6 ms·
U.S. unemployment rose in November despite job gains
- toomuchtodo 11mo agohttps://archive.today/r3mCK https://archive.today/r3mCK
- tdb7893 11mo agoThe article talks about how the Fed chair thinks we might be overestimating jobs and with the number of people I know who are currently struggling to find jobs I would believe that (not engineers, just people that had random jobs). Lots of people I know are out of work right now.
- Glyptodon 11mo agoWhy not engineers? I've definitely never had a harder time getting interviews, though obviously anecdotal. Or do you just mean that the scope is larger than software eng?
- Pwntastic 11mo agoi think they meant that the people they know having trouble finding jobs are not engineers
- tdb7893 11mo agoMany of my engineering friends happen to work in defense (I'm friends with a lot of aerospace engineers from college) and are now highly specialized engineers on stable and long term projects and happen to be at the forefront of innovation in that space and all have high level security clearances (for some of them I don't really know what they do since it's classified). Though it also could be they just have gotten lucky. My friends I made from hobbies work random and less highly technical jobs and I know a decent amount of people "in between jobs" right now. It's all anecdotal but there's a clear enough pattern that if the chair of the Fed also thinks we're underestimating I think it's very likely we are.
- Glyptodon 11mo agoThanks for clarifying, I wasn't clear on how to interpret!
- duxup 11mo agoA few articles I've read note that there are indications that there has been a very strong "low fire, low hire" pattern. So while we don't see mass layoffs, those who are out, are really out.
- alecco 11mo agoThe gig economy is hiding the real employment problem in most of the West. How money Works "The Gig Economy is Full" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dqmJN5z6Rjc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dqmJN5z6Rjc (10 Dec 25)
- reactordev 11mo agoThat’s just one facet. It’s not just the gig economy is “full”, all economies are “full”. There are not enough jobs for the employable people.
- petcat 11mo agoI saw a statistic that roughly 10% of the US workforce is in some form of "customer-facing service" role and I just have to wonder how many of those jobs are nearly gone, or already gone. Even if it's a 5% reduction, or 3% over the next decade, that seems catastrophic without a completely new category of jobs to replace them. I haven't talked to a cashier at a grocery store in years. It's all self-checkout. I stayed in a hotel recently and I didn't even talk to someone at the front desk. I just checked in at a kiosk and got my room card. There was no one else around. I guess the people that used to do those jobs are all just driving Ubers and Doordash now?
- jmathai 11mo agoThose who are still employed by my local grocery store don't seem too motivated to do their jobs. It's an unfortunate but foreseeable scenario that expedites the problem where people prefer self-checkout. I wish we'd pump the brakes on efficiency and profit.
- treyd 11mo ago> I wish we'd pump the brakes on efficiency and profit. This is not legal, executives of publicly traded companies are required to put maximizing shareholder value above all other considerations.
- int32_64 11mo agoThe most meaningful American employment stat should be employed Americans with health insurance. What's the point of being considered 'employed' if you can be wiped out with one trip to the ER?
- andrewflnr 11mo agoThis is such a myopic perspective. You're not completely wrong about the risk, but there's no good reason health insurance should be so tied to employment.
- MSFT_Edging 11mo agoBut it generally is though. You have to be doing very well as a solo contractor to afford the 1k/mo for almost comparable marketplace insurance.
- deleted 11mo ago[deleted]
- Spivak 11mo agoI think the parent agrees with you and that tracking uninsured rather than unemployed is a better view of the economy from the ground floor. My metric for "fully employed" would be has a job, has health insurance and has enough money in savings to fully cover their out of pocket max. Could not be a barer minimum of survival.
- danaris 11mo agoThere is a divide here between "is" and "ought". What "is", right now, leads us to the suggestion of int32_64, which would actually be a good metric to keep track of. You are right about what "ought" to be, but until and unless we can get there, maybe we can at least base our information on what "is" in the moment, not on what we would like to be the case?
- Der_Einzige 11mo agoSo that we aren’t “europoors”. Unironically.
