6 ms·
OpenAI is paying employees more than any major tech startup in history
- bookofjoe 11mo agono paywall: https://www.wsj.com/tech/ai/openai-is-paying-employees-more-than-any-major-tech-startup-in-history-23472527?st=aAAaWw&reflink=desktopwebshare_permalink https://www.wsj.com/tech/ai/openai-is-paying-employees-more-...
- no_wizard 11mo agoThe article talks about averages, but what I want know is the median. The usual situation, and I have zero reason to believe OpenAI is different, is that stock options are top heavy leaning heavily toward executives. I want to know rank and file salaries as opposed to stock options
- raw_anon_1111 11mo agoIlllquid “stock options” in a private company is not what I consider compensation.
- ceejayoz 11mo agoThis is the general rule, but not for ones the size of OpenAI. There’s always a secondary market for prominent enough companies.
- soared 11mo agoDont all private companies require approval for secondary sales, which I assume are not ever approved?
- no_wizard 11mo agoTypically. I’d be shocked if OpenAI let employees sell their options like this without requiring approval
- htrp 11mo agoThey don't but you effectively do it under the table
- raw_anon_1111 11mo agoDo they sell at full value?
- judahmeek 11mo agoHow do you define value without an IPO?
- matt-attack 11mo agoWhatever they sell them for is the value.
- cik 11mo agoThey do, but you sell forward contracts instead. This is perfectly legal, and the approach I've seen. There are a few companies, and even funds that will engage in this, in an effort to attain future upside.
- throw-12-16 11mo agoIts pretty common, Ive personally done this.
- Eridrus 11mo agoI am sure you can make OpenAI stock liquid pretty easily.
- LunaSea 11mo agoOnly if you're allowed to which is not always the case.
- Atotalnoob 11mo agoIt’s allowed pretty easily. They had had tender events (where you can sell your private stock super easily)
- mikeyouse 11mo agoThey've changed the laws recently which makes it far easier - I believe you'd still need to be accredited but for most of HN, that's a low bar. For OpenAI specifically, they've allowed employees to participate in the funding rounds and they did a separate tender offer with Softbank to provide liquidity to early employees as well; https://fortune.com/2024/12/17/hundreds-openai-employees-10-million-payday-softbank-stock-tender-offer-details/ https://fortune.com/2024/12/17/hundreds-openai-employees-10-...
- ls612 11mo agoOpenAI has regular tender offers for their employees, so while this advice is reasonable in general it is less true for this case.
- no_wizard 11mo agoLess true isn’t the same as not true. Simply put we don’t know because it’s not what they are disclosing This article feels more like paid publicity than it does journalism
- ls612 11mo agoThe various valuations you see for OpenAI are overwhelmingly based on the prices offered for shares in their employee tender offers so I’d say for OpenAI and SpaceX at a minimum (which has a similar setup for its employees) we have a pretty good idea of what employees are getting for their equity compensation if they so choose.
- belter 11mo agoDont worry...there is always an acquisition by Meta, on the horizon for any company with nowhere to go.
- eitally 11mo agoBusiness & back office employee salaries are standard but not impressive. Similarly, stock grants are better than most places but not wildly high unless you're in specific engineering & research functions. This is the same at Anthropic, too (I recently interviewed for director level business roles at both).
- lokar 11mo agoIn general, I wish the media would stop using just the average when the distribution is not normal.
- functionmouse 11mo agoThat's exactly why they use averages, though. Propaganda is insidious in that way.
- itsdrewmiller 11mo agoWho is “they”? I believe open AI would share averages for that reason but not that media would choose to cover it that way.
- lokar 11mo agoI think the simpler answer (and thus more likely) is that statistics education in the US is very bad (they should teach stats in high school, not calculus), and reporters just don't understand it. And the ones who do, believe (correctly) that their audience does not understand it.
- Garlef 11mo agoThe whole way media treats numbers is more than tiring: "X increased by Y" Sure... but: - What's the relative increase? - Is this increase out of the ordinary? Annually? Globally? But I don't think this is some sort of conspiracy. Rather: Most journalists are not very smart.
- pcurve 11mo ago"OpenAI’s compensation as a percentage of revenue was set to reach 46% in 2025" At least the revenue is large enough to cover the payroll. That's a good milestone. Not really a fan of Altman, but I don't mind the competition he brings to the landscape.
