5 ms·
I've generally had some antipathy to Joel Spolsky, seeing him as more management oriented than programmer oriented. But I have to say that he seems both right a
by joe_the_user 18y ago
I've generally had some antipathy to Joel Spolsky, seeing him as more management oriented than programmer oriented. But I have to say that he seems both right and honest here.
TDD is great if you use it appropriate along with good design - but "tests for everything" is just ideology. As he says, it's like the old OO schema, where you created these ridiculous inheritance trees and unnecessarily complex diagrams and such.
- dws 18y agoIf Spolsky is going after "tests for everything", his target is Robert Martin, not Kent Beck. Beck freely admits that he doesn't test everything. Pulling Beck into the argument feels like a cheap debate trick.
- jacobscott 18y agoIf you are: * selling software people pay money for * writing software people install -- that is, /not/ web stuff Then under what circumstances would it make sense to ship untested code? When is there a difference between code that has unit tests, versus that with only end-to-end tests?
- silentbicycle 18y agoI don't think anybody is arguing that shipping completely untested code is a good idea.