5 ms·
> It probably doesn't really matter Millions—if not billions—of dollars are likely to be wasted on this over the coming years.
by JumpCrisscross 11mo ago
> It probably doesn't really matter
Millions—if not billions—of dollars are likely to be wasted on this over the coming years.
- hermitcrab 11mo agoBut think of the aesthetics!
- krogenx 11mo agoBig “beautiful” bill comes to mind.
- lostlogin 11mo agoNow the ‘One Big Beautiful Bill Act’. Even the name is flawed.
- tokai 11mo agoThat super sized destroyer has non of the battleship aesthetics though.
- hermitcrab 11mo agoIndeed. WW1 and WW2 battleships are incredible pieces of engineering and (IMHO) rather beautiful in their own way. And some of them were built in very short time frames when you consider they had no computers to design them with.
- lostlogin 11mo agoIt’s lucky the were pretty. They were outdated before the First World War.
- hermitcrab 11mo agoBased on what evidence? The battleship was clearly vulnerable to airpower in WWII. Much less so in WW1.
- lostlogin 11mo agoBased on them being involved in one battle in WW1 and being massively vulnerable to air attack in WW2. It’s an exaggeration saying that they were outdated in WW1, as they basically acted as a deterrent, but it was at enormous expense and they don’t do much. Too big, too slow, too expensive. The argument was playing out even prior to WW1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battleship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battleship Aircraft carriers took over, as you say.
- hermitcrab 11mo agoThat 1 battleship vs battleship action (Jutland) was hugely influential on the course of the war. Also there were several battlecruiser/cruiser vs battlecruiser/cruiser actions.
- lostlogin 11mo agoFaster and cheaper battleships was what they all wanted, and heavy cruisers seem to fill that role. Jutland was influential, but mainly just resulted in big ships doing nothing. That is sort of the role nuclear weapons have too I guess?
- hermitcrab 11mo ago>Faster and cheaper battleships was what they all wanted That would be a battlecruiser, and they don't seem to have been regarded as a success.
- api 11mo agoNot "wasted." Handed to allies of the administration. It's just naked kleptocracy. I suspect that the "ball room" attachment to the White House will also still be a hole by the end of the administration, but a lot of money will get handed out.
- actionfromafar 11mo agoThat’s where the Trump dynasty will live in the future, in the bunker.
- ourmandave 11mo agoAt least the name Golden Fleet makes sense since everything the US military buys is priced like it's made of solid gold.
- doom2 11mo agoIt reminded me of Chinese style military naming conventions, which makes sense since for all the anti-China bluster, Trump seems to be a big admirer of the power Xi has.
- krapp 11mo agoDon't worry - we're dismantling our science and research infrastructure and cutting welfare programs so it all evens out.
- Analemma_ 11mo agoAs much as I love any opportunity to stick it to Trump, wasting billions of dollars is about the only thing the US Navy does anymore; in this case he's keeping them on-brand and on-mission. It's kind of hilarious they announced this at the same time as the Constellation-class getting canceled, just to make sure there's no chance the Navy goes even a single day without an active boondoggle of a ship which will never sail.
- JumpCrisscross 11mo ago> As much as I love any opportunity to stick it to Trump You’re the first one in this thread mentioning him.
- decimalenough 11mo agoThe non-battleship in question is literally named the Trump Class.
- hermitcrab 11mo agoAnd has an image of him on the back of the ship on this rendering: https://www.twz.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/USS-Defiant-Trump-class-battleship.jpg https://www.twz.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/USS-Defiant-T...
- Havoc 11mo agoThey're hard at work nuking the dollar too so maybe that doesn't matter anymore then
- caconym_ 11mo agoThere's also potentially a substantial opportunity cost re: parity with China in the near to mid term even if we don't actually end up cancelling the next gen destroyer in favor of this thing: https://youtu.be/qvUbx9TvOwk https://youtu.be/qvUbx9TvOwk
- bruce511 11mo agoI mean, define "wasted"? Presumably money will flow to American companies, American employees, American steel industry and so on. In other words, yes it is billions pushed back into the economy, and yes, there will likely be very little "permanent" to show for it (and presumably the navy won't be much better for it) but it's not like they're just burying the cash. It's important to understand that for the military industrial complex the goal is to "feed the machine", not actually to produce anything. In that sense this money is not wasted, it's doing exactly what it is supposed to do.
- deleted 11mo ago[deleted]
- fastball 11mo agoMoney isn't real. Yes, allocating funds to this means there is a large swath of the population (with accompanying hard resources) which would work on this when they could arguably be working more productively on something else. But would they be spending their time more productively? Keeping what little remains of our shipbuilding capacity on life support might actually be more productive than the alternatives, given how little of value the US seems to produce when it comes to heavy manufacturing. "Spending billions" is meaningless concern until you ask the question: what would these people have been doing instead?
- Reubachi 11mo agoOf course money is real. Any financial movements humans make + the sovereignty of our respective states are completely beholden to purchasing power parity via the modern economy. The "spent billions" isn't about me/my constituents/the US not having those billions. It's that those billions where finely calculated by (supposed) experts to help maintain PPP advantages over adversaries. When one "side" starts playing pretend with money (IE; using 50 billion in western currency on the Zumwalt class of destroyers before tossing them) the other side doesn't do the same, and stop taking advantage of PPP.