12 ms·
Why can't the article just come out and say what it means? Militant Islam scares the crap out of the West, and we're willing to pass laws and endure a certain l
by javajosh 14y ago
Why can't the article just come out and say what it means? Militant Islam scares the crap out of the West, and we're willing to pass laws and endure a certain level of self-censorship to avoid provoking violence out of these people.
The simple lesson here is that if you want to stop non-believers from doing blasphemy, violent reprisals work.
And really, self-censorship is a practical stance, if not a principled one. There is a terrible slippery slope here, not only in encouraging islamists to demand more from us (what's next? threatening farmers who sell pork?) but also to send a message to other put-upon groups that they can demand the same thing - if they want it badly enough.
Yes, I wish that people would grow a spine and stop worrying about getting killed for hurting someone's feelings. But when I wonder whether I'd be willing to take that risk, the answer is no.
- gbog 14y agoI see what you mean but I have the opposite feeling: the thing about Islam and all is just a minor part of the self-censorship and new taboos problem in the West, and this article should not focus only on that.
- milfot 14y agoQuick question, do you actually think it is the 'militant' or the 'islam' that scares the west? And once you figure out the (right) answer to that question, please rewrite your post to replace 'islamists' with 'militants'. The real lesson here is what better way to mobilise a generation of a nation into militancy than occupy their country, sell off their assets, kill 5% of the population and then insult their religion.
- spindritf 14y ago> please rewrite your post to replace 'islamists' with 'militants'. No need to rewrite anything, it's both their hostility and philosophical differences that scare us. Overcoming that fear and reaffirming our values is the basis for one of the most important texts in the European culture — The Song of Roland. EDIT: I do know what you mean and I'm sorry but those are just feel-good platitudes. West quite obviously is not afraid of militant Christians or atheists. Mostly because there aren't really any left, and those who still hang around don't regularly erupt in violence, but also because they're much more like us and it's easier for us to understand their particular extremism.
- milfot 14y agoThe hostility and philosophical differences of muslims or militants? I think you also misunderstand. Militants are a small subset of society which also includes some muslims, some christians, hindus, atheists etc. Point is, vast majority of muslims are peaceful, just the same as christians or atheists.
- milfot 14y agoAt this risk of getting this all out of order (since you edited rather than replying).. The west is RUN by militant christians (and militant jews and militant atheists etc). They use armies to inflict their particular brand of extremism. They killed about a million iraquis. They murder people in cold blood by dropping missiles from drones from 50,000 ft up. Pretty fucking extreme if you ask me.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoCould you please show us the militant Jews and atheists running the West?
- milfot 14y agoYeah, you got me there, I actually have no idea.. I just assumed there would be some people with other beliefs in the armed forces in US, UK, Israel, Australia (ie. the west).
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoI'd bet the UK and Australia have atheists in their armed forces, but they don't run the world. I've met militant Jews in Israel's armed forces, but they don't run the world either. The United States runs the world, but has a heavily Protestant tilt.
- milfot 14y agoFair cop.. I was just trying to be inclusive ;) Point I was trying to make is the militancy is an end in itself and the belief structures are simply bent to serve it.. in refutation of the idea that militancy in the muslim world is peculiarly religious. They find religious justifications for operational killings in order not to abandon their religion, not because their religion demands it. US forces just abandon religion when it suits them and call themselves a secular nation. The British made themselves a whole new religion answerable to the head of state. These are all just ways of twisting religion to serve power.
- coolestuk 14y agoAlmost the whole world that is islamic became muslim through military occupation, the mass slaughter of the males who fought or would not convert, the looting of property and the selling off into slavery of their women and children. This was all based on emulating the behaviour of Mohammed (known as sunnah in islamic practice); Mohammed took 20% of the spoils from his army of warriors. (Some describe him as the profit of 20% because of this). This can be verified in The Life of Mohammed, the first biography of Mohammed (and written by a muslim 100 years after the death of Mohammed). The author, Ibn Ishaq, was a christian who was taken as a slave to Medina, and converted to islam for a better life (one of the inducements used in the spread of islam). The real lesson is that christianity endured 300 years of this aggression, before Pope Urban made christianity do an about turn, and began the (very minimal) Crusades against islam. They were a failure, and islamic violence against European christendom continued until the Siege of Vienna (when Jan Sobieski defeated the muslim army on September 11, 1683). Watch just 1 minute of this video to see what happened: http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=WPwZ7MC3YPU#t=731s http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v... The muslim attack against Europe continued beyond this. The white slave trade continued for hundreds of years (it was stopped by a joint British/US naval bombardment of Algeria in 1815). In 1951 the UN report on slavery calculated that 5% of the population of Saudi Arabia and Yemen were still slaves. Buddhism did not respond in the same way as christianity to islamic aggression. Many experts on the history of buddhism say that buddhism died about 1000 years ago (e.g. Conze). And they explicitly attribute this death of buddhism to the onslaught of the islamic invasion & destruction in India. The real lesson is that some religions are actually militant political movements wrapped up in religion. Islam is one such religion. Islamic militancy was going on for hundreds of years before christianity responded in kind.
