4 ms·

I need you to know that the discussion on this news on Reddit today was the last straw for me, there is no nuance. It’s just simple minded left, and right. I as

I need you to know that the discussion on this news on Reddit today was the last straw for me, there is no nuance. It’s just simple minded left, and right. I asked ChatGPT to help me find a site that might have more intelligent discussion more nuance, and this was the very first comment I saw after I registered my account and I literally let a sigh of a relief. Thank you.

Sprotch 9mo ago
Yep - Reddit is unfortunately now where the simpletons hang out. This is far better, you can have intelligent debates
- jennyholzer3 9mo ago
  The people and LLMs that use this website are as numb-skulled, illiterate, and misanthropic as the people and LLMs that use reddit; In fact, these are the same people and the same LLMs.
  - llmslave2 9mo ago
    Yep, only real difference is Redditors now know they aren't smart or special, people here haven't figured that out yet.
- llmslave2 9mo ago
  There isn't really much difference between here and Reddit. Especially on political topics, you get the same tired and defeated arguments and opinions over and over again.
  - komali2 9mo ago
    To an extent yes, but individually I have much more nuanced interactions here with users. Whereas on Reddit I get dog piled by hundreds of black and white thinkers all circle jerking each other, making identical replies to my comments. Here I often will get a deep thread with one user that's quite interesting, even if we disagree in many ways. It's also usually polite for the most part.
    - jacquesm 9mo ago
      That's why I'm so happy HN has resisted the call to allow people to post images. You get the occasional link to that stick figure site but other than that posting here requires some minimal effort. Rate limiting all posters might be another way to increase the signal to noise ratio.
  - 0xDEAFBEAD 9mo ago
    reddit is simply on another level though. See Paul Graham's concept of the "aggressively conventional-minded": https://paulgraham.com/conformism.html https://paulgraham.com/conformism.html
    - Sprotch 9mo ago
      Thanks for this - Graham hits the nail on the head
- jacquesm 9mo ago
  But with every redditor that moves here the difference is getting smaller.
0xDEAFBEAD 9mo ago
Substack is another good platform for nuanced discussions. The Notes feature is a bit like Twitter but with +20 IQ points. Literally the first post that popped up when I opened the app: https://substack.com/@jaysophalkalyan/note/c-194741864 https://substack.com/@jaysophalkalyan/note/c-194741864?

Sprotch 9mo ago

Yep - Reddit is unfortunately now where the simpletons hang out. This is far better, you can have intelligent debates

jennyholzer3 9mo ago
The people and LLMs that use this website are as numb-skulled, illiterate, and misanthropic as the people and LLMs that use reddit; In fact, these are the same people and the same LLMs.
- llmslave2 9mo ago
  Yep, only real difference is Redditors now know they aren't smart or special, people here haven't figured that out yet.
llmslave2 9mo ago
There isn't really much difference between here and Reddit. Especially on political topics, you get the same tired and defeated arguments and opinions over and over again.
- komali2 9mo ago
  To an extent yes, but individually I have much more nuanced interactions here with users. Whereas on Reddit I get dog piled by hundreds of black and white thinkers all circle jerking each other, making identical replies to my comments. Here I often will get a deep thread with one user that's quite interesting, even if we disagree in many ways. It's also usually polite for the most part.
  - jacquesm 9mo ago
    That's why I'm so happy HN has resisted the call to allow people to post images. You get the occasional link to that stick figure site but other than that posting here requires some minimal effort. Rate limiting all posters might be another way to increase the signal to noise ratio.
- 0xDEAFBEAD 9mo ago
  reddit is simply on another level though. See Paul Graham's concept of the "aggressively conventional-minded": https://paulgraham.com/conformism.html https://paulgraham.com/conformism.html
  - Sprotch 9mo ago
    Thanks for this - Graham hits the nail on the head
jacquesm 9mo ago
But with every redditor that moves here the difference is getting smaller.

0xDEAFBEAD 9mo ago

Substack is another good platform for nuanced discussions. The Notes feature is a bit like Twitter but with +20 IQ points. Literally the first post that popped up when I opened the app: https://substack.com/@jaysophalkalyan/note/c-194741864 https://substack.com/@jaysophalkalyan/note/c-194741864?