someone has to buy o
by JumpCrisscross 10mo ago
> why do we continue to allow them to operate Healthcare facilities?
We don’t want to pay for them. When private equity is forced to sell, someone has to buy or the providers get shuttered.
On the other hand, we’re clearly willing to blow the money and deficit on stupid stuff. But only if it goes boom, apparently.
- lukev 10mo agoWho do you mean by "we", here? The only possible entities who could buy a company are either a bigger company, or private equity. That the leavings of a PE business are unattractive to either of them is not a surprise. That has nothing to do with what society at large (a better definition of "we") actually wants or needs.
- JumpCrisscross 10mo ago> Who do you mean by "we", here? Voters, broadly and monolithically. > only possible entities who could buy a company are either a bigger company, or private equity Communities. Forcing PE to divest from healthcare would require setting up a lending facility communities can borrow from to buy back their healthcare infrastructure. (Or have the government just buy it outright.) I guess you could make it work as a window-dressing bill. Force PE to divest. Leave unsaid that you’re letting billionaires and family offices buy it up to continue the same shit. But actually solving the problem means ponying up cash to buy this stuff back. Even if it’s out of bankruptcy. (I’m not even touching the politics of paying PE and its lenders with public money.)
- john01dav 10mo agoIf you change rules to make the PE business model unprofitable, since it's in many ways toxic to society, you can result in them then needing to sell, for much less than they'd like most likely, or adapt and become less toxic.
- JumpCrisscross 10mo ago> you can result in them then needing to sell, for much less than they'd like most likely I’m imagining harder. Forced divestiture. Good amount of the hospitals and nursing homes would be bought of out bankruptcy. But they still need to be bought and funded. And I think nobody wants to have a conversation about how much that costs and who winds up paying for it, particularly with many of PE’s hospitals being in rural America.
- UqWBcuFx6NV4r 10mo ago> The only possible entities who could buy a company are either a bigger company, or private equity. The American mind virus at work. My (non-US) state government literally purchased a private hospital late last year. Now it’s public. Keep telling yourself that corporations are going to save you. Maybe it’ll happen eventually.
- lukev 10mo agoOh, trust me, I would absolutely love for a lot more of the US to be socialized (certainly healthcare, housing, and transportation.) Unfortunately that is virtually impossible in the current political climate, so I didn't include it. What I was trying to say is that, as it stands, PE is the end of an entity's life. Once it's been strip-mined for all value, of course nobody wants it.
- JumpCrisscross 10mo ago> that is virtually impossible in the current political climate We probably need a Constitutional amendment codifying independent agencies before it can happen. We don’t need the President denying protesters medical treatment because he needs to distract from his pediphilia.
- xp84 10mo agoThe government-owned things still suck too, they just give sweetheart contracts to whoever greases the right palms even though they suck. The money still flows to bad people, no matter what. Having it be tax money in the first place just increases the possible money available to be stolen, since government budgets can in practice only go up, plus the feds can print money.
- _DeadFred_ 10mo agoMy red state rural county setup our own ambulance district. We now get much better service than before.
- gardnr 10mo ago
- hermanzegerman 10mo agoThey could be owned by Physicians or by the Local Government. But the US has practically banned the first one https://www.cms.gov/medicare/regulations-guidance/physician-self-referral/physician-owned-hospitals https://www.cms.gov/medicare/regulations-guidance/physician-...
- SkyeCA 10mo ago> We don’t want to pay for them. Perhaps we should have kept taxing the rich the we did during WW2 and the few decades following it? No, clearly that would never work!
- JumpCrisscross 10mo ago> we should have kept taxing the rich the we did during WW2 and the few decades following it? Genuine question: source for any of the rich having paid more in the 50s than they did in the 90s? My understanding is that while published rates were high, effective rates were roughly flat until the Bush and Trump tax cuts.
- polotics 10mo agogenuine answer that it's really easy to look this up. start with a search on "Roosevelt".
- dpe82 10mo agohttps://taxpolicycenter.org/sites/default/files/statistics/pdf/historical_individual_income_parameters_0.pdf https://taxpolicycenter.org/sites/default/files/statistics/p...
- JumpCrisscross 10mo agoThese are literally the rates. Not effectives.
- gusgus01 10mo agoThe average effective tax rate stayed flat from 1945-2015, but the effective tax rate for the 0.1% and 1% fell during that time period. Bottoming out around the Bush years (although the graph only goes to 2015 so another source is needed to see how the Trump tax breaks have played out). The top for the 0.1% was almost 50% and the bottom was almost 20%. Now those almosts are working in the opposite directions so you should look at the graphs. https://taxpolicycenter.org/taxvox/effective-income-tax-rates-have-fallen-top-one-percent-world-war-ii-0 https://taxpolicycenter.org/taxvox/effective-income-tax-rate... Now the 1% is paying more of the overall taxes, about 40%, but that number is also skewed (and can be misleading) by the absolute massive disparity between what the top and bottom make now. Plus of course reporting and tax compliance has changed a bit, plus a whole host of other confounding factors that this 40% statistic subsumes, but it's worth mentioning because it's always brought up in these discussions.
- phkahler 10mo ago>> > why do we continue to allow them to operate Healthcare facilities? We don’t want to pay for them. When private equity is forced to sell, someone has to buy or the providers get shuttered. Sell? The point is that PE should never have purchased these things in the first place.
- JumpCrisscross 10mo ago> The point is that PE should never have purchased these things in the first place You can change the present. Not the past. Private equity owns these things. If you want them to not own it, you have to buy it back. Even if out of bankruptcy. Even if via eminent domain. Then you have to run it. All of that costs money.
- nradov 10mo agoYou're missing the point. It's too late to unwind those transactions. In theory state or federal governments could seize ownership of those healthcare provider organizations. But then legally the government would be forced to compensate the current owners at fair market value.