- saagarjha 11mo agoLooking at the stick compensation of companies in 2000 doesn’t seem particularly relevant today?
- ur-whale 11mo agoOpenAI is exactly what happens when a company finds itself in such a far, far away blue ocean strategy that there are no more traditional "economic anchors" (to call it that) to reason with. It usually ends in blood and tears, for both employees and investors. BUT: the SOTA has been greatly advanced, which matters a great deal more than the destiny of a particular corporation or the social status of sam-i-am. So, overall: good news.
- philipallstar 11mo agoDefinitely. If VCs want to fund expensive salaries, so what?
- plaidfuji 11mo agoI like this viewpoint - it basically casts VC-backed AI startups as privately-subsidized applied R&D projects, which largely seems to be the case for foundational model companies.
- causal 11mo agoBrowsing OpenAI's careers page, I'm seeing at most $275k for most positions, so I'm assuming the median is much lower than an average being pulled up by a few rockstar positions.
- tonfa 11mo agoYou also need to take into account equity, since it went up 250% in a year it can be a large amount of someone's compensation.
- no_wizard 11mo agoUntil it’s really liquid it’s still fiction. The salary and other cash compensation is all that matters until you can actually sell the options
- tayo42 11mo agoAren't their secondary markets for this? My wife gets offers constantly for her options even though they're not public yet and the offers are higher then what she was awarded them at. Maybe it's scams? we never took any of them up on it.
- tverbeure 11mo agoWant does “really” mean? If there are enough opportunities to offload stock on the secondary market (which seems to be the case of them), then it’s not fiction.
- pfannkuchen 11mo agoAdjusted for inflation?
- hn_throwaway_99 11mo agoFrom the article: > The compensation figures have been adjusted into 2025 dollars to account for inflation.
- pfannkuchen 11mo agoI skimmed but missed that, thanks! I have seen so many times where comparisons are breathlessly made without adjustment in the media, so I’m pleasantly surprised it was done here.
- jacknews 11mo agooh no, that might put upward pressure on Amazon employee salary demands!
- cmiles8 11mo agoThe best people have all seemed to fled Amazon the last 24 months. LinkedIn is flooded with long tenured top tech folks leaving. I doubt that gives those left a great deal of leverage and Amazon was never known for market-leading comp.
- sinenomine 11mo agoGPT-5.2 has radically changed my outlook on OpenAI. Head and shoulders above others. The excellence is there.
- imhhdhgfih 11mo ago[dead]
- TrackerFF 11mo agoI'm also a happy customer. But, one thing has been consistent for the past 3 years: After every release from all the serious competitors, the hype can go either way. As far as the hype cycles go, OpenAI is oscillating between "Best model ever" and "What a letdown, it's over" at least twice a year. The competition is fierce, and a never-ending marathon of all the players getting ahead just a bit. No clear long-term winner.
- Insanity 11mo ago5.2 is good. But at this point every few months company A trumps company B with a new “SOTA” (for some definition of SOTA). OpenAI has no real moat. Anthropic is focusing on developers as a clear target, and Gemini has the backing of Google. I don’t see OpenAI winning the AI race with marginally better models and arguably a nicer UI/UX (ymmv, but I do like the ChatGPT app experience). That said, my usage decreases month over month.
- jackling 11mo agoReally, I found 5.2 to be a rather weak model. It constantly gives me code that doesn't work and gets simple APIs wrong. Maybe it's just weak on the domain I'm working in.
- NBJack 11mo agoIt hasn't done great in the head-to-head comparisons I've seen, and has trailed in several areas on the leaderboards (though not all). Based on the 'code red' they declared, this model seems to have been rushed a bit.
- whitehexagon 11mo agoI'm not surprised they have to pay higher, since no amount of money could convince me to work towards human irrelevance, or BigAdTech. When I see this technology improve and free the lives of those whose salary is akin to slavery, then I might reconsider. Context: I've been reading about the Mondragon Corporation, and it seems a much better model than this maximum extraction economy we are building. I'll submit a story for it, although I discovered it through a HN book recommendation (Kim Stanley Robinson).