- milfot 14y ago"Almost the whole world that is islamic became muslim through military occupation." This is just plain bullshit! The introduction of islam to much of the world was through trade, just the same as the christians. And if you take slavery, trade and military occupations to be evidence that "The real lesson is that some religions are actually militant political movements wrapped up in religion." then I am afraid you will have to say the same of christianity. Once again, the point is that extremists / militants use religion (or any other reason) to justify occupation, oppression and murder. To fight militant-ism you have to do just two things. 1.resist. 2.not become one. ps: were you serious about that video you linked? seems like dumb paranoid aryan propaganda to me..
- skylan_q 14y ago"The simple lesson here is that if you want to stop non-believers from doing blasphemy, violent reprisals work." And it's the wrong lesson learned. Violent reprisals didn't happen as a result of blasphemy, but of murder and occupation and dominance.
- gizmo686 14y agoI think you are right that most of the violence we see aren't really a result of hate speach. However, I think the parent's point is still valid in the more general sense, that our weakening of free speech due to threats of violence sends the signal that terrorism is an effective means of politics. Having said that, reading a history books also sends that signal, although it likely frames it in terms of guerilla warfare, and cutting losses, and such.
- guylhem 14y agoSome (dead) people might disagree with you. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theo_van_Gogh_(film_director) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theo_van_Gogh_(film_director)
- w1ntermute 14y ago> Militant Islam scares the crap out of the West, and we're willing to pass laws and endure a certain level of self-censorship to avoid provoking violence out of these people. This is such a stupid strategy. The right thing to do is to look at the root cause of all this. After all, there are lots of angry people all across the world that hate the Western world and want to hurt it, but most can't. What sets the Arabs apart is their vast oil riches. Without that, they wouldn't have the money or power to do anything to the West. If you want to fight militant Islam, the first thing to do is to limit immigration from those countries and spread the immigrants out to force assimilation. The second thing to do is to invest as much money as possible into developing domestic energy sources, as well as alternatives to crude oil. The minute that crude oil loses its relevance to the Western world, the Arabs will just go back to what they were before - a bunch of desert nomads with no real power.
- killwhitey 14y agoThis would be a good strategy to stop state sponsored attacks, but what about the rest? What about the World Trade Center attacks? The 2002 Bali bombings? The 2005 London bombings?
- tsotha 14y agoThe WTC attacks were committed by people who were in the country legally, either at the time or they had overstayed a visa. Those attacks would not have happened if the individuals involved weren't granted visas.
- mansoor-s 14y agoAre you telling me I should not be allowed in the USA of which I am a law abiding citizen because of my ethnicity? Its okay, be strait with me. You won't hurt my feelings.
- mcantelon 14y agoPerhaps the user is referring to the allegations that US intelligence agencies, using the State Department as a proxy, let people into the US who otherwise would have been denied. http://www.globalresearch.ca/articles/SPR302A.html http://www.globalresearch.ca/articles/SPR302A.html
- nazgulnarsil 14y agobecause the lessons of history are that appeasement works...
- guylhem 14y ago> we're willing to pass laws and endure a certain level of self-censorship to avoid provoking violence out of these people Benjamin Franklin addressed that issue "Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." Sometimes, I wonder what's the next target after free speech. I don't think farmers are a strategic objective. If I had to make that call, I'd go after woman rights, and trade that against something strategically insignificant concession (say like "allowing" farmers to keep raising pork). (EDIT: Fixed Franklin quote. human memory failure :-)
- sliverstorm 14y agoQuote him correctly: Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety. It is important to do so; "essential liberty" and "temporary safety" are not the same as "liberty" and "safety".
- guylhem 14y agoYou are right. My mistake. I fixed that. Freedom of speech is an essential liberty. The #1 most essential liberty, to allow science, progress and democracy
- sliverstorm 14y agoAt which point the discussion simply derails into a debate over whether you believe limitations to freedom of speech are ever acceptable. As another note, don't forget to consider the second element- "temporary safety". If the safety purchased by showing greater deference to militant Islamism is not temporary, the quote is not applicable. I am not arguing that this is the case, merely reminding to think critically- his quote was very specific, and it aggravates me when people abuse it without a moment's thought. Anyway, I know what I believe, but I don't have the material to make a case right now, so that is all.
- hso9791 14y ago
- mcantelon 14y agoThis is just a government power grab cloaked with a bunch of rhetoric that happens involved Muslims. And it's probably not a coincidence that this debate flares up in the media just as sable rattling for military action against Iran reaches its peak.