- juliusceasar 11mo agoHow reliable are the unemployment numbers? Trump sacked people for not liking the numbers.
- jdross 11mo agoThe US job market is way more dynamic than people realize. Roughly 1/5 of jobs are changed every year in roles permanently lost to roles newly created. Gross job creation & destruction annually is roughly 10–12 percent of all jobs (new positions added and permanently lost across all employers). This is down from the past, when it was 15-18 percent. Source: US Census Bureau Data https://ycharts.com/indicators/us_job_destruction_rate https://ycharts.com/indicators/us_job_destruction_rate
- vondur 11mo agoI get the feeling most of the newer jobs that are going to be created are going to be in the blue collar fields and the US isn't geared for providing those. I'm also not sure that people who have been conditioned to work white collar jobs will be happy to work in blue collar jobs.
- spacephysics 11mo agoI think it has a potential to raise a lot of the salaries of blue-collar positions in middle America, and then create demand for the trades over the next decade or so. I find it unlikely that white collar positions will be switching drastically to blue collar unless they’re already on the fence about it or they’re not middle to high up in the white collar ladder (six figures+)
- hearsathought 11mo ago> I get the feeling most of the newer jobs that are going to be created are going to be in the blue collar fields and the US isn't geared for providing those. What blue collar field/industry is expected to grow? > I'm also not sure that people who have been conditioned to work white collar jobs will be happy to work in blue collar jobs. A quick google search shows about 60% of workers are white collar and about 30% are blue collar. I suspect blue collar workers are not going to be happy with the influx of white collar workers competing for their jobs.
- givemeethekeys 11mo agoMost job listings are fake - keep the investors, competitors and other employees think you are hiring. And who knows, maybe the right resume will actually be worth a look.
- jm4 11mo agoI've heard this from other people. Is there any evidence of it though?
- ulfw 11mo agoI've had 500 applications over the last four years come back without ever having gotten an interview. With my background and experience I've always gotten at the bare minimum an HR call before. Now none. None of the jobs ads are real.
- jack_tripper 11mo agoI think it's more that for white collar jobs in the west, applications get spammed into oblivion that your resume will never reach an actual human without the ATS triggering a 100% match on all the buzzwords.
- jm4 11mo agoI hear you. I've been through it too. I'm not necessarily doubting there are fake job postings. Just asking if there's any credible evidence besides our anecdotal accounts. Is it possible it's largely caused by shitty ATS software that everyone uses and we are mistakenly attributing it to fake job postings?
- Glyptodon 11mo agoIf you look at HN who is hiring threads sometimes the same companies post every time for very extended periods of time. And I've applied at some of them to never hear back. IMO they're just fishing for people who have specific profiles that they don't disclose in the job description, not actually hiring.
- 11mo ago
- earlyreturns 11mo agoH1B abuse is rampant, so the headline is what we expect. Jobs are for the foreign born, just look at HN for evidence of that. They even hire lawyers to help the outsourced labor “navigate our system.”
- readthenotes1 11mo agoMy understanding is that after being nearly flat since 2016 with nearly all the jobs going to foreign born people, there have been job gains of nearly half a million citizens in 2025 "for whatever reason".
- josefritzishere 11mo agoAnecdotally, from personal experience... job hunting is worse now than the recessions of 2000 or 2008. I think I belive Jerome Powell based on that. https://www.wsj.com/economy/jobs/fed-chair-jerome-powell-says-u-s-may-be-drastically-overstating-jobs-numbers-741c635d https://www.wsj.com/economy/jobs/fed-chair-jerome-powell-say...?
- ghaff 11mo agoYou probably need to be more granular. I got lucky, but in 2000 anything tech-related was nuclear winter. A lot of people just left the industry. 2008 was more broad-based and, while it wasn't a great market for tech (I held off making a change for a couple of years for that reason), I'm not sure it was terrible for a lot of tech.
- laughingluvky6 11mo agoChina also have the same problem
- alfiedotwtf 11mo agoAfter Trump didn’t like the numbers, weren’t unemployment figures kept secret from then on by the administration?