- no_wizard 11mo ago> I'm not surprised they have to pay higher, since no amount of money could convince me to work towards human irrelevance The way Altman and others want AI to develop, this is what they’re working toward too
- Tiberium 11mo agoDo people who contribute to YouTube Shorts get paid a lot? It's a very nasty thing in the current form.
- riku_iki 11mo ago> BigAdTech I argue that BigAdTech solves important logistical problem connecting buyers and sellers, and makes humanity more efficient.
- TrackerFF 11mo agoI just can't see any clear winners in the AI race. At least not as far as the models/products go. Maybe a wild round of mergers & acquisitions, combined with regulatory capture and some monopoly will be what settles everything. Probably with a crash in the middle of it all.
- imiric 11mo agoThe market has not settled yet. We're in the late 90s internet era when it comes to "AI". As with the dotcom bubble, real value will only become evident after the crash.
- cmiles8 11mo ago“Paying” is a relative term here. Anyone that works for startups knows that it’s not really “compensation” until it’s cash in your bank account. Until then it’s just a theoretical number on paper, which tends to end up being worth a lot less than originally advertised/hoped. I’ve lost track of the number of times that someone’s startup got acquired for (insert what sounds like a big number) and everyone is like “wow the employees must all be rich” only to find out later that after preferred cap tables and other terms the employees got very little. A lot could happen here, but history says “watch this space” on this stock-based comp. Some options on the secondary markets but that only works as long as OpenAI can convince more people to dump money on the burning pile of cash they have going at the moment.
- yieldcrv 11mo agoThe private secondary markets are extremely liquid if you’re a household name The user experience is nearly the same as cash if you have an ounce of interest in having cash
- dwaltrip 11mo agoYou need company approval to sell yeah? That could be a major issue.
- yieldcrv 11mo agothe industry secret is "not really", no, you don't way before private secondaries got big, there were boutique funds and lawyers that set up the contracts and structures to circumvent this friction and most companies do not care about that covenant, they care about the optics around their cap table to attract other investors and also satisfy securities regulators
- mikert89 11mo agothis is a completely false and outdated take, you can easily sell openai shares
- 11mo ago
- sam0x17 11mo agoThe funniest part is there is no amount of money that would get me back in the office again
- faizshah 11mo agoI heard that the environment there is 996 with high turnover. So you might be paid double in comparison to a FAANG job but you work double as well. (This was about dev positions not researchers) Anyone know if that’s true? I only heard it second hand.
- therealdrag0 11mo agoI would expect so. They have no moat and are in a race to survive.
- bespokedevelopr 11mo agoEmployees also have no moat, and that is not unique to OAI. You either work as much as the other people on your team or you get replaced by one of the many people eager to work harder than you for that money.
- NBJack 11mo agoThis assumes a constant stream of an available workforce. Meanwhile, in the US where OpenAI is based, scrutiny and pressure from the current administration is making it harder to hire at their largest locations.
- suzakus 11mo agoOpenAI doesn't offer traditional rsus (at least to regular employees?), but instead profit sharing units. https://www.levels.fyi/blog/openai-compensation.html https://www.levels.fyi/blog/openai-compensation.html Might change how you evaluate the value here.
- kristianc 11mo agoThe value of any traditional RSU is to treat it as a nice bonus if you get it, so not so much different from any other stock or option package.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 11mo agoI don't think this way at all. RSU (for public companies) is real, tangible money. Sure, there is some amount of risk involved with it, but it is WAY more tangible than options than can just be diluted if the person with the cap table is feeling ornery that day. The key that makes RSU's real money is their immediate liquidity on award, so you can literally just treat them as cash compensation in this regard if you decide not to hold them. When you work at BigCorp for an extended period of time, your salary often ends up being majority by RSU as the vest rolls start to stack up
- hn_throwaway_99 11mo agoYeah, agreed. It was options I always thought of as a "nice bonus", but RSUs I always thought of like cash. The tax situation around options also makes for many more variables in the risk calculation (i.e. do I exercise as soon as I vest to reduce potential AMT, but then I may need to find sizable cash to execute), while RSUs are just much simpler
- hn_throwaway_99 11mo agoMost private companies don't offer RSUs.
- dasil003 11mo ago
- darqis 11mo agoThe codex github gatekeeper is the wrong hire for the job. He's hurting progress