- gleenn 14y agoThe real unfortunate thing is that while you may make the personal decision to not take the risk, legislation makes that decision for everyone. I'd definitely err on the side not letting violent extremists censor me.
- javajosh 14y agoLast I checked you have the option to insult Mohammad as much as you like! There is no limit on your free speech - many of the laws mentioned in the article that might apply were from Britian, so assuming you're from the US, you're good to say what you like, and take that personal risk.
- cousin_it 14y ago> what's next? threatening farmers who sell pork? No, threatening shop owners who sell alcohol. It's already happening in some regions of Russia that have large Muslim populations, like Dagestan. Typically they'd send you a "flash card" with photos of your wife and kids. Then you're on the hook to pay money to Muslim militants, or your family suffers. Going to the authorities won't work, since many government officials are on the same hook. Here's an article about these "flash cards" on a militant website: http://guraba.info/2011-02-27-17-49-46/28-facty/1344-2012-06-22-02-36-13.html http://guraba.info/2011-02-27-17-49-46/28-facty/1344-2012-06... It's in Russian, you'll need a translator.
- mlvljr 14y agoThese are future freedom fighters (already funded by the saudits, btw), you just don't get it! Чтоб им...
- lloeki 14y ago> when I wonder whether I'd be willing to take that risk, the answer is no. Please, compute the odds. You have a higher chance of being struck by lightning, or being killed by one of your relatives, or suffering an airplane crash, or simply dying from lung cancer even if you don't smoke. Violent reprisals work only if you get scared. This is the fundamental mechanism of terrorism, and terrorism has found a perfect echo chamber with modern media, be it broadcast TV or the web and their unquenchable thirst for drama, blowing the actual risk completely out of proportion[0]. Resisting the cognitive bias and refusing to be terrorized is the only winning move. [0] http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2010/01/the_comparative.html http://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2010/01/the_comparativ...
- dmorgan 14y ago>Why can't the article just come out and say what it means? Militant Islam scares the crap out of the West, and we're willing to pass laws and endure a certain level of self-censorship to avoid provoking violence out of these people. No, it's not just that. Western politically correct liberals, the kind of people that likes to hell-ban dissenting opinions on social issues on HN too, is all for self-censorship on lots of issues, even without involving the "scare of militant Islam". People also get the equivalent of "hell-banned" from the media, or get fines and prison terms and such for non-PC talk that has nothing to do with muslims. If you count "hate speech" in that, a loosely defined term that can mean anything, it gets even worse.
- jonnathanson 14y ago"And really, self-censorship is a practical stance, if not a principled one." No, it's neither a practical nor principled stance. It's an act of cowardice, and it's self-destructive. If we want to win the so-called "war on terror" (god I hate that term), then we need to stop being so terrified. The real enemy in the "war" is ourselves: our emotions, our fears, our gut reactions, and our knee-jerk impulses. Terrorists win when they induce terror, and when that terror compels us to bend and flex our basic beliefs. Plain and simple. The best response to militant Islam is to reaffirm free speech, to stand up in the face of our fears, and to allow terrorism not to affect us. A defiant lack of terror robs terrorism of its power. Now, I'm not so naive as to suggest that terrorists won't keep attempting terrorism. They probably always will. But they'll do it regardless of what degree we try to kowtow to their religious sensitivities. They'll do it not because they are Muslims, or because they're offended by us, but because they are militants attempting to advance a specific, political agenda. The Muslims who aren't violently advancing a political agenda, i.e., the majority of them, aren't going to be driven to do so by our free expression.
- javajosh 14y ago>If we want to win the so-called "war on terror" (god I hate that term), then we need to stop being so terrified. But I'm not terrified. I just don't want to get killed for saying something that I probably wasn't inclined to say anyway, so I choose not to say it. I consider it an appeasement, but a reasonable one. We say we don't bargain with hostage takers - but what if the hostage taker demanded a stick of gum. Would you insist on not giving them the gum on the principal that if you give them gum, the next time they'll want a sandwich, and the time after that, the world?! No, I say give them their stick of gum. It's the polite thing anyway. But if they push it too far, then not only will we not agree to it, but we'll go ahead and take away the gum too.
- Evbn 14y agoPoland was a stick of gum in 1939.
- JasonFruit 14y agoDid you stop reading halfway through? Note the points about hateful, discriminatory, and deceitful speech, which comprise a significant portion of the article. Yes, hypersensitivity to religious criticism by some Muslims is a part of the reason for the problem, but much more than that was discussed.
- white_devil 14y agoStrange how here you are, sounding like you're well aware that there are problems with Islam. But when I attempt to point out that Muslim immigrants in particular are over-represented in crime statistics in Europe, you call me a racist. Somalis are quite militant about Islam, you know.